Premature ejaculation (PE) and erectile dysfunction (ED), which cause negative outcomes in men and their partners, are common sexual dysfunctions worldwide (1). Little research has focused on the association between the anatomical characteristics of the penis and sexual dysfunction. In the present study, we investigated the associations between self-reported anatomical characteristics of the penis and PE and ED. Given that age has been previously found to be associated with sexual dysfunction (2, 3) as well as there being the reason to believe that age could be associated with how men relate to their sexual anatomy, we also included age in our analyses.
PE and ED
Premature ejaculation (PE) is characterized by a lack of control over the timing of ejaculation, a short intravaginal ejaculation latency time (i.e., the time between the start of vaginal penetration to ejaculation), and subsequent sexual distress (4, 5). On the one hand, men with PE experience lower self-confidence and self-esteem (6, 7), higher anxiety and depression (8), and interpersonal difficulties (9, 10). On the other hand, PE is associated with lower relationship and sexual satisfaction and an increased prevalence of sexual dysfunctions for female partners (2). In a related vein, one in five women reported that they had broken up or divorced men because of early ejaculation problems in a large sample (11).
Erectile dysfunction (ED) is defined as the inability to attain or maintain an erection sufficient to obtain satisfaction from sexual intercourse (12). Also, ED is associated with lower self-esteem and sexual satisfaction (13). Several studies have also found that ED is associated with an increased risk of PE (14, 15).
Penis Size and Sexual Dysfunction
Penis size is a specific concern related to body image among men as part of men’s appearance self-esteem (16). In a sample of 25,594 heterosexual men, 45% suffered from dissatisfaction and anxiety with their penis size including men with an objectively normal size penis (17). Excessive worry and shame concerning penis size may meet the criteria of body dysmorphic disorder with men being preoccupied with a perceived defect with their penis that may not be observable to others or may only appear slight (18). Such concerns have been found to be negatively associated with erectile and orgasmic function and sexual intercourse satisfaction (19). Prior studies have demonstrated that a generally negative body image is linked to decreased sexual satisfaction and sexual function (20, 21). Satisfaction with penis size has also been found to be associated with fewer early ejaculation and erectile problems (22, 23). We suggest that a possible mechanism is excessive anxiety, worry, and shame concerning penis size during sex triggering an overactive sympathetic nervous system response (24–26) which in turn would disturb both normal erectile function as well as ejaculation control (27, 28).
So far, little research into the connections between penis size and male sexual function has been conducted. Recently, men have started to seek surgical penile augmentation to increase penile length or circumference (29, 30). The increases in penile length and circumference after penile augmentation (e.g., the use of allografts, specifically an acellular inert dermal matrix derived from donated human skin tissue, to enhance the circumference of the penis) have been found to improve the participants’ sexual self-esteem, satisfaction with the penis (29). Further, increased penile circumference after penile augmentation has been associated with longer ejaculation latency times and better erectile function probably due to the reduction of penile sensation compared to baseline data before the surgery (30). Although suggestive of a causal effect of penile length on sexual function, these findings may not be generalizable given that men seeking surgery may be different from other men. A study of 1027 Egyptian men found that men with ED had shorter fully stretched penis lengths than men without ED, but no connection between the penile circumference and ED was found (31). However, a study of 689 Brazilian men did not find any association between penile length and erectile function (23).
So far, no studies have directly investigated the link between penis size and sexual function in a non-clinical Asian sample. Based on the available evidence, we expected men with longer penises to have fewer early ejaculation and erectile problems while only conducting analyses regarding girth in an exploratory manner.
Penile Circumcision and Sexual Dysfunction
Circumcision of the penis is one of the most common surgical procedures worldwide. The procedure involves the surgical removal of part or all the foreskin from the penis for, among others, religious, cultural, and medical reasons. Approximately one in three men has been circumcised worldwide (32). The foreskin is the double layer of skin that covers the glans penis. Possible roles of the foreskin may include keeping the glans moist (33), protecting the developing penis in the womb (34), and enhancing sexual pleasure due to the presence of nerve receptors (35). Tight foreskin (i.e., phimosis) may cause erectile problems and even pain during sexual intercourse (36) which is a common medical reason for circumcision.
The effect of penile circumcision on sexual function has been investigated for a long time but remains controversial. Recent reviews indicate that penile circumcision may not have a robust effect on sexual function (37, 38), penile sensitivity (37, 38), or sexual pleasure (37, 38). Bronselaer et al. (39) found that male circumcision decreased men’s sexual pleasure and orgasm intensity. However, some recent studies have found that circumcised men reported better erectile function and less penile pain at rest and during sex which might be the reason for observed improvements of erectile function (36), higher intravaginal ejaculatory latency times and better control over ejaculation and more satisfaction with sexual intercourse compared to themselves before circumcision (40).
Bossio et al. (41) found that uncircumcised men’s foreskin sensitivity to tactile stimulation was higher than that of other penile sites (glans penis, proximal to midline shaft of the penis, midline shaft). Further, penile sensitivity was not different between circumcised and uncircumcised men among the latter penile sites (41). In conclusion, the foreskin of the penis may be one of the most important sites for tactile stimulation during sex. One possibility is that the reason that circumcision can improve ejaculation control is reduced penile sensitivity via removing part of the foreskin. In addition, a previous study also found circumcised men to report less sexual pleasure and lower orgasm intensity (39). In conclusion, we assumed that male circumcision improves erectile function (due to unknown reasons) and ejaculation control (due to reduced sensitivity).
We also looked at differences between men who naturally had different degrees of foreskin covering the glans penis while the penis had or did not have a full erection. In the flaccid state, the glans penis with a lower degree of foreskin coverage is more likely to come into contact with undergarments, resulting in friction between the glans penis and the clothes leading to thicker skin and thereby decreased sensitivity of the penis to stimulation which in turn would lead to a higher threshold to ejaculation. Assuming a correlation between foreskin coverage in flaccid and erect states, we expected erect state coverage to have the same effect. Also, considering the difficulty with erection if the penis has an excessively tight foreskin (36, 41), we expected men with less degree of foreskin covering glans when the penis was erect to have a less tight foreskin that would have less impact on the erection, resulting in fewer erectile problems.
Age and Sexual Dysfunction
The association between age and sexual function is still not fully understood. Although some previous research has found that older men have longer self-reported ejaculation latency times (2), age has not always been found to be associated with PE (42, 43). However, previous studies have relatively consistently found that higher age is associated with a higher risk of ED (15, 44), particularly in men aged over 40 (3). Also, on one hand, the higher risk of ED with increased age might also drive an increased risk of PE as PE and ED are positively associated (14, 45, 46). On the other hand, more sexual experience as a function of increased age may lead to less sexual performance anxiety (especially within long-term relationships) which in turn might decrease the risk of PE and ED (47).
Interestingly, both cross-sectional and longitudinal studies have shown that testosterone levels decline gradually as men age from their 30s to their 90s (48–50). Testosterone plays a role in every step of the male sexual response (51) with previous research showing that lower testosterone levels are associated with reduced sexual desire (52) and a higher risk of ED (52, 53). In addition, testosterone replacement treatment can improve the latency times of men with acquired PE (PE appearing only after a man’s first sexual experience) (54). However, a recent review has indicated that the effectiveness of testosterone replacement treatment in improving sexual function is modest and inconsistent, comparable to that of lifestyle interventions (53). In a similar vein, another contributing factor is cardiovascular disease contributing to ED with age (55). Based on the above, we supposed that the association between age and sexual dysfunction may not simply be linear. Instead, the effects of age on sexual function could be positive among younger men (due to the psychological effects of increased sexual experience) and negative among older men (due to biological changes caused by aging). Therefore, we investigated the association between age and sexual function among adult men while considering age itself also as a potential moderating factor.
Hypotheses
Previous research has indicated that a longer penile length is associated with fewer erectile problems (30, 56, 57) and longer ejaculation latency times (30), but penile circumference has not been found to have this effect. Therefore, we hypothesized that men with longer penises would experience fewer early ejaculation and erectile problems and only conducted analyses regarding girth in an exploratory manner (Hypothesis 1).
Previous research has suggested penile circumcision has a positive effect on ejaculation control and erectile function (36, 40, 58). Therefore, we hypothesized that circumcised men would experience fewer early ejaculation and erectile problems (Hypothesis 2). Based on the reduced sensitivity to friction stimulation due to friction between the glans penis with the less coverage of the foreskin and underclothes in the flaccid state, the highest sensitivity to tactile stimulation of the foreskin in the erection state, and the difficulty with erection if the penis has an excessively tight foreskin (36, 41), we expected that men with less degree of foreskin covering glans while the penis during full erection would experience fewer early ejaculation and erectile problems (Hypothesis 3).
The association between age and sexual function is still controversial (2, 42, 43). Testosterone levels in adult men, which are positively associated with better sexual function (51–53) begin to decline after age 30 (48–50). In contrast, as young men gain more sexual experience with increasing age, they may be less likely to experience sexual performance anxiety, particularly in long-term relationships, which could lower the risk of both PE and ED (47). Therefore, we expected that the association between age and sexual function is positive among younger men and negative among older men via the increasing sexual experience (Hypothesis 4).