To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to investigate antifungal susceptibility and genetic characteristics of T. verrucosum variants in clinical and environmental samples. Moreover, three drug-resistance genes and seven virulence genes were analyzed to understand pathogenicity better.
In this study, 61.9% of the clinical and 53.8% of the farm environment samples were positive for T. verrucosum, as confirmed by direct microscopic examination and fungal culture. The present diagnostic results differ from those observed in symptomatic animal samples in India (55.3%) (12), Egypt (84.9%) (13), Italy (95.7%) (14), and Iran (92.6%) (15). This is because the difficulty in clinically differentiating dermatophytosis from other non-dermatophyte infections and the similar clinical manifestations of different dermatophyte species make clinical examination less reliable for diagnostic purposes (16). A comparison of the sample types revealed that T. verrucosum-positivity ratio between clinical and environmental samples was not significantly different. Trichophyton verrucosum is transmitted by direct contact with infected animals and environment. It separates from skin lesions in the environment and transmitted to other animals by contact (17). One of the most well-known risk factors for T. verrucosum infection is cattle age (13). In symptomatic animal samples, the T. verrucosum-positivity ratio in calves aged 1–6 months (73.1%) was significantly higher than that in calves aged > 6 months (55.2%). Young animals are more easily infected by ringworm because they are not immune to the effects of exposure to dermatophytes (14).
In this study, the 27 T. verrucosum isolates were classified as T. ochraceum (n = 9, 33%), T. album (n = 6, 22%), and T. discoides (n = 12, 44%). However, other studies have shown different results for separation rates among variants (18, 19). Classification of T. verrucosum into three variants was done by Sabouraud in 1910 (20). In 1950, Georg (4) found that these three fungi belonged to the same species, T. verrucosum. Morphologically, T. verrucosum is classified into three variants: T. ochraceum, flat and verrucose but with an ochraceous pigment; T. album, heaped and folded with a waxy appearance; T. discoides, disc-shaped with a small central knob. The sequencing of the ITS region of rDNA has been widely used for species identification (21). In previous studies (22, 23), T. verrucosum isolates showed 99% similarity in their ITS sequencing data, which is consistent with our results.
In this study, the MICs of five antifungal agents for T. verrucosum variant isolates were measured because of the importance of drug sensitivity test in the selection and dosage determination of drugs to effectively treat bovine dermatophytosis (24). Our results showed that enilconazole had the lowest geometric mean antifungal activity among the five antifungal agents tested against the three T. verrucosum variant isolates, followed by thiabendazole. Moreover, the MIC90 of enilconazole was 1 or 2 µg/ml and that of thiabendazole was 2 µg/ml for the three variants. The MIC90 of enilconazole was slightly higher than that reported previously (25). Our values were still lower than the commensal enilconazole drug dose (2 µg/ml) (7). Despite the wide application of enilconazole for bovine dermatophytosis, only one T. discoides isolate had a high MIC of enilconazole (8 ppm). However, there are no reports on T. verrucosum with a high MIC. Further research is needed to clarity resistance or tolerance of T. verrucosum to enilconazole. Thiabendazole is a well-known antifungal drug for bovine dermatophytosis, and our results are similar to those of a study from Mexico (26). Natamycin, resorcinol, and iodine are not widely used to treat dermatophytosis (7). The present study showed that the three antifungal agents were ineffective against all 27 isolates. No significantly different geometric means of MICs were observed for all antifungal agents. We recommend that antifungal susceptibility test be performed before choosing appropriate antifungal drugs to treat bovine dermatophytosis.
Ergosterol is a major sterol in fungi and maintains membrane fluidity, permeability, and structure (27). The ergosterol biosynthetic pathway includes nine nonessential genes, including ERG3 and ERG6 (28). Deletions and mutations in some nonessential ergosterol biosynthesis genes cause fungi to become resistant to antifungal drugs such as azoles and polyanes, which disrupt normal sterol biosynthesis (10). Among the three T. verrucosum variant isolates, the MIC50 of thiabendazole was the highest for T. album, which had the highest ERG3 and ERG6 detection ratios. The MIC90 of enilconazole was the lowest for T. ochraceum, in which ERG3 and ERG6 were not detected. This result is similar to that of a previous study (29), which reported that strains with polymorphic ERG genes are resistant to drugs, whereas strains without this gene family are sensitive to all antifungals.
In this study, seven SUB genes in T. verrucosum variant isolates were detected. Only SUB6 was detected in all isolated strains. Other genes showed a 55.6–88.9% positive ratio. This value was slightly higher than that in a previous study, which showed a 50–60% detection rate of SUB3-7 in animal samples (30). However, this rate is lower than that in Lemsaddek et al.’s study (31), in which the seven SUB genes were 100% positive in all T. verrucosum variants. The SUB gene is one of the most important virulence genes for initial invasion (11). SUB6 is a key element in the induction of inflammation by Trichophyton rubrum (32). SUB5 has been significantly associated with T. rubrum infection in humans (31). However, the absence of SUB1-3 in Microsporum canis isolates is not indispensable for dermatophyte invasion (33). SUB4 plays a less significant role in infection (34). In our study, SUB6 was the most prevalent, followed by SUB2. Significantly different ratios of SUB5 were found among the three variants. Overall, pathogenicity may not be related to specific genes but to the accumulation and synergistic effects of their products