One of the salient findings from the screening is that catechols and redox-related quinones/anthraquinones represent a broad class of amyloid inhibitors. As shown in Fig. 1A, these molecules made up a substantial portion of the identified strong inhibitors, which were defined as exhibiting greater than three standard deviation units below the ThT RFU observed for buffer treated individual amyloidogenic protein controls (dotted line). Fully 13 out of 41 strong inhibitors (32%) for amylin, 11 out of 22 (50%) for tau (2N4R isoform), and 14 out of 29 (48%) for Aβ were catechols or quinone/anthraquinones (highlighted as red dots). In the screens against amylin amyloid, out of 22 catechols and quinones/anthraquinones from the NIHCC library, 21 of them exhibited significant amyloid inhibitory activities (Table S1) with isoproterenol being the exception, with only a weak inhibitory effect. The majority of these catechols and quinones/anthraquinones (16 out of 22 drugs) were further validated by an orthogonal biochemical assay, Photo-Induced Cross-linking of Unmodified Proteins (PICUP), which identified cross-linked oligomers (Figs. S1B and S3A), or by a biophysical method, transmission electron microscopy (TEM; Fig. 1C, Fig. S1C and Table S1).
Similar with amylin screening results, 17 out of 22 catechols and quinones/anthraquinones showed significant activities against tau 2N4R amyloid (Table S2), with a majority of them further validated by a ThT fluorescence-based tau amyloid remodeling assay, accomplished by spiking testing compounds into pre-formed tau amyloids (Fig. S3B). Fully 18 out of 22 catechols and quinones/anthraquinones exhibited significant inhibition against Aβ amyloid, with nine of them validated previously by assays including TEM and atomic force microscopy (AFM) (Table S3). Chemical structures of catechols and quinones/anthraquinones of the top hits are shown (Fig. S2). Numerous hits such as idarubicin (Compound #318), daunorubicin (Compound #321), and rifapentine (Compound #601), showed strong inhibitory effects to all three amyloidogenic proteins (boxed red dots in Fig. 1A), whereas a few hits displayed preferential inhibition, such as rutin (Compound #548; Tables S1-S3), which preferentially inhibited amylin amyloid formation.
To test the hypothesis whether the catechol functional group alone inhibits amyloid formation, we tested catechol in secondary assays and compared it with its control analog phenol. Catechol demonstrated moderate, yet significant activities in amylin amyloid inhibition in both ThT fluorescence assays and TEM analyses, whereas phenol showed no such inhibitory effects in both assays (Figs. 1B and 1C). These data demonstrate that the catechol functional moiety possesses general anti-amyloid activities. Our finding is supported not only by individual catechol-containing inhibitor examples (Caruana et al, 2011; Sato et al, 2013; Velander et al, 2016; Wu et al, 2017), but also by a large-scale computational data mining study: In a fragment-based combinatorial library screening to identify molecular scaffolds to target certain amyloidogenic proteins in neurodegeneration (Joshi et al, 2016), the catechol group was identified as the fragment with the highest observed occurrence, present in nearly 4,500 compounds among the 16,850 (27%) in the Aβ small molecule library.
Another class of chemical structures enriched in our screens was the anthraquinones/quinones (redox-related to catechols) and tetracyclines. Anthraquinones were previously observed to inhibit tau aggregation (Pickhardt et al, 2005) and quinones were reported to inhibit insulin oligomerization as well as fibril formation (Gong et al, 2014). With respect to tetracycline, our screen revealed that several variants were active in amyloid inhibition. This class of compounds was reported to also inhibit Aβ and β2-microglobulin amyloid fibrils (Forioni et al, 2001; Giorgetti et al, 2010).
Based on the fact that catechol-containing compounds and multiple anthraquinone/quinone compounds (redox related to catechols) exhibited strong anti-amyloid activities, we hypothesized that catechol autoxidation may be part of the general mechanism that significantly enhances the anti-amyloid activities of the catechol-containing compounds. To test this hypothesis, we compared the anti-amyloid activities of a collection of oxidized (or aged - exposed to the air for 48 hours) with non-oxidized (non-aged or freshly prepared) catechol-containing compounds. In virtually all cases, aged samples exhibited significantly greater activities than their identically prepared non-aged counterparts (Fig. 2A). Oxidation-induced activity enhancement was not observed with phenol nor a structurally similar but non-catechol amyloid inhibitor, morin. These combined results strongly suggested a catechol-dependent enhancement specificity, which was recapitulated under stringently defined aerobic/anaerobic conditions using an anaerobic chamber. Aerobic, but not anaerobic conditions, significantly enhanced anti-amyloid activities of several catecholamines and other catechol-containing inhibitors (Fig. 2D). The kinetic profiles of ThT fluorescence-based amylin amyloid inhibition showed significantly stronger inhibition with aged RA versus non-aged RA, with an even more dramatic inhibition activity enhancement was observed with aged norepinephrine (Figs. 2B & 2C). Consistently, enhanced inhibition by norepinephrine occurred only under aerobic conditions (Fig. 2E), with marked reduction in fibril formation (Fig. 2F).
Multiple small molecule amyloid inhibitors, many of which are catechol-containing polyphenols, perturb or “remodel” unaggregated and/or pre-aggregated amyloid species into denaturant-resistant aggregates that displayed broad-range molecular weights; characterized as “smear-type” distributions on SDS-PAGE gels (Ehrnhoefer et al, 2008; Hong et al, 2008; Bieschke et al, 2010; Palhano et al, 2013; Wu et al, 2017). Using RA and norepinephrine as two representative cases, treatment with a reducing reagent such as cysteine nearly eliminated their amyloid remodeling activities in a dose dependent manner (Figs. 3A & 3B). Similar effect was observed with glutathione and cystamine as well, and importantly, with other catechol-containing compounds including epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG) and dopamine, but not negative controls phenol and a non-catechol amyloid inhibitor, curcumin (Fig. 3C).
The chemical changes that occur during autoxidation were investigated by both UV-Vis and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) approaches. UV-Vis time course spectra confirmed that chemical changes were only detectable under aerobic conditions, and occurred coincidently with their enhanced anti-amyloid activities (Fig. 4A; highlighted by green asterisks). Such chemical changes were reflected in broad UV absorption spectra changes, particularly in the region of 300–350 nm (Fig. 4A). In an effort to identify the oxidized chemical species that contribute to the enhanced amyloid inhibition, we performed LC-MS analyses of aged norepinephrine. New species/peaks with increasing ion intensities over time (elution was collected at 0–96 hours) were detected in LC at the elution time between 0.85 min – 1.0 min (Fig. 4B). High-resolution MS identified four main ions within the norepinephrine sample (m/z peaks at 162.0548, 164.0715, 182.0458, and 301.1037 in Fig. 4B). While the known oxidized product of norepinephrine, noradrenochrome (C8H5NO3, 164.0342, [M + H]+) was anticipated product (Jimenez et al, 1984; Manini et al, 2007), the mass difference of 0.0373 from the observed 164.0715 does not support its presence. Thus all species remain unidentified. These ions may result from the acidic conditions of the LC separation as well as in-source reactions that may occur during the ionization process. Hence the features observed by LC-MS are presently considered signatures of the oxidation process and not the inhibitory species present in solution at neutral buffered pH. Nonetheless, these ions were present in the time course of autoxidation that correlate with norepinephrine anti-amyloid activities as exhibited by both ThT and TEM assays (Figs. 2E & 2F). These data agree well with studies that showed catecholamine oxidation products were effective anti-amyloidogenic agents against α-synuclein (Li et al, 2004) and tau (Soeda et al, 2015). Collectively, our data demonstrate that autoxidation is a general pathway enhancing the anti-amyloid activities of catechol-containing compounds (Fig. 4C). In supporting this covalent inhibition model, we demonstrated the covalent conjugate adduct by high resolution mass spectrometry in our specific investigation on baicalein (Velander et al, 2016). Redox state is therefore a key factor that modulates the activities of a large number of catechol-containing amyloid inhibitors.