Disease symptoms, incidence and fungal isolations. Characteristic external disease symptoms including general decline, cankers and plant death were seen during the summer and early autumn in three young apple orchards, both on the cvs. ‘Golden Delicious’ and ‘Red Delicious’. The leaves were pale yellow at first in some individual branches, then their margins became necrotic and in the late summer and early autumn, the color of the leaves changed to purple and finally died (Fig. 1). Shoot elongation was arrested in affected plants. Bark of the diseased plants was discolored and sunken at the soil line, longitudinal cracks and cankers were formed on the bark surface and discoloration was extended progressively both upward (up to 50 cm from the graft union) and downward to the main roots and into the wood. A distinct margin separated healthy from infected bark tissue and trees were killed when the infected area girdled entire trunk base. In cross-sections, there was a light brown to brown discoloration and necrosis as V or U shape in the hard wood (Fig. 1). Based on these external symptoms in the surveyed orchards, the incidence of the disease on the cv. ʻRed Delicious’ (15%) was higher than the cv. Golden Delicious (1%).
In this study, 24 fungal isolates (19 from the cv. ʻRed Delicious’ and 5 from the cv. ʻGolden Delicious’) were obtained and purified. Based on the comparison of morphological characteristics of the purified isolates, three were selected for multi-gene phylogenetic analysis and accurate species identification.
Phylogenetic analysis
The phylogenetic analysis of combined dataset (ITS, LSU, rpb2, act1 and tef 1-a) include 207 Cytospora ingroup strains representing 144 Cytospora species and Diaporthe eres CBS 145040 and Diaporthe vaccinii CBS 160.32 as outgroup strains with a total of 2676 characters including gaps (570 for ITS, 922 for LSU, 968 for rpb2, 238 for act1 and 509 for tef1-α). The best scoring RaxML tree with the final ML optimization likelihood value of –36304.329463 (ln) is selected to denote and consider the phylogenetic relationships among the strains (Fig. 2). Cytospora balanejica represented a monophyletic clade with high support value (87%) (marked in pink in Fig. 2).
Taxonomy
Cytospora balanejica R. Azizi, Y. Ghosta & A. Ahmadpour sp. nov. (Fig. 3)
MycoBank No.: MB843116.
Etymology: Named after the locality, Balanej village, where the holotype was collected.
Typification: Iran, West Azarbaijan Province, Urmia City, Balanej Village, 37°23′50.4″ N, 45°09′15.9″ E., from crown of Malus × domestica cv. ʻRed Delicious’, 15 Oct. 2017, R. Azizi (Holotype: IRAN 18133F; ex-type living culture: IRAN 4419C).
Description: Asexual morph: Conidiomata labyrinthine cytosporoid, immersed in the bark, erumpent when mature through the surface of the bark, discoid to conical, pale luteous to luteous, with multiple locules, (800–)850–1,490(–1,700) µm in diam. Conceptacle conspicuous, black, circular, surrounded the stromata. Ectostromatic disk greenish black to black, circular to ovoid, (473–)563–802(–845) µm in diam., with a single ostiole per disk in center. Ostiole conspicuous, circular to ovoid, olivaceous grey, at the same level as the disk surface, (94–)101–215(–230) µm in diam. Locules numerous, arranged circularly with shared invaginated walls. Conidiophores borne along the locules, hyaline, smooth, thin walled, unbranched or occasionally branched at base. Conidiogenous cells entroblastic, phialidic, subcylindrical to cylindrical, tapering towards apices, (6.2–)9–17(–19) × (1–)1.2–2 µm. Conidia hyaline, smooth, elongate allantoid, mostly biguttulate, aseptate, 3–5 × 1–1.8 µm. Sexual morph: not observed.
Culture characteristics: Colonies after 3 d at 25 °C on PDA average 57 mm and entirely covering the 9-cm diam. Petri dish after 7 days, margin entire, white to buff, with scattered aerial hyphae at center, the hyphae becoming very dense, pale luteous at center and honey at margins, forming abundant solitary or rarely aggregated pycnidia surrounded by off-white hyphae with age. Hyphae hyaline to light brown, septate, smooth walled and branched.
Habitat and distribution: Known only on Malus × domestica in Urmia, Iran.
Additional specimens examined: Iran, West Azarbaijan Province, Urmia City, Balanej Village, 37°24′26.1″ N, 45°10′24.8″ E., from the trunk of Malus × domestica cv. ‘Red Delicious’, 15 Oct. 2017, R. Azizi, (IRAN 4420C); West Azarbaijan Province, Urmia City, Kurane Village, 37°24′44.4″ N 45°8'45.3" E., from the trunk of Malus × domestica cv. ‘Golden Delicious’, 12 Sept. 2018, R. Azizi, (FCCUU 350).
Notes: Cytospora balanejica was isolated from young, declining apple trees showing symptoms of crown and collar canker and necrosis. The phylogenetic inferences based on combined multi-gene phylogeny resolved this species as a separate lineage distinct from all other strains included in this study, although it shared a sister relationship with a clade containing C. albodisca M. Pan & X.L. Fan and C. corylina H. Gao & X.L. Fan (Fig. 2). However, C. balanejica differs from C. albodisca based on slower growth rate (57 mm vs. 70 mm after 3 days), colony color (pale luteous vs. dark herbage green to dull green in C. albodisca), absence of ascomata and smaller conidia (3–5 × 1–1.8 µm vs. 5–7 × 1–2 µm)26. Also, it differs from C. corylina based on slower growth rate on PDA medium (57 mm after 3 days vs. 90 mm after 2 days in C. corylina), colony color (pale luteous vs. fucous black), the formation of distinct conceptacle, larger conidiomata (800–1700 µm vs. 850–1280 µm) and shorter conidia (3–5 µm vs. 3.5–7.5 µm)39. Therefore, we describe C. balanejica here as a new species.
Pathogenicity trials
Results of pathogenicity tests of the isolates on shoots of the cv. ‘Red Delicious’ showed sunken discolored lesions around the inoculated sites 14 days post-inoculation. Bark and wood discoloration was extended progressively upward and downward the inoculation site and after 20 days, fungal pycnidia were formed on the discolored bark. Despite this, the mean length of necrotic lesions varied among the isolates (data not shown). Re-isolation of the inoculated fungus and re-identification based on morphological characteristics fulfilled Koch’s postulates. All negative controls were symptomless and no colonies were obtained from samples taken from controls. The reaction of 12 tested cultivars against five selected isolates with higher virulence showed that the interaction between the factors isolates × cultivars was varied and significantly different at P ≤ 0.05 (Fig. 5). Except for the cv. ‘Braeburn’ which did not produce any symptoms of infection similar to control treatment against all tested fungal isolates, the other cultivars showed symptoms of infection at least against two fungal isolates (Fig. 4). The mean length of necrotic lesion ranged from 19.3 mm (the cv. ‘Idared’) to 188.3 mm (the cv. ‘M4’) for isolate BA 2–4 and from 63.3 mm (the cv. ‘MM106’) to 196.6 mm (the cv. ‘M4’) for isolate BA 1–1, both isolates were obtained from the cv. ‘Red Delicious’ (Fig. 5). The mean length of necrotic lesions ranged from 18.3 mm (the cv. ‘MM106’) to 193.3 mm (the cv. ‘M4’) for isolate KU 1–1 which was isolated from the cv. ‘Golden Delicious’, although the cvs. ‘Granny Smith’, ‘MM109’ and ‘Idared’ did not show any symptoms of infection against this isolate (Fig. 5). Also, the cvs. ‘Delbard Estivale’, ‘MM109’, ‘Idared’ and ‘Golden Delicious’ did not develop any symptoms of infection against BA 2–1 isolate and the mean length of necrotic lesion ranged from 101.6 mm (the cv. ‘Red Delicious’) to 190 mm (the cv. ‘Granny Smith’). At last, only four cultivars including ‘M4’, ‘M7’, ‘Golden Primrose’ and ‘Red Delicious’ developed symptoms of infection against BA 3–1 isolate and the mean length of necrotic lesion ranged from 93.3 mm (the cv. ‘Red Delicious’) to 206.6 mm (the cv. ‘M4’) (Fig. 5). Moreover, the aggressiveness of five tested isolates was varied and the isolates BA 2–4 and BA 3–1 had the highest and lowest aggressiveness against 12 tested cultivars, respectively. Re-isolation of the inoculated fungus was done in all symptomatic shoots and re-identified by morphological characteristics, fulfilled Koch’s postulates. Re-isolation of the fungus from asymptomatic shoots as well as negative controls was failed.