A total of 445 patients were included in the study. The outcomes of this study presented that preoperative low Hb, high IBL, advanced age, and low body mass index (BMI) were independent risk factors of ABT after HA in elderly FNF patients.
Regarding the blood transfusion rate after hip fracture surgery, there have been different reports in domestic and foreign literature. This may be related to the age, fracture type, comorbid diseases, blood transfusion policy, etc. of the subjects in each study. Arshi A et al. [7] studied 8416 elderly hip fracture patients over 65 years of age and found that 28.3% of them were transfused after surgery. Many previous studies have concluded that compared with FNF, the risk of blood transfusion after femoral intertrochanter fracture is increased [7, 8]. This study did not include patients with femoral intertrochanteric fractures, but the postoperative ABT was even higher. It may be because our hospital is a large-scale upper first-class general hospital with orthopedics and burns as the key department. Part of the patients admitted were referred from primary hospitals. The patients were older, had many complicated diseases, and had relatively severe illness, which also resulted in the relatively high postoperative ABT rate in this study. In the study of Wang JQ et al. [9], the elderly patients with HA after FNF were also taken as the research objects, but they found that the postoperative blood transfusion rate was only 13.9%, which was significantly lower than the 44.0% in this study. Then what are the reasons? In the study of Wang JQ et al. [9], the average age of the blood transfusion group was (78.95 ± 5.26) years old, the non-transfusion group was (80.82 ± 5.23) years old, while in this study, the blood transfusion group was (83.72 ± 6.94) years old, and the non-transfusion group was (81.09 ± 6.78). It can be seen that the patients in this study are older, and advanced age itself is one of the risk factors for postoperative ABT.
At present, there is no clear regulation on the standard of blood transfusion for elderly patients with hip fracture [10]. Carson JL et al. [11] systematically reviewed the results of 31 studies (including 12587 patients) and suggested that the restrictive blood transfusion strategy of controlling the blood transfusion standard at Hb 7–8 g/dL can reduce the ABT rate by 43%. It will not increase the mortality, complication rate and readmission rate within 30 days after surgery, nor will it affect the recovery of patients after surgery. The research of Xie Xuhong et al. [12] shows that for elderly patients undergoing surgical treatment of hip fractures, restricted blood transfusion is safe and effective, and it does not affect the prognosis of patients, and is significantly better than unrestricted blood transfusion in terms of adverse reactions after blood transfusion and blood saving. Based on the above reasons, this study adopted a restrictive blood transfusion strategy.
Multivariate stepwise logistic regression analysis showed that low preoperative Hb, high IBL, advanced age, and low BMI were independent risk factors for ABT in elderly FNF patients after HA. In this study, the preoperative Hb of the blood transfusion group was (113.18 ± 14.69) g/L, which was significantly lower than the preoperative Hb (128.80 ± 12.41) g/L of the non-transfusion group (p < 0.05). This result is consistent with many previous studies [7, 9, 13]. Adunsky A et al. [14] found that patients with preoperative Hb lower than 120 g/L have a 5-fold increase in the risk of postoperative blood transfusion. It is speculated that the reason may be due to the poor immune response and compensatory ability of patients with low Hb before surgery when faced with stresses such as surgery and blood loss. Shokoohi A et al. [15] further reported that for every 1 g/dl increase in Hb on admission, the chance of a patient's blood transfusion decreased by about 49%.
There are many reasons for preoperative anemia [6] ①Acute and chronic hemorrhagic anemia: acute hemorrhagic anemia caused by fractures; chronic hemorrhagic anemia caused by bleeding from digestive ulcers, intestinal polyps or hemorrhoids. ② Nutritional anemia: anemia caused by lack of hematopoietic materials, and iron deficiency anemia is the most common, and megaloblastic anemia caused by lack of folic acid and vitamin B is rare. ③Anemia of chronic disease: refers to anemia characterized by disorders of iron metabolism that occurs in the course of some chronic diseases, and is common in anemia combined with chronic infection, inflammation, and tumor. ④Other anemia: it may involve a variety of complex pathogenic mechanisms and comorbidities. The elderly are more likely to have preoperative anemia due to multiple diseases, reduced absorption and utilization of hematopoietic materials, and reduced hematopoietic reserves. Yoon BH et al. [16] believed that intravenous iron supplementation with restrictive blood transfusion is safe and effective for elderly patients with hip fractures.
We also found that IBL is an independent risk factor for ABT. The IBL of the transfusion group was (227.12 ± 93.38) ml, which was significantly higher than that of the non-transfusion group (190.75 ± 82.32) ml (p < 0.05). It is consistent with the results of Wang JQ et al. [9]. Under normal circumstances, the amount of intraoperative blood loss increases the risk of blood transfusion. Xie J et al. [17] believed that intraoperative use of tranexamic acid can reduce intraoperative bleeding, reduce postoperative ABT, and will not increase the risk of postoperative thromboembolic events or other adverse events. Tranexamic acid was used in all patients in this study.
Consistent with previous studies [7, 13], we found that advanced age is an independent risk factor for ABT in elderly FNF patients after HA. This may be related to the lower baseline Hb of older people. In addition, elderly patients are more likely to experience unstable vital signs and acute blood loss related symptoms after surgery due to reduced organ function and weak compensatory ability to surgical stress, thus increasing the demand for ABT.
Our research shows that a lower BMI is a risk factor for postoperative ABT, similar to previous experimental results [7, 18, 19]. Frisch N et al. [18] studied more than 2300 patients and found that after total hip and knee replacement, patients with high BMI had a lower blood transfusion rate. The author believes that the protective effect of BMI on the risk of blood transfusion may be related to the increase in overall blood volume with the increase of BMI. Although obese patients may lose more blood due to larger incisions during surgery, compared with patients with lower BMI, their estimated blood loss during a particular surgery may have a lower proportion of total blood volume [18]. In addition, lower BMI may also be an indicator of malnutrition in the elderly.
Different from the study of Yan Ge et al. [13], in our study, whether antiplatelet drugs were taken 1 week before surgery did not affect ABT in FNF patients after HA. The experiment of Abdulhamid AK [20] included 325 FNF patients, of which 163 had long-term use of antiplatelet drugs and 162 had not used antiplatelet drugs. It was found that there was no statistical difference between the two groups in terms of IBL or postoperative blood transfusion requirements. In this experiment, many elderly patients with cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases have a high risk of stopping antiplatelet drugs, so antiplatelet drugs were not stopped during the perioperative period.
Previous studies reported that blood transfusion increased the incidence of complications and leads to blood shortage, prolonged hospital stay and increased hospital costs [21–22]. For elderly FNF patients undergoing HA, these problems cannot be ignored. In addition, for elderly patients with potential risk factors, it is necessary to improve blood management. It is currently believed that through risk assessment, careful surgical planning and optimization of preoperative evaluation, the need for blood transfusions during the perioperative period of elderly patients undergoing major surgery can be reduced [23].
This study had several limitations. Firstly, this study was a retrospective trial, not a randomized controlled trial. Secondly, the sample size was limited which will inevitably be affected by inherent data;. Another trial with large sample size was still needed in the future. Thirdly, all data in this study came from a hospital. Therefore, it was necessary to conduct a prospective multi-center study to validate our results.