We suggest that Tonian extension, recorded by bimodal magmatism and rift-related sedimentation followed by passive margin sedimentation, would have opened a narrow ocean recorded by marginal ophiolites dated at ca. 0.82 Ga, breaking apart the greater São Francisco Craton/Benino-Nigerian Shield18 (Fig. 4A). This process pulled out crustal ribbons, such as the Pernambuco-Alagoas terrane (PEAL, Fig. 4A), from the cratonic margin by ca. 0.82 Ga15 and continued to 0.72-0.68 Ga with the last pulses of rifting recorded by the mafic-ultramafic intrusive rocks of the Canindé Group in the Southern Borborema Province16.
The break-up of the conjoined São Francisco Craton/Benino-Nigerian Shield during extension indicates that decratonization started already in the Early Neoproterozoic, in a manner akin to the Mesozoic decratonization of the North China Craton9, where extension associated with metasomatism10 transferred continental lithospheric mantle to the asthenosphere43 and facilitated continental breakup44. This hypothesis is supported by alkaline volcanism (e.g. kimberlites) in the northern SFC from 1150 to 680 Ma45,46.
The long-term effect of extension on lithospheric strength depends on the relative thinning of the crust in relation to the sub-continental lithospheric mantle (SCLM)47,48. Starting from a thick Archean lithosphere, as for the SFC49,50. Tonian thinning and refertilization of the SCLM (indicated by the alkaline volcanism), would have led to weakening that persisted long-after extension ended. Thus, the Tonian extensional event would have made sections of the cratonic paleocontinent amenable to subsequent reworking within the orogenic realm.
This weakened, decratonized lithosphere between the Benino-Nigerian Shield and the São Francisco Craton was reworked in two steps during the construction of the Borborema Province Orogen. The first step was a result of oblique continental collision with the West African Craton being thrust under the Benino-Nigerian Shield17,26,51,52. This was preceded by oceanic lithosphere subduction and magmatism in the aforementioned Santa Quiteria arc, and terminal collision led to the development of the dextral Transbrasiliano-Kandi strike-slip belt (Fig. 4B and C). The second step was a result of dextral movement on the Transbrasiliano-Kandi strike-slip belt. This movement brought the Benino-Nigerian Shield closer to the São Francisco Craton deforming the weakened decratonized area in between these two stiffer lithospheric domains leading to the transpressional Borborema Province Orogeny (see cross section in Fig. 4D).
The transcurrent shear zones that characterize the Borborema Province splayed out of the Transbrasiliano-Kandi shear zone23 and deformed the weakened cratonic margin. Deformation was a result of these two quasi-contemporaneous collisions23,26 (Fig. 4D). In the north part of the Borborema Province, old Paleoproterozoic and minor volumes of Archean rocks dominate and represent the southern continuation of the Benino-Nigerian Shield17 (north of the Patos shear zone in Figure 1B). To the south, the Borborema Province record the interaction of the decratonized lithosphere and the São Francisco Craton. In this region, the transcurrent shear zones wrenched the blocks of the northern margin of the São Francisco Craton that had been previously weakened by the Cariris Velho extension. Deformation included a number of continental ribbons (e.g. PEAL terrane) pulled away from the craton and the intervening Tonian sedimentary basins (Fig. 4C and D).
The exact geometry of the decratonized terrane at the start of wrenching, and the source region of individual blocks now embedded in the BP are generally unknown. However, using rock ages, isotopic and geophysical signatures, we have linked the Tonian-aged Afeicão domain and the ancient Entremontes block south of the Pernambuco shear zone, with the Tonian-age Alto Pajeú and the ancient Alto Moxotó terranes, north of the shear zone. This implies a ≈ 200 km dextral wrenching across the Pernambuco shear zone (Fig. 3). The rocks south of the shear zone record only incipient deformation, whereas those to the north are intensely strained into sigmoidal terranes, in harmony with the regional transcurrent deformation and geological-geophysical structure of this region.
It is also possible to recognize signatures of specific sections of the SFC in the old blocks now within the BP. For example, the geological features of the Gavião Block in the SFC can be found in blocks within the Central and Northern Borborema Province36,38,53. These features include rare occurrences of Paleoarchean rocks (>3.4 Ga) embedded in Neoarchean (2.8-2.6 Ga) to Paleoproterozoic (2.1-2.0 Ga) rocks imprinted by ca. 2.0 Ga high-grade metamorphism53,54. We conclude that deformation of craton margin blocks, such as the Entremontes block, into the sigmoidal-shaped Alto Moxotó terrane within the Borborema Province, illustrates how a number of other Archean-Paleoproterozoic blocks may have been pulled away from the original craton to form inliers within the orogeny. It is important to note, however, that dispersal of São Francisco Craton decratonized blocks was more effective along the southern and central zones of the Borborema Province, where evidence for Cariris Velhos extensional events has been better defined. The Benino-Nigerian Shield also comprises Paleoarchean rocks of ca. 3.5 Ga such as the Kaduna Massif55 that could be linked to the São José do Campestre Massif36 of the northern Borborema Province, unrelated to the orogenic dispersal of former cratonic fragments documented in the province’s southern and central zones.
Decratonization related to early to late Neoproterozoic extension and juvenile magmatism could have been widespread throughout West Gondwana, related to the break-up of Rodinia. For example, it might account for thinning of the cratonic lithosphere in the Ribeira and Araçuaí belts of southeastern Brazil56, decratonizing the eastern margin of the SFC, preparing it for later involvement in the transcurrent Brasiliano tectonics57. In the Araçuaí Belt fissural mafic magmatism preceded the opening of the Adamastor Ocean starting at 1.0 Ga58,59 with subsequent Tonian rift-related, A-type continental plutonism, dated at c. 0.87 Ga30. Further south, in the Dom Feliciano-Kaoko belt, rift-related siliciclastic and bimodal volcanic rocks preserved in the Neoproterozoic schist belts from both the Rio de la Plata/Paranapanema and Congo/Kalahari cratonic margins suggest a continental rifting phase between 0.9 and 0.78 Ga60. In the African side of these orogens (e.g. Gariep, Kaoko and Damara-Lufilian belts) extensional tectonics and breakup of surrounding cratons are also constrained to between 0.85 to 0.77 Ga61–63. These protracted extensional events preceding the Brasiliano/Panafrican orogens of coastal South America and their African equivalents, disrupted and weakened the surrounding cratons enabling orogenic reworking and transcurrent dispersal of old terranes such as the São Luiz, Curitiba, and Cabo Frio terranes64,65. The same could account for Archean/Paleoproterozoic lithosphere in the West Gondwana Orogen in Africa where c. 1.1-1.0 Ga extension in the Tuareg Shield allowed reworking during the Pan-African Orogeny2.
Global estimates for the construction of Gondwana between 0.5-0.6 Ga indicate only a minor mantle addition66, in accordance to our observations. This final stage of reworking and transcurrent tectonics was accompanied by abundant syn-transcurrent magmatism with dominant lithospheric mantle affinities67,68 from 590 to 560 Ma, but peaking at c. 580 Ma19. The orogenic collisional period of BP resulted in crustal thickening (>80 km), especially along the West Gondwana Orogen26, however, Rayleigh wave tomography indicate that this orogen are marked by thinner lithosphere69, thus suggesting that the orogenic roots have been delaminated after collision. The lithospheric mantle signatures of the 590 to 560 Ma syn-transcurrent and post-collisional magmatism may reflect the delamination of the orogenic lithosphere, resulting in low-viscosity zones that would facilitate lateral crustal flow70 leading to the processes of scape tectonics and terrane dispersion in the Borborema Province19 (cross section in Figure 4B). Finally, Ar-Ar colling ages and emplacement of poorly deformed to isotropic granitoids indicate slow cooling rates with continuous heat supply by the delamination process until the Cambrian (530-500 Ma)19.
We conclude that the cratonic roots of the São Francisco Craton/Benino-Nigerian Shield, responsible for craton integrity, were weakened by Tonian-age extension, similar to the evolution of the North China Craton where extension and alkaline magmatism provided a mechanism for decratonization. This created the conditions required for the involvement and dispersal of decratonized inliers within the Brasiliano orogen. We suggest that this may have been the general sequence of events for many of the Brasiliano/Panafrican orogens, where extension related to the break-up of cratonic masses and opening of oceanic realms with varying degrees of maturity were followed by convergence and wrench tectonics during Gondwana amalgamation.