The mean age of COVID-19 patients in our hospital cohort was 55 ± 15 years old, 538 (55%) of them were males while 441 (45%) of them were females.
383 of the 427 confirmed cases had a baseline eGFR of higher than 60 ml/min/1,73 m2. Eighty-nine of these 383 patients (23%) experienced AKI according to the KDIGO criteria. Patients who developed AKI were older than other patients in the cohort (62,4 ± 14,2 years) and there was a male predominance. Twenty-nine (32%) of the patients had AKI on admission, 33 of them (37%) developed AKI during the first week of admission and 27 patients (30%) developed AKI starting from the second week of admission. For patients who developed AKI later than hospital admission date, AKI developed on 6,7 ± 5,4 days.
Initial laboratory values on hospital admission day and in-hospital prognostic indices of all 89 patients who were included in the study can be found in supplementary document-1.
Twenty-nine patients had AKI on admission. Kidney functions in the 15 of on-admission AKIs were rescued by fluid resuscitation and were accepted to have pre-renal AKI (51%). Two (6%) of the patients had high creatine kinase (CK) levels (5243 and 1045 IU/L), thus accepted to have rhabdomyolysis related AKI. Six patients (20%) were hypoxemic while remaining six patients (20%) had either coagulopathy or the features of cytokine release syndrome. COVID severity of the patients with AKI on admission was mainly moderate and just 7 of them (24%) had severe or critical disease.
Among patients who experienced AKI during the 1st week (n:33), eight patients had pre-renal AKI which was cured by relevant fluid therapy (24%). Seven patients (21%) had hypoxemia concomitant with the AKI diagnosis. Twelve patients either had coagulopathy or the features of cytokine release (36%). AKI in three patients (9%) was thought to be related to drug toxicity and was cured by stopping the offending agents. Three patients (9%) had high CK values (1214, 1198 and 3690IU/L) pointing out to rhabdomyolysis as the etiology. When COVID severity of the patients was evaluated, 14 of these 33 patients (42%) were classified as severe or critical.
Among patients who had AKI with the start of 2nd week (n:27), 18 patients were in the hyper-inflammation state (66%). Three patients (11%) had pre-renal AKI, five patients (18%) had drug toxicity and one patient (3%) had rhabdomyolysis (CK: 1977 IU/L). Clinical evaluation pointed out to severe or critical illness in 22 of these 27 patients (81%).
Patients of three groups were in similar age and had similar baseline mean arterial pressure, creatinine and hemoglobin levels. Co-morbidities such as diabetes, hypertension, malignancies and ischemic heart diseases/heart failure were also similar between three groups. While CRP and D-dimer levels on admission didn’t differ between the groups, patients who were presented with lower lymphocyte counts tend to develop AKI later in the disease course. Patients who had AKI on admission day had higher initial uric acid levels. All initial laboratory values of the patients can be found in table-1. In hospital stay length, intensive care unit (ICU) requirement and mortality was higher when AKI developed later in the disease course, especially after 7th day. Pre-dominant stage of AKI was stage 1; however, stage 2 & 3 AKIs, which have worse prognosis tend to increase with AKIs that occurred later (figure-2). AKI related prognostic indices of patients in three groups can be found in table-2.
Table-1: Characteristics and initial laboratory values of patients of three groups.
|
Presented with AKI
(n=29)
|
AKI in the 1st week
(n=33)
|
AKI after 7 days
(n=27)
|
p
|
Age
|
61,6 ± 14,2
|
62,5 ± 12,9
|
63,1 ± 16,2
|
0,926
|
Baseline eGFR (ml/min/1,73 m2)
|
79,6 ± 16,38
|
82,11 ± 14,53
|
86,55 ± 16,43
|
0,258
|
MAP (mmHg)
|
89,9 ± 17,2
|
88,9 ± 13,1
|
87,4 ± 10,1
|
0,801
|
Hemoglobin (g/dL)
|
12,3 ± 1,9
|
12,5 ± 1,5
|
11,9 ± 1,9
|
0,474
|
Lymphocytes (per μL)
|
1317 ± 568
|
1509 ± 798
|
1044 ± 437
|
0,022*
|
CRP (mg/L)
|
81,9 ± 76,1
|
68,5 ± 79,1
|
98,4 ± 77,6
|
0,336
|
Prokalsitonin (ng/mL)
|
0,27 ± 0,38
|
0,4 ± 1,1
|
0,4 ± 0,8
|
0,683
|
CK (IU/L)
|
383 ± 955
|
282 ± 663
|
149 ± 111
|
0,442
|
LDH (IU/L)
|
400 ± 194
|
408 ± 480
|
441 ± 213
|
0,889
|
Ferritin (ng/mL)
|
615 ± 599
|
474 ± 524
|
840 ± 599
|
0,055
|
D-dimer (mg/L)
|
1,5 ± 2,5
|
1,6 ± 2,4
|
2,5 ± 3,9
|
0,346
|
Uric acid (mg/dL)
|
6,9 ± 2,6
|
5,5 ±1,5
|
4,6 ± 1,6
|
0,000**
|
eGFR: estimated glomerular filtration rate, MAP: mean arterial pressure, CK: creatine kinase, LDH: lactate dehydrogenase, AKI: Acute kidney injury
*Post-hoc analysis reveals that the significance is between AKI in the 1st week and AKI after 7th day.
** Significance is mainly because of higher levels in patients who were presented with AKI.
Table-2: Acute kidney injury related prognostic indices of patients.
|
AKI on presentation
(n=29)
|
AKI in the first week
(n=33)
|
AKI after 7 days
(n=27)
|
p
|
Co-morbidities
DM
HT
Malignancy
IHD/HF
|
16
4
9
3
8
|
18
10
11
4
7
|
21
9
11
6
5
|
0,123
0,189
0,729
0,398
0,702
|
AKI stage 1
AKI stage 2
AKI stage 3
|
26
3
0
|
26
3
4
|
16
7
4
|
0,058
|
Severe or critical COVID-19 (n, (%))
|
7 (24)
|
14 (41)
|
22 (81)
|
0,000
|
Duration of hospital stay (days)
|
11,38 ± 6,41
|
11,85 ± 7,9
|
17,33 ± 6,58
|
0,003*
|
ICU requirement (n, (%))
|
5 (17)
|
9 (27)
|
17 (62)
|
0,001*
|
In hospital death (n, (%))
|
4 (13,7)
|
5 (15)
|
12 (44)
|
0,009*
|
Death on (day)
|
11,75 ± 7,4
|
10,8 ± 6,3
|
17,3 ± 8,0
|
0,21
|
DM: diabetes mellitus, HT: hypertension, IHD/HF: ischemic heart disease and heart failure
ICU: Intensive Care Unit , AKI: Acute kidney injury
*Significance mainly results from patients who developed AKI after 7th day.
Although there is no specific validated treatment for COVID-19 yet, some antiviral therapies were applied depending on the institutional availabilities. These can be found in supplementary document-2. Hemodialysis as renal replacement therapy (RRT) had to be performed in 6 patients who developed AKI later but none of the patients who had AKI on admission needed RRT. Anti IL-6 receptor antibody tocilizumab was used in patients who had high inflammatory response and its use was significantly more frequent for patients who developed AKI after 7th day.
While there were no significant differences between the initial values of the three groups, comparison of changes in the inflammatory markers put forth significant differences. Nadir lymphocyte counts were significantly lower while peak CRP and peak D-dimer levels were significantly higher for patients who developed AKI later in the disease course (Table-3). Although it couldn’t reach the statistical significance, peak ferritin levels were also higher for patients who developed AKI later.
Table-3: Comparison of changes in the inflammatory markers and lymphocyte counts during the course of the disease
|
AKI on presentation
(n=29)
|
1st week AKI
(n=33)
|
AKI after 7th day
(n=27)
|
p
|
Peak creatinin (mg/dL)
|
1,62 ± 0,53
|
1,69 ± 0,78
|
1,88 ± 0,87
|
0,405
|
AKI duration (days)
|
4,0 ± 3,7
|
3,03 ± 4,66
|
3,19 ± 3,3
|
0,602
|
Nadir lymphocytes (per μL)
|
967 ± 574
|
1100±692
|
585±343
|
0,003*
|
Peak CRP (mg/L)
|
125 ± 83
|
145 ± 122
|
246 ± 86
|
0,000*
|
Peak procalcitonin (ng/mL)
|
0,57 ± 0,87
|
3,36 ± 8,37
|
3,86 ± 6,34
|
0,100
|
Peak CK (IU/l)
|
445 ± 974
|
387 ± 696
|
611 ± 641
|
0,545
|
Peak LDH (IU/L)
|
533 ± 314
|
679 ± 794
|
888 ± 510
|
0,087
|
Peak ferritin (ng/mL)
|
754 ± 596
|
806 ± 659
|
1546 ± 1406
|
0,004*
|
Peak D-dimer (mg/L)
|
7,1 ± 16,3
|
8,03 ± 10,65
|
15,39 ± 14,53
|
0,058
|
AKI: Acute kidney injury
*Post-hoc analysis reveals that the significant difference was because of the values of AKIs after 7th day.
Survivors and non-survivors among patients who developed AKI were also compared. In-hospital stay length was not different for survivors (12,9 ± 7,48) and non-survivors (14,5 ± 7,6) (p=0,397). Those who died were older (68,14 ± 11,81) than those who didn’t (60,6 ± 14,5) (p=0,03). Patients who survived had similar diabetes or hypertension rates as patients who didn’t, while concomitant malignancies were more frequent in patients who died.
AKI had 23% mortality in our patients who had eGFRs above 60 ml/min/1,73 m2 according to the baseline creatinine values. Baseline creatinine levels were similar for survivors and non-survivors. AKI developed later in non-survivors and it lasted longer. Non-survivors had significantly higher initial CRP, LDH, ferritin and D-dimer levels while significantly lower hemoglobin and lymphocyte counts. (Table 4).
Table-4: Comparison of survivors and non-survivors. Laboratory values are initial values on hospital admission date.
|
Survivors (n=68)
|
Non-survivors (n=21)
|
p
|
Age
|
60,6 ± 14,5
|
68,1 ± 11,8
|
0,03
|
Co-morbidities (n)
Diabetes (n)
Hypertension (n)
Malignancy (n)
IHD/HF (n)
|
37
17
23
3
16
|
18
6
8
10
4
|
0,011
0,779
0,795
0,000
0,772
|
eGFR (ml/min/1,73 m2)
|
82,86 ± 16,15
|
82,03 ± 14,95
|
0,835
|
Peak creatinine (mg/dL)
|
1,48 ± 0,49
|
2,51 ± 0,87
|
0,000
|
AKI developed on (days)
|
5,93 ± 5,17
|
8,94 ± 5,71
|
0,053
|
AKI duration (days)
|
2,66 ± 3,45
|
5,76 ± 4,61
|
0,001
|
MAP (mmHg)
|
89,0 ± 14,1
|
88,0 ± 12,6
|
0,784
|
Hemoglobin (g/dL)
|
12,7 ± 1,5
|
10,8 ± 1,9
|
0,000
|
Lymphocytes (per μL)
|
1455 ± 667
|
819 ± 258
|
0,000
|
CRP (mg/L)
|
67,9 ± 68,5
|
127,3 ± 89,8
|
0,002
|
Prokalsitonin (ng/mL)
|
0,30 ± 0,92
|
0,63 ± 0,70
|
0,132
|
CK (IU/L)
|
292 ± 762
|
213 ± 260
|
0,651
|
LDH (IU/L)
|
357 ± 189
|
608 ± 558
|
0,002
|
Ferritin (ng/mL)
|
515 ± 475
|
1059 ± 757
|
0,000
|
D-dimer (mg/L)
|
1,04 ± 1,01
|
4,7± 5,09
|
0,000
|
Uric acid (mg/dL)
|
5,9 ± 2,1
|
4,8 ± 2,1
|
0,056
|
Duration of hospital stay (days)
|
12,9 ± 7,4
|
14,5 ± 7,6
|
0,397
|
AKI: Acute Kidney Injury, eGFR: estimated glomerular filtration rate, MAP: mean arterial pressure, CK: creatine kinase, LDH: lactate dehidrogenase