Substituted arenes are ubiquitous in molecules with medicinal functions, making their synthesis a critical consideration when designing synthetic routes.1,2 Regioselective C–H functionalization reactions are attractive for preparing alkylated arenes,3-5 however, the selectivity of existing methods is modest and primarily governed by substrate electronic properties.6,7 Here, we demonstrate a biocatalyst-controlled method for the regioselective alkylation of electron-rich and electron-deficient heteroarenes. Starting from an unselective ‘ene’-reductase (ERED) (GluER-T36A), we evolved a variant that selectively alkylates the C4 position of indole, an elusive position using prior technologies. Mechanistic studies across the evolutionary series indicate that changes to the protein active site alter the electronic character of the charge transfer (CT) complex responsible for radical formation. This resulted in a variant with a significant degree of ground state change transfer in the CT complex. Mechanistic studies on a C2 selective ERED suggest that the evolution of GluER-T36A helps disfavor a competing mechanistic pathway. Additional protein engineering campaigns were carried out for a C8 selective quinoline alkylation. This study highlights the opportunity to use enzymes for regioselective reactions where small molecule catalysts struggle to alter selectivity.