To our knowledge, our study is the first to demonstrate that Ccr2 is essential for the incidence of AAA rupture, and that diet-induced ketosis can also significantly decrease AAA progression and the risk of rupture. Using previously validated, pre-clinical murine and rat models for AAA 14,15, and different ketogenic supplementation strategies, we provide a robust and comprehensive assessment of the impact of dietary ketosis on AAA formation and the risk of rupture. We also specifically demonstrate that administration of either a ketogenic diet (KDp or KDt) or an oral ketone body supplementation (EKB) can reliably induce systemic ketosis, significantly reduced aortic wall CCR2 and pro-inflammatory cytokines, increase collagen content in the AAA media, and promote an MMP balance that minimizes elastin degredation (Fig. 5).
Animals that received KDp demonstrated the most notable decrease in AAA expansion and risk of rupture. Animals that received KDt and EKB supplements also demonstrated differences in AAA progression, but not to the same extent. There was also mild to moderate variability in the KDt and EKB values of CCR2, CD68, and MMP content in AAA tissue. Administration of BAPN was reliable in inducing AAA rupture and did not appear to confound the impact of ketosis on AAA expansion and risk of rupture. Additionally, our complementary studies demonstrated that ketosis can impact pro-inflammatory CCR2-mediated signaling mechanisms that can lead to AAA progression. Therefore, this pre-clinical study demonstrates that a low-risk, and relatively easy dietary intervention, can potentially alter the course of AAA disease progression, and provides important insights that can be easily translated to human patients with AAAs who lack an effective medical management strategy.
Endogenous ketone body production mainly occurs in the liver, and results in a high glucagon/insulin ratio leading to an increased serum free fatty acids production in the circulation 37. This naturally occurs during periods of fasting, where βHB is released into the bloodstream as a byproduct of enzymatic degradation of ketone bodies within the mitochondrial matrix and is converted into ATP through oxidative phosphorylation 38. βHB rises to a few hundred micromolar (µM) concentrations within 12–16 hours of fasting, 1–2 mM after 2 days of fasting 39, and 6–8 mM with prolonged starvation 40. Ketogenic diets modify a host’s systemic energy metabolism to mimic the biochemical impact of starvation by significantly increasing serum βHB levels, lowering blood glucose, and increasing fatty acid concentrations 41. These regimens were originally introduced as a treatment for refractory epilepsy in children and have now become popular for weight loss programs, patients with diabetes, obesity, various types of cancer, and among high performance athletes 42–46. Standard ketogenic diets that are devoid of carbohydrates can lead to elevated βHB serum levels that are consistently > 2 mM 46. Recent studies demonstrate that βHB can serve as an important signaling mediator that can inhibit histone deacetylases 47, blunt tissue oxidative stress 48,49, active G-protein-coupled receptors 50,51, and regulate inflammatory mediators such as prostaglandin D2 52, interleukins 53, nuclear factor kappa B (NF-κB) 54, and NLRP3 inflammasome 55. Similarly, our study shows that animals with high serum βHB have blunted tissue inflammation and CCR2 content, which in part likely contributes to reduced pathological AAA expansion and risk of rupture.
Uniquely, our study administered three different ketosis regimens: two types of ketogenic diets (KDp and KDt), and an oral supplement regimen (EKB). KDp included a 1-week priming period prior to AAA formation, that imitates the phenomenon of keto-adaptation that occurs in humans who are maintained longer-term on a ketogenic diet 56. This regimen aided in determining whether a ketosis primer can have a ‘protective’ impact against AAA formation and expansion. On the other hand, KDt was designed to evaluate the potential ‘therapeutic’ impact of ketosis on expansion and rupture of AAA post-induction with PPE. This regimen would hypothetically be similar to how medical management would be prescribed in humans with small AAAs that do not yet meet the traditional size criteria for operative intervention. In the course of this study, we observed that animals tolerated both KDp and KDt, and that both were successful in inducing a sustained systemic state of ketosis. Interestingly, both regimens yielded significant reductions in AAA expansion and incidence of rupture relative to animals that received SD. However, the longer-term KDp regimen appeared to have a more protective impact, and a more impressive reduction of CCR2 content in AAA tissue. These findings suggest that the length of diet-induced ketosis may be an important variable in the extent of reduction of AAA tissue inflammation and risk of rupture.
With the recent advent of EKB supplements, oral regimens have been increasingly utilized to manipulate levels of circulating blood ketone body concentrations in humans for various health benefits 57. While most studies involving EKB supplementation have traditionally focused on its impact among high-performance athletes 58, these supplements are increasingly being studied as remedies for conditions such as epilepsy, heart failure, diabetes, and sepsis-related muscle atrophy 59. Our study evaluated the use of EKB to induce ketosis in animals with AAAs that are prone to rupture. Interestingly, we observed that EKB not only decreased AAA tissue inflammation (Supplemental Fig. 10), but also reduced AAA expansion and incidence of rupture (Fig. 4). The impact of EKB on CCR2 content and AAA rupture was variable from KDp and KDt, and we suspect this is because EKB only induced intermittent ketosis (limited to 8 hours per day). Nonetheless, these findings are the first to show that oral supplementation with ketone bodies can indeed serve as a minimally invasive method for the potential medical management of AAAs, and is a compelling topic for further exploration in future human clinical trials that completement prior efforts 60–62.
Our study results also suggest that ketosis has a multifaceted impact on aortic wall structure and function. Inflammation is the major molecular mediator of AAA disease progression (Fig. 5). Previous studies demonstrated that excessive aortic wall inflammation can inhibit reparative signaling, wall fibrosis, and collagen deposition, which can in turn accelerate AAA expansion and lead to a higher risk of rupture 63. Tissue macrophages are known to promote AAA disease, in particular subsets that highly express CCR2 12. We as well as others, also previously demonstrated that genetic or molecular targeting of CCR2 can reduce AAA progression 13–15. Here we provide further compleing evidence that CCR2 content indeed correlates with AAA disease progression, and that systemic ketosis in vivo can significantly reduce its both CCR2 content as well as downstream pro-inflammatory cytokines in AAA tissue.
Previous studies investigating the inflammasome in AAA tissue, demonstrated that TNFα and RANTES are both up-regulated in expanding AAA wall tissue 64,65. Inhibition of TNFα appears to decrease aortic wall MMP activity, reduce ECM disruption, and decrease aortic diameter in a murine pre-clinical AAA model 66. In another study, Empagliflozin, a sodium-glucose cotransporter 2 inhibitor that increases plasma ketone bodies 67,68, was found to reduce aortic aneurysm diameter and aortic wall RANTES in Apo E -/- mice 69. Similarly, in our study we observed that diet-induced ketosis can significantly decrease aortic wall pro-inflammatory cytokines TNFα and RANTES, as well as increase aortic wall Collagen content. Although the direct mechanism of action for this is yet to be fully elucidated, we suspect that the molecular interplay between macrophage and other pro-inflammatory cell types may be playing a critical role in the immune modulation of these processes and AAA progression 70,71.
A central pathological feature of AAA disease progression is excessive and aberrant extracellular matrix (ECM) remodeling. This results from increased MMP activity, which promotes rapid ECM breakdown and disruption of the integrity of the aortic wall 72,73. Previous work demonstrates that MMP2 plays a central role in the formation and early expansion of AAAs, while MMP9 is more related to late AAA expansion and risk of aneurysm rupture 30,74,75. Synergistic activation of both MMP2 and MMP9 provides an unfavorable environment that can accelerate AAA dilation and lead to a higher risk of aneurysm rupture 76. Previous studies also demonstrate that ketosis, high serum βHB, and signaling via NF-Kβ, play key roles in suppressing MMP-9 expression in colonic tissue 77. Our studies extend on this molecular mechanism of action, and demonstrate that ketosis and elevated serum βHB can also significantly attenuate both active MMP9, and total MMP2 in aortic tissue. In fact, a CCR2 antagonist has shown to downregulate MMP-9 expression in lung cancer cells, therefore mitigating cellular motility and metastatic invasion 78. These results may help explain why we observed a notable decrease in MMP-9 content in AAA tissue from animals with ketosis.
TIMPs are endogenous specific inhibitors of MMPs produced by vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) as well as other cell types in AAA tissue 79, which inhibit zymogenesis of pro-MMPs and reduces overall MMP activation. Given their central role in maintaining the dynamic balance in ECM turnover in aortic wall tissue, the role of TIMPs in AAA progression continues to be an area of intense investigation 35. Our study demonstrates that while nutritional ketosis decreases the content of free TIMP1, it significantly increases the content of the stabilizing TIMP1/MMP9 complex in AAA tissue. This data suggests that complexed TIMP1 leads to a reduction in active MMP9 content, therefore decreasing AAA wall ECM degradation, further aneurysm expansion, and the overall risk of rupture (Fig. 5).
Our study also demonstrated a mild-moderate, but non-significant, increase in AAA tissue TGFβ content in animals treated with ketogenic diets (Fig. 5). TGFβ belongs to a superfamily of growth factors that regulate many cellular functions such as cell growth, adhesion, migration, differentiation, and apoptosis 80. TGFβ content appears to be significantly reduced in human AAA tissue 81. A recent study demonstrated that ketosis promoted TGFβ-induced myocardial fibrosis and Collagen 1 and 3 deposition in spontaneously hypertensive rats 82, suggesting that TGFβ up-regulation was deleterious in this setting. However, in aortic tissue, TGFβ appears to have a beneficial role. For example, administration of TGFβ neutralizing antibodies appeared to promote excessive monocyte-macrophage infiltration within murine and rat AAA tissue 34,83, while overexpression or administration of TGFβ1 significantly increased aortic wall collagen deposition 84, and collagen synthesis in normal arteries 85. This in part explains our observation that animals receiving a ketogenic diet had significantly increase aortic wall Collagen 1 deposition, which correlated with higher aortic tissue TGFβ content.
We acknowledge that there are some limitations in our study. First, all our data is derived from pre-clinical rodent models that are not necessarily representative of human AAA pathophysiology. However, the rat AAA rupture model was previously validated and shown to be the most reliable and consistent AAA rupture model currently available. Second, our studies did not systematically evaluate arterial blood pressure. This would have required sophisticated in dwelling sensors and the use of continuous telemetry. While such monitoring systems are feasible for shorter experimental protocols, our 2–3-week experimental protocol would have greatly complicated the experimental design and led to several confounding variables. We therefore elected to instead serially monitor AAA endpoints via ultrasound, which provided reliable and reproducible data. Third, our study used a single composition for the ketogenic diet intervention. We acknowledge that this is not fully representative of the wide variety of lipid and oil-based ketogenic diets consumed by humans, but this was selected to maintain consistency and adherence within all rodent study groups.
In conclusion, this study demonstrates that a ketogenic diet and EKB supplementation strategy that can significantly reduce AAA expansion and reduce the incidence of AAA rupture. Importantly, a ketogenic priming period appears to also be further protective, while EKB appears to be less effective than other dietary regimens. Ketogenic diets reduced CCR2 content, promoted MMP balance, and attenuated ECM degradation in AAA tissue. These findings provide the impetus for future pre-clinical and clinical studies geared to determine the role of ketosis as a medical management tool for human patients with AAAs that do not yet meet the criteria for surgical intervention.