3.1. Population and clinical findings
40 children were included: 20 with BC (mean age 99.00 ± 59 months, 12 males) and 20 without BC (mean age 97.00 ± 61 months p: 0.2918, 15 males p: 0.1577).
The symptoms reported in children with BC were: recurrent respiratory infections (in 17/20), chronic productive cough (in 2/20), and croup (in only one child).
The most frequently reported respiratory symptom in children without BC was chronic non-productive cough (in 10/20, 50%, of children). In addition, laryngospasm, hoarseness, episodes of apnea, dysphonia, laryngitis, pharyngeal globe were reported (each symptom in 2/20 children), and/or posterior rhinorrhea, stridor, drooling and snore (each recorded in one patient). In both groups all patients reported more than one respiratory symptom.
Gastrointestinal symptoms (vomit, heartburn, restrosternal and abdominal pain) were also complained by 10/20 patients with BC and 8/20 children without BC (p:0.05372).
3.2. MII-pH results
MII-pH was pathological in 7 (35%) patients with BC and in 8 (40%) children without BC. In particular, 4/7 patients with BC and 6/8 children without BC showed a significant association (positive SI or SAP) between respiratory symptoms and GER; 4/7 patients with BC and 4/8 children without BC had a pathological RI. No significant difference was found between the two groups of children (Table 2).
Table 2
Mean (standard deviation) of each MII-pH† parameter in children with bronchiectases and without bronchiectases.
Group
No. children
MII-pH† parameter
|
Bronchiectasis
(N = 20)
Mean (SD‡)
|
Without Bronchiectases
(N = 20)
Mean (SD‡)
|
p-value
|
RI§%
|
4.4 (5.3)
|
4.1 (5.2)
|
0.883
|
TNR’’
|
44 (37)
|
48 (25)
|
0.7
|
A TNR¥
|
25 (27)
|
32 (24)
|
0.3685
|
WA TNR¤
|
18 (21)
|
13 (9.7)
|
0.397
|
Al TNR°
|
1.3 (1.9)
|
2.3 (5.4)
|
0.4406
|
PRƍ
|
27 (27)
|
18 (13)
|
0.2093
|
†MII-pH = pH-impedance, ‡SD = Standard Deviation, §RI = Reflux Index,’’TNR = Total Number Of Impedance Refluxes, ¥A TNR = Acid TNR, ¤WA TNR = Weakly Acidic TNR, °Al TNR = Alkaline TNR, ƍPR = Proximal Refluxes.
Mean and standard deviation of MII-pH results in children with BC are showed in Table 3. As expected, in children with pathological MII-pH there were a significant higher RI and number of acid refluxes.
Gastrointestinal symptoms were reported in 3/7 (42.85%) and in 7/13 (53.8%) children with BC, with and without pathological MII-pH respectively (p-value 0.66).
Table 3
MII-pH† results in children with bronchiectases with and without pathological MII-pH† (mean ± SD‡).
MII-pH† parameter
|
Normal MII-pH†
(N = 7)
|
Pathological MII-pH†
(N = 13)
|
p-values
|
RI§%
|
1.92 ± 1.58
|
8.91 ± 6.86
|
0.0022
|
TNRƥ
|
34.15 ± 18.61
|
62.00 ± 54.71
|
0.1074
|
A TNR’’
|
23.23 ± 19.43
|
33.29 ± 40.47
|
0.4574
|
WA TNR¥
|
13.15 ± 8.02
|
27.71 ± 33.31
|
0.1437
|
Al TNR¤
|
1.38 ± 2.33
|
1.00 ± 1.00
|
0.6846
|
Acid reflux
|
25.00 ± 18.96
|
88.43 ± 95.36
|
0.0294
|
PR°
|
18.92 ± 14.07
|
41.00 ± 38.84
|
0.0780
|
†MII-pH = pH-impedance, ‡SD = Standard Deviation, §RI = Reflux Index, ƥTNR = Total Number Of Impedance Refluxes,’’A TNR = Acid TNR, ¥WA TNR = Weakly Acidic TNR, ¤Al TNR = Alkaline TNR, °PR = Proximal Refluxes.
3.3 Spirometry
Spirometry was successfully performed in 17/20 children with BC, in particular 5/17 (29.4%) had a pathological MII-pH. Children with pathological or normal MII-pH did not shown significant difference in any respiratory score (Table 4.).
Table 4
Comparison between FVC†, FEV-1‡, FEV1/FVC, MMEF 75/25§ z-score in children with bronchiectases with pathological and normal MII-pH¶.
|
Mean (Standard Deviation)
|
p-value
|
|
Pathological MII-pH¶
(N = 7)
|
Normal MII-pH¶
(N = 13)
|
|
FVC† z-score
|
-1.14 (1.19)
|
-0.92 (1.06)
|
0.7226
|
FEV1‡ z-score
|
-1.28 (1.58)
|
-1.36 (1.12)
|
0.9015
|
FEV1/FVC z-score
|
-0.38 (1.03)
|
-0.82 (1.15)
|
0.4752
|
MMEF 75/25§ z-score
|
-1.27 (1.26)
|
-1.54 (1.14)
|
0.6695
|
†FVC = forced vital capacity, ‡FEV1 = forced expiratory volume in one second, §MMEF 75/25 = forced expiratory flow 25/75%, ¶MII-pH = esophageal pH-impedance.
3.4. HRCT scoring system and GER
HRCT score in patients with BC ranged from 2 to 10 with a mean value of 5.45.
The mean value of HRCT score in children with a pathological or normal MII-pH was 6.571 and 4.846 respectively (p:0.0929).
There was no distinct lobe involvement or HRCT characteristic in children with pathological or normal MII-pH (Table 5); the lower and middle right lung lobes were affected by BC in 6 children with pathological MII-pH and in 9 children with normal MII-pH (p:0.412).
Table 5
Mean ± SD‡ of single parameters of HRCT† score in bronchiectases children with normal and pathological pH-impedance.
|
Bronchiectasis
(m¶ ± SD‡)
|
Mucus plugging
(m¶ ± SD‡)
|
Abscess/sacculations
(m¶ ± SD‡)
|
Consolidation
(m¶ ± SD‡)
|
Special findings
(m¶ ± SD‡)
|
Normal
MII-pH§ (N = 13)
|
1.69 ± 0.947
|
0.69 ± 0.751
|
0.08 ± 0.277
|
1.85 ± 0.689
|
0.54 ± 0.776
|
Pathological MII-pH§ (N = 7)
|
2 ± 0.816
|
0.71 ± 0.951
|
0.29 ± 0.756
|
2.57 ± 1.272
|
1 ± 1
|
p-value
|
0.460
|
0.959
|
0.504
|
0.199
|
0.314
|
†HRCT = High Resolution Computed Tomography, m¶= mean, ‡SD = Stadard Deviation, §MII-pH = pH-impedence
No significant relation between HRCT score and MII-pH parameters was found (Table 6.); however, a direct (not significant) correlation was noticed with RI, acid refluxes and SI/SAP (respiratory symptoms), while an inverse correlation was identified with all other MII-pH parameters.
Table 6
Correlation between HRCT† score and MII-pH§ parameters (assessed by Spearman Test).
|
Rs
|
p-value
|
Score HRCT†/Acid refluxes
|
0.022
|
0.925
|
Score HRCT†/RI‡
|
0.240
|
0.307
|
Score HRCT†/TNR¶
|
-0.435
|
0.055
|
Score HRCT†/A TNRǁ
|
-0.355
|
0.124
|
Score HRCT†/WA TNRƥ
|
-0.085
|
0.723
|
Score HRCT†/Al TNR’’
|
-0.168
|
0.478
|
Score HRCT†/PR¥
|
-0.282
|
0.228
|
Score HRCT†/SI°-SAPƍ
|
0.041
|
0.865
|
†HRCT = High-Resolution Computed Tomography, § MII-pH = pH-impedence, ‡RI = Reflux Index, ¶TNR = Total Number Of Impedance Refluxes, ǁA TNR = Acid TNR, ƥWA TNR = Weakly Acidic TNR, ’’Al TNR = Alkaline TNR, ¥PR = Proximal Refluxes, °SI = Symptom Index, ƍSAP = Symptom Association Probability.
HRCT score > 6 was associated with a 57% Se, 69% Sp, 50% PPV and 75% NPV.
Assessing the HRCT scoring system accuracy in predicting pathological MII-pH by ROC Curve, the Area Under the Curve was 0.736 (Fig. 1.). The score with the highest sensitivity and specificity resulted < 4.5 showing a NPV of 86,5% whilst a HCRT value > 7.5 had a PPV of 75%.