Ginkgetin promotes DDP-induced cytotoxicity
Ginkgetin, a biflavonoid from Ginkgo biloba leaves, exhibited cytotoxicity in cultured A549 cells15. Here, ginkgetin was combined with DDP at various concentrations in applying onto cultured A549 cells. Majority of combinations (ginkgetin + DDP) significantly increased the cytotoxicity, as compared with single usage of DDP or ginkgetin (Fig. 1A). The combination index indicated that ginkgetin at 5 µM, together with different concentrations of DDP, showed the lower CI value, suggesting a better synergy (Fig. 1B). The synergistic effect of GK at 5 µM with DDP were also demonstrated in NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 NSCLC cells (Fig. S1A&B). All these three NSCLC lines are EGFR wild type, which are not sensitive to target therapy, but more suitable for DDP treatment. Among these combinations, the mixture of ginkgetin and DDP (both at 5 µM) showed the relative lower CI value, and the lowest CI value at 0.5005 was observed in A549 cell line (Fig. 1B&C, S1B). To reveal pharmacodynamic interaction of ginkgetin and DDP on A549, a response surface fitting was constructed. As expected, the combination of ginkgetin and DDP, both at 5 µM each, was located on the highest region of dose–response surface, further confirmed that this combination having better anti-cancer function (Fig. 1D). This combination ratio was chosen for further mechanistic study.
Ginkgetin induces ferroptosis in DDP-treated cells
Previous study demonstrated ginkgetin induces autophagic cell death15, However, this phenomenon was not further promoted in ginkgetin + DDP treated cells. As ferroptosis is considered to be a consequent event after autophagy in recent year17,18. Thus, we hypothesis ferroptosis might be triggered in this combination. The two key characteristics of ferroptosis are lipid peroxidation and intracellular-free iron21. C11‐BODIPY581/591 could be used as a lipid peroxidation probe in mammalian cells22. Free iron levels could be measured via labile iron pool (LIP), stained by CA-AM17. Thus, C11‐BODIPY581/591 and CA-AM were employed here to observe lipid peroxidation and LIP, respectively. DDP did not alter the levels of lipid peroxidation and LIP in A549 cells; while ginkgetin significantly increased the levels to~2.6 and ~2.4 folds respectively (Fig. 2A&B). The combination of ginkgetin + DDP further increased the levels of lipid peroxidation and LIP to ~3.3 and ~7.1 folds, respectively (Fig. 2A&B). The enhancement of LIP was more robust than that of lipid peroxidation in ginkgetin + DDP-treated cells. Ginkgetin induced promotion on lipid peroxidation and LIP were also observed in DDP-treated NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 cells (Fig. S2A&B).
SLC7A11 and GPX4 are main targets for ferroptosis induction. Thus, we revealed expressions of SLC7A11 and GPX4 at transcriptional and post-transcriptional level after the treatment of combined drugs. There were no significant changes on SLC7A11 and GPX4 mRNAs after the combined drug treatment in cultured A549 cells (Fig. 2C). In contrast to mRNA level, the protein amounts of SLC7A11 and GPX4 were markedly decreased in application of ginkgetin + DDP in A549, NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 cells (Fig. 2D, S2C). These phenomena suggested the role of ginkgetin in increasing protein degradation of SLC7A11 and GPX4 in DDP-treated NSCLC cells. To further demonstrate the ferroptosis induction, we determined another key factor involving in iron accumulation during ferroptosis, i.e. SLC40A1 and transferrin. SLC40A1 is the sole iron exporter in mammalian cells, as well as a downstream target of Nrf223; while transferrin imports iron to cell24. In the cultures, DDP sharply increased the mRNA and protein levels of SLC40A1 (Fig. 2E&D). Gingketin alone did not change the mRNA level of SLC40A1; however, which could reverse the DDP-induced elevation on mRNA (Fig. 2E), as well as protein level (Fig. 2D). For the case of transferrin, DDP slightly increased the protein amount in A549 cells (Fig. 2D), while have no obvious change on NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 cells (Fig. S2C). Ginkgetin combine with DDP sharply increased transferrin expression in all these three NSCLC cells (Fig. 2D, S2C). The decreased SLC40A1 and increased transferrin might account for LIP elevation in combination treatment.
The inhibition on SLC7A11 triggers ferroptosis via cystine/glutamate transport. The reduction of SLC7A11 is expected to decrease glutamate release and cystine uptake. In accordance with this notion, we measured the levels of cystine and glutamate in drug treated A549 cells. The intracellular cystine was significantly decreased, accompanied with notably increased glutamate level, after the treatment of ginkgetin (Fig. 2F). No significant change of glutamate was observed in DDP-treated cells; while the cystine level was notably increased, which might contribute to the increased antioxidant activity. The combined treatment sharply reversed DDP-induced elevation on cystine, and significantly increased glutamate level, as compared to control (Fig. 2F). These results indicated that the anti-porter function of SLC7A11 was partially reversed after application of ginkgetin in DDP-treated A549 cells.
GSH is synthesized from cystine and eliminates lipid ROS via GPX4. As the decline of cystine and GPX4 were observed here after the combined drug treatment, thus the intracellular GSH level was determined. As expected, GSH amount was significantly decreased by ginkgetin. However, the GSH amount was increased after application of DDP, which might be due to the redox resetting via antioxidant system. The combined drug treatment sharply reversed DDP-induced increase on GSH (Fig. 2G). GSH is highly reactive with lipid ROS to generate glutathione disulfide (GSSG), and the reduced ratio of GSH/GSSG is considered to be a marker of oxidative stress. Ginkgetin + DDP application sharply decreased the ratio of GSH/GSSG (Fig. 2H), indicating elevation of oxidative stress. All these data illustrated above indicated that ferroptosis was being triggered in the drug combination.
Ginkgetin downregulates Nrf2/HO-1 axis in DDP-treated NSCLC cells
Ferroptosis could be downregulated by famous antioxidant system Nrf2/HO-1 via neutralized on oxidative stress, which responsible for the compromised anticancer function of DDP25,26. Our previous study has demonstrated ginkgetin could reduce Nrf2 activation, thus we hypothesis that it could downregulate elevated activity on Nrf2/HO-1 axis induced by DDP. Here, neither ginkgetin nor DDP could change the expression of Nrf2, which however was sharply reduced in treatment of ginkgetin + DDP in A549, NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 cells (Fig. 3A, S3A&B). DDP slightly increased the expression of HO-1 in A549 cells (Fig. 3A), there are no significant change in NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 cells (Fig. S3A&B); while ginkgetin robustly deceased the amount of HO-1 in all these three NSCLC cells (Fig. 3A, S3A&B). Activated Nrf2 binds to ARE and upregulates transcription of HO-1. To detect the effect of ginkgetin + DDP on ARE-mediated transcriptional activity, a luciferase reporter pARE-Luc was applied. This construct contained four repeats of antioxidant response element (ARE) and a luciferase reporter gene luc2P. In pARE-Luc-expressed A549 cells, DDP activated ARE-mediated transcription by ~3 folds; while ginkgetin did not show activation on ARE-mediated transcription (Fig. 3B). Application of ginkgetin in DDP-treated A549 cells largely reversed DDP-induced activation on ARE-mediated transcription, i.e. counter acting the induction by DDP (Fig. 3B). CHIP assay was applied to identify the binding of Nrf2 to HO-1 promoter. DDP sharply increased the binding of Nrf2 to HO-1 promotor by over 40 folds (Fig. 3C). Ginkgetin alone showed no significant change on this binding. As expected, ginkgetin sharply reduced DDP-induced elevation on the binding of Nrf2 to HO-1 promoter (Fig. 3C). Binding of Nrf2 to HO-1 promoter is leading to transcription of HO-1. In cultured A549 cells, DDP increased the mRNA expression of HO-1 (Fig. 3D). The application of ginkgetin significantly reversed DDP-induced upregulation of HO-1 mRNA expression (Fig. 3D). In consistent, this mRNA regulation was in line to protein level, ginkgetin reversed the DDP-induced HO-1 protein expression (Fig. 3A). These results indicated that DDP could promote the antioxidant system Nrf2/HO-1 to cope with ferroptosis induced oxidative stress, which could be reversed by ginkgetin.
The antioxidant activity, induced by Nrf2, is further enhanced by nuclear translocation of HO-127. Thus, the change on HO-1 nuclear translocation in ginkgetin, DDP and ginkgetin + DDP-treated A549 cells was revealed by immunostaining. The fluorescence intensity of HO-1 was observed both in cytosol and nucleus. In control group, the fluorescence was mainly located in cytosol, and a faint signal was observed in nucleus, as demonstrated by co-localization of DAPI signal. Application of DDP notably increased the HO-1 fluorescence intensity in nucleus; however, ginkgetin decreased significantly nuclear expression of HO-1 and sharply reversed DDP-induced HO-1 nuclear translocation (Fig. 3E&F). This result further confirmed that ginkgetin could reverse DDP-induced activation on Nrf2/HO-1 axis, which contribute to the mitigation on antioxidant effect in ginkgetin + DDP treated NSCLC cells.
Ferroptosis inhibition reversed ginkgetin induced promotion on cytotoxicity of DDP
To further observe the role of ferroptosis in ginkgetin + DDP induced anticancer function. Ferroptosis inhibitors UAMC 3203 and DFO were applied. Here, both UAMC 3203 and DFO markedly reversed ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity in cultured A549, NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 NSCLC cells (Fig. 4A, S4A&B). However, the Nrf2 activators DMF and SFN could not reverse ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity in all three NSCLC cells (Fig. 4B, S4A&B). The upregulation of DMF and SFN on Nrf2 was demonstrated by western blot, that the amount of Nrf2 were significantly increased by DMF and SFN in ginkgetin + DDP treated A549 cells (Fig.S4C). These phenomena indicated that the Nrf2 is not the nodal for ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity.
UAMC 3203 is a novel ferroptosis inhibitor. The reverse effect of UAMC 3203 in ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity was much obvious than DFO (Fig. 4A, S4A&B), which might be due to its better activity on ferroptosis suppression. Thus, we use UAMC 3203 for further observation. To confirm the ferroptosis suppression, the key markers lipid peroxidation, LIP, SLC7A11 and GPX4, were determined in A549 cultures. The application of UAMC 3203 moderately reversed ginkgetin-induced elevation on lipid peroxidation (Fig. 4C&D) and LIP (Fig. 4F), and this effect was much obvious in the scenario of ginkgetin + DDP (Fig. 4C, D&F). In parallel, UAMC 3203 reversed gingketin + DDP mediated decline of SLC7A11; while the reverse effect on GPX4 was identified in cultures being treated with gingketin or gingketin + DDP (Fig. 4E). These results indicated that ferroptosis, induced by ginkgetin + DDP, was blocked by UAMC 3203.
Considering ferroptosis induction could directly or indirectly downregulated GPX4, leading lipid peroxidation. To confirm the role of ferroptosis in ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity. We overexpressed GPX4 in A549 cells, the upregulated expression of GPX4 was confirmed by western blot in ginkgetin + DDP treated cells (Fig. 4G). To our respective, the cytotoxicity was notably decreased after GPX4 overexpression (Fig. 4H), concomitant with the downregulation on lipid peroxidation (Fig. 4I), and LIP (Fig. 4J). This result further elucidated that ferroptosis contributes to ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity.
Ferroptosis suppression mitigated attenuation on Nrf2/HO-1 activation and ROS promotion induced by ginkgetin
Redox homeostasis is governed by the balance of antioxidant system and ROS formation. The downregulation on antioxidant system Nrf2/HO-1 induced by ginkgetin in DDP treated NSCLC has driven us to found if ROS was further increased to disrupt the redox homeostasis. In cultured NSCLC cells, DDP- induced ROS formation, and which was sharply promoted by ginkgetin in A549, NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 cells (Fig. 5A&B, S5A). However, blocking ROS formation via N-acetylcysteine failed to reverse ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity (Fig. S5B).
Since ferroptosis inhibitors, not Nrf2 activators, could largely reversed ginkgetin + DDP induced cytotoxicity. In addition, the unchanged mRNA level of SCL7A11 and GPX4 partial indicated that these two ferroptosis genes were not transcriptionally regulated by Nrf2. Thus, we hypothesis that Nrf2/HO-1 antioxidant inactivation and ROS enhancement could be a consequent event of ferroptosis. Here, application of UAMC 3203 sharply rescued gingketin + DDP induced decline of Nrf2 (Fig. 5C), as well as ARE-mediated transcription activity (Fig. 5D). In addition, UAMC 3203 application reversed the ginkgetin + DDP suppressed expressions of mRNA and protein of HO-1 (Fig. 5G&C). Consistent with this, ginkgetin + DDP induced ROS increasement was sharply reversed by the application of UAMC 3203 in A549, NCI-H460 and SPC-A-1 cells (Fig. 5H, S5C). These results indicated that ferroptosis suppression mitigated attenuation on Nrf2/HO-1 activation and promotion on ROS formation induced by ginkgetin in DDP treated NSCLC cells.
Ginkgetin promoted DDP-induced apoptosis was alleviated via ferroptosis suppression
ROS elevation induced by ginkgetin in DDP-treated cells might result in increasing cell sensitivity to ROS. One consequent event of ROS elevation is the loss of mitochondria membrane potential (MMP). Here, we demonstrated that ginkgetin notably increased the MMP loss in DDP-treated A549 cells (Fig. 5E&F). MMP loss could lead to activation on caspase-9, consequently activate caspase-3, -7, leading apoptosis. As apoptosis is the key mechanism for DDP-induced anticancer effect. Thus, we observed if apoptosis was increased after ferroptosis induction. Here, we found that DDP at 5 µM slightly increased the apoptosis rate at ~15%: while ginkgetin at 5 µM induced apoptosis at ~30% (Fig. 6A&B). The combined DDP and ginkgetin sharply increased the apoptosis rate to over 50%, which was confirmed by increased apoptotic markers, i.e. cleaved-caspase 3, cleaved-caspase 7 and cleaved caspase 9, as revealed by western blotting (Fig. 6C&D).
Intriguingly, blocking apoptosis via Q-VD-Oph could statistically significantly reversed DDP-induced apoptosis, but could not reverse ginkgetin induced promotion on DDP-induced cytotoxicity (Fig. 6E). While ferroptosis suppression significantly reversed apoptosis in ginkgetin+DDP treated cells (Fig. 6F). Consistent with this, ferroptosis suppression attenuated ginkgetin + DDP induced MMP loss (Fig. 5I), characterized with the sharply increase on the mean FITC fluorescence and decline on PerCP-Cy5-5 fluorescence (Fig. 5J), which indicated the reduced MMP loss. These results indicated that ferroptosis might contribute to ginkgetin induced promotion on DDP triggered apoptosis.
Ginkgetin enhanced anticancer effect of DDP is compromised by ferroptosis suppression in xenograft nude mice model
To further confirm the ginkgetin induced promotion on anticancer function of DDP, we applied A549 xenograft nude mice model. After the treatment of 31 days, the mean body weight of DDP treated group significantly declined; while ginkgetin group showed no significant change, as compared with control mice (Fig. 7A). Combined administration of ginkgetin + DDP significantly increased the mean body weight since day 25, as compared with DDP group (Fig. 7A), which might indicate that ginkgetin treatment could relieve DDP-induced toxicity. The mean tumor volumes in DDP, ginkgetin, and ginkgetin + DDP group were decreased: the best reduction was revealed in the combined administration group (Fig. 7B). When combined with UAMC 3203 administration, the mean tumor volume was not statistically significantly changed in control group, as well as in DDP group. Ginkgetin group showed moderately increase on mean tumor volume in the presence of UAMC 3203. However, a notably increase was identified in ginkgetin + DDP group after UAMC 3203 treatment (Fig. 7B). Consistent with the change on tumor volume, the mean tumor weight was smallest in ginkgetin + DDP group (Fig. 7C&D). UAMC treatment statistically significantly reversed the tumor shrink in ginkgetin group, however, the reversed effect was more robustly in ginkgetin + DDP group (Fig. 7C&D).These results consistent with in vitro study in supporting the notion that ginkgetin induced promotion on anticancer effect of DDP in NSCLC could be mediated by ferroptosis.