In this study we examined the expression of 235 proteins and 60 phospho-proteins in
tumors from 80 patients diagnosed with lung adenocarcinomas. We identified 56 proteins
and phospho-proteins likely to impact the patient outcome. When stratifying the samples
according to mutations in the genes TP53, EGFR or KRAS, more proteins were associated with PFS in samples without mutations. This was also
seen when analyzing the corresponding mRNA data. When we compared proteins associated
with progression in never-smokers and former/current smokers, no overlapping proteins
were found, confirming the differences between these groups of lung cancer. Cluster analysis identified a small subcluster containing 11 patients enriched with
tumors of the PP subtype, recognized with early relapse, low expression of PKC isozymes,
and increased expression of neuroendocrine markers.
Cluster analysis
Based on the expression of 295 proteins, unsupervised hierarchical clustering separated
the samples into four subclusters. However, pathological stage, smoking status, or
mutations in the genes TP53, KRAS or EGFR did not seem to impact the clustering. Interestingly, the four subclusters were significantly
correlated with the molecular subtypes TRU, PP and PI. Previous work using protein
expression identified six subgroups of adenocarcinoma, where the subgroups partially
overlapped with the three mRNA-derived subtypes. The PP subtype was further divided
into two groups [
9
</a>], which also was seen in our data set. Subcluster 2a, enriched with PP subtype samples,
was recognized with lower expression of members of the mTOR pathway and the MAPK pathway.
This is in line with previous finding where TRU samples are associated with higher
expression of these proteins when compared to PP samples [<a href="#_ENREF_15">
15
</a>]. Interestingly, cluster analysis performed on mRNAs corresponding to the proteins,
grouped the samples with PP subtype from the protein-derived subcluster 2a together,
but not the non-PP subtypes. However, the distinct pattern with very low expressed
proteins within subcluster 2a, was not reflected using mRNA data. This can be explained
with a lower correlation between phosphorylated proteins and the corresponding genes.
Nine of the 11 samples within subcluster 2a showed a positive staining for synaptophysin
which are considered as a neuroendocrine marker and can be used to confirm the diagnosis
[<a href="#_ENREF_16">
16
</a>]. In total, all the 11 samples showed positive staining for at least one of the neuroendocrine
marker or NSE. In a recent study on NSCLCs, a molecular subgroup enriched with PP
subtype and shorter survival was identified. These samples had a mixed histology predominantly
with adenocarcinomas with molecular expression pattern associated with neuroendocrine
tumors [<a href="#_ENREF_15">
15
</a>]. LCNEC (large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma) can share some of the same pathological
features as adenocarcinomas, and LCNEC with areas of adenomatous differentiations
(mixed LCNEC) is described. Both pure LCNEC and mixed LCNEC tumors exhibit an aggressive
behavior and are associated with poor survival [<a href="#_ENREF_17">
17
</a>] as seen within subcluster 2a in our analyses. </p>
The hierarchical clustering performed on 186 mRNA samples resulted in a significantly
different distribution of the molecular subtypes between the clusters, although the
PI samples did not cluster together. Of note, the overlap between the genes used
for the original sub-typing [
8
</a>] and our clustering based on protein expression was sparse (n=18), indicating that
the proteins included in our analysis seem to be important for the subtypes. Both
the TRU- and PP-subtype clustered based on our mRNA data, and we suggest that the
TRU- and PP- subtypes are more distinct subtypes compared to PI. In a large meta-study,
the TRU subtype was identified as the most prognostically important subtype compared
to the non-TRU subtype, arguing for the need to identify additional classifiers [<a href="#_ENREF_18">
18
</a>]. </p>
Protein kinase C levels associated with survival
The protein kinase C is a group of enzymes known to be involved in diverse cellular
functions, including cell proliferation, apoptosis and cell migration, and has been
regarded as an onco-protein. The members of the PKC-family are encoded from nine different
genes which have several known splice variants. Recent work has demonstrated that
these proteins may have a more complex role than first assumed, which is supported
by the many failed clinical trials for cancer using PKC-inhibitors. In addition, mutational
studies have revealed that most cancers have loss of function (LOF) mutations in genes
belonging to the PKC-family, suggesting a tumor suppressor role for the proteins [
19
</a>, <a href="#_ENREF_20">
20
</a>]. A meta-study on the use of PKC-inhibitors combined with chemotherapy in lung cancer
patients reported decreased response rate and disease control, compared to chemotherapy
alone [<a href="#_ENREF_21">
21
</a>]. In our study, low expression of PKC-α, and phophorylated PKC-α, PKC-βII and PKC-δ
were associated with poor PFS. In addition, the levels of the PKC isozymes were strikingly
lower in subcluster 2a which also contained the samples with the overall poorest PFS.
An association with low expression of PKC- δ and decreased relapse free survival was
confirmed in the LUAD TCGA samples. Low levels of PKC-α, and phophorylated PKC-α and
PKC-δ in subtype PP were also found in the TCGA samples. This support the findings
in the Oslo cohort, with poor PFS and low expression of the isozymes of PKC in subgroup
2a containing mainly PP samples. Unfortunately, sparse information on mutational status,
reduced number of proteins analyzed, short follow-up time, limited further validation
on the TCGA samples. </p>
Thus, with regard to the classical role of the PKC-family, our results suggest a general
tendency towards a tumor suppressor role for PKC-α, PKC-βII and PKC-δ in NSCLC.
In the EGFR mutated samples, PKC-δ levels positively correlated to patient survival. It has been
reported that an activation of PKC-δ can be promoted by an activated EGFR [
22
</a>]. Further, activation of PKC-δ may induce apoptosis and growth arrest resulting in
reduced tumorigenesis [<a href="#_ENREF_23">
23
</a>]. As a response to DNA damage, it has been shown that over-expression of p53 increases
the transcription of PKC-δ resulting in apoptosis. This may explain the significant
correlation we discovered between expression of PKC-δ and PFS in <em>TP53</em> wild type samples, but not in the <em>TP53</em> mutated samples. These results were also reflected by gene expression data. It’s
been demonstrated that PKC can phosphorylate many oncoproteins to suppress their activity,
including KRas, PI3K and several tyrosine kinase receptors [<a href="#_ENREF_24">
24
</a>]. The oncoprotein KRas, recognized with activating mutations in cancer, can be suppressed
by activated PKC, which is proposed as a novel approach to target KRas [<a href="#_ENREF_25">
25
</a>]. A negative correlation between KRas and PKC-α was recently described in colorectal
cancer. Further, low expression of PKC-α was also associated with poor prognosis [<a href="#_ENREF_26">
26
</a>]. This is in concordance with our results, where high levels of PKC-α was associated
with better PFS in <em>KRAS</em> mutated samples, whereas PKC-δ showed a higher correlation to PFS in those with <em>KRAS</em> wild type. Interestingly, no isozymes of PKC did influence on survival in never-smoking
patients, further supporting this group as a distinct lung cancer disease driven by
other mechanisms. </p>
This leads to the hypothesis that PKC may also have an essential role keeping oncoproteins
in check [
24
</a>]. Based on our results, we suggest that the association to PFS for the different
PKC- isozymes is connected to mutational and smoking status. Results from gene expression
analysis performed on 186 NSCLC samples strengthen these observations.</p>
Proteins associated with PFS in subgroups of NSCLC
Interestingly, high expression of B7-H3, a molecule involved in immune checkpoint
signaling, was correlated to poor outcome in our study, especially in smokers, those
without any detected mutations in KRAS or TP53, and in those harboring an EGFR mutation. B7-H3 is a molecule known to inhibit T-cell activation in an immune suppressive
manner. This protein has been shown to be linked to poor survival in cancer, and have
been suggested as a new immune checkpoint target [
27
</a>]. In a recent study of lung cancer patients, expression of B7-H3 was associated with
overall survival only in smokers [<a href="#_ENREF_28">
28
</a>]. This indicates that future anti-B7-H3 therapy may have higher success rate among
ever smoking lung cancer patients with <em>KRAS</em> or <em>TP53</em> wild type tumors, or an <em>EGFR</em> mutation.</p>
Within subcluster 2a, eight proteins were significantly associated with PFS, where
low expression of myosin II showed the highest correlation with better PFS. This is
also supported by a protein study on early stage lung cancer where myosin IIa was
reported to be upregulated in stage Ia/Ib lung cancer patients with early relapse
[
29
</a>]. Interestingly, low expression of YAP, phosphorylated YAP(s127) and phosphorylated
HSP27(s82) were associated with increased PFS in subcluster 2a. It has been shown
that high expression of HSP27 leads to less phosphorylated YAP(s127). Further, phosphorylation
of YAP on S127 decreased the activity of YAP since this prevent its translocation
to the nucleus [<a href="#_ENREF_30">
30
</a>]. This also means that un-phosporylated YAP promotes tumor aggressiveness and is
related to poor prognosis which is in line with our study. These finding highlight
the central role HSP27 has in several pathways, including the Hippo pathway. </p>
Correlation analysis between mRNA and protein expression
Spearman Rank correlation revealed a high correlation (R >0.3) between expression
levels of almost half of the proteins and mRNAs. Previous studies have reported that
much of the variation in mean-level protein expression can be explained by variation
in mRNA expression [
31
</a>, <a href="#_ENREF_32">
32
</a>]. However, the variance in the proteomes across different tissue types can poorly
be explained by the mRNA levels, highlighting a tissue-specific posttranscriptional
regulation of gene expression. In a study of lung cancer, proteins involved in metabolic
and translational pathways were highly correlated with mRNA expression, whereas proteins
involved in extracellular matrix and adhesion, were not correlated or anti-correlated
[<a href="#_ENREF_32">
32
</a>]. In a study of breast cancer, 35% of the proteins correlated significantly (R >
0.3) with mRNA expression. The proteins, Cyclin B1, cyclin E1, 4E-BP1, PKC-α and RAB 25 were highly correlated with mRNA expression in breast cancer
[<a href="#_ENREF_33">
33
</a>]. This is in line with our study, where these proteins showed a high correlation
value (Rho > 0.6). Interestingly, HER2 was highly correlated in the breast cancer
study across all subtypes, but this protein was poorly correlated with mRNA expression
in our lung study (Rho =0.17). On the other hand, EGFR revealed Rho=0.72 in our study,
while in breast cancer a correlation between R=0.15 - 0.3 was found. This indicates
that genes known to be deregulated in a specific cancer type may be regulated by other
mechanisms. Proteins such as p53, CDKN1B, and MAPK14 showed very low correlation with the mRNA expression both in our
study on lung cancer and in the breast cancer study [<a href="#_ENREF_33">
33
</a>]. Lack of synergy between the level of proteins and mRNAs measured in the cells can
have several explanations including copy number aberrations, miRNA expression and
methylation.</p>
Conclusion
These results demonstrate that essential mutations in lung carcinomas affect several
proteins associated with outcome. Based on our results, expression of PKCα and phosphorylated
PKCα, PKCβ, and PKCδ seem to be positively associated with PFS, with different isozymes
linked to smoking and mutational status of EGFR, KRAS and TP53. These results illustrate the need to better understand the biological context in
order to further improve targeted therapy in cancer. This study supports that a therapy
restoring the level of specific isozymes of PKC activity may be beneficial for subgroups
of lung cancer patients based on the genetic background. We identified a subgroup
of samples enriched with the molecular subtype PP, recognized with early relapse,
increased expression of neuroendocrine markers, and a distinct protein expression
pattern, including low levels of PKC isozymes. These patients may benefit from a more
aggressive treatment regimen. Proteins associated with PFS among never smokers were
strikingly different compared to the other investigated subgroups. This is not surprising,
but underscores the need for a more stratified therapy in order to improve clinical
outcome.