Themes
The extracted results included a rich overview of the components of functional problems of breast cancer survivors and the factors that acted as facilitators and barriers to their functions, which were obtained from the interview with these women and specialists who had experience working with this group of patients. Based on the extracted results (849 initial codes), functioning in survivors of BC was described in 660 (78%) out of the initial codes. Nine subthemes were extracted which define factors creating functioning in BC patients, including factors related to impairment, factors related to physical function, factors related to mental function, factors related to social life, factors related to self-perception, factors related to emotional interactions with family and friends, factors related to the cost of treatment, factors related to the health system, and factors related to personal emotions. The extracted subthemes were further categorized into three main themes: a) body functioning (189, 29%), b) physical functioning (186, 28%), c) social functioning (108, 16%), and d) mental functioning (177, 27%). Other extracted factors were labelled as modifiers that could affect the level of function and categorized as personal, emotional, and environmental. (Table 2)
Table 2. Frequencies of Main themes, and initial codes (core codes) of functioning in patients and experts
Themes
|
|
Meaningful concepts
|
Frequency Patients
|
Frequency experts
|
impairment (189)
[patient (16), experts (21) ]
|
pain and sensation (74)
[patient (14), experts (18)]
|
Pain at rest in the upper limb of the affected side
|
6
|
16
|
Pain in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
11
|
5
|
Sense of numbness at rest in the upper limb of the affected side
|
2
|
4
|
Sense of numbness in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
4
|
1
|
Sense of stretching or prickling in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
11
|
1
|
Sense of heaviness in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
1
|
6
|
Tingling sensation in the upper limb of the affected side
|
3
|
3
|
|
total
|
38
|
36
|
Fatigue
(57)
[patient (14), experts (17)]
|
Decreased physical ability and fatigue during daily activities
|
12
|
17
|
Decreased physical ability and fatigue during work activities
|
5
|
8
|
Performing repetitive and long-term movement activities with the upper limb of the shoulder and elbow (such as reaching hands behind the neck and the back, closing buttons on the back of the neck, underwear tie)
|
3
|
0
|
Performing long-term movements with fingers and wrists (e.g., writing, drawing, using a knife to chop vegetables or making salads, grating, long-time holding of books/cellphones)
|
7
|
5
|
|
total
|
27
|
30
|
Lymph and skin (44)
[patient (12), experts (18) ]
|
Skin problems such as skin discoloration, darkening, dryness, thinness, tightness, and changes in nails
|
8
|
10
|
Swelling in the upper limb and torso of the affected side (edema)
|
8
|
18
|
|
|
total
|
16
|
28
|
|
Hearth and respiratory (14)
[patient (8), experts (5)]
|
Respiratory problems such as dyspnea and severe coughs
|
0
|
2
|
Heart problems
|
8
|
4
|
|
|
total
|
8
|
6
|
physical function (186)
[patient (16), experts (22) ]
|
Sexual (38)
[patient (7), experts (15) ]
|
Difficulty with weight maintenance (obesity and overweight)
|
4
|
3
|
Problems with sexual function
|
3
|
11
|
Problems with menstrual functions
|
2
|
9
|
Problems with pregnancy function (sterility /infertility)
|
1
|
5
|
|
total
|
10
|
28
|
Overhead functioning
(29)
[patient (10), experts (13) ]
|
limited ROM of the shoulder
|
1
|
13
|
Performing overhead movements, such as raising hands above the shoulder level (picking items from the top floor of refrigerators, kitchen cabinets)
|
9
|
6
|
|
total
|
10
|
19
|
Manipulation and pushing
(10)
[patient (7), experts (1) ]
|
Pressing tough/hard things with the affected hand such as pushing the door
|
1
|
0
|
Screwing lids on stiff bottles
|
2
|
0
|
Grasping fine/small objects with hands
|
1
|
0
|
Squeezing and pressing clothes, cleaning clothes
|
5
|
1
|
|
total
|
9
|
1
|
Weightlifting (27)
[patient (14), experts (13) ]
|
Lifting and carrying heavy equipment and loads (e.g. heavy shopping bags, carrying bags on the shoulder, moving heavy pots while sieving rice)
|
14
|
13
|
Self-care, ADL and IADL (73)
[patient (16), experts (16) ]
|
Dressing/undressing clothes
|
8
|
7
|
Personal hygiene (e.g. bathing or showering, washing hair, cleaning after defecation, make-up)
|
8
|
2
|
Doing household chores (e.g., dusting and cleaning the house, washing dishes, making the bed, sweeping)
|
15
|
13
|
Cooking
|
3
|
6
|
Caring for others (e.g., hugging babies, caring for children and others)
|
3
|
8
|
|
|
total
|
37
|
36
|
|
Sleep (9)
[patient (6), experts (3) ]
|
Sleeping on the affected side
|
6
|
3
|
mental functioning (10)
[patient (2), experts (5)]
|
Cognition
(10)
|
attention and concentration problems in doing daily activities
|
1
|
4
|
Problems with memory and amnesia in doing daily tasks
|
1
|
4
|
|
total
|
2
|
8
|
Emotional function (167)
[patient (15), experts (21) ]
|
|
Sense of losing the beauty of appearance such as muddled appearance and unfitting appearance/clothing
|
3
|
3
|
|
One's lifestyle
|
11
|
8
|
|
One's viewpoints and attitudes toward disease and life
|
2
|
3
|
|
Levels of education and literacy
|
0
|
6
|
|
Sense of distress and sadness
|
11
|
15
|
|
Sense of loneliness
|
2
|
1
|
|
Sense of fear and fear of relapse
|
9
|
13
|
|
Concern about the disease impact on personal life
|
1
|
11
|
|
Feeling worried about the future of the disease
|
3
|
14
|
|
Feeling worried about the future
|
5
|
4
|
|
Feel guilty
|
1
|
2
|
|
Sense of burdensomeness and inattention in the family
|
0
|
3
|
|
Lack of motivation and impatience
|
2
|
4
|
|
Sense of hopelessness about the future
|
2
|
6
|
|
Sense of disability and disablement
|
5
|
5
|
|
Sense of failure in performing tasks and duties
|
1
|
0
|
|
Irritability/angriness and losing temper
|
3
|
0
|
|
Non-expression of feelings and emotions/not talking about one's feelings and emotions toward people and daily life events
|
2
|
4
|
|
Mental fatigue
|
0
|
2
|
|
total
|
50
|
87
|
Social functioning (108)
[patient (15), experts (20)]
|
Driving (1)
[patient (1 )]
|
Driving
|
1
|
0
|
Social life and interaction/communication (59)
[patient (13), experts (19)]
|
Participation in gatherings such as attending meetings, religious ceremonies, friendly and formal parties, attending workplace
|
1
|
5
|
Spousal relationships such as intimate and sexual relationships
|
5
|
15
|
Communication with family members such as father, mother, sister, brother, and children
|
0
|
6
|
Communication with other people such as friends, relatives, acquaintances, and colleagues
|
9
|
10
|
Communication with recovered individuals and peer groups
|
3
|
4
|
Going out of the house
|
0
|
1
|
|
total
|
18
|
41
|
Work (18)
[patient (5), experts (13) ]
|
Job-related matters
|
5
|
13
|
Leisure and sport (20)
[patient (8), experts (7) ]
|
Light sports activities (such as walking)
|
2
|
2
|
Heavy sports activities (such as yoga, aerobics, swimming, badminton)
|
2
|
3
|
Doing finger-related leisure activities (e.g., writing, sewing, knitting, working with cellphones, playing musical instruments)
|
6
|
5
|
|
|
total
|
10
|
10
|
|
Religious (10)
[patient (7), experts (3)]
|
Patients' religious beliefs
|
7
|
3
|
Modifiers: Personal factors=90
|
Factor related to self-perception (37)
[patient (4), experts (19)]
|
Body scheme (17)
|
Changes in the appearance of the breast and hand by mastectomy and swelling of the affected side
|
1
|
16
|
|
Decreased self-confidence
|
1
|
4
|
|
Problems with body image
|
4
|
11
|
|
|
total
|
6
|
31
|
Factor related to Emotional interactions with family and friends (53)
[patient (12), experts (18) ]
|
|
Lack of emotional support from spouse, children, and family members such as father, mother, sister and brother
|
3
|
4
|
Emotional support from relatives, acquaintances, friends and colleagues
|
2
|
0
|
lack of help, accompaniment and support of spousal, children, and family members in daily activities
|
7
|
14
|
Compassionate and sympathetic behaviors of companions
|
4
|
4
|
Incorrect judgments of companions about one's disease
|
5
|
10
|
|
|
total
|
21
|
32
|
Modifiers: environmental factors=99
|
Factors related to the cost of treatment (49)
[patient (8), experts (18) ]
|
|
High costs of disease treatment
|
5
|
15
|
inaccessibility to medicines from distribution centers such as pharmacies
|
5
|
2
|
Non-coverage of treatment costs by health insurance firms
|
2
|
11
|
Financial inability to provide assistive devices such as breast prostheses, bandages, and compression sleeves (use of support systems or donors to undertake treatment costs)
|
2
|
7
|
|
|
total
|
14
|
35
|
Factor related to health system (50)
[patient (9), experts (14)]
|
|
Insufficient information about the disease and its treatments from treatment team members
|
3
|
10
|
|
Lack of support, understanding, and accompaniment of the patient treatment team
|
6
|
7
|
|
Lack of psychological and palliative support to the patient during treatment
|
2
|
4
|
|
Lack of support and accompaniment from employers, such as employers' understanding of the patient's disease
|
1
|
2
|
|
Inaccessibility to disease-related educational programs and its treatments at hospitals and medical clinics such as group therapy programs, etc.
|
0
|
5
|
|
Poor service quality at public hospitals
|
2
|
2
|
|
Screening of healthy women by the health system
|
2
|
4
|
|
total
|
|
16
|
34
|
- Body functioning
The most common reported impairments that were problematic for patients in this study were pain, sensation (74,39%) and fatigue (57, 30% codes). Sixteen patients (P) and 21 experts (E) reported problems in pain, sensation, fatigue, lymph, skin, heart, and respiratory dysfunctions.
"I have pain in my axilla and side of the affected side" (P12), "I have severe pain in the scapula of the affected side "(P16)), ("Pain in the shoulder area, pain in the chest and back, pain in the arm, pain in the lateral part of the trunk and sides, pain in the axilla, neck pain due to the heaviness of the hand edema" (E11).
2. physical functioning
The most reported physical functioning problems were related to difficulty in performing self-care, ADL and IADL (73, 39% codes), sexual (38, 20% codes), overhead functioning (29, 16% codes), weightlifting (27, 14.5% codes), manipulation and pushing (10, 5% codes), and sleep (9, 5% codes).
The problems that patients mentioned in self-care, ADL and IADL, overhead functioning, weightlifting, manipulation and pushing, and sleep were directly related to the patient's impairment level, such as pain and sensation, fatigue, and lymph. Problems with Self-care, ADL, and IADL were more commonly reported codes raised by both groups of participants (16 patients and 16 experts). Among them, household chores (e.g., dusting and cleaning the house, washing dishes, making the bed, sweeping) received more complaints.
“I cannot clean and dust the house with the injured hand due to heaviness, edema and pressure on the hand” (P14). “By doing repetitive tasks such as sweeping, the hand becomes swollen” (E7) and “they are unable to do continuous housework “(E2).
"I am much slower in housework. I am not as hard as I used to be working and living; I cannot go up the stairs quickly, for example, I cannot do housework in a row; whatever I do, I must sit for a quarter to twenty minutes to find some energy to start the next work again" (P2).
Ever since I got sick, I have felt sad and sad about the future of my family life as I cannot support them anymore and I cannot do even my self-care; I think I have been depressed" (P13)" I'm sad that I cannot have the previous routine of my life (P12).
3. Social functioning
Most of the problems in this content were raised by 15 patients and 20 experts in different areas such as social life and interaction/communication (59, 55% codes), leisure and sport (20, 18.5% codes), work (18, 17% codes), religious (10, 9% codes) and driving (1, 1% codes).
Most of the problems mentioned by patients and experts indicated that the level of impairment and physical functions are the reason for having difficulties in this area. The most common problem with social life and interaction /communication with others was "Spousal relationships such as intimate and sexual relationships."
"Sex with my wife was interrupted because my body's ability and endurance were deficient; then, the menopausal symptoms bothered me a lot; the injections I was taking to disable the ovaries and uterus bothered me a lot." (P2). "Decreased sexual intercourse with the spouse and dissatisfaction with sexual activities due to a disorder in the body's appearance and hiding one's appearance from the spouse, discomfort in bed during sexual intercourse due to swelling of the hands and trunk" (E15).
4. Mental functioning
The functional problems mentioned by two patients and five experts in this study included problems with attention, concentration (5, 50% codes), memory and amnesia (5, 50% codes) in daily tasks. The content of mental functions indicates that breast cancer survivors have experienced different negative emotions such as a sense of loneliness, concern about the disease's impact on personal life, feeling worried about the future of the disease, Feel guilty, sense of hopelessness about the future, Etc. The relation between difficulty in performing ADL, IADL, and self-care with emotional problems was reciprocal. Patients reported negative emotions in response to their level of functioning in Self-care, ADL and IADL. They also expressed that they cannot perform their functional activities due to emotional problems.
Modifiers of function
We also extracted codes which were modifiers of functioning and categorized them into three themes: environmental, personal, and emotional factors.
2. Environmental factors
a. Factors related to the costs of treatment
Eight patients and 18 experts reported problems with the costs of the treatment. Concepts extracted from participants' conversations on this theme include the high cost of treatment (20, 41% codes), the lack of insurance coverage for some drugs (13, 26.5% codes), the difficult access to some drugs (7, 14% codes), the lack of the small number of support systems and charities in the community to pay for assistive devices Such as breast prostheses, bandages, and pressure gloves (9, 18% codes).
b. Factors related to health systems
Nine patients and 14 experts reported problems in the health systems. The most common problem in this area was "insufficient information about the disease and its treatments from treatment team members" and "lack of support, understanding, and accompaniment of the patient treatment team," with 13, 26% codes.
Concepts related to health systems in this study by breast cancer survivors and specialists mainly indicated deficiencies in providing psychological and palliative services, educational programs, and screening of healthy women. In many cases, there was also a poor understanding and support of the treatment team in informing patients, which could be an inhibitor in improving the performance of these women.
"Women are not trained to examine their breasts; if this is done, it will cause women to come sooner, and their disease condition will not worsen, and they will not have to have their breasts removed completely" (P8).
2. Personal and emotional factors
- Factors related to personal emotions
Fifteen patients and 21 experts reported problems with personal emotions, and the most common problem in this area was categorized as "sense of distress and sadness (26, 19% codes)" and " sense of fear and fear of relapse (22, 16% codes)".
Breast cancer survivors have experienced different negative emotions such as a sense of loneliness, concern about the disease's impact on personal life, feeling worried about the future of the disease, feeling guilty, and hopelessness about the future. The most common negative emotions that patients experienced included a sense of distress and sadness and a sense of fear and fear of relapse. They stated that these negative emotions are related to their level of function in performing self-care, ADL and IADL.
"I am sad that I cannot have the previous routine of my life(P12). Ever since I got sick, I have felt sad and sad about the future of my family life; I think I have been depressed" (P13). (The patient becomes depressed and isolated due to a change in their breast appearance and edema of the hand., they feel uncomfortable with the tightness of the clothes she has already worn with the swelling created in her hand"(E9).
"I am always stressed by the negative impact of chemotherapy and cancer" (P12). "I am afraid of disease and death" (P8))" Patients have stress and anxiety due to not returning to normal life activities (whether housework or work activities) and are also afraid of leaving their spouse and remarrying" (E15).
- Factor related to self-perception
Four patients and 19 experts reported problems in self-perception, and the most common complaint in this area was body scheme (17, 46% codes). This topic included changes in appearance resulting from the removal of all or part of the breast and the swelling caused by the removal of lymph nodes, which disturbed the person's mental image. Self-perception was mentioned as a barrier to communicating with others in social life.
"I was afraid of the bad reaction of my children and my wife to the mutilation and removal of my breast" (P2)" Young women felt the loss of physical beauty and acceptance of breast resection "(S16).
- Factors related to emotional interactions with family and friends
Twelve patients and 18 experts reported problems in emotional interactions with family and friends that forced them to avoid socialization and participation. The most common problem in this area was a lack of help, accompaniment and support from spouses, children, and family members in daily activities (21, 40% codes). The content expressed by the participants here was emotional interactions, help and companionship of people who interacted with the individual in the family and community environment. However, some patients reported experiencing a bad feeling about incorrect judgments about their capability and receiving extreme support or compassion. In this theme, the most common concept mentioned by patients and specialists was help, accompaniment and support of spousal, children, and family members in daily activities.
"Sometime after my illness, my wife refused to accompany me, and I even paid for the hospital myself, "everyone around me was kind of tired, or I finally gave up, and after two years, I was left alone. " I need someone to accompany me for chemotherapy. I called my relatives to be by my side, but they refused, so I am alone for about 7 or 8 sessions now”. (P2).
We also extracted some extra 30, 3.5% codes that could not be classified as functioning directly; however, they could be considered facilitators or barriers to functioning in BC survivors. Most of the extracted codes were related to coping strategies (19, 63% codes), level of literacy and education (6, 20% codes), and personal views and attitudes toward illness and life (5, 17% codes).
For example, some patients stated that their perception of life had changed for the better:
"My outlook on life and the world has changed since I became ill, and I try to enjoy my life more and increase my satisfaction with life and the present" (P7), or another patient would say, "After the illness, I try to enjoy more of my free time with my family" (P12).
Experts also indicated that individuals' literacy levels sometimes helped them benefit from educational facilities (brochures or YouTube links). However, interviews revealed that patients with lower literacy levels were better able to cope with their illness. In contrast, patients with higher literacy levels were more stressed. Some patients indicated that they tried to change their lifestyle to cope with the illness. They increased the time in their leisure time and tried to have healthy eating and practice doing their self-care independently.
"I think doing my self-care can help me a lot. Everyone should take care of themselves so that one does not take care of oneself and cannot expect from others. For example, I now regularly take my medicine, regularly check with my doctor, or communicate and reach Completely to the sport that I have at home" (P1)" After the illness, my compatibility has improved to cope with the appearance of my body. I listen to music to increase my peace of mind and reduce my mental distress" (P16).
Linking to ICF
Extracted meaningful concepts from the interview with breast cancer survivors
Of the 338 concepts extracted from patient interviews, 146 (43%) concepts were linked with the ICF Body function and structure, 121(36%) to activity and participation, 44(13%) to environmental factors and 11 (3%) to personal factors category.
Patients reported difficulty in different areas of body function such as were Chapter B1: mental function (44, 30%), Chapter B7: Neuromusculoskeletal and movement-related functions (25, 17%), Chapter B4: Functions of the cardiovascular, hematological, immunological, and respiratory systems (33, 23%), and Chapter B2: Sensory functions and Pain (23, 16%). The highest frequency of reported functional problems was related to b152 Emotional functions (25, 17%), b2801 Pain in body parts, and b455 Exercise tolerance functions (17, 12%).
Patients reported difficulties in D4: Mobility 37 (30.5%), D5: Self-care (16,13 %) , D6: Domestic life (21 ,17%), D7: Interpersonal interactions and relationships (17, 14%), D8: Major life areas(12, 10%) and D9: Community, social and civic life (18,15%). The majority of the raised problem in the activity and participation area were Doing housework (d640-15,12%) and lifting and carrying objects (d430-14, 11.5%).
Some of the raised difficulty areas from the patient’s view could not be linked with any codes and categories of the core set for breast cancer. However, they were linked to eight codes from body function and 14 codes from activity and participation (Table 3).
The other 27 concepts could not be linked to the ICF. The content of the meaningful concepts, which could not be assigned to the most precise ICF categories, were classified into three concepts based on the updated linking. The concept refers to mental health (nd-mh : Sense of losing the beauty of appearance, Sense of loneliness, feeling guilty, sense of hopelessness about the future, Sense of disability and disablement and Sense of failure in performing tasks and duties) and concepts that cannot be covered by the ICF (nc; non-coverage of treatment costs by health insurance firms), and the concepts referred to personal factors(one's lifestyle) (Table 3)
Table 3 - ICF categories and IPC linked to the meaningful concepts were obtained from the interview with breast cancer survivors
Meaningful Concepts
|
Number of codes
|
ICF Core Set for breast cancer
|
General ICF
|
IPF code
|
Body Functions: 146
[patient (16)]
|
B1: Mental functions: 44
[patient (16)]
|
Decreased self-confidence :
|
1
|
b126 Temperament and personality functions
|
|
E_P
|
Lack of motivation and impatience :
|
2
|
b130 energy and drive functions
|
|
E_ P
|
attention and concentration problems in doing daily activities
|
1
|
|
b140 Attention functions
|
R_B*B
|
Problems with memory and amnesia in doing daily tasks
|
1
|
|
b144 Memory functions
|
R_ B*B
|
Sense of distress and sadness:
|
11
|
b152 Emotional functions
|
|
E_ P
|
Sense of fear and fear of relapse:
|
9
|
b152 Emotional functions
|
|
E_ P
|
Irritability/angriness and losing temper:
|
3
|
b152 Emotional functions
|
|
E_P
|
Non-expression of feelings and emotions/not talking about one's feelings and emotions toward people and daily life events:
|
2
|
b152 Emotional functions
|
|
E_P
|
Concern about the disease impact on personal life
|
1
|
|
b160 Thought functions
|
E_ P
|
Feeling worried about the future of the disease
|
3
|
|
b160 Thought functions
|
E_ P
|
Feeling worried about the future
|
5
|
|
b160 Thought functions
|
E_ P
|
Changes in the appearance of the breast and hand by mastectomy and swelling of the affected side
|
1
|
b1801 Body image
|
|
R_B
|
Problems with body image
|
4
|
b1801 Body image
|
|
R_ P
|
B2: Sensory functions and pain: 23
[patient (14)]
|
Sense of numbness at rest in the upper limb of the affected side
|
2
|
b265
Touch function
|
|
R_B
|
Sense of numbness in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
4
|
b265
Touch function
|
|
R_ B*B
|
Pain at rest in the upper limb of the affected side
|
6
|
b2801
Pain in body parts
|
|
R _ B
|
Pain in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
11
|
b2801
Pain in body parts
|
|
R_B*B
|
B4: Functions of the cardiovascular, haematological, immunological and respiratory systems: 33
[patient (16)]
|
Heart problems
|
8
|
|
b410 Heart functions
|
R_ B
|
Swelling in the upper limb and torso of the affected side (edema)
|
8
|
b4353 Functions of lymphatic vessels
|
|
R_ B
|
Decreased physical ability and fatigue during daily activities
|
12
|
b455 Exercise tolerance functions
|
b4552 Fatiguability
|
R_ B*B
|
Decreased physical ability and fatigue during work activities
|
5
|
b455 Exercise tolerance functions
|
b 4552 Fatiguability
|
R_B*S
|
B5: Functions of the digestive, metabolic and endocrine systems: 4
[patient (4)]
|
Difficulty with weight maintenance (obesity and overweight)
|
4
|
b530 Weight maintenance functions
|
|
R_ B
|
B6: Genitourinary and reproductive functions: 6
[patient (6)]
|
Problems with sexual function
|
3
|
b640 Sexual functions
|
|
R_ B
|
Problems with menstrual functions
|
2
|
b650 Menstruation functions
|
|
R_ B
|
Problems with pregnancy function (sterility /infertility)
|
1
|
b660 Procreation functions
|
|
R_ B
|
B7: Neuromusculoskeletal and movement-related functions: 25
[patient (12)]
|
limited ROM of the shoulder
|
1
|
b710 Mobility of joint functions
|
|
R_B
|
Performing overhead movements, such as raising hands above the shoulder level (picking items from the top floor of refrigerators, kitchen cabinets)
|
9
|
b710 Mobility of joint functions
|
|
R_B
|
Performing repetitive and long-term movement activities with the upper limb of the shoulder and elbow (such as reaching hands behind the neck and the back, closing buttons on the back of the neck, underwear tie)
|
3
|
b710 Mobility of joint functions
|
|
R_B
|
Sense of heaviness in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
1
|
b780 Sensations related to muscles and movement functions
|
|
R_ B*B
|
Sense of stretching or prickling in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
11
|
|
b7808 Sensations related to muscles and movement functions, other
specified
|
R_ B*B
|
B8: Functions of the skin and related structures: 11
[patient (9)]
|
Skin problems such as skin discoloration, darkening, dryness, thinness, tightness, and changes in nails
|
8
|
b810 Protective functions of the skin
|
b860 Functions of nails,
b849 Functions of the skin, other specified and unspecified
|
R_ B
|
Tingling sensation in the upper limb of the affected side
|
3
|
b840 Sensation related to the skin
|
|
R_B
|
Activity & Participation: 121
[patient (16)]
|
D4: Mobility: 37
[patient (15)]
|
Sleeping on the affected side
|
6
|
|
d415 Maintaining a body position
|
R_B
|
Lifting and carrying heavy equipment and loads (e.g. heavy shopping bags, carrying bags on the shoulder, moving heavy pots while sieving rice)
|
14
|
d430 Lifting and carrying objects
|
|
R_ B
|
Performing long-term movements with fingers and wrists (e.g. writing, drawing, using a knife to chopping vegetables or making salads, grating, long-time holding of books/cellphones)
|
7
|
|
d440 Fine hand use
|
R_ B
|
Grasping fine/small objects with hands
|
1
|
|
d 4402 Manipulating, d4401 Grasping
|
R_ B
|
Pressing tough/hard things with the affected hand such as pushing the door
|
1
|
d445 Hand and arm use
|
d4451 Pushing
|
R_B
|
Screwing lids on stiff bottles
|
2
|
d445Hand and arm use
|
d 4453 Turning or twisting the hands or arms
|
R_ B
|
Squeezing and pressing clothes, cleaning clothes
|
5
|
d445Hand and arm use
|
d4453 Turning or twisting the hands or arms
|
R_ B
|
Driving
|
1
|
|
d475 Driving
|
R_S
|
D5: Self-care: 16
[patient (10)]
|
Personal hygiene (e.g. bathing or showering, washing hair, cleaning after defecation, make-up)
|
8
|
d510 Washing oneself, d520 Caring for body parts
|
|
R_B
|
Dressing/undressing clothes
|
8
|
d540 Dressing
|
|
R_B
|
D6: Domestic life:21
[patient (15)]
|
Cooking
|
3
|
d630 Preparing meals
|
|
R_B
|
Doing household chores (e.g., dusting and cleaning the house, washing dishes, making the bed, sweeping)
|
15
|
d640 Doing housework
|
|
R_B
|
Caring for others (e.g., hugging babies, caring for children and others)
|
3
|
d660 Assisting others
|
|
R_S
|
D7: Interpersonal interactions and relationships: 17
[patient (13)]
|
Communication with other people such as friends, relatives, acquaintances, and colleagues
|
9
|
d750 Informal social relationships
|
d740 Formal relationships
|
R_ S
|
Communication with recovered individuals and peer groups
|
3
|
|
d 7504 Informal relationships with peers
|
R_ S
|
Spousal relationships such as intimate and sexual relationships
|
5
|
d770 Intimate relationships
|
|
R_B*S
|
D8: Major life areas: 12
[patient (7)]
|
Job-related matters
|
5
|
d 850 Remunerative employment
|
|
R_B*S
|
High costs of disease treatment
|
5
|
|
d 870 Economic self-sufficiency
|
R_I
|
Financial inability to provide assistive devices such as breast prostheses, bandages, and compression sleeves (use of support systems or donors to undertake treatment costs)
|
2
|
|
d 870 Economic self-sufficiency
|
R_ I
|
D9: Community, social and civic life: 18
[patient (10)]
|
Participation in gatherings such as attending meetings, religious ceremonies, friendly and formal parties, attending workplace
|
1
|
|
d910 Community life
|
R_S
|
Light sports activities (such as walking)
|
2
|
d920 Recreation and leisure
|
d9201 Sports, d450 Walking
|
R_B*S
|
Heavy sports activities (such as yoga, aerobics, swimming, badminton)
|
2
|
d920 Recreation and leisure
|
d9201 Sports
|
R_B*S
|
Doing finger-related leisure activities (e.g., writing, sewing, knitting, working with cellphones, playing musical instruments)
|
6
|
d920 Recreation and leisure
|
d440 Fine hand use
|
R_B
|
Patients' religious beliefs
|
7
|
|
d 930 Religion and spirituality
|
R_P
|
Environmental Factors: 44
[patient (13)]
|
E1: Products and technology: 5
[patient (5)]
|
inaccessibility to medicines from distribution centers such as pharmacies
|
5
|
e110 Products or substances for personal consumption
|
|
R_ I
|
E3: Support and relationships: 24
[patient (12)]
|
Lack of emotional support from spouse, children, and family members such as father, mother, sister and brother
|
3
|
e 310 Immediate family
|
|
E_P*S
|
Emotional support from relatives, acquaintances, friends and colleagues
|
2
|
e325 Acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors, and community members,
e320 Friends
|
|
E_ P*S
|
Lack of support and accompaniment from employers, such as employers' understanding of the patient's disease
|
1
|
|
e330 People in positions of authority
|
R_ S
|
Lack of support, understanding, and accompaniment of the patient treatment team
|
6
|
e 340 Personal care providers and personal assistants,
e 355 Health professionals
|
|
R_S
|
Lack of psychological and palliative support to the patient during treatment
|
2
|
e 340 Personal care providers and personal assistants,
e 355 Health professionals
|
|
E_P*S
|
Insufficient information about the disease and its treatments from treatment team members:
|
3
|
e355 Health professionals
|
|
R_S
|
lack of help, accompaniment and support of spousal, children, and family members in daily activities
|
7
|
|
e398 Support and relationships, other specified
|
R_S
|
E4: Attitudes: 11
[patient (7)]
|
Compassionate and sympathetic behaviors of companions
|
4
|
e425 Individual attitudes of acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors, and community members
|
|
E_ P*S
|
Incorrect judgments of companions about one's disease
|
5
|
e425 Individual attitudes of acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors, and community members
|
|
E_ P*S
|
One's viewpoints and attitudes toward disease and life
|
2
|
|
e498 Attitudes, other specified
|
R_ X
|
E5: Services, systems and policies: 4
[patient (3)]
|
Poor service quality at public hospitals
|
2
|
e580 Health services, systems, and policies
|
|
R_I
|
Screening of healthy women by the health system
|
2
|
e580 Health services, systems, and policies
|
|
R_ I
|
Personal Factors:11
[patient (11)]
|
One's lifestyle
|
11
|
pf
|
pf
|
R_ X
|
Nd-mh: 14
[patient (7)]
|
Sense of losing the beauty of appearance such as muddled appearance and unfitting appearance/clothing
|
3
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ B*P
|
Sense of loneliness
|
2
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ P
|
Feel guilty
|
1
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ P
|
Sense of hopelessness about the future
|
2
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ P
|
Sense of disability and disablement
|
5
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ B*P
|
Sense of failure in performing tasks and duties
|
1
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ B*P
|
Nc : 2
[patient (2)]
|
Non-coverage of treatment costs by health insurance firms
|
2
|
nc
|
nc
|
R_ I
|
Extracted meaningful concepts from the interview with specialists
Of the 511 concepts extracted from specialists’ interviews, 246 (48%) concepts were linked with the ICF Body function and structure, 147 (29%) to activity and participation, 71 (14%) to environmental factors and 14 (3%) to personal factors category. Specialists reported difficulty in different areas of body function such as were Chapter B1: mental function (104 ,42%), Chapter B7: Neuromusculoskeletal and movement-related functions (26, 10 %), Chapter B4: Functions of the cardiovascular, hematological, immunological, and respiratory systems (49, 20%), Chapter B2: Sensory functions and Pain (26 ,10 %), and Chapter B6: Genitourinary and reproductive functions (25 ,10%). The highest frequency of reported functional problems was related to b152 Emotional functions (32 ,13%), b160 Thought functions (29 ,12%), b1801 Body image (27,11%), b455 Exercise tolerance functions (25 ,10%), and b2801 Pain in body parts 21 (8.5%).
Specialists reported difficulties in D4: Mobility 22 (15%) , D5: Self-care (9, 6 %) , D6: Domestic life (28,19%), D7: Interpersonal interactions and relationships (35, 24%), D8: Major life areas(35, 24%) and D9: Community, social and civic life(18, 12%).The majority of raised problem in activity and participation area were Economic self-sufficiency (d 870 -22 ,15%), Intimate relationships (d770- 15,10%), Lifting and carrying objects with (d430- 13, 9%), Doing housework (d640-13 ,9%) and Remunerative employment (d850- 13, 9%)
Some of the raised difficulty areas from the specialists’ view could not be linked with any cedes and categories of the core set for breast cancer. However, they were linked to nine codes from body function and ten codes from activity and participation (Table 4).
Table 4 - ICF categories and IPC linked to the meaningful concepts were obtained from the interview with medical specialist
Meaningful Concepts
|
|
ICF Core Set for breast cancer
|
General ICF
|
IPF code
|
Body Functions: 246
[specialists (22) ]
|
B1: Mental functions:104
[specialists (22) ]
|
Decreased self-confidence
|
4
|
b126 Temperament and personality functions
|
|
E_P
|
Lack of motivation and impatience
|
4
|
b130 energy and drive functions
|
|
E_ P
|
attention and concentration problems in doing daily activities
|
4
|
|
b140 Attention functions
|
R_B*B
|
Problems with memory and amnesia in doing daily tasks
|
4
|
|
b144 Memory functions
|
R_ B*B
|
Sense of distress and sadness
|
15
|
b152 Emotional functions
|
|
E_ P
|
Sense of fear and fear of relapse
|
13
|
b152 Emotional functions
|
|
E_ P
|
Non-expression of feelings and emotions/not talking about one's feelings and emotions toward people and daily life events
|
4
|
b152 Emotional functions
|
|
E_P
|
Concern about the disease impact on personal life
|
11
|
|
b160 Thought functions
|
E_ P
|
Feeling worried about the future of the disease
|
14
|
|
b160 Thought functions
|
E_ P
|
Feeling worried about the future
|
4
|
|
b160 Thought functions
|
E_ P
|
Changes in the appearance of the breast and hand by mastectomy and swelling of the affected side
|
16
|
b1801 Body image
|
|
R_B
|
Problems with body image
|
11
|
b1801 Body image
|
|
R_ P
|
B2: Sensory functions and pain: 26
[specialists (18) ]
|
Sense of numbness at rest in the upper limb of the affected side
|
4
|
b265
Touch function
|
|
R_B
|
Sense of numbness in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
1
|
b265
Touch function
|
|
R_ B*B
|
Pain at rest in the upper limb of the affected side
|
16
|
b2801
Pain in body parts
|
|
R _ B
|
Pain in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
5
|
b2801
Pain in body parts
|
|
R_B*B
|
B4: Functions of the cardiovascular, haematological, immunological and respiratory systems: 49
[specialists (21) ]
|
Heart problems
|
4
|
|
b410 Heart functions
|
R_ B
|
Swelling in the upper limb and torso of the affected side (edema)
|
18
|
b4353 Functions of lymphatic vessels
|
|
R_ B
|
Respiratory problems such as dyspnea and severe coughs
|
2
|
|
b440 Respiration functions
|
R_ B
|
Decreased physical ability and fatigue during daily activities
|
17
|
b455 Exercise tolerance functions
|
b4552 Fatiguability
|
R_ B*B
|
Decreased physical ability and fatigue during work activities
|
8
|
b455 Exercise tolerance functions
|
b 4552 Fatiguability
|
R_B*S
|
B5: Functions of the digestive, metabolic and endocrine systems: 3
[specialists (3) ]
|
Difficulty with weight maintenance (obesity and overweight)
|
3
|
b530 Weight maintenance functions
|
|
R_ B
|
B6: Genitourinary and reproductive functions: 25
[specialists (15) ]
|
Problems with sexual function
|
11
|
b640 Sexual functions
|
|
R_ B
|
Problems with menstrual functions
|
9
|
b650 Menstruation functions
|
|
R_ B
|
Problems with pregnancy function (sterility /infertility)
|
5
|
b660 Procreation functions
|
|
R_ B
|
B7: Neuromusculoskeletal and movement-related functions: 26
[specialists (13) ]
|
limited ROM of the shoulder
|
13
|
b710 Mobility of joint functions
|
|
R_B
|
Performing overhead movements, such as raising hands above the shoulder level (picking items from the top floor of refrigerators, kitchen cabinets)
|
6
|
b710 Mobility of joint functions
|
|
R_B
|
Sense of heaviness in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
6
|
b780 Sensations related to muscles and movement functions
|
|
R_ B*B
|
Sense of stretching or prickling in the upper limb of the affected side during daily activities
|
1
|
|
b7808 Sensations related to muscles and movement functions, other
specified
|
R_ B*B
|
B8: Functions of the skin and related structures: 13
[specialists (11) ]
|
Skin problems such as skin discoloration, darkening, dryness, thinness, tightness, and changes in nails
|
10
|
b810 Protective functions of the skin
|
b860 Functions of nails,
b849 Functions of the skin, other specified and unspecified
|
R_ B
|
Tingling sensation in the upper limb of the affected side
|
3
|
b840 Sensation related to the skin
|
|
R_B
|
Activity & Participation: 147
[specialists (21) ]
|
D4: Mobility: 22
[specialists (15) ]
|
Sleeping on the affected side
|
3
|
|
d415 Maintaining a body position
|
R_B
|
Lifting and carrying heavy equipment and loads (e.g. heavy shopping bags, carrying bags on the shoulder, moving heavy pots while sieving rice)
|
13
|
d430 Lifting and carrying objects
|
|
R_ B
|
Performing long-term movements with fingers and wrists (e.g. writing, drawing, using a knife to chopping vegetables or making salads, grating, long-time holding of books/cellphones)
|
5
|
|
d440 Fine hand use
|
R_ B
|
Squeezing and pressing clothes, cleaning clothes
|
1
|
d445Hand and arm use
|
d4453 Turning or twisting the hands or arms
|
R_ B
|
D5: Self-care: 9
[specialists (7) ]
|
Personal hygiene (e.g. bathing or showering, washing hair, cleaning after defecation, make-up)
|
2
|
d510 Washing oneself, d520 Caring for body parts
|
|
R_B
|
Dressing/undressing clothes
|
7
|
d540 Dressing
|
|
R_B
|
D6: Domestic life:28
[specialists (16) ]
|
Going out of the house
|
1
|
d 620 Acquisition of goods and services
|
|
R_B*S
|
Cooking
|
6
|
d630 Preparing meals
|
|
R_B
|
Doing household chores (e.g., dusting and cleaning the house, washing dishes, making the bed, sweeping)
|
13
|
d640 Doing housework
|
|
R_B
|
Caring for others (e.g., hugging babies, caring for children and others)
|
8
|
d660 Assisting others
|
|
R_S
|
D7: Interpersonal interactions and relationships: 35
[specialists (17) ]
|
Communication with other people such as friends, relatives, acquaintances, and colleagues
|
10
|
d750 Informal social relationships
|
d740 Formal relationships
|
R_ S
|
Communication with recovered individuals and peer groups
|
4
|
|
d 7504 Informal relationships with peers
|
R_ S
|
Communication with family members such as father, mother, sister, brother, and children
|
6
|
d760 Family relationships
|
|
R_S
|
Spousal relationships such as intimate and sexual relationships
|
15
|
d770 Intimate relationships
|
|
R_B*S
|
D8: Major life areas: 35
[specialists (19) ]
|
Job-related matters
|
13
|
d 850 Remunerative employment
|
|
R_B*S
|
High costs of disease treatment
|
15
|
|
d 870 Economic self-sufficiency
|
R_I
|
Financial inability to provide assistive devices such as breast prostheses, bandages, and compression sleeves (use of support systems or donors to undertake treatment costs)
|
7
|
|
d 870 Economic self-sufficiency
|
R_ I
|
D9: Community, social and civic life:18
[specialists (11) ]
|
Participation in gatherings such as attending meetings, religious ceremonies, friendly and formal parties, attending workplace
|
5
|
|
d910 Community life
|
R_S
|
Light sports activities (such as walking)
|
2
|
d920 Recreation and leisure
|
d9201 Sports, d450 Walking
|
R_B*S
|
Heavy sports activities (such as yoga, aerobics, swimming, badminton)
|
3
|
d920 Recreation and leisure
|
d9201 Sports
|
R_B*S
|
Doing finger-related leisure activities (e.g., writing, sewing, knitting, working with cellphones, playing musical instruments)
|
5
|
d920 Recreation and leisure
|
d440 Fine hand use
|
R_B
|
Patients' religious beliefs
|
3
|
|
d 930 Religion and spirituality
|
R_P
|
Environmental Factors: 71
[specialists (19) ]
|
E1: Products and technology: 2
[specialists (2) ]
|
inaccessibility to medicines from distribution centers such as pharmacies
|
2
|
e110 Products or substances for personal consumption
|
|
R_ I
|
E3: Support and relationships:41
[specialists (19) ]
|
Lack of emotional support from spouse, children, and family members such as father, mother, sister and brother
|
4
|
e 310 Immediate family
|
|
E_P*S
|
Lack of support and accompaniment from employers, such as employers' understanding of the patient's disease
|
2
|
|
e330 People in positions of authority
|
R_ S
|
Lack of support, understanding, and accompaniment of the patient treatment team
|
7
|
e 340 Personal care providers and personal assistants,
e 355 Health professionals
|
|
R_S
|
Lack of psychological and palliative support to the patient during treatment
|
4
|
e 340 Personal care providers and personal assistants,
e 355 Health professionals
|
|
E_P*S
|
Insufficient information about the disease and its treatments from treatment team members
|
10
|
e355 Health professionals
|
|
R_S
|
lack of help, accompaniment and support of spousal, children, and family members in daily activities
|
14
|
|
e398 Support and relationships, other specified
|
R_S
|
E4: Attitudes: 17
[specialists (12) ]
|
Compassionate and sympathetic behaviors of companions
|
4
|
e425 Individual attitudes of acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors, and community members
|
|
E_ P*S
|
Incorrect judgments of companions about one's disease
|
10
|
e425 Individual attitudes of acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors, and community members
|
|
E_ P*S
|
One's viewpoints and attitudes toward disease and life
|
3
|
|
e498 Attitudes, other specified
|
R_ X
|
E5: Services, systems and policies:11
[specialists (8) ]
|
Poor service quality at public hospitals
|
2
|
e580 Health services, systems, and policies
|
|
R_I
|
Screening of healthy women by the health system
|
4
|
e580 Health services, systems, and policies
|
|
R_ I
|
Inaccessibility to disease-related educational programs and its treatments at hospitals and medical clinics such as group therapy programs, etc.
|
5
|
|
e585 Education and training services, systems, and policies
|
R_ S
|
Personal Factors:14
[specialists (12) ]
|
One's lifestyle
|
8
|
pf
|
pf
|
R_ X
|
Levels of education and literacy
|
6
|
pf
|
pf
|
R_ X
|
Nd-mh: 22
[specialists (14) ]
|
Sense of losing the beauty of appearance such as muddled appearance and unfitting appearance/clothing
|
3
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ B*P
|
Sense of loneliness
|
1
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ P
|
Feel guilty
|
2
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ P
|
Sense of burdensomeness and inattention in the family
|
3
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ P
|
Sense of hopelessness about the future
|
6
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ P
|
Sense of disability and disablement
|
5
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_ B*P
|
Mental fatigue
|
2
|
nd-mh
|
nd-mh
|
E_P
|
Nc : 11
[specialists (11) ]
|
Non-coverage of treatment costs by health insurance firms
|
11
|
nc
|
nc
|
R_ I
|
The other 47 concepts could not be linked to the ICF. The content of the meaningful concepts, which could not be assigned to the most precise ICF categories, were classified into three concepts based on the updated linking. The concept refers to mental health (nd-mh : Sense of losing the beauty of appearance, Sense of loneliness, feeling guilty, Sense of burdensomeness and inattention in the family, Sense of hopelessness about the future, Sense of disability and disablement, mental fatigue) and concepts that cannot be covered by the ICF (nc; non-coverage of treatment costs by health insurance firms), and the concepts referred to personal factors(one's lifestyle, levels of education and literacy) (Table 4).
In total, 592 meaningful concepts were linked with at least a comprehensive ICF Core Set category for BC, resulting in an absolute linkage score of 70%. Thirty-eight meaningful concepts were linked with a unique code comprehensive Core Set for BC, resulting in a unique linkage score of 4%. Concepts extracted in this study represented the Core Set for BC with 47% of coverage. The disability representation score for the extracted concepts was 61%.
Classification of the extracted meaningful concepts Based on IPF.
Two hundred seventy-one concepts from the interview with patients and 398 concepts extracted from the interview with specialists required rational appraisal. In contrast, 67 concepts from the interview with patients and 113 meaningful concepts extracted from the interview with the specialist required emotional appraisal.
Out of 271 Concepts from the interview with patients which required rational appraise, 195 concepts fell within the biological (B) domain, 34 concepts in the social (S) domain, 11 concepts in the psychological (P) domain, 18 concepts in the Inorganic (I) domain and 13 Concepts in open-ended (X) domain.41 concepts of the biological domain (B) were interactively related to this domain (B*B), and 19 other concepts of this domain were related to Social (S) domain (B*S).
Also, out of 67 concepts from interviews with patients which required emotional appraise, 58 concepts were classified in the domain of Psychology (P) and nine concepts in the domain of Biology (B). 9 concepts of the biological domain (B) were related to concepts of the psychological domain (P)(B*P), and 16 of the concepts of Psychological (P) were related to concepts of the social domain (S) (B*S).
Among the 398 meaningful concepts extracted that required rational appraise from interviews with experts, 255 concepts fell in the biological (B) domain, 71 concepts in the social (S) domain, 14 concepts in the psychological (P) domain, 41 Concepts in Inorganic (I) domain and 17 concepts in open-ended (X) domain. Thirty-eight concepts of the biological domain (B) were interactively related to this domain (B*B), and 42 other concepts of this domain were related to the social(S) domain (B*S).
Also, out of 113 concepts from the interview with experts that required emotional appraisal, 105 concepts were classified in the psychological domain (P) and eight in the biological domain (B). Eight concepts of the biological domain (B) were related to the concepts of the psychological domain (P) (B*P), and 22 of the concepts of Psychological (P) were related to the concepts of the social domain (S) (B*S).
The domains of concepts and their relationships are presented in Figures 3,4 and 5. In the patients’ chart, 60% of the extracted concepts were related to the biological (B) domain. Among the concepts appraised in the biological domain, 41% were classified as “No-related," which indicated no relationship between 41% of the biological concepts and other concepts. In contrast, 19% of the concepts appraised in the biological domain provided dynamic/interactive relationships with biological concepts(B*B) (12%), social concepts (B*S) (5%), and psychological concepts (2%).
In the expert’ chart, 51% of the extracted concepts were appraised to the biological (B) domain. Among the concepts appraised in the biological domain, 34.5% were classified as "No-related," which indicated no relationship between biological concepts and other concepts extracted from medical specialists. In contrast, 16.5% of concepts appraised in the biological domain provided dynamic/interactive relationships with biological concepts (7%), social concepts (8%), and psychological concepts (1.5%).