In the 60 years since its discovery, fungal toxin FC-A has been widely studied as a potent phytotoxin that promotes continuous stomatal opening and over-transpiration, thereby eventually leading to plant death. In this work, we found that FC-A stabilizes the PPI between 14-3-3 and PM H+-ATPase in guard cells, promoting stomatal opening and photosynthesis, thus resulting in approximately 30% enhancement of growth in Arabidopsis plants. A decrease in the carbon isotope ratio (δ13C) in chemically treated plants further supports the observation that the increase in biomass is due to the chemical activation of PM H+-ATPase in guard cells.
A structure-activity relationship study using FC-A and its biosynthetic intermediates FC-J and FC-H showed that the structurally similar FC-A and FC-J stabilize the binding of the phosphorylated C-terminal peptide of PM H+-ATPase to 14-3-3 by approximately 6-fold in terms of Kd value as compared with controls (Fig. 1E), enhance the PPI in plants (Fig. 1C), and enhance stomatal opening by approximately 200% (Fig. 1B). In contrast, hydrophilic FC-H was apparently less effective in both enhancement of the PPI and stomatal opening compared with FC-A and FC-J, indicating that the chemical functionality at the 12, 16, and 6’ positions is important for the activity. These results are consistent with those of a previous study showing that FC-A stabilizes the binding of human 14-3-3σ to the TASK-3 C-terminal phosphopeptide 10 times more effectively than FC-H40. The X-ray crystal structure of the ternary complex of 14-3-3σ bound to the TASK-3 phosphopeptide and FC-A showed that the 16-methoxy group of FC-A binds to a narrow hydrophobic pocket, anchoring the whole molecule to 14-3-3σ in a similar manner to that seen in the structure of tobacco 14-3-3 bound to FC-A (Fig. S1). In the case of the ternary complex of FC-H, which lacks the O-methyl group (3ux0), a highly defined water molecule was found to occupy this position40, suggesting that binding of the O-methyl group to the pocket squeezes out the water molecule, thus achieving entropically favored binding to 14-3-3. Indeed, whole-plant evaluations demonstrated that FC-A and FC-J enhance the growth of Arabidopsis plants to a similar degree, whereas FC-H is less effective (Fig. 3C). These results confirmed that the enhancement of plant growth is caused by enhancement of the PPI between 14-3-3 and PM H+-ATPase by FCs in guard cells.
It remains unclear whether FC-A reversibly or irreversibly upregulates stomatal opening in whole plants. Earlier studies based on in vitro evaluations concluded that FC-A irreversibly activates PM H+-ATPase19,41. In these studies, upregulation of the binding of 14-3-3 to PM H+-ATPase was evaluated by surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy19 or by submerging guard-cell protoplasts41 in a buffer solution containing a relatively high concentration of FC-A (10 µM). In the present study, a sub-nmol amount of FC-A was applied to plant leaves, and at least under these conditions, the effect of FC-A on stomatal opening was found to be transient, being active up to 24 h and becoming ineffective by 48 h (Fig. 4). These results strongly suggest that inactivation of FC-A occurs in the plant leaves. At least two α-glucosidase genes and more than 40 β-glucosidase genes have been identified in Arabidopsis42,43. Thus, metabolic degradation and inactivation involving deglycosylation are possible, as removal of the glucoside moiety from FC-A reduces its apparent affinity for 14-3-3 by approximately one order of magnitude40.
Most importantly, the activity of FC-A in terms of plant growth enhancement found in this work suggests that the promotion of stomatal opening is not the sole cause of plant death and that there are other unelucidated mechanisms underlying the phytotoxicity of FC-A. Extensive studies have shown that FC-A affects a number of physiological processes in plants12,30, including the induction of abscission44,45, proton extrusion46, cell enlargement and cotyledon growth47, and seed germination48. These activities are often explained by the “acid-growth theory”49, in which overactivation of PM H+-ATPase by FC-A results in cell-wall acidification, followed by activation of expansin, which loosens the cellulose network for growth. The diverse activities of FC-A may also reflect the wide range of physiological roles of PM H+-ATPase50 as well as 14-3-3 signaling networks in plants51. For instance, in Arabidopsis, PM H+-ATPase is encoded by 12 genes52, and 13 isoforms of 14-3-3 (10 characterized and 3 putative isoforms) have been identified that are expressed in many organelles in addition to the cytoplasm, such as chloroplasts53 and the nucleus54. Other studies have shown that 14-3-3 plays roles in a diverse array of physiological processes, including nitrogen metabolism55, ATP synthesis56, potassium ion diffusion57, flowering58, and hormone-driven transcriptional regulation59. The protein sequences of the 14-3-3 isoforms are highly conserved, and the residues involved in binding to FC-A are identical across all of the isoforms (Fig. S9); thus, FC-A could potentially stabilize any 14-3-3 interaction if the binding partner includes an appropriate consensus motif capable of forming a ternary complex with FC-A. Our present results, therefore, do not exclude any additional mechanism(s) underlying the enhancement of growth triggered by FC-A. Further research will be necessary to elucidate more details regarding the mechanism leading to growth enhancement as well as the molecular basis of the phytotoxicity of FC-A.
In the present work, we found that the fungal toxin FC-A and its biosynthetic intermediate FC-J enhance plant growth. This effect can be attributed to stabilization of the PPI between 14-3-3 and PM H+-ATPase in guard cells, which promotes stomatal opening and photosynthesis. This unexpected property should stimulate further research examining potential agricultural applications of FC-A and FC-J.