Italian Covid-19 cases
Overall the number of Italian Sars-CoV-2 positive cases was increasing but the exponential phase, that mark out the first epidemic phase of a virus infection, seemed definitively distance from data. The grow factor, based on number of cases and not on virus reproduction number, was lower than 1 since March 20, 2020. Figure 1 shows the daily increase of new positive Covid-19 cases in Italy. Considering the daily increase, we should consider both the test’s execution time and the number of swabs daily made. The number of Sars-CoV-2’s RNA evaluation tests changed in time and increased from 2.07/1000 Italian inhabitants on March 15 (18.14% positive) to 8.40/1000 on March 31 (13.70% positive) and it was 18.51/1000 on April 15, 2020 (6.10% positive)3,5. It should be considered that available tests’ number was swabs’ number. Taking into consideration confirmation’s and repeat’s tests, it should be reasonable a number of people who were tested that was about the 70% of the swabs’ number.
Up to April 18, 2020 according to official data, Italy recorded 175,925 Sars-CoV-2 positive cases, 10.68% among health care professionals3,4. The age and sex distribution of cases is reported in Table 1, incidence is reported as well. Median age was 62 years (0-100 range)4 and overall male/female ratio was 1.00. The different behavior in more aged people was probably due to the higher number of women aged more than 90s (male female ratio equal to 0.37, according to last census5). Between health care professional Covid-19 patients, median age at diagnosis was 48 years and male/female ratio was 0.474.
From available literature the estimated mean incubation time of Covid-19 was 5.5 days and symptoms occurred by 11.5 days in the 97.5% of infected people7. Italy reported a median time between symptoms and diagnosis equal to 3 days for cases recorded on February 20-29 (1,614 cases analyzed), 5 days for cases recorded on March 1-10 (9,732 analyzed), 6 days for cases recorded on March 11-20 (27,679 analyzed) and 7 days for cases recorded between March 21 and April 9 (46,236 analyzed)4.
Overall 25.74% of positive cases were hospitalized3. During hospitalization patients were treated by antibiotics (84%), antivirals (56%) and corticosteroids (35%)4. The 19.6% of patients was concomitant treated with all of these medications4. On April 18, 2020 the 9.85% of all Covid-19 hospitalized patients received intensive care3. Detail on hospitalization status and number of patients who needed intensive care is reported in Figure 2.
Italian Covid-19 deaths
Up to April 18, 2020 according to official data, Italy recorded overall 23,227 Covid-19 deaths3. Considering the daily deaths increase, reported in Figure 2, we should also considered the disease progression time.
The age and sex distribution of patients who died is reported in Table 14, lethality rate is reported as well. On April 18, 2020 Italian lethality rate was equal to 13.2%, 0.4% among health care professionals3,4. Overall lethality increased with age, especially in male patients. Median age at death was 80 years (range 0-100; IQR 73-86), with differences between sexes (83 for women and 79 for men)4.
According to data on comorbidities, available for 1,738 patients, at least one concomitant medical condition (mean 3.3, sd 1.9) was present in 96.4% of patients who died4. In detail, the 3.6% had no one concomitant pathologies, 14.4% one, 20.7% two and the 61.3% had three or more concomitant pathologies4. Most representative comorbidities were hypertension (69.7%), type 2 diabetes (32.0%), ischemic heart disease (27.7%), chronic renal failure (22.0%), atrial fibrillation (21.9%), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (17.8%), history of cancer in the past 5 years (16.2%) and heart failure (15.5%)4.
Between who died, most common symptoms before hospitalization were fever (76.0%), dyspnea (72.0%), cough (38.0%) diarrhea (6.0%) and hemoptysis (1.0%)4. The 5.9% of patients did not experienced any symptom at hospital admission4. Median time between presence of symptoms and death was 10 days; between hospitalization and death 5 days, and was 4 days longer if patient was moved to intensive care unit4.
Most common complications that finally lead to patient’s death were acute respiratory distress syndrome (96.7%), acute kidney injury (22.9%), superinfection (12.4%) and acute myocardial injury (9.5%)4.
Figure 1. Positive Covid-19 cases, daily increase since February 24, 2020 (up to April 18, 2020)3; as absolute number (N, continuous blue line, in dotted blue line its 6 days moving average) and as percentage (%, brown line). As reported by Italian Authorities in their newsletter, data were daily updated and we should considered a possible delay in data communication by regions due to a such high number of tests performed a day4. We should also considered the execution time of test needed to evaluate the presence of virus’s RNA.
|
Male Patients
|
Female Patients
|
|
Overall
|
Age
|
Positive (N)
|
Death (N)
|
Lethality (%)
|
Positive (N)
|
Death (N)
|
Lethality (%)
|
Cases, M/F
|
Positive (N)
|
Cum Inc (%)
|
Crude Inc Rate
|
Age Std Inc Rate
|
Death (N)
|
Lethality (%)
|
|
0-9
|
596
|
0
|
0.00
|
519
|
1
|
0.19
|
1.15
|
1,123
|
0.02
|
12.03
|
1.26
|
1
|
0.09
|
|
10-19
|
901
|
0
|
0.00
|
897
|
0
|
0.00
|
1.00
|
1,804
|
0.03
|
17.06
|
1.88
|
0
|
0.00
|
|
20-29
|
3,350
|
5
|
0.15
|
4,338
|
2
|
0.05
|
0.77
|
7,737
|
0.12
|
68.05
|
8.17
|
7
|
0.09
|
|
30-39
|
5,344
|
28
|
0.52
|
6,299
|
12
|
0.19
|
0.85
|
11,686
|
0.17
|
90.10
|
12.16
|
40
|
0.34
|
|
40-49
|
9,009
|
133
|
1.48
|
11,452
|
45
|
0.39
|
0.79
|
20,519
|
0.22
|
121.09
|
16.95
|
178
|
0.87
|
|
50-59
|
14,779
|
606
|
4.10
|
15,015
|
150
|
1.00
|
0.98
|
29,858
|
0.32
|
174.14
|
23.51
|
756
|
2.53
|
|
60-69
|
14,963
|
1,776
|
11.87
|
9,024
|
504
|
5.59
|
1.66
|
24,040
|
0.33
|
178.72
|
20.55
|
2,284
|
9.50
|
|
70-79
|
15,577
|
4,532
|
29.09
|
10,097
|
1,664
|
16.48
|
1.54
|
25,717
|
0.43
|
235.26
|
21.17
|
6,203
|
24.12
|
|
80-89
|
12,332
|
4,992
|
40.48
|
14,329
|
3,071
|
21.43
|
0.86
|
26,706
|
0.75
|
409.70
|
16.39
|
8,070
|
30.22
|
|
>=90
|
2,470
|
970
|
39.27
|
7,333
|
1,483
|
20.22
|
0.34
|
9,813
|
1.27
|
691.07
|
6.91
|
2,455
|
25.02
|
|
Unk
|
49
|
2
|
|
54
|
0
|
|
|
104
|
|
|
|
2
|
|
|
Total
|
79,370
|
13,044
|
16.43
|
79,357
|
6,932
|
8.74
|
1.00
|
159,107
|
0.26
|
143.78
|
128.96
|
19,996
|
12.57
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Table 1. Positive cases diagnosed and number of deaths recorded overall, by age and by sex since February 21, 2020 (up to April 16, 2020); information about sex was missing in 380 cases4. Number of Italian inhabitants available at last census5 was used to calculate cumulative incidence and crude rate. Eurostat 2013 standard population6 was used to calculate age standardized rate. Legend: “Unk” is for unknown, “Cum Inc” is for cumulative incidence, “Crude Inc Rate” is for crude incidence rate; “Age Std Inc Rate” is for age standardized incidence rate. Both incidence rates are monthly incidence rate for the observation time period, x100,000); “M” was for male ,“F” female.
Figure 2. Distribution of Covid-19 Italian cases by hospitalization status and exitus since February 24, 2020 (up to April 18, 2020)3. Homecare Covid-19 patients, recovered cases or cases still positive that were dismissed from hospital are not included in this graph. As reported by Italian Authorities in their newsletter the number of deaths were deaths occurred in patients who tested positive for Sars-CoV-2’s RNA, independently from pre-existing diseases4.
Focus on Lombardia, the region where the Italian Covid-19 outbreak began
Italy is organized in 19 regions and 2 autonomous provinces and the most affected Italian area was the region of Lombardia, in the North of Italy. Up to April 18, 2020 Lombardia recorded 65,381 Covid-19 cases (37.2% of all cases), and 12,050 related deaths (51.9% of all deaths)3. In this area the districts of Cremona, Lodi, Bergamo, Brescia and Milano were the most affected cities and according to last official data, their cumulative incidence values were equal to 1,51%, 1.18%, 0.95%, 0.93% and 0.48% respectively3,5.
Codogno and the around area, for a total of 10 municipalities in the province of Lodi, at the boundary of the province of Cremona (Codogno, Castiglione d’Adda, Casalpusterlengo, Fombio, Maleo, Somaglia, Bertonico, Terranova dei Passerini, Castelgerundo and San Fiorano), were quarantined and defined “red zone” since February 23, 20208. Up to March 5, 2020 this area reached 5,830 laboratory-confirmed Sars-CoV-2 cases3. As reported, the quarantine strategy pointed out a valid approach to slowdown the spread of the infection and no positive new cases were recorded on March 10, 2020 in Codogno, where the 99.94% of inhabitants followed the restriction policies9.
Due to the increase of cases outside this area, Lombardia and all Italy, was quarantined from March 8, 2020 and a strengthening of restriction policies was made on March 20, 20208. Increase of cases across the most affected cities in Lombardia is reported in Figure 3; Italy compared to Lombardia is reported as well (Figure 4). The effects of restriction policies should considered also disease incubation time.
Figure 3. Cumulative Sars-CoV-2 cases, by day across the most affected cities in Lombardia since February 24, 2020 (up to April 18, 2020)3. Milano (blue line), Bergamo (green line), Brescia (yellow line), Cremona (red line) and Lodi (purple line). Number of inhabitants (number of municipalities) are reported as well5.
Figure 4. Cumulative Sars-CoV-2 cases, by day in Lombardia and overall in Italy since February 24, 2020 (up to April 18, 2020)3. Positive Sars-CoV-2 cases (dark lines) and hospitalized Covid-19 patients (light lines) in Italy (without cases recorded in Lombardia, blue lines) and in Lombardia (red lines) on a semilogarithmic scale. Legend: “Positive cases” includes both hospitalized and homecare Covid-19 patients; “Hospitalized” includes patients admitted to all hospital wards.