Despite much research, the pathogenesis of PD remains elusive. Both genetic and environmental factors in combination are suspected to contribute to the pathogenesis of PD [35]. LBs are the main pathological hallmark of PD. Additionally, Lewy pathology progressively involves more regions of the nervous system as the disease advances, and it is present prior to the appearance of motor symptoms in PD [8], Accordingly, it is important to identify which factors initiate Lewy pathology to understand the pathogenesis of PD. Several factors are suspected to be triggers of Lewy pathology. Several environmental factors that contribute include pathogens, such as influenza virus, environmental pollutants like pesticides, heavy metals, and head trauma [36]. In particular, viral infection has long been considered a risk factor for neurodegenerative diseases [13]. The present data demonstrate that CVB3 interacts with α-syn to promote PD.
Concerning the influence of CVB3 on α-syn, CVB3 infection induces very large autophagy-related structures ranging 10–20 µm in diameter in neurons. These structures colocalize with LC3 and have a similar morphology to that of megaphagosomes shown in pancreatic acinar cells [27]. They also stain with α-syn, pSer129 α-syn, and ubiquitin antibodies, suggesting a resemblance to LBs. LBs have significant morphological diversity and are heterogeneous in their shape, biochemical composition, and organization [29]. Examinations of the brains of patients with PD using super-high resolution microscopy based on stimulated emission depletion (STED) revealed LBS with crowded organelles and lipid membranes. This prompted the proposal that α-syn may modulate the compartmentalization and function of membranes and organelles in LB-affected cells [30]. A recent report demonstrated the formation of filament-like structures accompanying the sequestration of lipids, organelles, and endomembrane structures using a seeding-based model of α-syn fibrillization, which recapitulated the features of LBs observed in the brains of patients with PD [37]. Likewise, our TEM findings also suggested that CVB3 infection resulted in the clustering of several organelles in the perinuclear space in neurons. The crowded organelles contained damaged mitochondria and many fibrillar structures surrounded the organelles. The number of fibrillar structures in α-syn OE dSH-SY5Y cells was higher than that in dSH-SY5Y cells. These structures in α-syn OE dSH-SY5Y cells were also longer than those in dSH-SY5Y cells. Given that α-syn fibrils exhibit 20 nm diameter in vitro [38], these observations suggested that these fibrillar structures may be α-syn fibrils. Additionally, the process of LB formation consists of several stages [39, 40]. CVB3 induced different types of LB-like inclusion bodies over time, which may reflect the maturation of the inclusion bodies. In α-syn OE cells, the maturation of these inclusions was accelerated and inclusion bodies were more condensed, suggesting that α-syn may regulate the maturation of inclusion bodies as a major component. In addition, mitochondrial damage was induced by CVB3, which was more in α-syn OE dSH-SY5Y cells. The observations are supported in part by previous studies demonstrating that α-syn localizes in mitochondria and α-syn OE cells exhibit mitochondrial dysfunction [41–43]. We demonstrated that CVB3 inhibited the late stage of the autophagic process in dSH-SY5Y cells, consistent with a previous study [27]. It is well known that α-syn is somewhat degraded through autophagy in cells [44–46], although other mechanisms have also been reported to be involved in α-syn degradation [47]. Blocked late stage autophagy has been reported to cause α-syn accumulation [48]. Accordingly, the use of autophagy machinery by CVB3 may induce the formation of LB-like inclusions associated with α-syn.
Although CVB3 induced large inclusion bodies containing α-syn, its expression was decreased. We confirmed this using in vitro and in vivo model systems, and open source data from CVB3-infected hearts of mice. In particular, neighboring cells may be more affected. How α-syn expression is regulated differentially requires further investigation. A previous report demonstrated that WNV induced α-syn expression, and α-syn was proposed as a viral restriction factor [21]. We also observed that treatment with polyIC increased α-syn expression in dSH-SY5Y cells, suggesting that α-syn expression can be regulated by viral infection. However, the decrease in α-syn expression may be CVB3 specific. Interestingly, decreased α-syn mRNA in brains of patients with PD has been described [49, 50]. These findings are contentious due to several technical issues, including sampling and normalization methods. Our analysis of open data sources from patients with PD also confirmed it. Therefore, CVB3 infection may reflect patients with PD.
When we infected mice with CVB3, CVB3 infection first appeared in the region of several anatomical structures along the ventricles, suggesting the route of CVB3 into the CNS from the periphery. Neuron and microglia infection progressed with time to other regions. In neurons, CVB3 was observed in the hippocampus, lateral thalamus, and midbrain in the brain of mice at day 4 PI. Although we observed the colocalization of CVB3 with α-syn in vitro, we could not observe the colocalization in the brain of mice infected with CVB3. Instead, we observed α-syn aggregation in the cell bodies of neurons located in the midbrain of WT mice at day 28 PI, and more neurons containing cytosolic α-syn aggregation were observed in α-syn TG mice at day 7 PI. In addition, western blot analysis indicated that pSer129 α-syn was slightly increased in the brain infected with CVB3. In a previous report [36], the authors proposed that triggers alone are usually insufficient for PD to develop. Triggers often act transiently, with the triggering event lasting a few weeks or months and occurring relatively early in the life of individuals that develop PD. Accordingly, CVB3 infection may act transiently. It alone may not induce LB formation in the brain, unlike in vitro. Alternatively, the neuronal α-syn aggregation observed in our in vivo system may not reach the same mature stage as the PD LB, because our in vivo model system is not adequate for prolonged observations due to the high mortality of CVB3 infection in C57BL/6 mice [51]. The long-term consequences of CVB3 infection in the CNS are largely unknown. However, these viruses persist, and the presence of viral RNA by itself is potentially pathogenic in some cases including schizophrenia [52] and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis [53]. Interestingly, CVB3 infected BALB/c mice, which are more susceptible to chronic CVB3 infection, reportedly showed TDP-43 aggregation in the hippocampal region at 90 days PI [54]. In addition, it has been reported that cytosolic aggregates as well as soluble oligomers, which were not observed in healthy controls, were observed in the heart of patients with dilated cardiomyopathy, which is suspected to be caused by CVB3 infections [55, 56]. Congo red merged islet amyloid polypeptide was also seen in pancreatic biopsies of patients with type 1 diabetes, suggesting that these aggregations may be caused by enteroviruses stressing beta cells [57]. Accordingly, viral-induced intracellular protein inclusions do not restrict neurons; rather, they are a general phenomenon.
In this study, we observed that α-syn expression regulated CVB3 replication. Overexpression of α-syn increased CVB3 replication and CVB3 induced cytotoxicity. We confirmed this in vivo in brains of α-syn TG mice. CVB3 replication was increased and the spread of CVB3 infected regions was also accelerated in α-syn TG mice compared with control mice. In addition, CVB3 infection induced neuronal cell death, especially dopaminergic neuronal cell death in the substantia nigra. Interestingly and supporting our observation, patients with chronic EV71 encephalitis whose symptoms persisted for more than 2 months displayed damage in most of the midbrain, including the substantia nigra [58]. Dopaminergic neuronal cell death in the substantia nigra was also accelerated in α-syn TG mice. Furthermore, α-syn TG mice survived less than WT mice. A previous report demonstrated that α-syn expression inhibits WNV growth and replication, resulting in increased mortality of α-syn knock-out mice [21], which contradicts our findings, demonstrating that α-syn TG mice show more CVB3 replication and a lower survival rate after CVB3 infection. We cannot completely explain the discrepancy between these results. The balance of the amount of α-syn in the brain may be important for the regulation of viral infection. Nevertheless, this could be explained by the viral usage of autophagy. Previous studies have suggested that CVB3 uses autophagosomes as their replication centers by inhibiting the binding of autophagosomes to lysosomes [27, 59, 60]. The induction of autophagy in neurons was also associated with increased CVB3 replication [59–61]. Given that an increase in α-syn expression accelerated autophagic flux, this environment favors the replication of CVB3. In contrast, autophagy is known to inhibit WNV replication [62, 63]. Accordingly, it may be virus-specific, and autophagy in both viruses may explain this discrepancy.
The epidemiologic links suggest that viral exposure over time may increase the risk for PD, although it is unclear whether any specific viral infection causes PD. It could be related to direct virus-induced cytotoxicity or virus-related inflammation [64–66]. Influenza viral infections induce parkinsonian symptoms and a significant increase in phosphorylation and aggregation of α-syn [67, 68]. Repeated viral infection may induce α-syn expression or/and α-syn aggregation, and chronic viral infection also induces further inflammation, which may initiate and progress PD. Likewise, we observed that α-syn responded to CVB3 infection. CVB3 infection regulated α-syn expression and aggregation. α-Syn may function as a defense mechanism of the host cells against viral infection. The finding that infecting CVB3 interacted with α-syn in various ways suggests an unexpected role of α-syn in the pathogenesis of PD. Further studies are needed to explore this in more detail.