We report data from a cohort of children with severe COVID-19 disease treated with RDV. To date, only one US retrospective study of 77 pediatric patients with SARS-CoV-2 treated with RDV reported good tolerance to the drug with a low incidence of serious adverse events (16%) [19]. In Spain, a nationwide multicenter observational study of 8 children with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection treated with RDV had a positive clinical outcome of 80% [20]. This is therefore the second largest dataset on the use of RDV for the treatment of pediatric COVID-19: in this cohort, the majority of children were treated with RDV because they had a severe form of COVID-19 and and serious comorbidities, as widely reported in literature [25, 10]. In fact, the children with comorbidities, including cardiac disease, neurologic disorders, diabetes, obesity (particularly severe obesity), chronic lung disease, feeding tube dependence, malignancies, sickle cell anemia, and immunocompromised status are often associated to severe form of COVID-19 [2, 26–31].
Recently, obesity has been recognized as a significant risk factor for COVID-19 related prognosis. Brambilla et al. described how obesity increases the risk of hospitalization, intensive care unit admission, need for mechanical ventilation, and death among children and adolescents with COVID-19 [32]. Indeed, the chronic inflammation, nutritional, cardiac, respiratory, and immunological impairment characterizing obesity contribute to the risk of severe COVID-19 [32]. The second common comorbidity in our cohort was neurological disorder. These data are in line with pediatric epidemiologic studies of SARS-CoV-2 infection and are consistent with those reported by Centers for Disease Control and Prevention surveillance data on children hospitalized with COVID-19, highlighting the potential role of these conditions in predisposing patients to severe illness [25].
Expert groups recommend the use of RDV mainly in children with "severe COVID-19" defined as a new or increased demand for supplemental oxygen compared with baseline [16, 17, 36]. However, in our study we administered RDV also in a proportion of children diagnosed with severe pneumonia before the actual need for supplemental oxygen, with few side effects. Therefore this can be considered as an additional criterion for the use of RDV in children with severe COVID-19.
Overall, RDV was well tolerated in our cohort. Therapy was discontinued in 3 cases because of bradycardia, a side effect also reported by Eleftheriou et al. in 3 of 4 children treated with RDV. After drug discontinuation, the heart rate was back to normal within 24 hours [21]. Therefore, we suggest to perform an ECG monitoring before and during RDV treatment in order to highlight this adverse effect as soon as possible. Regarding the mild elevation of liver transaminases observed in our study (47%), it is not possible to define if it is attributable to COVID-19 disease, RDV, or both as 1/3 of patients shows an increase before treatment. A recent review on the use of RDV in children reported hypertransaminasemia in 32.1% of cases [33]. However, the highest level of ALT and AST observed in our population was 350 U/L e 164 U/L respectively. Furthermore, we found a statistically significant difference, with higher incidence of hypertransaminasemia in patients treated with RDV for 5 or less days, suggesting the role of agents other than RDV in the occurrence of this finding. However, the presence of hypertransaminasemia may have influenced the choice of a more restrained use of the drug, thus no more than 5 days of standard treatment.
Recently, interim data were released from a phase 2/3 study: a single-arm, open-label clinical trial that assessed the safety, tolerability and pharmacokinetics of RDV in 53 paediatric patients. Children enrolled were at least 28 days of age and weighing at least 3 kilograms with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection and mild, moderate or severe COVID-19 [37]. Patients in this pediatric phase 2/3 trial received RDV for up to 10 days. Adverse events included acute kidney injury (11%) and an increase in alanine transaminase levels (8%). However, this study had no placebo group, thus limiting the possibility to draw conclusions regarding the significance of these adverse events [34].
Interestingly, the analysis of the different variables and the duration of treatment for more or less than 5 days, showed that patients who were administered RDV for more than 5 days waited longer before RDV administration after the detection of COVID-19-associated pneumonia. This might suggest that patient diagnosed with pneumonia need to start antiviral treatment promptly, to avoid getting critically ill.
Our study has some limitations: it is a descriptive analysis and the results have been clinically interpreted. This happened because it was not a clinical study designed for the collection of data. Without comparative data from a randomly assigned control group, it is not possible to say if the high level of recoveries observed in these patients was due to the effects of RDV, the natural course of the disease, or other therapeutic interventions. Another limitation is the absence of a follow up and of SARS-CoV-2 viral load data on nasal swab during treatment: the lack of this data prevents us from evaluating the real effect of RDV on virus clearance. Nevertheless our results highlight and support the safety and tolerability of RDV administration in pediatric patients, even if the absence of a control arm prevents us from determining how much RDV really contributed to recovery. This confirms the need for pediatric clinical trials on the efficacy of RDV in children with severe COVID-19, and to improve the limited data available on pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamics of RDV.
In conclusion our data suggest that RDV against SARS-CoV-2 is safe and well-tolerated in pediatric populations at high risk of developing severe COVID-19; a delayed administration of RDV therapy after diagnosis of pneumonia may be associated with a longer duration of antiviral therapy, especially in patients with comorbidities.