Vegetation composition and biostratigraphy
Some of the taxa reported from the Zilanba section (excluding Anthrophyopsis venulosa and Storgaardia mentoukouensis) have been reported by previous researchers working in the Sichuan Basin (Li 1964; Ye et al. 1986; Wu 1999). The composition of Zilanba fossil assemblage has much in common at family and genus level (e.g., Anthrophyopsis, Anomozamites, Clathropteris, Dictyophyllum, Ptilozamites; Table 1) with the well-studied Rhaetian florals of Europe and Greenland (e.g., the Bayreuth flora in Germany; the Rhaetian flora of Upper Silesia and the Tatra Mountains in Poland; the Skåne Rhaetian (Bjuv Member) floras in Sweden and the Lepidopteris Zone in Greenland) (Kustatscher et al. 2018), despite its lower diversity and few shared species.
Table 1
Comparisons of the new Rhaetian plant assemblage found at Zilanba in the Sichuan Basin, South China, with those of the Rhaetian floras from Germany, Poland, Sweden and East Greenland (data from Kustatscher et al. 2018 and references therein).
| Germany | Poland | Sweden | East Greenland | This study |
Anthrophyopsis | | | | * | * |
Anomozamites | * | | * | * | * |
Annulariopsis | | | | | * |
Baiera | | | * | * | |
Brachyphyllum | | * | | | |
Camptopteris | | | * | | |
Cladophlebis | * | * | * | * | * |
Clathropteris | * | * | | * | * |
Ctenis | * | | | | |
Cycadolepis | | | | * | |
Cyparissidium | | | * | | |
Czekanowskia | | * | | * | |
Desmiophyllum | * | | | | |
Dictyophyllum | * | | * | * | * |
Doratophyllum | | | | * | * |
Elatocladus | * | | * | * | |
Equisetites | * | | * | * | * |
Ginkgo | | | * | | |
Ginkgoites | * | * | * | * | * |
Hausmannia | | | | * | |
Lepidopteris | * | * | * | * | |
Marattia | * | | | | |
Neocalamites | | * | * | | * |
Nilssonia | * | | | * | * |
Nilssoniopteris | * | | | | |
Pachypteris | * | | | * | |
Pagiophyllum | | * | | | |
Palissya | * | * | * | | |
Peltaspermum | | * | | | |
Phlebopteris | * | | * | | |
Pityophyllum | | | | | * |
Podocarpites | | | | | * |
Podozamites | | | | * | * |
Pseudoctenis | * | | | * | * |
Pterophyllum | * | * | * | * | |
Ptilozamites | * | | * | * | * |
Radicites | | | | | * |
Rhapidopteris | * | | | | |
Rhinipteris | | | | * | |
Sagenopteris | | | * | | |
Schizolepis | * | | | | |
Schmeissneria | * | | | | |
Selaginellites | * | | | | |
Sphenobaiera | | | * | * | |
Spiropteris | | | | * | |
Stachytaxus | * | | * | * | |
Stenorachis | | | | | * |
Taeniopteris | | * | | * | |
Thaumatopteris | * | | * | | |
Todites | * | | * | | |
Voltzia | * | | | | |
Weltrichia | | | | * | |
Widdringtonites | | * | | * | |
Wielandiella | | | | * | |
Williamsonia | | | * | * | |
During the Late Triassic, two main floristic provinces were defined in China: the Northern Floristic Province (NFP) which was marked by the “Danaeopsis-Bernoullia” macrofossil assemblage, and the Southern Floristic Province (SFP) which was characterized by the “Dictyophyllum-Clathropteris” plant association (Sun 1995). Within the Zilanba flora, Clathropteris meniscioides and Dictyophyllum nathorsti are typical elements of the SFP during the Late Triassic. Ptilozamites chinensis is widely reported from Upper Triassic strata in Sichuan, Hunan, Jiangxi, Fujian and Guangdong provinces, and with typical occurrences in the SFP (Xu et al. 2022). Anthrophyopsis has been described from Upper Triassic successions of Sweden, Greenland, China, Russia, Georgia, Tajikistan and Iran, and became especially common during the Rhaetian (Xu et al. 2021). Doratophyllum hsuchiahoense, originally established by Li (1964), has been reported from many fossil assemblages of the Upper Triassic Xujiahe Formation in the Sichuan Basin. This taxon appears to have been endemic to the Sichuan Basin.
The Late Triassic floras in the SFP can be divided into Carnian, Norian and Rhaetian associations based on their taxon representation and have been dated precisely using intercalated marine strata with age-indicative fauna (Sun 1995; Kustatscher et al. 2018). Among these, the Rhaetian succession is marked by the Ptilozamites–Anthrophyopsis assemblage defined from the Yangbaichong Formation of Shaqiao, Hunan Province (Zhou 1989), incorporating Clathropteris, Cycadocarpidium, Nilssoniopteris, Pterophyllum, Ptilozamites, Podozamites, Stalagma and Todites. This flora is highly similar to the Anyuan flora in Jiangxi Province (Xiong et al. 2009), Wenbinshan flora in Fujian Province (Zhou 1978), and is equivalent to the Lepidopteris Zone of eastern Greenland (Jameson Land), Sweden, Poland and Germany (Kustatscher et al. 2018), although the nominal taxon of this zone is absent from the Zilanba assemblage. Based on the combination of the newly collected material and the fossil assemblages reported elsewhere (Li 1964; Ye et al. 1986; Wu 1999), the common occurrences of Anthrophyopsis, Clathropteris, Ptilozamites, Todites, Pterophyllum and Cycadocarpidium indicate that the fossil flora from ‘member Ⅲ’ of the Xujiahe Formation belongs to the Ptilozamites–Anthrophyopsis assemblage and is, thus, Rhaetian in age. This is corroborated by magnetostratigraphic (Li M.S. et al. 2017) and palynostratigraphic (Li et al. 2020) data.
Palaeoclimate significance
The fossil flora of the Xujiahe Formation indicates that the Sichuan Basin was dominated by gymnosperms (especially cycads and bennettites) and ferns during the Late Triassic (Li 1964; Ye et al. 1986; Wu 1999). The newly collected fossil assemblage from ‘member Ⅲ’ of the Xujiahe Formation at Zilanba confirms a floral composition consistent with previous reports.
Ecologically, Equisetites and Neocalamites occupied riverbank and marsh habitats (Deng 2007) but their climatic preferences are ambiguous.
Extant representatives of Dipteridaceae (i.e., Dipteris Reinward 1825) are restricted to tropical regions (Kramer 1990), although the family may have had a broader climatic and biogeographic range during hyperthermal intervals of the Mesozoic (Corsin and Waterlot 1979). Fossil Dipteridaceae, such as Clathropteris and Dictyophyllum occur at Zilanba and, on this basis, hot and humid climates have been inferred in the region for the Rhaetian (Wang et al. 2015; Zhou et al. 2016). These taxa were probably understorey plants of forests, riverbanks and marshes (Deng 2007; Guignard et al. 2009; Wang et al. 2015; Zhou et al. 2016).
Among the gymnosperms, the most representative Late Triassic leaf genus Anthrophyopsis, is usually very well-preserved (Xu et al. 2021). Anthrophyopsis produced leaves in excess of 50 cm long and 20 cm wide (macrophylls in the leaf size scale of Raunkiaer 1934 and Webb 1959), and can be regarded as a warm and humid palaeoclimate indicator, since such large leaves are characteristic of modern tropical humid climates (Jacobs 1999; Xu et al. 2021). Ptilozamites is one of the most widespread genera of Mesozoic seed ferns, reaching its greatest diversity during the Late Triassic. According to the re-appraisal of Ptilozamites chinensis based on the newly collected specimen at Zilanba (Xu et al. 2022), and fossil records from other Mesozoic strata in China, this plant is generally reported from fluvio-deltaic-lagoonal marshes, terrigenous marine and fluvio-lacustrine or swampy settings, with a preference for warm and humid conditions (Xu et al. 2022).
Ginkgoopsida and conifers account for a small percentage of the Zilanba flora. Extant Ginkgoales are deciduous and limited mainly to subtropical valley floors and lower montane slopes, preferring cool conditions with moderate humidity (Deng 2007; Tang et al. 2012). However, Mesozoic Ginkgoales are abundant in coal-bearing strata over a much broader geographic range indicating much wider climatic and edaphic tolerances than the single extant species (Abbink et al. 2004; Deng 2007). Deciduousness appears to be a universal character within the clade suggesting a preference for moderate to strongly seasonal climates. Ginkgoales were secondary contributors to Triassic and Jurassic coal deposits in Europe and Greenland, co-occurring with abundant Bennettitales and ferns (Popa 2014), and they played a similar role in China along with other regions along the northern fringe of the Tethys Ocean (Sadovnikov 2020). Therefore, the presence of Ginkgoites at Zilanba is considered to denote a humid climate with seasonal variations, albeit that only a single specimen is available.
Extant conifers are widely distributed and adapted to various climatic conditions (Deng 2007). Some Mesozoic conifers bear close ecological resemblances to extant forms (Deng 2007). Among the new material from Zilanba, Podozamites is considered to be an indicator of humid climates owing to its broad leaves, and Storgaardia mentoukouensis is considered indicative of a warm-temperate to temperate climate (Li Q.J. et al. 2017).
The Guangyuan area was located in tropical-subtropical latitudes during the Late Triassic (early Rhaetian), consistent with a humid and warm palaeoclimate inferred from the majority of the leaf fossils. The occurrence of a fossil wood taxon Xenoxylon guangyuanense Tian, Wang et Philippe in ‘member Ⅱ’ of the Xujiahe Formation has been argued to indicate a short-term cooling event in the Sichuan Basin during the Norian-Rhaetian interval (Tian et al. 2016) but the climatic significance of this wood taxon with ambiguous affinities remains to be fully resolved. Collectively, the fossil data suggest that the palaeoclimate during deposition of the Xujiahe Formation was predominantly warm and humid but may have been punctuated by short-term cooling events. In general, the precisely dated Xujiahe flora at Zilanba provides a key datum for further palaeoclimate reconstructions for the Norian to Rhaetian interval in the lead-up to the end-Triassic biotic crisis.
Palaeoenvironmental significance
The upper part of ‘member Ⅲ’ of the Xujiahe Formation at Zilanba is well-exposed and yields abundant fossil plants. It is lithologically dominated by a grey-dark mudstone intercalated with coal seams and grey fine-gained sandstones, typical of organic-rich (peat-forming) paludal conditions with sporadic flooding events. Cross-bedding and large fossil transported trunks in sandstones indicate frequent crevasse-splay or local fluvial channels intersecting the mire environments representative of ‘member Ⅲ’ (Fig. 6).
Of the fossil material from ‘member Ⅲ’ at Zilanba, cycads, bennettites ferns and sphenopsids are most commonly preserved in dark-grey to black, silty mudstone, with layer seven (Fig. 1), a dark-grey silty mudstone, the richest in fossils. Most plant fossils are exquisitely preserved indicating hypautochthonous burial. Among these fossils, the occurrence of Anthrophyopsis indicates typical lakeside wetlands, delta plains and wet fluvial flood plain conditions. Most conifers (predominantly isolated fragmentary leaves of Podozamites) are preserved in dark-grey fine sandstones, indicating a modest degree of transport before burial.
In summary, the sedimentary environment during the deposition of ‘member Ⅲ’ of the Xujiahe Formation at Zilanba was a fluvial flood plain with local peat swamp development. The plant assemblage represents a lowland community with only minor contributors from plants growing on better-drained sites.