Regenerative periodontal therapy designed to regenerate periodontal tissues use multiple materials each with their own purposes with the aim to accelerate certain cells. Regenerating bone through adding scaffold and applying membrane are some of periodontal treatments those rely on osteogenic material. Bone graft, specifically FDBA, is one of the gold standards of scaffold used in periodontal treatment. Price, availability, and immunogenic response may become the deciding factor of their usage as osteogenic material. A newer, cheaper, and superior bone regeneration materials is needed to help dentists improving patient’s periodontal status and quality of life.
Collagen chitosan hydrogel is one of bio scaffold materials consisted of osteogenic components. Collagen is considered as ideal scaffold material because its low antigenicity and high cytocompatibility.13 It can increase bone density by inducing osteoblast activity and bone matrix maturation by increasing ALP activity, osteogenic mRNA, and protein expression.14 Chitosan hydrogel has been also used in drug delivery system from oral, ocular, and nasal as wound healing accelerator and tissue engineering material through its porous structure.15
Alkaline phosphatase is expressed in early development of bone and decreases as the development progresses. This enzyme is produced by osteoblast to promote bone formation through the hydrolysis of pyrophosphate (PPi), a mineralization inhibitor. Pyrophosphate acts as bone mineralization regulator by inhibiting crystallization of calcium ion and Pi to form hydroxyapatite. It can also bind strongly to hydroxyapatite, preventing further crystal growth. The abundance of Pi ion enhances the production of hydroxyapatite, hence increasing bone formation.16
Greater number of cell (leukocyte, platelet, erythrocyte) and PDGF found in red i-PRF results in higher proliferation and migration of PDLSC. The earlier upper yellowish layer described as i-PRF, found to be inferior compared to the red i-PRF proposed by the researchers.5 Among the growth factors contained in i-PRF, the main groups of growth factors associated with bone regeneration are VEGF, IGF, TGF-β, PDGF, and BMP, presented great potentials in bone healing and osteogenesis through regulating cell behavior, including recruitment, migration, adhesion, proliferation, and differentiation.17 Growth factor delivery strategies, specifically hydrogel, for sustained release and stability of GF is needed to promote bone healing.
In our study, we observed that collagen chitosan hydrogel i-PRF increased ALP activity and calcium deposition compared to bone graft i-PRF and control groups at day 7, 14, and 21 in osteoblast. In day 1, osteoblast ALP level shown no significant difference in all groups. This result demonstrates alkaline phosphatase as early osteoblastic marker increasing after 7 days following the proliferation rate. These numbers increased significantly at day 7 in collagen chitosan hydrogel i-PRF and bone graft i-PRF group, showing significant difference to control group. These shown the effect of i-PRF as growth factor for osteoblast in increasing its early proliferative marker. Collagen chitosan hydrogel i-PRF group ALP activity was also significantly different with bone graft group which demonstrates the advantages of collagen chitosan hydrogel over bone graft as scaffold material. Through chitosan and hydrogel porous structure, osteoblast interaction with other active agent, such as growth factor, can take place more conveniently through hydrogel’s porosity.
Growth factor contained in i-PRF such as Platelet-Derived Growth Factor (PDGF), Bone Morphogenetic Protein (BMP), Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF), Transforming Growth Factor Beta 1 (TGF-β1), Insulin-Like Growth Factor 1 (IGF-1), and Epidermal Growth Factor (EGF) can interact with osteoblast. Previous study shown effective therapy in bone regeneration by using growth factor combination, PDGF and BMP-6. PDGF’s role in osteoblast matrix deposition increases its proliferative and migration rate whereas BMP-6 can accelerate differentiation and mineralization of osteoblast.18 In another study, endothelial and osteoblast coculture exhibited increased VEGF and BMP-2 level which control osteoblast ALP expression and mineralization.19
In day 14, ALP activity in collagen chitosan hydrogel i-PRF and bone graft i-PRF group stays relatively the same with day 7 which shows i-PRF’s ability in maintaining ALP expression until day 14. ALP level may be peaked between day 7 and day 14 when collagen matrix deposition reaches its higher point, ending the proliferative period and starting mineralization stage.20 However, collagen chitosan hydrogel i-PRF group still shown significant difference with all groups. Through collagen fibril inside the hydrogel, growth factor molecules those directly loaded into can diffuse slower through collagen little pores. Direct loading of growth factor into collagen mainly has rapid burst release profile, but PDGF-BB has sustained release profile parallel to biodegradation of collagen.21
All groups ALP activity dropped significantly at day 21 showing no significant difference between groups. This decrease shown no significant difference against day 1, showing ALP level in all groups reverted to day 1. This happened as osteoblast enter to the end of mineralization stage, showing low early differentiation marker expression including ALP. In the late differentiation stage of osteoblast, many osteoblasts died due to well’s confluence and maturation, leaving calcium nodule inside the well. These calcium ions reside intracellularly as granule in mitochondria or inside matrix vesicle and promote extracellular matrix mineralization through calcium and phosphate storage.22
Calcium deposition in day 1 shown no significant difference in all groups. This late differentiation marker is not yet to emerge at the early stage of osteoblast. This number went up significantly at day 7 compared to day 1. Both collagen chitosan hydrogel i-PRF and bone graft i-PRF group calcium deposition were found to be significantly higher control group, as seen as ALP activity in day 7. The osteogenic capability of i-PRF causes the increasing number of mineral depositions in both groups. This shown the effect of growth factor contained in i-PRF effect on accelerating osteoblast mineralization to begin before control group mineralization started. Hence, higher calcium ion level found in i-PRF treated groups.
Day 14 shown calcium deposition of collagen chitosan hydrogel staying relatively the same with day 7 with the highest level of calcium between all groups. The superiority of collagen chitosan hydrogel over bone graft is shown through this result. Bone graft i-PRF group’s calcium deposition decreased significantly at day 14 demonstrating bone graft failed to maintain mineral deposition in the late differentiation stage of osteoblast. The calcium deposition stays nearly the same at day 21 with collagen chitosan hydrogel still holds the highest calcium content, showing significant difference with other groups. This shown sustain released of growth factor by collagen chitosan hydrogel until late differentiation stage of osteoblast ended. Further studies about growth factor release profile of red i-PRF and collagen chitosan hydrogel is needed to elucidate this biomaterial scaffold role in periodontal tissue regeneration.
The use of 2D cell culture in this research has several disadvantages such as assessments of ALP activity and calcium deposition was limited to attached cell only, disregarding the cell inside of the hydrogel. This happened because the cell inside of the hydrogel get washed away as the requirement of the assay used for 2D cell culture. Hydrogel function as growth factor and cell reservoir cannot work properly, thus the result may be lessened than the actual bone formation. Hence, 3D cell culture is recommended as this study focus on scaffold and the length of this study makes 2D cell culture less effective. Through 3D cell culture, monitoring viability; proliferation; differentiation; and function of osteoblast can be done thoroughly with higher in vivo relevance.23