Previously, we have reported that prolonged OS induced by PQ leads to an unexpected autophagy inhibition in astrocytes, while S29434, a specific NQO2 inhibitor, protects U373 astrocytes against PQ-induced autophagy defect and cell death [30]. While molecular mechanisms of NQO2 ligand/inhibitor-mediated autophagy remain to be determined, several other questions raised with respect to a toxifying role of NQO2 in glial degeneration. First, it was not clear if a role of NQO2 in OS and autophagy regulation can be generalized to other parkinsonian toxins with a more selective dopaminergic toxicity, such as 6OHDA. Second, little is known regarding the expression levels and mutations of NQO2 in PD, that would support a possible role of this oxidoreductase in PD. Here, we addressed both issues.
6OHDA is a neurotoxin widely used to investigate cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying selective degeneration of dopaminergic neurons in PD. Similarly to other parkinsonian toxins, this neurotoxicant reproduces the main cellular processes of PD, such as OS, neurodegeneration, neuroinflammation, and neuronal death by apoptosis, although 6OHDA-induced animal PD model does not exhibit some human symptoms such as the presence of Lewy bodies [45]. The mechanism of 6OHDA toxicity has been linked to ROS production by extracellular auto-oxidation [46], leading to intracellular OS induction in various cell types [30, 47]. In agreement with this, we observed that mitochondrial and cytoplasmic ROS increase in a dose- and time-dependent fashion also in U373 cells, but the intensity and duration of the ROS burst was totally different than in case of PQ. In fact, OS induced by 6OHDA was more rapidly increasing and disappearing and several times stronger than in case of PQ. Nevertheless, the effects of both toxins on autophagy were similar and consistent with a concept that persistent and/or high levels of OS inhibit, rather than stimulating autophagy. Indeed, the exposure of U373 astrocytes to increasing 6OHDA concentrations had no effect or significantly downregulated autophagic machinery as evidenced by more than 50% decrease in LC3 lipidation when 100 µM 6OHDA was applied for 24 h. This correlated with a significant increase in p62 levels at 24 h after addition of 6OHDA (Fig. 1C,G), but not at 48 h (Fig. 1H) as previously found for PQ [30]. It is likely, however, that lack of p62 upregulation is due to very low solubility of p62 aggregates that accumulate at later time points and can be detected only by a specific high-detergent lysis. In addition, the exposure of astrocytes, under optimal culture conditions, to different concentrations of 6OHDA led to no or marginal lethality. In contrast, in our previous study we were not able to distinguish between PQ–induced general toxicity and PQ-dependent autophagy dysfunction in astrocytes, since a clear reduction of autophagic flux occurred at 24 and 48 h and preceded a massive cell death that took place at 72 h [30]. Thus, despite evident differences in OS dynamics and cellular toxicity, both parkinsonian toxins efficiently lead to autophagy dysfunction in astrocytes. This observation is fundamental for understanding why these toxins lead to a degenerative process in the brain. In light of our findings, it takes place because the oxidative damage induced by parkinsonian toxins is not mitigated by efficient autophagic response in astrocytes, leading to glial degeneration and poor or no neuroprotection. In fact, we would expect a strong induction of glial autophagy as it was widely reported for dopaminergic neurons in the presence of rotenone, paraquat, MPTP, 6OHDA and other parkinsonian toxins [11]. However, it does not occur in astrocytes, likely due to certain pathways activated by toxins, comprising reported here NQO2 pathway, that counterbalance any proautophagic signals triggered by OS. This concept is well supported not only by our observations in astrocytes [2, 30], but also more recently by other authors in several alternative models of PD based on neurotoxicants [48–52].
Autophagy emerged as a critical mediator of antioxidant responses in both cellular signaling and cellular damage[10]. Its deregulation or impairment by genetic or epigenetic mechanisms is strictly linked to the progression of PD [2, 53] and several reports suggest an autophagy defect in astrocytes in addition to autophagy dysregulation in dopaminergic neurons [18, 54, 55]. Accordingly, autophagy has been implicated in protective cellular responses in astrocytes [52, 56–58]. Thus, it is likely that 6OHDA-induced astrocytes dysfunction is at least partially mediated by autophagy inhibition. Future studies should shed more light on the critical role of autophagy in glial compartment. The important contribution of this work to our understanding of complex mechanisms involved in the etiology of PD, is the identification of NQO2 as a player in the autophagy impairment in astrocytes.
The role of NQO2 in neurodegenerative process is also supported by another finding reported in this work, i.e., the upregulation of protein levels and activity of NQO2 in cells exposed to 6OHDA. This observation is in line with our previous findings obtained with cells exposed to PQ and then assayed in the reactions containing BNAH and K3 [31]. In addition, we showed that cells pre-treated with 6OHDA sustain faster BNAH oxidation in the absence of exogenous substrates, such as K3 (Fig. 3A), suggesting that 6OHDA metabolism leads to the production of quinones that act as substrates for NQO2 in vivo. Such quinones do not seem to be produced in vitro and 6OHDA itself is not a substrate for NQO2, under our experimental conditions (Fig. 3C), but could be produced in vivo. In fact, our previous results obtained with PQ, support this hypothesis, since U373 lysates of cells pre-exposed to PQ in vivo and then assayed for NQO2 activity without exogenous substrates showed higher oxidative capacity for BNAH, although we were not able to detect any increase in NQO2 levels [30]. Future experiments would be required to validate these hypotheses.
Another novel finding of the present work is that NQO2 contributes to 6OHDA-induced ROS induction, but much less than to the autophagy impairment in astrocytes. In fact, S29434, a potent NQO2 inhibitor almost doubled autophagy levels in control cells and fully restored or even upregulated autophagic flux in U373 cells exposed to 6OHDA (Fig. 1D,F). In contrast, S29434 had a moderate effect on OS induced by the toxin, reducing it by around 25% at the peak oxidative burst (Fig. 2B), suggesting that the main beneficial activity of the compound is linked to autophagy stimulation. However, the murine astrocytes were less responsive to S29434, since the compound produced a significant stimulation of autophagy only in 6OHDA-treated cells, as judged by the increase of LC3II in control cells and no effect on the Beclin-1 levels (Fig. 5C,D). Overall, due to the reported specificity of S29434 towards NQO2 [38], these and our previous data strongly suggest that NQO2 is an important modulator of autophagy. The question whether it is due to the enzymatic activity of NQO2 or to the formation of NQO2 complexes with protein partners hypothetically regulated by S29434 and other inhibitors, as suggested previously [39], is not yet clear.
A possible role of NQO2 in PD progression is further supported by another important finding presented here, i.e., the difference in expression levels of NQO2 between PD patients and healthy donors. Higher expression of NQO2 in PD was first suggested by Harada et al [34]. NQO2 in 2001 who described a positive association of a common form of PD with D (deletion) polymorphism in the NQO2 promoter region. This “gain of function” genetic variant of the promoter without Sp3 transcriptional suppressor binding site [59] was 3.46 times more frequent in PD patients than in healthy subjects in Japanese population [34]. Only two attempts to reproduce the findings of Harada’s work have been done so far. Among them one study yielded discordant results [60], while another minor work confirmed them [61]. More recent and extensive studies of NQO2 gene or protein expression in PD patients are missing, but higher NQO2 protein levels were reported in postmortem brain specimens of patients with Alzheimer disease (AD) [62] and an elevated NQO2 expression was convincingly associated with learning deficit in rodent models [37]. The data retrieved from GSE data sets, suggest the opposite in postmortem SN specimens of late-stage PD patients, namely a statistically significant reduction of NQO2 mRNA levels in all analyzed samples. Such, a reduction is further substantiated by a higher expression of lnRNA NQO2, which might repress the expression of regular NQO2 mRNA as other long-noncoding transcripts in colon cancer, where lnRNA NQO2 was found to be significantly modulated [63]. These data are unexpected, but do not exclude that higher NQO2 expression, might be a trigger or risk factor of neurodegenerative changes at early stages of PD. This hypothesis is supported by the evidence coming from the analysis of NQO2 expression in whole blood of 50 early PD cases, which revealed that majority (39/50 (~ 75%) of early PD patients present significantly higher levels of NQO2 then its mean expression in healthy individuals. We do not know if the levels of blood born transcripts predict the brain expression of a given gene, but a higher NQO2 expression in the blood may indicate a more active promoter. According to our analysis, the higher NQO2 expression is 3 times more frequent in PD patients than in controls, thus well in line with the observations of the study by Harada et al [34].
In conclusion, our observations suggest that drugs targeting NQO2 may stimulate autophagy as well as protect against dopamine quinone and hydroxyquinone toxicity. Thus, S29434 by acting as a protective agent on astrocytes, might delay neuronal damages in PD and other pathological conditions concerning OS and autophagy impairment mediated by NQO2, suggesting that NQO2 inhibitors might have a therapeutic potential for the treatment of cerebral injuries involving oxidative neurodegeneration. The vast literature suggesting a protective effect of several natural polyphenols in neurodegeneration strongly supports this idea, since NQO2 is a well-documented target of these compounds [39, 64]. Future studies should validate this hypothesis.