We conducted a study to analyze the distribution of post-treatment L1-AB subclasses in HPV-positive OPSCC over time. To our knowledge this is the first study, in which AB-kinetics of L1-IgG, -IgA, and -IgM are investigated over time.
In HPV-positive OPSCCs the tonsillar complex and the BOT are the most frequently reported locations (96%)(18). Our study cohort included carcinomas located only in these two areas. This is of importance, as a retrospective analysis in 23 297 patients by the US National Cancer Database found that HPV-positive OPSCCs located outside the tonsillar areas are associated with an inferior overall survival compared to carcinomas located in the tonsils (HR: 0.76, 95% CI: 0.67–0.86, P < .0001)(19). In our patient cohort HPV 16 and 33 have been identified in ~ 88% and ~ 7%, respectively. These findings are in concordance with previously published data by Amanda et al., who found that high-risk HPV16 is by far the most prevalent HPV subtype (18). In concordance with data published by Khalid et al., most of our patients presented with small tumors (T1, T2; ~18%, ~ 53%) and nodal metastases (N1, N2; ~24%, ~ 62%) at diagnosis(20).
Although HPV-positive OPSCC is associated with a favorable prognosis, up to 25% develop relapsing disease 2–5 years after first-line treatment(21). Hence robust and easy-to-use clinical monitoring is needed to effectively evaluate post-treatment disease status. In the past few years different serological tests have been studied in HPV-positive OPSCC. Antibody-based serological tests revealed that E6 and E7 oncoproteins of high-risk HPVs strongly correlate to HPV-driven malignancies, whereas L1-antibodies are regarded as cumulative-exposure markers(22, 23). Oton-Gonzales et al. used a commercial kit (HPV16 L1, Cusabio, Houston, TX, USA) to investigate serological L1-IgG kinetics in 20 HPV-positive HNSCC cases(22). They found that L1-IgG antibody levels did not significantly fluctuate during a follow-up period of 24 months (p > 0.05)(22). Piontek and co-workers conducted a study in 184 HPV16-driven invasive cervical cancer patients to characterize post-treatment AB-dynamics using multiplex HPV serological testing (GST-derived antigens)(23). They showed that L1 antibody levels are stable over time whereas E6 and E7 AB levels decreased after cervical cancer treatment(23). Both studies confirm the hypothesis that L1 IgG-ABs remain stable over time. In contrast to available data, findings of our previously published paper suggest that HPV16-L1 DRH1 epitope-specific antibodies are linked to HPV16-induced tumor recurrence(16). In the current study four different patterns of antibody-dynamics have been identified in the following frequency: 1. IgG > > IgA > IgM, 2. IgG > IgA > IgM, 3. IgA > IgG > IgM, and 4. IgG ≈ IgA > IgM. Although not statistically significant (p = 0.326), higher IgG/IgA-Ratios at diagnosis gravitated towards higher AJCC-stages. These findings indicate that the dominance of IgG at the time of diagnosis might play an important role in further risk-stratification of HPV-positive OPSCCs. Relapse was in 3 out of 4 cases associated with an increase of HPVL1-IgG beforehand, which, on the other hand, would support the conclusion of our previous study that HPV-L1 antibody detection might be used as a post-treatment biomarker.
Although analyses of the entire cohort did not show statistically significant AB-fluctuation over time (mainly due to the small sample size), individual antibody profiles revealed some interesting abnormalities. (Fig. 4)
Serum IgA dominance at diagnosis has been observed in 50% (2/4) cases primary located at the BOT. The remaining two cases presented with IgG dominance but subsequently switched to IgA dominance over time. IgA dominance at diagnosis in cases primary located at the tonsillar complex, has been found in 16,6% (3/18) cases. In one case IgA and IgG antibodies reached an equal level over time. IgA dominance at diagnosis has been associated with a superior disease-free survival. Only one out of seven cases developed relapse, associated with an IgA to IgG switch several months prior to clinical diagnosis of tumor recurrence. We observed an IgA to IgG switch in one additional case, but so far without any hint of disease recurrence. IgG dominance at the time of tumor recurrence has been found in all four clinically confirmed recurrences. So far there is no reasonable explanation for the association between superior clinical outcome and serum IgA dominance over time. Literature supports the assumption that IgA is the predominant AB-subclass found in saliva, and IgG in serum(24). IgM to IgA AB-class switch in naive B-cells seems to be predominantly controlled by TGF-β(25). HPV E6/E7 oncoproteins can upregulate TGF-β promotor activity resulting in TGF-β overexpression, which stimulates survival and proliferation of cervical cancer cell lines. Interestingly, TGF-β overexpression has also been described in OPSCC(26). It is unclear whether OPSCC-cells themselves or cells of the tumor microenvironment are responsible for the expression of different amounts of TGF-β which may explain IgA or IgG dominance. Von Witzleben and colleagues found that HPV E2 and E7 related IgA antibodies have not been associated with a superior overall survival in HPV-positive OPSCC patients, which may be indicative that the observed effect could rather be related to the HPV late proteins. A reason for this difference could be the high molecular weight of L1 based virus like particles that in contrast to the very small early proteins are able to bind to toll like receptors (TLR4) of the innate immune system, possibly thereby changing the cytokine network of the tumor microenvironment which in turn may influence the adaptive immune response as well(27).
In conclusion, our findings indicate that HPV-L1 AB-subclass analyses may add additional value to risk-stratification at diagnosis and for monitoring potential relapsing disease in HPV-positive OPSCC. Nonetheless, further investigations are needed to better characterize immunologic mechanisms, which may explain superior clinical outcomes in IgA dominant HPV-positive OPSCC- cases.