Starting the process from a master alloy with the approximate percentages of the desired composition will be the best alternative due to economic-environmental viability for casting Mg alloys for biomedical purposes.
Regarding the release of harmful ions, Cicha et al, propose to use ferritic elements for cardiovascular applications, this in order to be able to recover dissolved metal ions with adherence of endothelial cells by magnetism and to evaluate the therapeutic benefit(120)(121). When using Mg base alloys, this would not be possible mainly due to Mg ions due to their characteristic paramagnetic, if this study phenomenon is of interest, a good strategy would be to dope Mg with elements such as Nd to promote a partial recovery of ions metallic where the effect on Nd ions can be sampled. An advantage of its use is that Nd acts as a grain refiner, contributing to mechanical integrity, however its toxicological potential has limited its use in medical devices (122)(123), a possible alternative to use it at an exposure limit with biosecurity precautions could be implemented through the magnetic cell recruitment technique proposed by Cicha.
The contribution of the MgCa2 phase to the mechanical behavior of the alloy is related to the morphology of the eutectic lamellar phase providing the characteristic brittleness and has the implication that the melting point of the phase is below the melting point of both main constituents., the solidification of interlocking sheets explains the nature of brittleness in the material. The development and medical use of Mg alloys have been limited due to the poor formation of sliding systems that induce low ductility, becoming more complicated when adding elements to reinforce the matrix of the alloy(97). Adding pure elements such as Ca and Zn to form this base-Mg alloy will be restricted due to the solubility limits of the elements. Understanding the formation of each of the phases and checking the preferential orientation of the grain in the morphological characterization would indicate the affectation of Mg alloys when transformed by fusion or mechanical deformation, providing evidence that dynamic recrystallization occurs(124)(125). Park et al, have reported that both plastic deformation and the atomic diffusion process induce preferential orientation of the grain(126). The existence of diffuse diffraction rings is an indicator of the replacement of Mg ions by Ca, there was variation in intensity and circumference, this phenomenon was also reported by Bowen(99). The crystalline orientation (texture) has an impact on the degradation of Mg alloys (127). This impact is greater in the application, if the flow of the body fluid affects the normal orientation to the surface, when the surface of the Mg is exposed to the flow of a body fluid, the bio-erosion produced by the fluid influencing the material accelerates the degradation, to prolong the life of a Mg implant, it should be recommended in surgical techniques to take care of the placement, avoiding as much as possible that the implant is exposed to a blood flow that affects perpendicularly on the surface, considering this effect can improve the performance of a medical device manufactured in Mg. Deepening the characterization of the texture of a MgCa implant depends largely on the behavior of the alloy, even when the texture is improved, the behavior of MgCa alloys will show tendencies towards brittleness.(128)(129). Various efforts have been made to improve the casting process and consequently the mechanical properties of MgCa alloys(48). However, no matter how much the process can be improved, it must be considered that the eutectic lamellar phases that originate will always be present in the incorporation of Ca to Mg, the homogenization due to the improvements in foundry offers to improve the biocompatibility(130)(131)(132)(133), however the characteristics of the morphologies reported indicate a strong inclination towards fragility.
The mechanical properties are also affected due to the orientation of the grain, causing microstructural changes due to the elongation of the grains themselves and this is reflected in their elastic components, inducing anisotropy(134)(135)(136)(137)(138).
The combination of SEM-EDS, XRD & TEM techniques allow us to understand the importance of each microstructural phase and its effect. Twins within the grains can prevent band dislocations and are related to material creep. The α-Mg phase normalizes the MgCa2 matrix and prevents acceleration in degradation(139).
In Fig. 4a non-homogenized morphology can be seen, and it is logical since the ideal is to melt these materials under vacuum and centrifuge them, however, a diffusion of Zn over MgCa is achieved, which is the most important part of the work because allows us to carry out the evaluation of cell viability directly from the material.
Traces of pitting corrosion were observed during the SEM-EDS analysis that indicate that the alloy is resistant to corrosion, however, this corrosion will act as a stress concentrator and the degradation process will start as soon as the material is superficially affected. affecting the mechanical properties and leading to eventual dissolution(140). The distribution of mechanical stresses is not homogeneous throughout the material due to the crystallographic orientation and the second phases that initiate the nucleation of the material, also generating cracks, pores, and precipitates. Cesarz et al, reported that dissolved Ca particles can precipitate and form anticorrosive layers that slow down degradation (141)(142).
It is possible that Zn is not detected because there are only small amounts in the alloy, however, it has already been reported that in Mg-Zn diffraction, only the α-Mg phase diffracts intensity, Yan Jingli, reported that by decreasing the Scanning speed during XRD analysis, the formation of weak diffraction peaks of the MgZn2 phase is revealed, such as those formed and not identified in the result shown for XRD (See Fig. 5). The lack of identification of Zn phases can be attributed to multiple causes, including a possible preferential reorientation during the preparation of the specimens, unfortunately Yan Jingli does not report a scanning speed for the detection of the MgZn2 phases by XRD, the value used in this work corresponds to scan step time [s], 59.69, which suggests that a lower speed should be used. An atomic rearrangement by a mechanism such as hardening deformation will increase the intensity of Zn (128). The structured lattice arrangement in the generation of quasicrystalline phases has shown excellent mechanical properties, reducing the coefficient of friction and resistance to corrosion (143).
This alloy shows a phenomenon due to precipitates where the Zn peaks do not appear, it could be partly that a rearrangement is required and what existed was a preferential orientation due to the sanding process, when polishing the sample or When the elements were melted, they were superficially deposited and agglomerated, which causes them to be removed with sandpaper when polishing or a preferential reorientation occurs.
Avoid increasing the temperature above 200 ° C on the surface of an implant made of MgZn alloy, this will minimize microstructural modification (56)(144). Galvanic corrosion that occurs between Mg and Zn generates a rapid dissolution of secondary phases, weakening the Mg matrix, this explains the potential for bioactivity generated by these elements acting together in an alloy.
Tripathy, reported that solid Zn-Ca solutions could be prepared in the entire range of compositions, although incoherent values of the grating parameters and diffraction patterns were observed, through the study by the ritveld method it was determined that the parameters change when adding Zn existing a modification(113)(111).
The results shown correspond to the average value of 9 tests for longitudinal and transverse orientation, in the upper half of the load vs displacement curve are the data with which the elastic modulus (E) and hardness H (VK) are calculated.), during load application, elastic and plastic deformations occur under the indenter as the contacts change deeper. The discharge part of the curve is dominated by elastic displacements. The diamond indenter has a V = 0.07 and an E = 1140 GPa, the MgCa-Zn material has a V = 0.30, through sensivity studies it has been determined that variations in the range of 0.2–0.4 in V, will present a variation the elastic modulus E not greater than 8%.
The determination of the elastic modulus derived from the Oliver and Pharr method consists of an average of the isotropic elastic constants, however, for an anisotropic material it has been determined that the measurements are inclined towards the elastic modulus in the direction of the test. For a material that exhibits an HCP structure, the determination of the elastic modulus only considers the normal direction, underestimating the other elastic components by mono-crystallinity, the influence of the elastic constants that occur in an orthotropic material are of vital importance for understand the behavior of the material.
Fibroblasts tend to adhere to the surface and show an elongated polygonal morphology, this if they are healthy and normal. And if they present a degraded appearance and spherical morphology in addition to the detachment of the surface, they usually indicate cell death, which is not observed.
As complementary perspectives to cell viability it is widely recommended to use analyzes that represent cell dynamics by monitoring cell properties in real time, it is desired know the adherence to non-foulding surfaces, proliferation, and cell migration(145)(146)(147)(148)(149).
Viz, Yang et al reported an increase in cell viability of osteoblasts reducing DNA damage in the formation of new bone using Zn-Mg alloys (150)
Conclusion
As a general conclusion
-
The optimization of the casting process of a Mg-Ca-Zn alloy has a microstructural limit, which is due to the eutectic mixture, even when the process is optimized, a fine dispersion between phases will continue to appear, resulting in an origin for crack nucleation.
-
The period of exposure to elements such as Mg, Ca and Zn within the body causes pathophysiology to occur, being clear about the period of exposure in days for the effects to occur is a key factor to understand the beneficial effect that they can contribute prior to hydrolytic degradation in vivo.
-
Zn improves the mechanical response when hardening this type of alloys, however, exceeding the permitted limits damages the toxicological limit which will have an impact on cell viability. Viz, Zhuang, et al reported Zn dose-dependent and over-boosted concentration caused cell death due to cytotoxicity(103). Elements such as Sr and Ca have been reported to be able to counteract and reduce the toxicity of Zn (151)(152). Lu et al reported that Zn promotes the absorption of the hydrogen that is released due to the Mg reaction in vitro (153).
-
An annealing process on this alloy will dissolve the intermetallic phases that occur and help to homogenize the distribution of the solutes in the Mg matrix, however, the precipitates could have a detrimental effect on the corrosion rate.
-
The melting of Mg, Ca and Zn and their modification by diffusion are possible from MgCa master alloys, this process manages to diffuse Zn in powder over MgCa, the use of a vacuum system will allow to have a clean atmosphere. The alloy microstructure and grain size will be finer.
-
The coatings on Mg alloys are very important depending on the type of medical application for which they are required to be used, a coating used on Mg alloys has the purpose of increasing the implant time in vivo, that will provide mechanical resistance to the fracture, for this application, using a coating that reduces the appearance of pitting corrosion is a multidisciplinary strategy that will completely depend on the initial weeks in which it is required to maintain the mechanical integrity of the implant, it is suggested to evaluate a coating based on Chitosan that allows to maintain implant surface intact for 6 weeks to minimize places where crack propagation can begin.
-
The elastic modulus was 74.2 GPa for the longitudinal direction and 66.2 GPa in the transverse direction, it has been determined from the repetitions of the test that the elastic modulus was always higher in the longitudinal direction, the hardness follows a similar pattern being reported 278.9 and 264.3 HV in longitudinal and transverse direction, respectively. An anisotropy condition between the longitudinal and transverse direction is fulfilled by having different elastic modulus and hardness. The determination of the elastic modulus and hardness in each triad for each degree of freedom could be useful to relate to the orientation of the planes and to have the behavior of the elastic constants characterized.
-
The ideal application for this type of alloy corresponds to anatomical sites where it is only exposed to gravity and forces caused by muscles such as the movement of the upper extremities and the skull.
-
Experimenting with texture control techniques on Mg alloys could be an effective strategy to determine the ideal method for manufacturing Mg-based implants. However, the mechanical behavior of Mg depends on the adequate relationship between the volumetric fraction of elements and the formation of lamellar long period stacking order (LPSO) secondary phases.(144)(154)(155).