Screening of wild type PHBHs for 3-hydroxylation of 4-ABA in C. glutamicum
To obtain a wild type enzyme suitable for the 3-hydroxylation of 4-ABA, a series of C. glutamicum strains expressing heterologous PHBHs were constructed and evaluated based on 4,3-AHBA concentration produced in the culture supernatant.
An Escherichia coli/C. glutamicum shuttle vector pKCG_Ptuf_T1 was constructed to express the protein of interest in C. glutamicum, which has an expression cassette comprising a strong constitutive promoter (Ptuf) derived from upstream of the tuf gene (gene number: cg0587) encoding the elongation factor TU [20] and the rrnB T1 terminator sequence derived from pVWEx1 (GenBank ID: MF034723.1). Then, the pobA genes for expression of PHBHs from Bradyrhizobium diazoefficiens (BdPHBH, NCBI accession number: WP_011089160.1), Caulobacter vibrioides (CvPHBH, WP_010920262.1), Rhodopseudomonas palustris (RpPHBH, WP_011157287.1), Sinorhizobium meliloti (SmPHBH, WP_010976283.1), Cupriavidus metallidurans (CmPHBH, WP_011519894.1), and Rhodococcus fascians (RfPHBH, WP_027494688.1) were selected, codon-optimized for C. glutamicum, and inserted into the expression cassette on the pKCG_Ptuf_T1. The amino acid sequences of the six PHBHs were less than 67% identical to each other (Additional file 1: Table S1). The resulting plasmids were used to construct C. glutamicum transformant strains KN001–KN007 (Table 1).
Table 1
C. glutamicum strains used in this study
Strain | Relevant characteristics | Reference |
NBRC 12168 | Wild type C. glutamicum strain identical to ATCC 13032 | aNBRC |
NBRC 12169 | Wild type C. glutamicum strain identical to ATCC 13058 | NBRC |
HT23 | NBRC 12168 derivate; ΔcglIM (cg1996), ΔcglIR (cg1997), ΔcglIIR (cg1998) | [42] |
KC265 | HT23 derivate; Ptuf_aroG (cg2391) | This study |
KC282 | KC265 derivate; Ptuf_aroE3 (cg1835) | This study |
KC300 | KC282 derivate; Ptuf_aroB (cg1827) | This study |
KC314 | KC300 derivate; Ptuf_aroA (cg0873) | This study |
KC315 | KC314 derivate; bΔpobB (cg1226), Ptuf_qsuC (cg0503) | This study |
KC367 | KC315 derivate; cPtuf_aroC (cg1829) | This study |
KC376 | KC367 derivate; dPtuf_tkt (cg1774) | This study |
KC408 | KC376 derivate; Ptuf_ppsA (cg0644) | This study |
KC525 | KC408 derivate; ΔqsuB (cg0502) | This study |
KC551 | KC525 derivate; ePtuf_pabAB (cg1134) | This study |
KC594 | KC551 derivate; fPtuf_aroGD146N | This study |
KC617 | KC594 derivate; gPtuf_aroFP155L | This study |
KN001 | hKmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_T1 | This study |
KN002 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_BdPHBH_T1 | This study |
KN003 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBH_T1 | This study |
KN004 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_RpPHBH_T1 | This study |
KN005 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_SmPHBH_T1 | This study |
KN006 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CmPHBH_T1 | This study |
KN007 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_RfPHBH_T1 | This study |
KN008 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHY201F_T1 | This study |
KN009 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHT294G_T1 | This study |
KN010 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHT294A_T1 | This study |
KN011 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHT294V_T1 | This study |
KN012 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHT294L_T1 | This study |
KN013 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHT294I_T1 | This study |
KN014 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHT294S_T1 | This study |
KN015 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHT294L_T1 | This study |
KN016 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHY201F/T294S_T1 | This study |
KN017 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHY161S/D357V_T1 | This study |
KN018 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHY161S_T1 | This study |
KN019 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHD357V_T1 | This study |
KN020 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106T_T1 | This study |
KN021 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106G_T1 | This study |
KN022 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106A_T1 | This study |
KN023 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106V_T1 | This study |
KN024 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106L_T1 | This study |
KN025 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106I_T1 | This study |
KN026 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106S_T1 | This study |
KN027 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106C_T1 | This study |
KN028 | KmR; KC551 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106A/T294S_T1 | This study |
KN029 | KmR; KC617 harboring pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106A/T294S_T1 | This study |
a NBRC: Biological Resource Center, National Institute of Technology and Evaluation, Japan. |
b The endogenous pobB (cg1226) gene encoding PHBH was disrupted to prevent potential background 3-hydroxylation. |
c The aroK (cg1828) gene is adjacent downstream and constitutes an operon. |
d The tal (cg1776), zwf (cg1778), opcA (cg1779), and pgl (cg1780) genes are adjacent downstream and constitute an operon. |
e The pabC (cg1135) gene is adjacent downstream and constitutes an operon. |
faroGD146N: the codon-optimized aroG gene variant encoding D146N mutant of DAHP synthase from E. coli. |
garoFP155L: the aroF (cg1129) gene variant encoding P155L mutant of DAHP synthase. |
h KmR: kanamycin resistance. |
To evaluate the PHBHs under sufficient 4-ABA supply, the strain KC551 (Table 1), endowed with an enhanced 4-ABA biosynthetic pathway, was used as the parental strain for transformation. The strain KC551 has Ptuf promoters inserted upstream of the endogenous genes that comprise the pentose phosphate pathway, the shikimate pathway, the subsequent 4-ABA production pathway, and the ppsA gene encoding phosphoenolpyruvate synthase, and has two additional genes (qsuB and pobB) deleted to prevent undesirable reactions. To confirm the adequate supply of 4-ABA, we measured 4-ABA concentration, glucose concentration, and optical density at 600 nm (OD600) every 24 h for 96 h in deep-well plate culture of strain KN001 (Fig. 2A), in which the pKCG_Ptuf_T1 empty vector was introduced into strain KC551. At 72 h of culture, glucose was depleted, OD600 reached 40, while 1.2 g/L (8.8 mM) of 4-ABA was detected in the culture supernatant, indicating successful 4-ABA overproduction.
Subsequently, six strains (KN002–KN007) carrying the plasmids harboring the heterologous pobA genes were cultured, and the concentrations of 4-ABA and 4,3-AHBA in the culture supernatants at 96 h were analyzed. Analysis of cell lysates from strains KN001–KN007 by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) revealed an additional band around 40 kDa in all strains except KN001 (Additional file 2: Fig. S1), suggesting that each PHBH was successfully expressed. Analysis of 4,3-AHBA and 4-ABA concentrations in the culture supernatants of strains KN002–007 using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) revealed that 4,3-AHBA was detected in the supernatants of all six strains (Fig. 2B). Since 4,3-AHBA was detected in the culture supernatant of the strains KN002–007 except for KN001, it was suggested that the intracellularly expressed heterologous PHBHs could catalyze 3-hydroxylation of 4-ABA to produce 4,3-AHBA. The highest mean 4,3-AHBA concentration (4.3 ± 0.1 mM) and mean 4,3-AHBA percentage (58%) was detected in the culture supernatant of strain KN003, which expressed CvPHBH that had 61% identity to the amino acid sequence of PaPHBH. Thus, CvPHBH was selected as the wild type enzyme for further amino acid mutagenesis studies.
Site-directed mutagenesis targeting the active site of Cv PHBH
Using CvPHBH as a template enzyme, amino acid mutations effective for increasing 4,3-AHBA productivity in C. glutamicum were investigated by site-directed mutagenesis to the residues located in the active site.
PHBH is classified as a flavoprotein monooxygenase (FPMO) and normally catalyzes 3-hydroxylation of 4-HBA to produce 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid using reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH), molecular oxygen (O2), and flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) [12]. Based on a three-dimensional structure model of CvPHBH constructed by a homology modelling method, 11 residues (G46, V47, W185, L199, Y201, L210, S212, R214, Y222, P293, and T294) located within 4 Å from 4-ABA and a residue (Y385) involved in the formation of hydrogen-bond networks from the substrate to protein surface [12] are shown in Fig. 3A. All 12 of these amino acid residues were identical to residues in the same position in the amino acid sequence of PaPHBH (Additional file 2: Fig. S2). Among them, in light of the studies on PaPHBH and PfPHBH [12, 21, 22, 23, 24], three residues (S212, R214, and Y222) that could form non-covalent bonds with the carboxy group of 4-ABA and another three (Y201, P293, and T294) that could form a hydrogen-bond loop with the amine group of 4-ABA were considered to be largely responsible for the 3-hydroxylation activity of CvPHBH toward 4-ABA. In particular, given that deprotonation of the phenolic group of 4-HBA is an important step in the catalytic process of PaPHBH [12], Y201 was deemed a pivotal residue, as the phenol group of the side chain could form hydrogen bonds with the amino group of 4-ABA. Furthermore, T294 was considered a suitable residue for modifying CvPHBH activity by mutagenesis while maintaining the enzyme function since the carbonyl group of the main chain, whose molecular species is unaffected by mutagenesis, could be involved in hydrogen-bond formation with Y201. Indeed, mutations of T294 have been found in PaPHBH mutants exhibiting increased hydroxylation activity toward 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid [24, 25, 26]. On the other hand, mutations of P293, which are reportedly responsible for the movement of FAD in the catalytic cycle [27], were expected to disrupt the catalytic function of the enzyme. Therefore, we focused on Y201 and T294 as target residues for site-directed mutagenesis and examined eight mutants (CvPHBHY201F, CvPHBHT294G, CvPHBHT294A, CvPHBHT294V, CvPHBHT294L, CvPHBHT294I, CvPHBHT294S, and CvPHBHT294C), excluding mutations that were expected to disrupt the catalytic function beforehand.
The C. glutamicum strains expressing selected CvPHBH mutants were constructed (KN008–KN015), and the concentrations of 4,3-AHBA and 4-ABA in the culture supernatants of those strains after 96 h were analyzed. The results showed improvement in mean 4,3-AHBA concentration and mean 4,3-AHBA percentage when the five single-mutants (CvPHBHY201F, CvPHBHT294G, CvPHBHT294A, CvPHBHT294S, and CvPHBHT294C) were expressed (Fig. 3B). Conversely, expression of three single-mutants (CvPHBHT294V, CvPHBHT294L, and CvPHBHT294I) did not enhance the 4,3-AHBA productivity compared to that of the wild type CvPHBH. The highest mean 4,3-AHBA concentration was detected in the strain KN008 expressing CvPHBHY201F (6.1 ± 0.8 mM, 94%), while the highest mean 4,3-AHBA percentage was detected in the CvPHBHT294S-expressing KN014 strain (5.8 ± 0.3 mM, 98%).
Following the observation of a marked increase in the 4,3-AHBA productivity in strains expressing two mutants, namely CvPHBHY201F and CvPHBHT294S, we evaluated the 4,3-AHBA productivity of the strain KN016 expressing the double-mutant CvPHBHY201F/T294S. The results showed that strain KN016 exhibited a higher mean 4,3-AHBA concentration (4.7 ± 0.7 mM) and mean 4,3-AHBA percentage (87%) than strain KN003 expressing the wild type CvPHBH; however, the improvement was not as remarkable as that observed when the respective single-mutants were expressed.
Random mutagenesis screening with colorimetric detection of 4,3-AHBA
In parallel with site-directed mutagenesis, a random library of CvPHBH mutants was screened using a colorimetric assay method newly constructed to simply estimate the concentration of 4,3-AHBA in the culture supernatants.
For rapid screening, we first established a method to estimate 4,3-AHBA concentration by oxidizing 4,3-AHBA with a commercially available laccase and spectrophotometrically measuring the amount of dye produced (Fig. 4A). Fortunately, it has been reported that oxidative dimerization of 4,3-AHBA naturally occurs under aerobic conditions at room temperature, forming 2-aminophenoxazin-3-one-7-carboxylic acid (2,3,7-APOC), which is easily observed as orange-yellow by the naked eye [28]. In addition, studies on multi-copper oxidases such as tyrosinase and laccase have shown that these enzymes oxidize molecules retaining ortho-aminophenol group with O2 and the subsequent non-enzymatic dimerization reaction produces phenoxazinone dyes [29, 30]. Given the commercial availability of laccases, a colorimetric assay method based on the oxidation of 4,3-AHBA with laccase was devised. As shown in Fig. 4B, the addition of 4,3-AHBA to 0.1 M citrate buffer (pH 4.5) containing the laccase immediately caused a change in the color of the solution, which turned orange-yellow. The absorption spectrum of the reaction solution showed an absorption peak at ca. 446 nm, which was consistent with previously reported results [28]. In addition, the molecular mass of the eluate with an absorption peak at ca. 446 nm in the liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) measurement was m/z = 257 (Additional file 2: Fig. S3), which was consistent with that of 2,3,7-APOC ([M + H]+ = 257).
Then, a plasmid library harboring the gene encoding random CvPHBH mutants in the expression cassette of the pKCG_Ptuf_T1 vector was generated by error-prone PCR and used to transform the C. glutamicum strain KC551. The 1152 colonies of the resulting transformants were screened based on the absorbance at 446 nm of the mixture of the culture supernatants and the laccase solutions. Sequencing of the CvPHBH mutant expressed in the strains with the highest absorbance resulted in the identification of the CvPHBHY161S/D357V double-mutant. The effect of the double-mutation on the 4,3-AHBA productivity was re-evaluated using HPLC analysis, along with the effect of the two single mutations that comprise it (Fig. 4C). The analysis of the culture supernatant of strain KN017 expressing CvPHBHY161S/D357V after 96 h resulted in 7.7 ± 0.5 mM of mean 4,3-AHBA concentration and 96% of mean 4,3-AHBA percentage. On the other hand, when strains KN018 and KN019 expressing CvPHBHY161S and CvPHBHD357V were used, 6.0 ± 0.3 mM (70%) and 5.1 ± 0.5 mM (69%) of the 4,3-AHBA productivity were observed, respectively. All three mutants had improved 4,3-AHBA productivity compared to that of the wild type CvPHBH but were inferior to the improvement of the 4,3-AHBA productivity exhibited by the single-mutant CvPHBHT294S.
Exploration of effective mutations around FAD
Of the two mutation sites found in the random screening, we noted that Y161 was located around FAD, a cofactor required in the catalytic cycle, in the three-dimensional structure model of CvPHBH (Fig. 5A). Similarly, we were interested in introducing mutations into residue M106, which is located opposite Y161 across FAD and expected to affect the position and movement of the cofactor. Therefore, eight strains (KN020–KN027) expressing CvPHBH mutants with a seemingly non-destructive mutation introduced at residue M106 (CvPHBHM106G, CvPHBHM106A, CvPHBHM106V, CvPHBHM106L, CvPHBHM106I, CvPHBHM106S, CvPHBHM106T, CvPHBHM106C) were constructed and evaluated for 4,3-AHBA productivity (Fig. 5B). Unexpectedly, the strain KN023 expressing CvPHBHM106A exhibited even higher 4,3-AHBA productivity (6.6 ± 0.5 mM, 99%) than the strain KN014 expressing the active site mutant CvPHBHT294S. Furthermore, the evaluation of the strain KN028 expressing a double-mutant CvPHBHM106A/T294S also resulted in high 4,3-AHBA productivity (5.9 ± 0.3 mM, 98%), indicating that the M106A mutation located around FAD was compatible with the T294S mutation located at the active site.
Production of 4,3-AHBA in fed-batch culture
To investigate the capability of gram-scale 4,3-AHBA production, a C. glutamicum strain expressing CvPHBHM106A/T294S was cultivated in fed-batch culture. To further enhance the supply of 4-ABA, aroGD146N from E. coli and aroFP155L from C. glutamicum that encode 3-deoxy-D-arabino-heptulosonate-7-phosphate (DAHP) synthase with feedback-resistance [31, 32] were introduced into the strain KC551; the resulting strain KC617 was transformed with the plasmid pKCG_Ptuf_CvPHBHM106A/T294S_T1, obtaining the KN029 strain. The fed-batch culture of KN029 was provided glucose under constant pH, temperature, and dissolved O2 conditions with an initial culture volume of 60 mL (Fig. 6A and Additional file 2: Fig. S4). After 75 h of culture (final volume, 84 mL), the concentration of 4,3-AHBA in the culture supernatant reached 13.5 g/L (88 mM; Fig. 6B), and that of 4-ABA was 0.059 g/L (0.43 mM). The 4,3-AHBA percentage was calculated as 99.5%.