The present study included adult DED patients between 19 and 44 years of age as a case group and healthy volunteers of the same age group as controls. In previous studies, negative correlations between the density of corneal basal nerves and age in both DED subjects and healthy people were reported.3,19 In addition, to determine whether mice show changes in cornea nerves with aging, M.A. Stepp20compared cornea nerve axon density of 6 to 8 week old mice to that of 20 to 24 months, and the results showed that the corneal nerve axon density of older mice was significantly lower than that of younger mice.Nevertheless, there have been no reports of age classifications or observations of corneal neuromorphology in adult DED patients. Therefore, to exclude the influence of aging on the corneal nerve, adult patients with DED were selected as research subjects for this study. Moreover, as adult patients with DED tend to have a short disease course, we were able to observe morphological changes in corneal nerves in the early stage of DED.
Furthermore, we included DED patients with mild to moderate DED. Previous studies have found that the density of corneal basal nerves in DED patients with Sjögren's syndrome are lower than those in DED patients without Sjögren's syndrome,21 and such cases tend to be more serious, indicating that the severity of the disease has an impact on corneal neuromorphology.4 Indeed, we selected mild to moderate DED patients without Sjögren's syndrome to reduce influencing factors.
As expected, the corneal nerves of adult patients with mild to moderate DED displayed obvious morphological changes. Compared with healthy subjects, the density of corneal basal nerves was significantly increased, which was not consistent with most previous reports. Most assert that the density of corneal basal nerves decrease,3–8 some believe that the density does not change,9,10 and a few purport that the density increases.11 Some researchers suggest that the decreased corneal basal nerve density in patients with DED is a sign of nerve injury22–25 Labbe et al.4 also reported that the density of corneal basal nerves in DED correlates negatively with the severity. Nonetheless, regeneration of the corneal nerve is a key point that cannot be ignored. The pathological process of DED is likely a coexisting process of corneal nerve injury and regeneration,4,11 with inflammation being the driving force.26–28
In addition, two interesting results were obtained in this study: although the main number of corneal basal nerves in the DED group was higher than that in the control group, the difference was not statistically significant. Regardless, the number of nerve branches in the DED group was significantly higher than that in the control group. As the density of subbasal nerves refers to the length of all visible nerves in the image,4 namely, the main nerve and branch of corneal basal nerves, they will directly affect nerve density measurement results. It is suggested that the increased density of the corneal basal nerve in the DED group may be caused by the increase in nerve branches, with possible regeneration of corneal nerves during the pathological changes of DED.
Dry eye is a chronic inflammatory ocular surface disease, and a decrease in corneal nerve density might be considered a marker of nerve injury.22–25 Previous studies have found that inflammation correlates negatively with nerve density.16,29−31 For instance, higher levels of inflammation and lower nerve density have been observed in patients with severe dry eye, such as Sjögren's syndrome.3,4,30,32 In addition, using IVCM, Cox et al.33 observed higher inflammation levels and lower nerve density in aqueous-deficient dry eye than in evaporative dry eye. Some researchers have proposed that cytokines produced by immune cells are recognized by receptors on nerves, which may result in nerve degradation.34 In the process of chronic inflammatory injury in DED, overexpression of inflammatory factors not only causes damage to the corneal epithelium and nerves but also activates corneal stromal cells, causing an increase in nerve growth factor (NGF) levels, and overexpressed NGF further promotes nerve regeneration.6,9 Villani et al.7 reported an increase in the number of hyperreflective corneal stromal cells in dry eye with Sjögren's syndrome based on IVCM. Studies have also found increased levels of interleukin-1 (IL-1) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF) as well as NGF in the tears of dry eye patients.6,35 In the process of injury and regeneration, different densities and numbers of corneal basal nerves in different processes are likely.
Therefore, we propose the following hypothesis for the mechanism of increased density and branch number of corneal basal nerves in adult patients with mild to moderate DED. Because inflammation has not caused significant nerve damage in adult patients with DED, overexpression of NGF promotes the regeneration of compensatory hyperplasia of the corneal basal nerve branches such that the regeneration rate of corneal nerves is greater than the damage rate, resulting in an increase in the density of corneal basal nerves. The increase in bead number, width, tortuosity and reflectivity also indicates metabolic activity in the nerve. The above theory suggests that timely intervention in the stage of corneal neurocompensatory hyperplasia may avoid corneal nerve injury. In a randomized clinical trial, Kheirkhah et al.36 showed the effect of the corneal nerve on DED: after a month of therapy, only patients with near-normal corneal nerve density experienced improvements in both symptoms and signs, whereas patients with low corneal nerve density did not show changes in signs or symptoms. This study provides theoretical support for the need for early treatment of mild to moderate DED.
In addition, we found that the density of corneal basal nerves correlated negatively with tortuosity. In fact, tortuosity may be intuitive evidence of corneal nerve injury and regeneration, and morphological changes become more obvious with the prolongation and aggravation of disease.30,37 Studies have found that the tortuosity of the corneal basal nerve in the dry eyes of patients with Sjögren's syndrome is significantly higher than that in the dry eyes of patients without Sjögren's syndrome.38 Therefore, we propose the following hypothesis: in the early or mild to moderate stage of DED, the frequency of nerve injury is low, the cornea undergoes compensatory hyperplastic change, and the tortuosity of the cornea changes little; with progression of the disease, nerve damage gradually increases, the frequency of damage increases correspondingly, and obvious tortuosity morphological changes gradually appear. Hence, tortuosity may be used as an indicator of the course and severity of DED, and the corresponding corneal basal nerve density and quantity can be used as an indicator of early DED.
To evaluate the impact of the course of DED on corneal nerves, our patients were also grouped according to the time of chief complaint in this study, although we found no significant differences in corneal nerve parameters among the three groups. Thus, the time of chief complaint cannot objectively reflect the actual course of DED.
There are some limitations to the present methodology that must be mentioned. First, we excluded patients with immune-related DED, such as Sjögren's syndrome, and subjectively considered adult DED patients to have milder disease without grouping them according to disease severity. Second, although we discuss the influence of the course of DED on corneal neuromorphology, we used no statistical data on the specific course of DED. Third, staging based on the time of chief complaint in this study is subjective and cannot objectively distinguish the course of DED in patients.