This study demonstrated successful regeneration of peripheral nerves using CNT yarn as a nerve scaffold in vivo by anatomical as well as functional measures for the first time. In contrast, the 15 mm nerve defect did not show spontaneous reconstruction within a hollow silicone tube. These results indicate that the nano-scale topographical scaffold alone enabled significant regeneration, with no exogenous neurotrophic proteins nor cell transplantation. The sagittal section of the immunohistochemical analysis clearly indicated that, across the distance of the transected sciatic nerve, axons extended along the aligned CNT yarns with migrated Schwann cells, and reached the distal stump. Electrophysiological and muscle weight analysis also demonstrated that the CNT constructs facilitated regeneration of motor nerve and significantly improving the functional deficit after the peripheral nerve injury. Our results indicated that a 2% CNT density tended to be most effective for nerve regeneration as measured by both histological axonal regeneration and motor function. We consider that tissue regrowth did not occur at the 35% CNT density due to the high occupancy of CNT yarns in the silicon tube, which may have impeded perfusion of tissue fluid.
This study was able to confirm the effect of CNTs on peripheral nerve regeneration in vivo and clarified the optimum density of CNT fiber scaffold.
However, other biological impacts of CNT yarns, including effects on cell migration ability and cell adhesion, were not elucidated. Further investigations of the mechanisms of peripheral nerve regeneration alongside this material are needed before more efficient regeneration protocols can be achieved.
In nerve conduits of various materials, it is important that a fibrin matrix forms to bridge the proximal and distal nerve stumps. The fibrin matrix contains inflammatory cells and vascular endothelial cells, and its formation is crucial for the migration and proliferation of Schwann cells and axonal growth. This is facilitated by the tube structure to a certain extent, as it connects the proximal and distal nerve ends27,28. However, If the distance between the nerve ends is too long, the matrix is not formed and the regeneration process across the nerve defect is interfered29,30.
Recent studies have revealed the mechanism by which two nerve stumps reconnect during nerve repair. First, macrophages secrete VEGF-A, which stimulates the formation of blood vessels oriented in the direction of nerve regeneration. The Schwann cell cord (Büngner band) is then formed using the polarized blood vessels as a migratory scaffold. Finally, axons extend from the proximal stump to the distal stump, guided by the Schwann cell cord31. In support of these known mechanisms, the intraluminal fibers may induce fibrin cable polarized blood vessels and Schwann cell cords and thus help to bridge the nerve proximal stump and distal stump over long nerve gaps.
A study culturing rat hippocampal neurons on two patterns of CNT yarns (parallel aligned and cross linked) demonstrated that almost all neurites grow along the CNT yarns in the growth direction of the neurites. Even on the cross-linked CNT yarn patterned substrate, a neurite could grow along one CNT yarn and then turn towards another cross-linked yarn. This indicates that CNT yarns possess the main characteristics of a guidance scaffold for neurite outgrowth32.
Another possible reason why nerve tissue was regenerated along the cYarn® fiber is thought to be not only CNT character itself, but also the structural features of our nerve conduit model composed of thin and aligned fibers. A previous study cultured DRG on different diameters of fiber scaffolds and found that the direction and extent of neurite extension and Schwann cell migration from DRG explants was influenced significantly by fiber diameter33. Another study indicated that fibers with smaller diameter have better cell adhesion effects34. In addition, Kim et al. demonstrated that aligned, oriented fibers accelerated DRG outgrowth in vitro and nerve regeneration in vivo compared with randomly oriented fibers35. cYarn® fiber is a fiber of 15 µm in diameter, composed of 10 nm fibers. As shown in Fig. 1, the cYarn® surface exhibits irregularities due to these 10 nm fibers, as well as increased surface fiber area. Scaffolds with a high surface area are advantageous for cell adhesion and proliferation36.
Although we were able to clearly demonstrate the effectiveness of CNT yarns in peripheral nerve regeneration, this study has several limitations. Firstly, we used an artificial nerve model that combines a silicon tube and CNT yarn, which is far from clinical use. In the clinical applications, conduits should be made from biodegradable material. However, in previous in vivo studies examining the effects of nerve guides or cell therapy on nerve regeneration, hollow silicone tubes were inserted as nerve guide in a standard model (i.e., a 37,38), in order to obtain external stability to provide space for nerve regeneration to occur. Secondly, our study was a short-term evaluation of only 8 weeks, where improvement in motor function by CNT yarn transplantation was demonstrated by muscle wet weight ratio and electrophysiological examination, but no improvement in the sciatic nerve functional index was observed. A longer-term assessment may demonstrate a clearer recovery of motor function.
Currently, animal-related research to promote nerve regeneration by stem cell transplantation is underway. However, stem cell transplantation requires cell harvesting and culturing, causing the transplant surgery to be long in duration, with a high associated cost. On the other hand, CNTs have sterilizable and stable material properties, are mass-producible, and can be provided at a low cost. Therefore, CNT artificial nerves may one day be an off-the-shelf product that is unlimited in supply.
Another biological benefit of CNTs is the ease with which a broad range of molecules can be bound to the yarn, due to the extremely high reactivity of the CNT surface39. Chemical modifications can be made to increase the probability of nerve regeneration, including modification of electrical charge40 and binding of growth factors41.