Urothelial carcinoma (UC) is the most commonly diagnosed malignant bladder neoplasm in dogs and affects the trigone region in more than half of the cases. Obtaining adequate local control of the disease is one of the greatest challenges owing to surgical limitations and a high rate of tumor recurrence. Total cystectomy can be considered when complete tumor resection is not possible, and often when the trigone is involved. However, this surgical approach is not commonly performed because of the high rates of postsurgical complications, low acceptance by owners, and compromised quality of life in most patients. Unfortunately, even when tumors arise away from the trigonal area and partial cystectomy is feasible, local recurrence rates remain considerable.
ECT is an effective therapeutic modality for tumors with different histologies [31, 38]. This technique stands out for its high efficacy, low cost, and selectivity towards neoplastic tissues. The latter feature allows for the conservation of important anatomical structures, especially when tumors develop in sites with a difficult surgical approach. Recently, ECT has demonstrated significant efficacy in the treatment of canine carcinomas such as squamous cell, anal sac, and nasal carcinomas [38, 39, 40, 41]. ECT has also been shown to be safe and effective for deep-seated tumors in humans, such as pancreatic and hepatocellular carcinomas [42, 43].
To date, two preliminary studies have reported the application of ECT in canine bladder UC; however, both studies used a small sample of dogs [36, 44]. Considering the anatomical characteristics of the urinary bladder as well as the possible side effects associated with ECT, the present study evaluated the safety and feasibility of this technique for the treatment of bladder UC in 21 dogs. Additionally, the local ECT antitumor effect was preliminarily assessed.
Demographic data regarding sex predisposition, age at diagnosis, and reproductive status are in agreement with previous studies [1, 7, 21]. Shih Tzu and Poodle (38%) were the most affected breeds in this study, with no occurrence of the most known predisposed breeds. This fact may be related to differences in racial distribution between the canine population in Brazil, the United States, and Europe.
Most dogs (90.4%) had T2 tumors, while 9.6% had T1 tumors, corroborating the data found in the literature, which states that T2 tumors account for approximately 68–78% of canine bladder neoplasms [1, 21].
Intravenous bleomycin (BLM) was selected as the antineoplastic drug for ECT in this study. BLM possesses a selective mechanism of cell death, and its systemic administration allows for a more homogenous distribution through tissues. In addition, electropermeabilization promotes BLM intracellular uptake by a factor of 700-fold [29, 45, 46]. Once inside the nucleus, BLM leads to single- and double-strand breaks in the DNA. This damage accumulates as the cells proliferate, and after a threshold is reached, cell death occurs via a process called mitotic cell death. This mechanism confers BLM with unique selectivity towards rapidly dividing cancer cells. In turn, cells from healthy tissues (such as those from tumor margins) are quiescent and slow or non-dividing, and remain viable even if electropermeabilized [29, 46, 47].
Thus, the process of cell death and consequent tissue necrosis caused by ECT occurs in any tissue where cancer cells infiltrate. Consequently, ECT application in bladder tumors that infiltrate the serosa would entail significant risks of bladder rupture and uroperitoneum due to necrosis, as the serosa is the last layer of the bladder lining. Therefore, the non-involvement of serosa was a crucial inclusion criterion in this study.
None of the patients in this study died during the procedure or in the immediate postoperative period, and there were no occurrences of bladder rupture, uroperitoneum, or suture dehiscence. Similarly, Rangel et al. (2018) [36] performed ECT with intravenous BLM in two dogs with bladder UC and adopted the non-involvement of the serosa as a safety criterion. None of their patients developed any of these complications.
The vast majority of patients in this study developed mild adverse effects (90%; VCOG = 1), which had already manifested at the first presentation. However, transient urinary incontinence (lasting 7–86 days) was the only adverse effect not previously reported. Likewise, Rangel et al. (2018) [36] also reported transient urinary incontinence in patients treated for 56 and 76 days. The development of this condition may be due to transient inflammation and edema in the bladder mucosa, which are expected to be caused by ECT, leading to nerve stunning and involuntary muscle spasms.
Two patients (9.5%) developed ureteral stenosis at 69 and 73 days after the second ECT session (VCOG = 3). They were treated surgically by placement of a “double-J” stent with good tolerability. Ureteral stenosis might be attributed to scarring fibrosis resulting from tumor death, which is an expected effect after ECT. However, as the amount of fibrotic tissue increases, the risk of stenosis increases.
In comparison, studies evaluating partial or total cystectomy in dogs with bladder UC have found more significant complication rates (range 43–70%), including suture dehiscence, ureteral obstruction, pyelonephritis, and uroperitoneum [6, 11, 14].
Studies evaluating partial cystectomy, with or without adjuvant chemotherapy, have reported death rates due to disease progression ranging from 45 to 91% [6, 8, 14]. In the present study, only two dogs (9.5%) died of UC. One of them died due to local progression of the disease 517 days after the first and only ECT session. The owners refused additional sessions or other treatment. However, the survival time was above the average for dogs treated with conventional therapies (surgery and/or chemotherapy) [6, 8, 48, 49].
The other patient who died because of UC progression developed metastatic disease in the lungs, which was identified on chest radiographs approximately 5 months after ECT. This dog was the only patient who developed distant metastasis until the end of the study, resulting in a distant metastasis rate of 4.7%. In contrast, according to a study by Knapp et al. (2000) [5], the rate of distant metastasis at death was 49% among 80 dogs with bladder UC. This discrepancy could be attributed to the earlier stages of the disease in the present study. Another hypothesis may be attributed to the potential efficacy of ECT in eliminating cancer cells at the primary tumor site. This good local control would decrease the probability of cancer progression to distant sites, which is facilitated when residual tumor remains in the patient’s bladder (as occurs during chemotherapy and after debulking surgery).
Regional metastasis to the lymph nodes was assessed through intraoperative cytological evaluation by fine needle aspiration of the regional iliac lymph nodes, even if apparently normal. Although histopathology is the gold standard for definitive diagnosis of lymph node metastasis, we elected cytological evaluation because it is a less time-consuming examination, either for sample collection or intraoperative evaluation, and it is associated with lower rates of intraoperative complications. It is important to note that all patients who had regional lymph node metastasis were also staged as T2 with serosa involvement or T3 during intraoperative evaluation, and consequently excluded from the study.
Local spread of tumor cells is also a concern in patients with bladder UC who undergo cystotomy. According to Higuchi et al. (2013) [50], 75% (18/24) of dogs with bladder UC developed metastatic foci in the abdominal wall after cystotomy. In the study by Marvel et al. (2017), 10% (4/37) of dogs that underwent partial cystectomy developed tumor spread in the abdominal wall [7]. In contrast, none of the patients in the present study developed this complication after cystotomy and ECT. These results could be attributed to the safety criteria carefully adopted during bladder manipulation and ECT application, minimizing the risk of tumor spread.
Regarding local response, out of the 21 dogs treated in this study, 13 (62%) achieved CR, 5 (24%) had PR, and 3 (14.3%) died before the minimum period for response evaluation because of reasons unrelated to the disease or ECT therapy. This overall response rate (86%) was greater than those reported in studies evaluating different chemotherapy protocols for dogs with bladder UC, ranging from 3–71%, in which partial responses were predominant [7].
The overall duration of response obtained was 370 days on average, which was higher than the 235 and 85 days obtained by Marvel et al. (2017) and Bradburry et al. (2021) [6, 8], respectively. The mean duration of response was also higher than that reported in several studies evaluating medical therapy, which ranged from 96 to 199 days [51, 52, 53, 54].
One of the greatest challenges in treating bladder UC is the high recurrence rate after partial cystectomy, which ranges from 66 to 100% even when the tumor is resected with complete histological margins [6, 8, 14]. This finding may be explained by the phenomenon called “field cancerization effect,” which hypothesizes that bladder urothelium is uniformly exposed to carcinogens through urine contact, making it more susceptible to the development of multiple microscopic foci of malignant transformation, ultimately leading to macroscopic UC [6, 8, 55].
In comparison, of the 13 dogs that achieved a CR in this study, five had local tumor recurrence, with a recurrence rate of 38.4%, which was considerably inferior to the aforementioned studies. The mean time to recurrence in these patients was 354 days, which is longer than that reported by Marvel et al. (2017) and Bradburry et al. (2021) [6, 8] (101 and 85 days, respectively). It is important to note that in these two studies, medical therapy (chemotherapy and/or NSAIDs) was initiated after surgery. However, in the present study, ECT was performed as the sole treatment for all 21 dogs, indicating efficient disease control even without medical therapy.
One of the factors that may have contributed to the lower recurrence rate in this study might be attributed to the treatment of the entire bladder inner wall with ECT using intravenous BLM. This approach could lead to the destruction of possible microscopic neoplastic foci along the urothelium, minimizing the development of tumor recurrence and the risk of tumor implantation in other bladder regions. These effects are related to the selective mechanism of action of BLM, which leads to the preservation of the healthy urothelium [29, 46, 47].
Regarding survival data, studies evaluating partial cystectomy in bladder tumors away from the trigone have reported a median survival time (MST) varying from 348 to 498 days [8, 13, 14]. For most patients in these studies, adjuvant chemotherapy and/or NSAIDs were combined with surgery, making it difficult to determine whether this association resulted in an increase in survival time. In this context, it is important to highlight two main points in the present study:1) ECT was not combined with any other adjuvant therapy and 2) the majority of dogs (76.1%) had tumors located in the bladder trigone. Dogs presenting with tumors in this location naturally have a worse prognosis and shorter survival times because of the complex surgical approach [6, 21]. Despite this unfavorable scenario, the MST achieved by the dogs in this study was 420 days, which is similar or superior to those obtained in the aforementioned studies [8, 13, 14]. Furthermore, tumor location was not correlated with DFS and survival time.
The MST achieved was also superior to that obtained in studies that evaluated the use of chemotherapy (and/or NSAIDs) as a single treatment, with MST ranging from 108 to 338 days [48, 49, 51, 53, 54, 56, 57].
The time between ECT sessions varied in each case depending on the individual response, and usually ranged between 30 and 60 days. During the follow-up visits, it was noted that patients who underwent a new procedure at shorter time intervals (33–40 days) had a greater amount of necrotic tissue in the tumor region, which remained from the previous session. This fact can be explained by the mitotic cell death caused by BLM, which is a slower process that relies on the mitotic rate of the tumor cells and may take a longer time to achieve a response and tissue healing [46, 47]. Although there is still no consensus on when it is more appropriate to perform a subsequent ECT session, it is possible to determine the preferable interval between ECT sessions to range from 45 to 60 days.
Regarding the number of ECT sessions, the majority of treated dogs (57%) received only one session. Furthermore, among patients who achieved CR, 77% achieved CR in the first session. In addition, in the Kaplan-Meier analysis, the number of sessions did not influence patient survival (P > 0,01). However, care must be taken when interpreting these data, as there was a non-homogenous distribution of patients among the groups, which may constitute a bias in the analysis.
These results indicate that ECT offers good local control and antitumor effects regardless of the number of sessions. This favorable initial response is in agreement with different published studies that demonstrate the efficiency of ECT for different types of carcinomas [31, 39, 40]; despite being of different origins, they show similar morphology and response to ECT.
In conclusion, ECT is a safe and feasible therapy for canine patients with T1 and T2 bladder UC without serosal involvement. The therapy was well tolerated by the patients, providing significant local control of the disease along with a good quality of life. Regarding its antitumor efficiency, the results obtained in this study are promising; however, they are still preliminary. Further prospective studies should be conducted to evaluate the efficiency of ECT in bladder tumors, using a larger sample size of dogs and performing comparative analysis between different treatment groups (ECT vs. conventional therapy).
Limitations
Although the primary aim of this study was to evaluate the safety and viability of ECT in canine bladder UC, one of its limitations is the lack of a control group with appropriate statistical analysis comparing ECT with conventional treatments of bladder UC. The absence of a control group is due the fact that all dogs presented with bladder UC, that met the inclusion criteria, were treated with ECT.
In addition, it is important to highlight that the small sample size can represent a statistical bias when the survival of patients is compared according to the number of sessions and type of response.