Population PK characteristics of AEDs
A total of 14 population PK models for nine AEDs were identified.36–49 The enrolled patients ranged from 44 in the study of levetiracetam for children48 to 902 in the study of valproic acid for children.43 In all 14 population PK studies, 10 were prospective clinical studies.37, 39–41, 43, 44, 46–49 In addition, studies for carbamazepine, eslicarbazepine, levetiracetam, topiramate, and valproic acid were conducted in multi-centers,37, 39, 40, 43, 44, 47, 48 in which studies for eslicarbazepine and levetiracetam contained intensive sampling data.39, 47, 48
For population PK models of AEDs described by a one-compartment model with first-order absorption and elimination, the concentration at time t (Ct; mg/L) could be estimated according to Eq. 1 (Eq. 1).
\({C}_{t}=\frac{{k}_{a}\bullet DOSE}{V/F\bullet ({k}_{a}-\frac{0.693}{{t}_{1/2}})}\bullet \left[\left(\frac{1-{e}^{-\frac{0.693}{{t}_{1/2}}\bullet n\bullet \tau }}{1-{e}^{-\frac{0.693}{{t}_{1/2}}\bullet \tau }}\bullet {e}^{-\frac{0.693}{{t}_{1/2}}\bullet t}\right)-(\frac{1-{e}^{-{k}_{a}\bullet n\bullet \tau }}{1-{e}^{-{k}_{a}\bullet \tau }}\bullet {e}^{{k}_{a}\bullet t})\right]\) (Eq. 1)
where DOSE (mg) represents the administered dose; \({k}_{a}\) (h− 1) represents absorption rate constant; \(n\) represents the number of doses administered;\({t}_{1/2}\)(h) represents the half-life; t (h) represents the time after the last dose;\(V/F\) (L) represents the apparent volume of distribution, and τ (h) represents the dosing interval. The characteristics and parameter estimates of each identified model are summarized in Supplementary Table 1.
Remedial dosing regimens
The Monte Carlo simulation showed that the recommended remedial regimens were mostly dependent on the delayed time. For typical patients with normal renal function (eGFR of 90 mL/min) taking monotherapy of AEDs every 12 h (q12 h), the recommended remedial regimens for various delayed times are summarized in Table 2.
Table 2
The recommended remedial regimens for typical patients.
Patient type | AEDs | Dosage (mg) | Delayed time (h) |
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
Children | CBZ | 100 | 100(B) | 100(B) | 100(B) | 100(B) | 100(B) 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) 150(E/F) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 150(F) |
Adults | CBZ | 400 | 400(B) | 400(B) | 400(B) 200(C) | 200(C/D) | 200(C) | 200(C) | 200(C) | 200(C/D) | 200(C/D) | 200(C/D) | 200(D) 600(E) | 600(F) |
Children | CLB | 5 | 2.5(C/D) | 2.5(D) | 2.5(D) | 2.5(D) | 2.5(D) | 2.5(D) 7.5(F) | 2.5(D) 7.5(F) | 2.5(D) 7.5(F) | 2.5(C/D) 7.5(F) | 2.5(C/D) 7.5(E/F) | 2.5(C/D) 7.5(E/F) | 7.5(F) |
Adults | CLB | 10 | 5(C/D) | 5(C/D) | 5(C/D) | 5(D) | 5(D) | 5(D) 15(F) | 5(D) 15(F) | 5(D) 15(F) | 5(C/D) 15(E/F) | 5(C/D) 15(E/F) | 5(C/D) 15(E/F) | 15(F) |
Children | LTG | 50 | 50(B) | 50 (B) | 50 (B) 25(C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) 75(E) | 25 (C/D) 75(E/F) | 75 (F) |
Adults | LTG | 100 | 100(B) | 100(B) | 100(B) 50(D) | 100(B) 50(C/D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) 150(F) | 50(D) 150(E/F) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 150(F) |
Children | LEV | 250 | 250(B) | 250(B) 125(C) | 250(B) 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C/D) | 125(D) | 125(D) | 125(D) 375(E) | 375(F) |
Adults | LEV | 500 | 500(B) 250(C) | 250(C/D) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(E) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
Children | OXC | 300 | 300(B) | 300(B) 150(C/D) | 150(C/D) | 150(C/D) | 150(C/D) | 150(C) | 150(C) | 150(C/D) | 150(C/D) | 150(D) | 150(D) 450(E) | 450(F) |
Adults | OXC | 600 | 600(B) | 600(B) 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) 900(F) | 300(D) 900(F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 900(F) |
Children | PB | 60 | 60(B) | 60(B) | 60(B) 30(D) | 60(B) 30(D) | 60(B) 30(D) | 30(D) | 30(D) | 30(D) 90(E) | 30(D) 90(E) | 30(C/D) 90(E/F) | 30(C/D) 90(E/F) | 90(F) |
Adults | PB | 60 | 60(B) | 60(B) | 60(B) | 60(B) | 60(B) | 60(B) | 60(B) 30(D) | 60(B) 30(D) | 30(D) 90(F) | 30(C/D) 90(E/F) | 30(C/D) 90(E/F) | 90(F) |
Table 2 (continue) | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Patient type | AEDs | Dosage (mg) | Delayed time (h) |
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
Children | TPM | 100 | 100(B) | 100(B) 50(C/D) | 50(C/D) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C/D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 100(A) | 100(A) | 100(A) |
Adults | TPM | 200 | 200(B) 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(D) | 100(D) | 100(D) 300(E) | 100(A) | 100(A) |
Children | VPA | 250 | 250(B) | 250(B) | 250(B) 125(C/D) | 250(B) 125(C/D) | 125(C/D) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C/D) | 125(C/D) 375(E) | 125(C/D) 375(E) | 375(F) |
| VPA | 200a | 200(B) 160(C/D) | 160(C/D) | 160(C/D) | 120(C) 160(C/D) | 120(C) 160(D) | 120(C) 160(D) | 120(C/D) | 80(C) 120(C/D) | 80(C) 120(C/D) | 80(C/D) 120(D) | 80(C/D) 280(E/F) | 240(F) 280(F) |
Adults | VPA | 500 | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) | 250(C/D) 500(B) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(F) | 250(C/D) 750(F) | 250(D) 750(F) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
CBZ carbamazepine; CLB clobazam; LTG lamotrigine; LEV levetiracetam; OXC oxcarbazepine; PB phenobarbital; TPM topiramate; VPA valproate acid; |
Children 10 years, 30 kg, 140 cm, 90 ml/min; |
Adults 40 years, 70 kg, 180 cm, 90 ml/min; |
a Syrup of 5 mL for children with 5 years old with 16 kg and 110 cm; |
When the dose was delayed within 2 h, the whole delayed dose was recommended to be taken immediately, followed by resuming the regular regimens (Strategy B) for most AEDs except clobazam. For patients taking clobazam, they were recommended to take half of the missed dose immediately and resume the regular regimens (Strategy C) or to take the missed dose immediately and half of the missed dose at the next scheduled time (Strategy D) even if the dose was delayed within 2 h. For adults taking levetiracetam or topiramate, Strategy B was only recommended when the dose was delayed within 1 h. Moreover, for children taking oxcarbazepine or topiramate, all Strategies B, C, and D were recommended when the dose was delayed within 2 h.
When the delay time was more than 2 h and up to 2 h to the next scheduled time, patients were recommended to take Strategy C or D, depending on the AEDs and patient’s demographics. For example, when the delayed time was 4 h, Strategy C was recommended for adults taking levetiracetam, while Strategy D was recommended for adults taking oxcarbazepine, and both Strategy C and D were recommended for children taking oxcarbazepine.
When the dose was delayed within 2 h to the next dose, one-and-a-half of the missed doses were recommended to be taken immediately (Strategy E) for most AEDs. Especially, when the dose was missed (delayed 12 h for q12 h dosing), one-and-a-half of the missed doses were recommended to be taken at the scheduled time (Strategy F). Except for topiramate, when the dose was missed (delayed 12 h for q12 h dosing), taking only the scheduled dose (Strategy A) was recommended.
For children taking valproate acid syrup, the minimum remedial dose unit was smaller. Therefore, the recommended remedial regimens could be more precisely restored to the individual therapeutic range. When the dose was delayed within 4 h, either Strategy C or D with a remedial dose of 160 mg (4 mL of syrup) was recommended. When the dose was missed (delayed 12 h for q12 h dosing), Strategy F with a remedial dose of either 240 mg (6 mL of syrup) or 280 mg (7 mL of syrup) was recommended.
Impact of patient’s demographics, concomitant medication, and scheduled dosing regimen
For most AEDs, the recommended remedial regimens for pediatric (10 years old, 30 kg and 140 cm) and adult (40 years old, 70 kg and 180 cm) patients were different. For example, regarding topiramate, when the dose was delayed within 2 h, Strategy B was recommended for children while only Strategy C or D was recommended for adults.
Renal function only influences the CL/F of levetiracetam and oxcarbazepine, and the impact on remedial regimens was not the same for those two AEDs. For adults taking levetiracetam, the same remedial regimens were recommended for those with eGFR values between 30 and 60 mL/min. As for adults taking oxcarbazepine, the remedial regimens were the same for these with eGFR values between 60 and 90 mL/min. The recommended remedial regimens for adults with various eGFR levels taking levetiracetam or oxcarbazepine are summarized in Table 3.
Table 3
The recommended remedial regimens for adults with different renal function levels.
AEDs | Dosage (mg) | eGFR (ml/min) | Delayed time (h) |
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
LEV | 500 | 90 | 500(B) 250(C) | 250(C/D) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(E) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
| 500 | 60 | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) 250(C/D) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(E) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
| 500 | 30 | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(E) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
OXC | 600 | 90 | 600(B) | 600(B) 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) 900(F) | 300(D) 900(F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 900(F) |
| 600 | 60 | 600(B) | 600(B) 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) | 300(D) 900(F) | 300(D) 900(E/F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 300(C/D) 900(E/F) | 900(F) |
| 300 | 30 | 150(D) | 150(D) | 150(D) | 150(D) | 150(D) | 150(D) | 150(D) 450(E) | 150(D) 450(E) | 150(D) 450(E) | 150(C/D) 450(E) | 150(C/D) 450(E) | 450(F) |
LEV levetiracetam; OXC oxcarbazepine; |
For patients taking AEDs concomitant with inducers such as carbamazepine, phenobarbital, and phenytoin, the recommended remedial strategies were similar to those with monotherapy or with neutral comedications. For children taking lamotrigine and inducers simultaneously, half of the delayed dose was recommended if the dose was delayed between 2 to 3 h, while the whole delayed dose was recommended for those with monotherapy. Moreover, for children taking lamotrigine concomitant with inhibitors such as valproic acid, the whole delayed dose was recommended even the dose was delayed within 5 h. The recommended remedial regimens for patients with various concomitant medications are summarized in Table 4.
Table 4
The recommended remedial regimens for typical adults with different concomitant medications.
Patient type | AEDs | Dosage (mg) | Co-Med | Delayed time (h) |
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
Children | LTG | 50 | / | 50(B) | 50 (B) | 50 (B) 25(C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) 75(E) | 25 (C/D) 75(E/F) | 75 (F) |
| | | IND | 50 (B) 25(C) | 25(C) | 25(C) | 25(C) | 25(C) | 25(C) | 25(C) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (C/D) | 25 (D) 75(E) | 25 (D) 75(E) | 75 (F) |
| | | INH | 50(B) | 50 (B) | 50 (B) | 50 (B) | 50(B) 25 (D) | 25 (D) | 25 (D) | 25 (D) 75(F) | 25 (D) 75(E/F) | 25 (C/D) 75(E/F) | 25 (C/D) 75(E/F) | 75 (F) |
Adults | LTG | 100 | / | 100(B) | 100(B) | 100(B) 50(D) | 100(B) 50(C/D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) 150(F) | 50(D) 150(E/F) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 150(F) |
| | IND | 100(B) | 100(B) | 100(B) 50(D) | 50(C/D) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C/D) | 50(C/D) 150(E) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 150(F) |
| | | INH | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 50(D) 150(F) | 50(D) 150(E/F) | 50(C/D) 150(E/F) | 150(F) |
Children | TPM | 100 | / | 100(B) | 100(B) 50(C/D) | 50(C/D) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C/D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 100(A) | 100(A) | 100(A) |
| | | IND | 100(B) | 100(B) 50(C/D) | 50(C/D) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 100(A) | 100(A) | 100(A) |
| | | VPA | 100(B) 50(C/D) | 50(C/D) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C) | 50(C/D) | 50(D) | 50(D) | 100(A) | 100(A) | 100(A) |
Adults | TPM | 200 | / | 200(B) 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(D) | 100(D) | 100(D) 300(E) | 200(A) | 200(A) |
| IND | 200(B) 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(D) | 100(D) | 100(D) 300(E) | 200(A) | 200(A) |
| | | VPA | 200(B) 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C/D) | 100(C) | 100(C/D) | 100(D) | 100(D) | 100(D) | 100(D) | 300(E) | 200(A) |
Table 4 (continue) | | |
Patient type | AEDs | Dosage (mg) | Co-Med | Delayed time (h) |
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
Children | VPA | 500 | / | 250(B) | 250(B) | 250(B) 125(C/D) | 250(B) 125(C/D) | 125(C/D) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C/D) | 125(C/D) 375(E) | 125(C/D) 375(E) | 375(F) |
| | | CBZ | 250(B) | 250(B) 125(C) | 250(B) 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C) | 125(C/D) | 125(C/D) | 125(C/D) 375(E) | 375(F) |
Adults | VPA | 500 | / | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) | 250(C/D) 500(B) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(F) | 250(C/D) 750(F) | 250(D) 750(F) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
| CBZ | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) 250(C) | 500(B) 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(F) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
| PHT | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(E) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
| PB | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) | 500(B) 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) | 250(C/D) 750(F) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 250(C/D) 750(E/F) | 750(F) |
CBZ carbamazepine; IND enzyme inducer like carbamazepine; INH enzyme inhibitor like valproate acid; LTG lamotrigine; PB phenobarbital; PHT phenytoin; TPM topiramate; VPA valproate acid; |
Supplementary materials |
The remedial regimens were also dependent on the dosing interval. For example, one-and-a-half of missed valproic acid doses were recommended to be taken immediately (Strategy F) when it was within 5 h to the next dose for q12 h and within 3 h for q24 h. The remedial regimens for dosing intervals of 24 h are summarized in Supplementary Table 2.
Web-based dashboard
The web-based dashboard for individual remedial regimens could be visited at https://make-up-dose.shinyapps.io/shinyapp/. After inputting the patient’s demographics, regular dosing regimens, concomitant medication, minimum remedial dose unit, and delayed time, the individual therapeutic range could be estimated within a few seconds. Meanwhile, the deviation time for all six remedial strategies was displayed and the optimal remedial regimens would be recommended.
The screenshots of this dashboard are present in Fig. 3, which indicated the example of a 10-year-old pediatric patient weighing 30 kg and having an eGFR of 90 mL/min, who was taking 300 mg oxcarbazepine monotherapy q12 h (Fig. 3a). Two scenarios including a delayed dose of 2 and 11 h were investigated in this example. The oxcarbazepine is usually used as the immediate-release tablet, which can be taken by splitting half. Therefore, the minimum dose unit for providing remedial regimens was assumed to be half of the tablet (150 mg).
When the dose was delayed within 2 h, the Strategy B (administer 300 mg immediately followed by 300 mg at the next scheduled time) showed a total deviation time of 6.9 h (4.9 h above the upper limit + 2.0 h below the lower limit), Strategy C (administer 150 mg immediately followed by 300 mg at the next scheduled time) showed a similar total deviation time of 6.6 h (0 h above the upper limit + 6.6 h below the lower limit), and Strategy D (administer 300 mg immediately followed by 150 mg at the next scheduled time) showed the total deviation time of 7.2 h (7.2 h below the lower limit + 0 h above the upper limit) as indicated in Fig. 3b. The proposed PK profiles of all six remedial strategies with deviation time are shown in Fig. 3c.
For patients with a high risk of epilepsy recurrence, Strategy B with the lowest deviation time below the lower limit was preferred, while for patients with low tolerance of adverse drug reactions, Strategy C or D with less deviation time above the upper limit could be more appropriate.
When the dose was delayed by 11 h, the total deviation time was 11.9 h (11.4 h below the lower limit + 0.5 h above the upper limit) for Strategy D and 12.6 h (11.2 h below the lower limit + 1.4 h above the upper limit) for Strategy E (administer 450 mg immediately and skip the next scheduled time).
Therefore, in such a scenario, both Strategy D and E were recommended. Moreover, since strategy E recommended taking a large dose immediately, it could rapidly restore to the therapeutic range, which is more proper for patients who have a high risk of seizure recurrence.
The user-defined module is also provided in the dashboard, which could be visited at https://make-up-dose-user-defined.shinyapps.io/shinyapp2/. In the user-defined module, all PK parameters (absorption rate, apparent clearance, and apparent volume of distribution) and the individual therapeutic window (upper and lower limit as well as the weight for estimation of the total deviation time) could be modified according to the clinical setting.
Figure 4a showed a specific pediatric patient taking an AED, who had an absorption rate constant of 0.83 h− 1, clearance of 2.5 L/h, and distribution volume of 14.7 L. Moreover, the therapeutic window was set as 3–20 mg/L. When the dose was delayed by 2 h, only Strategy B with a total deviation time of 1.9 h (0 h above the upper limit + 1.9 h below the lower limit) was recommended as shown in Fig. 4b. The deviation time and concentration-time curves of all remedial strategies are present in Fig. 4c.