3.1. Hydrogeological and hydrochemical characterization of the Beberibe aquifer
Figure 3 shows spatially the hydrogeological characterization of the groundwater of the Beberibe aquifer. Most of the artesian wells in the mineral water production units are close to the coast, a densely populated region (Figures 1 and 3). The artesian wells close to the coast are of porous geological formation, with the lowest altitudes (Figure 2), with flow variations from medium to very high. From the western portion of the study region, there is a fissural geological formation, considering the higher altitudes, with greater rocky extension and flow variations from medium to very high (Figures 2 and 3).
[INSERT TO FIGURE 3 HERE]
There is a specific homogeneous flow occurring close to the coastal region, categorized as “very high productivity” (Figure 3). The obtained result corroborates with the studies carried out by Hu et al. (2017) who analyzed the hydrogeological configuration of groundwater for the entire Brazilian territory and highlighted good water retention capacity for recharging and discharging aquifers. The authors also pointed out that the aquifers close to the Atlantic Ocean play a role as a “wall or barrier”, because the water tables in these regions always remain at the same level as the sea surface at the limits of the coast, thus maintaining better retention, which will lead to homogenization of water flow.
Although the original depth of the well is unknown, part of the water may come from shallower horizons (Pernambuco coast) and another part may come from the western region of the state, via deeper horizons, in superior topographic conditions. Such observations are in line with Silva et al. (2020), who studied the predominant hydrochemical mechanisms and processes that control the hydrochemistry of groundwater in a region of Acre, Northern Brazil, that regardless of the knowledge of the depth of the well, the origin of the water can come from different horizons, again highlighting the topographic conditions under the influence of a given region.
Figure 4 highlights the hydrochemical characterization of the groundwater in the Beberibe aquifer. It appears that in all of the sampled points (artesian wells), the waters are of the mixed bicarbonate type (Bm) and high potability for human consumption (IBGE, 2020). However, one should not only consider the hydrochemical reactions that occur in the Beberibe aquifer, but also the anthropic actions that occur in RMRE.
[INSERT TO FIGURE 4 HERE]
The composition of groundwater can provide relevant information about interactions in aquifers since hydrochemistry is the result of specific reactions related to rock-water interactions that vary within an aquifer unit (Teramoto et al., 2020). Consequently, the interpretation of aquifer mineralogy and water chemistry data may indicate the transport of groundwater within and between aquifers.
As recently highlighted by Teramoto et al. (2020), the hydrochemistry in the Guarani aquifer, due to its mixed bicarbonate composition, influences the geological formation of the porous type. This statement is confirmed in the present study since the geological composition is heterogeneous and presents an advanced state of decomposition, which implies a high variability of bicarbonates.
3.3. Descriptive statistics and geostatistics of the data
Table 2 shows the temporal variability based on descriptive statistics (see section 2.5), for the hydrochemical parameters of the mineral water in the Beberibe aquifer. According to the criteria of Warrick and Nielsen (1980), the CV% presented values of medium too high for all the studied variables, in which the average variation (14.77%) was only for the hydrogen potential (pH), for the other variables had a high variation, CV > 29%. All parameters showed normal distribution, according to the KS test at the level of 1% probability.
Table 2
Descriptive statistics of the hydrochemical parameters of mineral water.
Variable
|
Mean
|
Median
|
20Min
|
21Max
|
22CV
|
23SD
|
24A
|
25K
|
1NO3
|
4.53
|
1.29
|
0.15
|
43.25
|
195.14
|
8.83
|
3.52
|
12.91
|
2DR
|
66.17
|
57.90
|
20.00
|
124.98
|
42.13
|
27.87
|
0.61
|
-0.42
|
3pH
|
5.31
|
5.41
|
4.10
|
7.70
|
14.77
|
0.78
|
1.32
|
2.77
|
4SO4
|
3.77
|
2.03
|
0.00
|
18.25
|
105.64
|
3.98
|
2.54
|
6.32
|
5Na
|
9.21
|
8.69
|
5.00
|
19.94
|
29.44
|
2.71
|
2.04
|
6.59
|
6Ca
|
0.90
|
0.61
|
0.00
|
2.66
|
77.37
|
0.70
|
0.96
|
0.12
|
7Mg
|
1.44
|
1.00
|
0.40
|
5.30
|
77.84
|
1.12
|
2.04
|
4.03
|
8Cl
|
12.27
|
11.97
|
0.12
|
26.51
|
40.00
|
4.91
|
0.29
|
3.34
|
9K
|
4.29
|
4.65
|
0.00
|
10.45
|
81.45
|
3.50
|
0.17
|
-1.47
|
10Mn
|
0.03
|
0.00
|
0.00
|
0.85
|
485.27
|
0.15
|
5.75
|
33.30
|
11F
|
0.04
|
0.00
|
0.00
|
0.85
|
361.79
|
0.15
|
5.51
|
31.31
|
12Zn
|
0.01
|
0.01
|
0.00
|
0.08
|
166.80
|
0.02
|
2.51
|
6.71
|
13Fe
|
0.06
|
0.02
|
0.00
|
0.38
|
186.85
|
0.11
|
2.27
|
3.93
|
14EC
|
86.88
|
78.70
|
40.00
|
197.00
|
41.64
|
36.18
|
1.68
|
3.14
|
15Hn
|
9.68
|
7.13
|
4.86
|
30.50
|
62.85
|
6.08
|
1.82
|
3.36
|
16HCO3
|
8.94
|
8.48
|
0.00
|
22.87
|
71.13
|
6.36
|
0.40
|
-0.70
|
17Si
|
13.43
|
13.99
|
0.00
|
43.66
|
66.33
|
8.91
|
0.89
|
2.71
|
18Sr
|
0.01
|
0.01
|
0.00
|
0.05
|
143.13
|
0.01
|
1.85
|
3.28
|
19Ba
|
0.04
|
0.01
|
0.00
|
0.23
|
138.00
|
0.06
|
1.62
|
2.78
|
1NO3: Nitrate; 2DR: Evaporative resistance; 3pH: Hydrogen potential; 4SO4: Sulfate; 5Na: Sodium; 6Ca: Calcium; 7Mg: Magnesium; 8Cl: Chlorine; 9K: Potassium; 10Mn: Manganese; 11F: Fluorine; 12Zn: Zinc; 13Fe: Iron; 14EC: Electrical conductivity; 15Hn: Hardness; 16HCO3: Bicarbonate; 17Si: Silicon; 18Sr: Strontium; 19Ba: Barium; 20Min: Minimum; 21Max: Maximo; 22CV: Coefficient of variation; 23SD: Standard deviation; 24A: Asymmetry; and 25K: Kurtosis. |
The variability between the medium and high categories is mainly due to the hydrogeological and hydrochemical diversity, which in turn occurs in the geological formation of rocks and which has a direct impact on the chemistry of groundwater (IBGE, 2018; IBGE, 2020). The results obtained corroborate those mentioned by Yang et al. (2020), where they investigated the hydrochemical composition of groundwater to highlight its quality and assess its risk/suitability for irrigation purposes in the Ordos Basin, China, they identified high CV% for all variables studied, except for the pH, where the CV% presented a value referring to the medium variability.
The highest CV% indicated that the ions were sensitive to the external environment, such as hydrological conditions, topography, and anthropogenic activities, as discussed by Yang et al. (2020). Another key factor is pH, which according to Liu et al. (2018), in a study of the dynamic characteristics of groundwater in the valley plain of the city of Lhasa (capital of the Autonomous Region of Tibet), the low CV% indicated that the pH of groundwater tends to be relatively stable, which differs from the present study, in which the pH was not stable and CV% is admitted with medium variability, according to the criterion of Warrick and Nielsen (1980) - (Table 2).
The pH according to the standards established in Table 1 and compliance with the minimum values recorded in Table 2, presented low standards, indicative of points of distribution of acidic mineral water for human health. High concentrations of NO3 were observed in some mineral water distribution points, therefore, outside the limits established by Brazilian legislation (Table 1), probably caused by the socio-economic development of the study region, as highlighted earlier by Liu et al. (2018).
The electrical conductivity (EC) showed high CV%, due to the oscillation of salinity in urban areas (natural effect due to the rock/soil factor, and anthropization), such variations are characteristics of low permeability and low hydraulic gradient, due to the dilution effect salts during the rainy season and evaporation in the dry season. The results similar to those obtained by Tlili-Zrelli et al. (2015), they studied the hydrogeochemistry of groundwater in an alluvial aquifer in northern Tunisia, where the zones of low permeability and low hydraulic gradient, occur due to the dilution effect of salts during the rainy season and evaporation during the dry season, which favors a high variability in the levels of salts diluted in the water due to the climate and the greater and/or less water availability.
The analysis of the spatial variability for the hydrochemical parameters is shown in Table 3. All the parameters evaluated, the Gaussian model was the one that best fit, which is indicated for studies of groundwater. The highlight for the coefficient R2 with variations between 0.6 to 0.99.
Table 3
Analysis of spatial variability followed by adjusted semivariograms for the hydrochemical parameters of mineral water.
20Var
|
21Mo
|
22C0
|
23C0+C
|
24a
|
25R2
|
26C0
|
27DSD
|
Jack-Knifing
|
(C0+C)
|
28m
|
29SD
|
1NO3
|
Gau
|
2.000
|
10.500
|
25000.000
|
0.800
|
19.047
|
Ft
|
-0.082
|
1.017
|
2DR
|
Gau
|
90.000
|
1396.000
|
4886.115
|
0.849
|
6.446
|
Ft
|
0.006
|
1.007
|
3pH
|
Gau
|
0.128
|
1.975
|
14440.107
|
0.933
|
6.481
|
Ft
|
0.070
|
0.998
|
4SO4
|
Gau
|
0.200
|
3.000
|
100.000
|
0.599
|
6.667
|
Ft
|
-0.087
|
1.113
|
5Na
|
Gau
|
3.000
|
18.900
|
20000.000
|
0.728
|
15.873
|
Ft
|
0.012
|
1.044
|
6Ca
|
Gau
|
0.120
|
0.491
|
417.424
|
0.713
|
24.439
|
Ft
|
-0.048
|
1.041
|
7Mg
|
Gau
|
0.136
|
1.292
|
3360.178
|
0.908
|
10.526
|
Ft
|
-0.011
|
0.940
|
8Cl
|
Gau
|
5.000
|
28.000
|
13000.000
|
0.701
|
17.857
|
Ft
|
0.050
|
1.049
|
9K
|
Gau
|
4.000
|
22.000
|
5000.000
|
0.708
|
18.182
|
Ft
|
0.029
|
1.061
|
10Mn
|
Gau
|
1.50E-05
|
1.54E-04
|
16956.777
|
0.657
|
9.740
|
Ft
|
0.027
|
1.081
|
11F
|
Gau
|
1.00E-06
|
1.00E-02
|
1000.000
|
0.989
|
0.010
|
Ft
|
-0.056
|
1.112
|
12Zn
|
Gau
|
2.00E-04
|
0.724
|
8861.172
|
0.935
|
0.027
|
Ft
|
0.049
|
1.032
|
13Fe
|
Gau
|
1.00E-6
|
0.002
|
169.741
|
0.917
|
4.234E-4
|
Ft
|
0.017
|
1.028
|
14EC
|
Gau
|
80.000
|
557.100
|
2468.172
|
0.961
|
14.360
|
Ft
|
-0.057
|
1.070
|
15Hn
|
Gau
|
12.000
|
60.000
|
12500.000
|
0.790
|
20.000
|
Ft
|
0.017
|
1.071
|
16HCO3
|
Gau
|
25.000
|
110.000
|
4200.000
|
0.812
|
22.727
|
Ft
|
0.023
|
1.053
|
17Si
|
Gau
|
50.000
|
210.000
|
7000.000
|
0.905
|
23.810
|
Ft
|
0.049
|
1.004
|
18Sr
|
Gau
|
5.00E-06
|
7.30E-05
|
803.671
|
0.867
|
6.849
|
Ft
|
-0.053
|
1.246
|
19Ba
|
Gau
|
8.00E-04
|
0.021
|
4588.202
|
0.630
|
3.810
|
Ft
|
-0.010
|
1.080
|
1NO3: Nitrate; 2DR: Evaporative resistance; 3pH: Hydrogen potential; 4SO4: Sulfate; 5Na: Sodium; 6Ca: Calcium; 7Mg: Magnesium; 8Cl: Chlorine; 9K: Potassium; 10Mn: Manganese; 11F: Fluorine; 12Zn: Zinc; 13Fe: Iron; 14EC: Electrical conductivity; 15Hn: Hardness; 16HCO3: Bicarbonate; 17Si: Silicon; 18Sr: Strontium; 19Ba: Barium; 20Var: Variable; 21Mo: Model; 22C0: Nugget effect; 23C0+C: Sill; 24a: Range; 25R2: Coefficient of determination; 26C0/(C0+C): Degree of spatial dependence (%); 27DSD: Class of the degree of spatial dependence; 28m: Mean; 29SD: Standard deviation; Gau: Gaussian; Ft: Strong. |
Yin et al. (2019), analyzed geostatistically the hydrochemical variations and the causes of NO3 pollution of groundwater in a plain in southern Beijing, China. They highlighted the need for interactions between the transitive theoretical models to validate the best for each parameter. However, in the present study, cross-validation by Jack-Knifing (Vauclin et al., 1983) was applied, were all established semivariograms presented the mean close to 0 and the standard deviation close to 1, and thus used in kriging maps for each studied hydrochemical variable (Table 3).
The DSD was strong for all the parameters analyzed, which indicates that the value of each parameter associated with a given location, was more similar to the value of a neighboring sample than to the rest of the location of the sample set, which reinforces the validation of the Gaussian model for the studied hydrochemical variables (Cambardella et al., 1994).
Figure 6 illustrates the spatial distribution of the hydrochemical parameters of the mineral water sources in the Beberibe aquifer in the study area. Based on the semivariograms, kriging of the maps was performed, according to each model generated for the hydrochemical variables of the groundwater, implementing the nugget effect, level, and range of each model.
[INSERT TO FIGURE 6 HERE]
NO3 concentrations occurred mainly on the coast of Pernambuco, with an emphasis on the municipalities of Recife and Olinda (Figure 6). In both municipalities, the NO3 concentrations were higher, mainly because these municipalities have a high population density and have a high flow of tourists, vegetable cultivation near rivers (causing eutrophication), as well as the holding of major cultural events, such as Carnival in the city of Recife and Olinda, Brazil, considered cities that host the carnival festival with the largest flow of people in the world, with an average of 1 million people a day. Within this theme, one of the factors that imply high concentrations of NO3 is caused by the high pollution generated by tourists and the consequent contamination of the main rivers, highlighting Capibaribe, Beberibe, and Tejipió.
Also noteworthy is the fact that the city of Recife is among the 10 largest Brazilian metropolises, with a population of 1.555 million inhabitants, according to the IBGE - (IBGE, 2020). In this context, the rate of pollution generated in the urban centers of the metropolis, associated with the lack of sanitation in neighborhoods, provides for the contamination of rivers, which in turn contribute to recharge the aquifer, which implies the contamination of groundwater and the increase of NO3 concentration. Therefore, there is still the spread of waterborne diseases, mainly diarrhea, typhoid fever, hepatitis A, leptospirosis, cholera, and intestinal infections, caused by bacteria.
Concomitant with NO3 concentrations, it is observed in the maps of the hydrochemical variables that the evaporative resistance (DR), sodium (Na), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), chlorine (Cl), electrical conductivity (EC), hardness (Hn) and strontium (Sr), presented higher concentrations in the places with the highest concentration of NO3 (Figure 6). From the coast that comprises the municipality of Recife and Olinda, it is where the greatest concentrations of these elements are found, among them are heavy metals and EC, which is associated with greater contractions of soluble solids in water, which in turn correlate with anthropic pollution.
Corroborating the findings of the present study, Bodrud-Doza et al. (2016), carried out the characterization of groundwater quality based on water assessment indices, multivariate statistics, and geostatistics in central Bangladesh, and concluded that anthropogenic factors (e.g., industrial pollution, inadequate garbage discharge, inadequate sanitation) contribute groundwater quality. Bhuiyan et al. (2016) also assessed the groundwater quality of the Lakhimpur district in Bangladesh based on water quality indices, geostatistical methods, and multivariate analysis pointed out that a kriging method is an effective tool for decision-makers on groundwater quality management.
It is noteworthy that the hydrogeological formation also contributes to NO3 concentrations. It appears that the Pernambuco coast has a hydrogeological formation of the mixed bicarbonate type (Figure 4), which because of this, there is a high variability (> CV%) of the hydrochemical elements of groundwater (Table 2). This mixed diversity of bicarbonate can also be considered as one of the factors for this high concentration of NO3, as such regions are common of fissural geological formation, which in turn reflects and a greater tendency for contamination of these waters.
According to the Ministério da Saúde (1999), Ministério da Saúde (2006), and CETESB (2016), concentrations of NO3, DR, Na, Ca, Mg, Cl, EC, Hn and Sr, only NO3 and Cl did not comply with Brazilian legislation, with values higher than allowed (Table 1). However, to the west of the coast, values were observed within the limits allowed for NO3 and Cl, which reinforces the anthropogenic impact in the coastal region (Figure 6). Corroborating the findings of Yin et al. (2019), who claim that industrial areas and intense urbanization promote greater groundwater pollution by NO3.
The pH of groundwater on the coast met the acceptable standard for human health (pH between 6 and 9), with variations between acid to alkaline (pH between 6.4 and 7.6) (Ministério da Saúde, 1999; Ministério da Saúde, 2006; CETESB, 2016). However, the west region of the coast had a pH < 6 (Figure 6). Abu-alnaeem et al. (2018), evaluated the salinity and quality of groundwater in the Gaza coastal aquifer, Gaza Strip in Palestine, and highlighted that acidity and alkalinity close to neutralization, is derived from the dissolution of carbonate minerals in the form of bicarbonate (HCO3−). Corroborating the statement of the aforementioned authors, the coastal region of the present study, to the east, showed pH with variations between acid and alkaline, still because it presents mixed bicarbonate hydrogeological formation (Figure 4).
The elements SO4, K, Mn, F, Zn, Fe, HCO3, Si, Sr and Ba were the elements that had the highest concentrations west of the coast (Figure 6). This study region was also the one with the lowest pH. It is noteworthy that only the elements SO4, F, Zn, and Ba, presented concentrations within the quality standards for human consumption (Ministério da Saúde, 1999; Ministério da Saúde, 2006; CETESB, 2016). The elements K, Mn, and Fe showed values above that allowed by current legislation. HCO3, Si, and Sr, on the other hand, do not have a defined quality standard.
Hossain and Patra, (2020) carried out a contamination zoning and health risk assessment of trace elements in groundwater utilizing geostatistical modeling and reported that pH controls chemistry, which is a component that influences the hydrochemical standards of water and, thus, corroborates with the observations of the present study, in which the elements K, Mn, and Fe presented higher values for the region of lower pH.
3.4. Principal component analysis (PCA)
The PCA presents the eigenvalue, the proportion, and the accumulation of the total variance for all variables studied (Table 4). The cumulative total variance for principal component 2 (PC2) was 49.61%, a significant result for the analyzed data set. According to the criteria established by Kaiser (1958), PC1 and PC2 presented their eigenvalues greater than 1, which indicated a significant information load and, thus, generate the biplot graphs.
Table 4
Principal components of the hydrochemical parameters of mineral water.
Components
|
Eigenvalue
|
Proportion (%)
|
Cumulative (%)
|
PC1
|
6.30
|
33.14
|
33.14
|
PC2
|
3.13
|
16.46
|
49.61
|
PC: Principal component. |
Yang et al. (2016) carried out the identification of hydrogeochemical processes and assessment of groundwater quality in the southeastern part of the Ordos basin in China, based on the PCA and obtained total cumulative variance for the PC2, of 59.26%, which is higher than the study.
In Figure 7, the PC’s biplot chart stands out and Pearson correlation of the hydrochemical parameters of the mineral water of the Beberibe aquifer in the study area, referring to the municipalities of Recife, Olinda, Paulista, Camaragibe, São Lourenço da Mata, and Paudalho.
[INSERT TO FIGURE 7 HERE]
For the PC's, the 19 studied variables (NO3; DR; pH; SO4; Na; Ca; Mg; Cl; K; Mn; F; Zn; Fe; EC; Hn; HCO3; Si; Sr and Ba) were admitted and the correlated points refer to the artesian sample collection wells (A01 to A34). The variables DR, Na, Ca, Mg, Cl, EC, Hn, and Sr, showed a correlation with NO3, as observed in kriging maps (Figure 7A). However, it is noteworthy that among the observed correlations, Cl was the one with the highest correlation with NO3, in which, the Cl projection line follows the NO3 line, which characterizes this strong correlation (Figure 7B).
Similar results were found by Cao et al. (2020), where they studied the heterogeneity of an aquifer in a region of France, through PCA and observed a high correlation between Cl and NO3. The same results were found by Ayed et al. (2017), where they performed a hydrochemical characterization of groundwater using PCA for the southeastern region of Tunisia, and observed the same correlation between Cl and NO3.
To clarify more precisely the correlations between the variables, Pearson's correlation was applied, where the correlation was significant between Cl and NO3 (Figure 7B). Corroborating the findings of this study, Ayed et al. (2017) also observed a strong correlation between Cl and NO3.