In the present study, we have shown that a recombinant rabies virus with two identical glycoprotein genes (dG) had a higher glycoprotein expression and produced more virus particles in cell culture than the parental PV strain. Further assessments for immunization of laboratory animals with an inactive form of those viruses showed that the glycoprotein duplication conferred more immunogenicity to the dG virus strain.
The overexpressed glycoproteins might incorporate into virus particles or increase the free glycoproteins in culture media. Some previous studies have shown the effect of the genomic location of G insertion on the incorporation of the glycoproteins in virus particles. The additional glycoprotein in this study, inserted in the rabies virus genome, was located downstream of the matrix gene, between G and L genes, and conferred improved immunogenicity to the recombinant virus. This finding is in accordance with previous studies that show the advantage of this region for gene insertion [15]. The suggested mechanism behind this issue is that the proximity of a gene with the promoter sequence determines the transcription and protein expression level. The addition of a G gene between P and M led to lower virus titers and lower glycoprotein numbers in virion particles. Despite the overexpression of total glycoprotein, the distance between M and promoter results in downregulation of matrix protein which has a crucial role in virus packaging, leading to lower amounts of glycoprotein in assembled virions. It has been shown that incorporating the additional glycoprotein in a location between M and G contributed to less apoptosis induction, more glycoprotein incorporation in virion particles, and better immunogenicity against rabies virus [15].
Current rabies vaccines need several visits for vaccine injection, making it difficult to comply with the completion of the vaccination course. Scientists attempt to improve vaccine quality by developing epitope-based and nucleic acid-based vaccines, virus-like particles, simian adenovirus-based vaccines, and chimeric rabies vaccines [20–23]. Consequently, certain efforts have been made successfully to improve the virus immunogenicity by concentrating on gene duplications [14, 24]. The glycoprotein of the rabies virus has a fundamental role in virus attachment and infectivity as well as inducing the host’s antiviral immune response [25, 26]; therefore, an increase in the virus glycoprotein can inherently enhance the host defense mechanism. Thus, the enhanced immune response induced by the gene duplication in our study in the mouse model could suggest that the glycoprotein duplication might be applicable to other vaccine strains of the rabies virus. Additionally, it has been reported that the intergenic region between G and L genes could be an appropriate location for other forms of gene incorporation into the virus genome [27].
The results of this study revealed a significant increase in virus titer after cloning an additive copy of the glycoprotein gene in the virus genome 72, 96, and 120 hours after infecting the BHK-21 cells. The dG strain titers were significantly higher than the PV strain in all studied hours of infection. These findings complied with previous works by Navid et al. and Liu et al., in which a similar increase in titers of the virus with two glycoprotein genes was observed [14, 15]. Both studies have demonstrated the increase of virus titers despite the witnessed increase in apoptosis. On the contrary, in another study by Tao, no differences were reported in virus titers after duplicating the glycoprotein gene [24]. These findings suggest that the impact of apoptosis conducted by duplication of glycoprotein is negligible. On the other hand, the overexpression of glycoprotein has a much higher impact on virus propagation. There is evidence that overexpression of the glycoprotein is witnessed in double G particles, which showed higher virus titers [15].
In all previous studies, there was a similar increase in glycoprotein expression. In two similar studies, Tariq et al. [15] and Liu et al.[14], reported an increase in the titration of recombinant SAD-B19 and Flurry-HEP strains with two glycoprotein genes, respectively [14, 15, 24, 25]. Tao et al. [24] witnessed no difference in virus titer after duplication of G in Flurry LEP strain, while Faber et al. [25] reported a decrease in the titer of recombinant double glycoprotein SAD-B19 virus. There has been a common report for the increase of apoptosis after overexpression of rabies virus glycoprotein [14, 15]. It seems that G overexpression has more positive impacts on virus titer compared to related negative impacts of increased apoptosis.
Laboratory animals are abundantly utilized to demonstrate vaccine quality, especially for rabies vaccine potency testing using the NIH challenge test. The NIH test, used for rabies vaccine potency assessment, has several inherent disadvantages and limitations [28]. Comparison between the immunizing capabilities of two viruses in this study was implemented based on a single-dose serological method recommended by the Monograph 0451 of the European Pharmacopoeia, thus considerably reducing the number of animals and averting rabies challenge infection [29, 30]. Seventy-two mice were vaccinated in three groups, including dG, PV, and control. The results of the RFFIT test from blood samples revealed a significant increase in the level of induced VNA in the dG vaccine. The rise in induced VNAs is common in similar previous studies [14, 15, 24, 25]. The proposed protocol by European Pharmacopeia has suggested collecting blood samples 14 days post-inoculation (DPI) [29, 30]. In addition to the proposed assessment in 14 DPI, which was used to compare with other studies, three other groups were studied, including 7DPI, 21 DPI, and a 14DPI group with an extra inoculation on day 7. The VNA titers of the dG strain were significantly higher in all four studied groups compared to the PV strain. For both strains, all four mentioned groups were compared with each other, and the results showed an order of 7DPI < 14 DPI < 14 DPI-2 injections < 21 DPI, in which all the differences were significant except the difference between 14 DPI-2injections and 21 DPI which was not statistically significant for both strains. In addition to comparing the VNA titers, preliminary results of this study might draw attention to a vaccination schedule on days 0, 7, and 14 for higher VNA titers.
According to WHO recommendations for inactivated rabies vaccine, the virus used for vaccine preparation should be a laboratory-adapted and attenuated strain with stable biological characteristics. The virus rescued in the current work has been recovered and purely generated from verified genetic sequences. In this regard, this type of modified virus has the potential to be used under regulations for manufacturing the rabies vaccine.