ATC Treatment of WT/NHD13 chimeric mice leads to T-ALL in both donor and recipient tissue. To assess the in vivo pre-clinical efficacy of ATC, a newly described DNMT1 inhibitor, we generated a cohort of chimeric mice with both wild-type (WT) and MDS hematopoiesis. The chimeric mice were generated by co-transplantation of 200,000 WT and 1,000,000 NHD13 (MDS) bone marrow nucleated cells (BMNC) into WT recipients, following a myeloablative conditioning regimen of 900 cGy ionizing radiation. The NHD13 BMNC expressed the CD45.2 allele, while the WT BMNC and WT recipients expressed the CD45.1 allele, allowing us to distinguish hematopoiesis generated from WT and NHD13 cells using flow cytometry. Chimeric mice successfully engrafted both WT and NHD13 cells, as shown in Extended Data Fig. 1A-B; in addition, chimeric mice developed peripheral blood abnormalities consistent with MDS, such as macrocytic anemia and leukopenia (Extended Data Fig. 1C-D). Similar to the findings with NHD13 transgenic mice, 71% percent of NHD13/WT chimeric mice progressed to myelodysplastic syndrome or acute leukemia of donor origin, most commonly acute myeloid leukemia (AML; Ext Data Fig. 1E-G).
NHD13/WT chimeric mice were treated with either vehicle control (phosphate buffered saline; PBS) or ATC (1.0 mg/kg) once daily via intraperitoneal injection for up to 14 cycles of therapy, each cycle being two weeks of treatment followed by one week rest. Pooled results from three independent experiments revealed that ATC treated mice did not show prolonged survival, but instead showed reduced survival compared to PBS treated controls (Fig. 1A). Surprisingly, further analysis showed that over half of the ATC treated mice had developed leukemia of WT, not donor origin (Fig. 1B). Notably, leukemias that developed in WT cells were exclusively lymphoid, as opposed to myeloid leukemia that was seen in most NHD13 transformed cells. The most common form of lymphoid leukemia we identified was T cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (T- ALL), also referred to as precursor T-lymphoblastic leukemia/lymphoma (pre-T LBL)20 (Extended Data Table 1). The T-ALL cases typically showed thymic enlargement (Extended Data Table 1), along with peripheral blood abnormalities such as anemia, thrombocytopenia, and leukocytosis (Fig. 1C). More detailed analysis revealed invasion of lymphoblasts in the BM and spleen (Fig. 1D), and clonal T cell receptor beta (Trb) gene rearrangements (Ext Data Table 2; Fig. 1E). In sum, 72.7% of mice treated with ATC developed recipient T-ALL. Ionizing radiation, which was used as a preparative regimen, is well-established to be leukemogenic in mice; however, the 72.7% incidence is significantly higher than the 5–10% incidence of T-ALL seen in historical controls from our lab (p = 0.0001) (Fig. 1F).
WES of ATC treated mouse leukemia reveals marked increase in C > G transversion. We utilized whole exome sequencing (WES) to search for acquired mutations in the T-ALL samples. Remarkably, we found a dramatic increase in both number (mean +/- standard deviation of 762 +/- 642 vs 2 +/- 1; Mann-Whitney p = 0.003189) and percentage (89 +/- 5 vs 7.5 +/- 2.5; Mann-Whitney p = .003318) of C > G transversions in all ATC treated samples, with up to thousands of acquired mutations per sample (Fig. 2A-B, Supp Data Table 1). Further characterization of the acquired mutations using Single Base Substitution (SBS) profile software (SigProfiler MatrixGenerator, Extractor, Simulator, and Plotter) demonstrated that the C > G transversions occurred almost exclusively in a 5’-NCG-3’context (Fig. 2C). This signature was not recognized as an existing signature present in the COSMIC database by the SigProfiler software, which led us to regard this as a novel SBS signature21–25; we have provisionally designated this new signature as SBS-ATC. Figure 2C shows the stark difference between T-ALL in a PBS treated mouse, with 1 C > G transversion, as opposed to T-ALL in an ATC treated mouse, with > 1000 C > G transversions. Additional evidence for the specificity of ATC associated mutations comes from analysis of two mice that developed early thymocyte precursor (ETP) ALL in donor NHD13 cells (Fig. 2D; Extended Data Fig. 2). Close examination of these ETP samples demonstrated that these two leukemias had identical, clonal D-J rearrangements, indicating that a pre-malignant ETP clone had been transplanted to the recipient mice; this model is consistent with a recent report that NHD13/IDH2R140Q mice frequently develop ETP ALL 26. However, despite the fact that these two donor ETP originated from the same pre-malignant clone, the ETP-ALL clone in a PBS treated mouse acquired only two C > G transversions, whereas an ETP clone from an ATC treated mouse demonstrated over 2000 acquired C > G transversions (Fig. 2D). The reproducibility of the SBS-ATC signature is evident in Supp Fig. 1A, in which a marked increase in C > G transversions, in a 5’-NCG-3’ context, is seen in every leukemia from mice treated with > 0.1 mg/kg of ATC.
We employed PCR amplification and Sanger sequencing to verify a subset of the acquired C > G transversions that were identified by NGS; in all cases tested, the C > G transversions were detected by Sanger sequencing (Ext data Fig. 3A). In a smaller subset, we verified that the C > G transversions were indeed transcribed into mRNA (Ext data Fig. 3B). The detection of these mutations in both gDNA and cDNA using Sanger sequencing demonstrated that these highly specific C > G transversions were bona fide mutations and not sequencing artefacts.
ATC treatment of transplanted mice leads to recipient (r) T-ALL in the absence of ionizing radiation. Given the use of myeloablative ionizing radiation (IR) in generating the NHD13 chimeric model, and the known mutagenic potential of IR, we sought to examine a requirement for IR in the unique C > G transversions characterized above. To avoid IR, we used CASIN as a non-genotoxic conditioning regimen 27. CASIN, for Cdc42 activity-specific inhibitor, treatment leads to egress of WT hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPC) from the recipient BM, allowing for engraftment of transplanted HSPC 28. We also varied the dosage of ATC in this experiment to investigate the possibility of a dose-dependent effect on C > G transversion. CASIN conditioning led to successful engraftment of NHD13 HSPC (Fig. 3A, Extended Data Table 2).
The engraftment of NHD13 HSPC varied with ATC dosage, as higher ATC doses were associated with a lower median engraftment; this may have been due to effective treatment of the Cd45.2 + NHD13 MDS (Fig. 3A). Similar to the transplants using IR, we noted a highly penetrant phenotype; all mice treated with either 0.5 mg/kg or 1.0 mg/kg ATC developed rT-ALL (Fig. 3B). In contrast, only one of six mice treated with 0.1 mg/kg ATC developed rT-ALL, and none of six PBS control mice developed rT-ALL. All mice treated with PBS developed donor MDS/AML, confirming the high penetrance of MDS/AML in recipients of NHD13 BMNC (Fig. 3B, Extended Data Tables 1 and 2). Two ATC-treated mice developed a concurrent donor AML and a recipient T – lineage ALL; this is not surprising given the highly penetrant nature of both ATC treatment and NHD13 BMNC transplantation (Supp Fig S2).
Similar to the results with transplants that employed IR, WES of leukemia from ATC treated mice following CASIN conditioning showed hundreds to thousands of C > G transversions (Fig. 3C, Supp Data Table 2) and that almost all SNV were C > G transversions (Fig. 3D). In addition, the number of C > G transversions increased with increasing ATC dosage (Fig. 3C). The unique 5’-NCG-3’ context for the C > G transversion was reproduced in all ATC treated mice that received CASIN conditioning (Fig. 3E; Supp Fig. 1B). These results demonstrate that the C > G transversion and induction of lymphoid leukemias in ATC treated NHD13 chimeric mice was not dependent on IR.
ATC induces C > G transversions and T-ALL in non-transplanted WT mice
There is evidence that both human 29,30 and murine 31 MDS hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPC) cells can “re-shape” the wild-type BM microenvironment. To eliminate the possibility that a BM microenvironment re-shaped by NHD13 HSPC was required for ATC-induced mutagenesis, we treated non-transplanted WT C57BL6 mice with ATC. Given that the thymus typically involutes with age, we also wished to determine if age effected the susceptibility to ATC-induced T-cell leukemogenesis. Three independent experiments were conducted using WT mice aged 2, 8, or 12–15 months and 1.0 mg/kg ATC. Sublethal IR (600 cGy) was also included in some experiments to allow for comparison to prior experiments with ATC and IR.
All three age groups showed significantly decreased survival (Figs. 4A-C) for both ATC alone and ATC + IR treatment, with ATC + IR consistently showing poorer survival. A pooled survival curve along with cause of death is shown in Fig. 4D. All mice that received ATC, with or without IR, were either found dead or developed lymphoid leukemia within 27 weeks of beginning ATC treatment, with the majority of mice developing lymphoid leukemia between 15–20 weeks. This peak corresponds to 5–6 cycles of ATC treatment.
Recipient T-ALL in non-transplanted WT mice treated with ATC was similar to that which developed in the NHD13 transplant recipients, with invasion of T-lymphoblasts in BM and spleen (Ext Data Fig. 4A), as well as non-hematopoietic tissues such as kidney and liver (Ext Data Fig. 4B), and clonal Trb gene rearrangements (Ext Data 4C-D). In addition to T-ALL, we also observed B-ALL in a smaller number of mice, suggesting the possibility that ATC treatment could be oncogenic in B as well as T lymphoblasts. The B-ALL were characterized by anemia, thrombocytopenia, and leukocytosis. (Supp Fig S3A). Flow cytometry showed invasion of CD19+/B220+ lymphoblasts in the BM, spleen, and lymph nodes (Supp Fig S3B) as well as non-hematopoietic tissue such as liver and kidney (Supp Fig. 3C). Further supporting a diagnosis of B-ALL was a clonal Igh gene rearrangement (Supp Fig. 3D), and establishment of immortal B-ALL cell lines from some of these samples. A small subset of ATC-treated WT mice developed concurrent T- and B-ALL. These mice again showed anemia, thrombocytopenia, and leukocytosis (Supp Fig S3E), and invasion of clonal B cells in BM and spleen and T cells in the thymus (Supp Fig S3F-G). These were two independent leukemias, as there were only nine mutations shared between the T-ALL and B-ALL, as compared to 6272 mutations that were not shared (Supp Fig. 3H). Acquired mutations included those associated with murine T-ALL (Notch1) in the thymus and murine B-ALL (Bcor) in the BM (Supp Fig. 3I).
WES (Supp Data Table 3) of leukemias that arose in ATC treated mice revealed increased number and percentage of C > G transversions (Fig. 4E-F) similar to prior experiments, once more in a 5’-NCG-3’ context (Supp Fig. 1C). These results demonstrate that neither IR nor NHD13 transplantation was required for the induction of lymphoid leukemia by ATC; and that ATC treatment could induce B-ALL as well as T-ALL in WT mice (Fig. 4D).
WGS shows correlation of ATC-induced C > G transversions and global CpG density. We used Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS) (Supp Data Table 4) to map the location of C > G transversions on a subset of eight ATC-induced T-ALL samples. We detected an average of more than 24,000 mutations per sample, primarily C > G transversions in a 5’-NCG-3’ context. As shown in Supp Fig. 1D, despite a considerable difference in the total number of SNV (range 3,865 − 42,867), the mutation profiles of these samples are almost identical. Using the ChromoMap package in R, we mapped pooled C > G transversion density as well as each individual mouse C > G transversion density 32,33 (Supp Fig. 4A-H). Given the 5’-NCG-3’ context of C > G transversions, we hypothesized that C > G transversion would correspond to known CpG density. We found that while C > G transversion dense areas generally mapped to CpG dense regions, the highest density of C > G transversions did not invariably map to the highest density of CpG dinucleotides (e.g., the distal portion of chromosome 2 in Fig. 5). In addition, not every CpG dense region had high C > G transversion density (e.g., chromosome 18 in Fig. 5), and there is considerable heterogeneity in C > G transversion mapping when examining individual mouse samples (Supp Fig S4A-H). We also found increased C > G transversion density in genomic regions that contain known cancer-associated genes, such as Notch1, Ikzf1, and Trp53 (Fig. 5), suggesting that C > G transversion may lead to in vivo selection due to mutations that confer a fitness advantage. Nonetheless, Supp Data Table 5 reveals that among 193,839 total mutations detected by WGS, only 281 (0.145%) C > G transversions occurred in the exact same nucleotide position among two different mice, and no exact nucleotide position was mutated more than twice; therefore, it seems ATC does not preferentially mutate at any single nucleotide position, but rather acts preferentially within larger chromosomal regions.
Numerous C > G transversions occur in genes relevant for human lymphoid leukemia. To investigate a relationship between C > G mutagenesis and lymphoid oncogenesis, we determined whether C > G transversions commonly occurred in genes associated with human cancer, especially lymphoid malignancy. To avoid complexities introduced by IR and NHD13 transplant, we focused these studies on 22 lymphoid leukemias (19 T-ALL and 3 B-ALL) that were generated by ATC treatment of WT mice. We compared Tier 1 mutations identified in this set to a set of 432 genes commonly associated with cancer that were part of the FoundationOne® Heme Gene panel (Foundation Medicine, Inc.) used to detect relevant cancer mutations in human hematologic malignancy. This analysis identified a total of 612 Tier 1 C > G transversions in genes associated with cancer in the 22 mouse samples for an average of 28 potentially oncogenic mutations per leukemia sample (Fig. 6A, Supp Data Table 6). Additionally, the 40 genes most commonly mutated included genes well known to be associated with human lymphoid malignancy, such as Bcl11b, Ikzf1, Trp53, Pten, Kras, Jak3, and Notch1 (Fig. 6A). Further analysis of C > G transversion position revealed that amino acid mutations often occurred in known oncogenic “hotspots”, such as Trp53 R270P, homologous to human R273 mutants (Fig. 6B), Pax5 P80R (Fig. 6C), and Pten R130G (Fig. 6D)34 These results indicate that the induction of C > G transversions in lymphoid cells is the likely proximal cause of leukemic transformation observed in ATC treated mice.
C > G transversions can be generated in human cells after brief ATC exposure in vitro. We treated the human AML cell line U937 with ATC in vitro (Fig. 7A) to address two questions; 1) were human cells susceptible to the mutagenic effect of ATC, and 2) could we develop an in vitro assay for ATC-induced mutagenesis. To minimize diversity of the initial U937 cell population, we first single cell cloned the U937 cell line. The cloned U937 parental line was then treated for 6 days in vitro with 25, 50, or 100nM ATC or PBS. Reasoning that DNA harvested at this time may contain multiple populations of mutagenized U937 cells, we then single cell cloned the treated cells, and harvested genomic DNA from both the bulk U937 population as well as the individual single cell clones.
WES (filtered for VAF > = 0.2 and alternate allele count > = 5) from bulk ATC treated cells revealed 0 SNV. However, there was a dramatic difference in number and percent of C > G SNV in the ATC treated individual clones. The ATC treated clones had 495 ± 360 C > G transversions per clone (Fig. 7B), whereas the PBS treated clones had 0.2 ± 0.4 C > G transversions per clone, p = 0.009701, a difference of > 1000-fold (Supp Data Table 7). There were similar differences in the percent C > G SNV among all mutations (Fig. 7C). SBS analysis revealed a similar 5’-NCG-3’ mutational context in human cells, but without the 5’-TCG-3’ peak as observed in mice (Fig. 7D, Supp Fig. 5). We refer to this in vitro assay as GEMINI for Genotoxic Mutation Signature Identified After Clonal Expansion In Vitro.
The human T-cell line CEM was also examined using the GEMINI assay. Similar to U937 cells, we noted a marked increase in C > G transversions in ATC treated single cell clones (1172 ± 447 vs 55 ± 38, p = 0.007937) (Ext Data Fig. 5A). However, in contrast to treatment of U937 cells, in which the percent of C > G transversions was 86–91% (Fig. 7C), the percent of mutations that were C > G transversions in ATC treated CEM clones was much lower, only 26–45% (Ext Data Fig. 5B). Moreover, the total number of variants in the CEM PBS control single cell clones was far higher than the U937 PBS single cell clones (1215 ± 194 vs. 0.25 ± 0.4, p = 0.01193)(Supp Data Table 7). However, it has previously been reported that the CEM cell line has a mismatch repair deficiency due to deletion of MLH1 35. Examination of the CEM WES .bam files revealed an almost total absence of MLH1 reads, consistent with a homozygous MLH1 deletion. SBS analysis of the CEM clones identified two signatures associated with mismatch repair deficiency (COSMIC signatures SBS15 and SBS21), as well as a novel, previously unreported signature, similar to that seen in U937 cells. Inspection of the SBS profiles for CEM reveals C > G and C > T SNVs, both preferentially in a 5’-VCG-3’ context (V indicating not T) (Ext Data Fig. 5C) (See Supp Fig. 5 for all SBS plots). Taken together, these results demonstrate that ATC can induce C > G transversions in human cells.
In addition to ATC, we evaluated the DNMTi decitabine (DAC; FDA approved for treatment of MDS) for a potential mutagenic effect, as both molecules are deoxycytidine analogs with Aza moieties in the cytosine base. WES using the protocol outlined in Fig. 7A revealed an increase in the number (10 ± 6 vs. 0.2 ± 0.4, p = 0.009701) (Ext Data Fig. 6A) and proportion (20–70%, p = 0.009701)(Ext Data Fig. 6B) of C > G mutations in DAC treated vs PBS controls (Supp Data Table 7). However, this effect was markedly reduced compared to ATC, and no clear 5’-NCG-3’ or 5’-VCG-3’ signature was observed in DAC treated samples (Ext Data Fig. 6C) (See Supp Fig. 5 for all SBS plots). These results suggest that DAC may have a similar, but weaker mutagenic effect compared to ATC.
Dck is required for C > G transversions induced by ATC. It is unclear why ATC induced only lymphoid malignancy in the in vivo studies. Given that ATC is an unphosphorylated cytidine analog, we reasoned that ATC would need to be phosphorylated to be incorporated into DNA. Phosphorylation of deoxycytidine is mediated by deoxycytidine kinase (Dck), the rate-limiting enzyme in the cytosine “salvage” pathway (Fig. 8A) 36. Dck is most highly expressed in lymphoid tissue 37,38 and its importance in lymphoid cell development is underscored by the observation that the only phenotype noted in Dck KO mice was in T and B cell precursors 39. We thus hypothesized the expression of Dck in lymphoid tissue allowed for incorporation of ATC into the lymphoid cell genome, leading to C > G mutations and leukemogenesis.
To assess whether phosphorylation of ATC by Dck was required for the mutagenic effect of ATC, we utilized a murine T-ALL cell line with a homozygous deletion of Dck that had been generated by serial passage in the presence of cytarabine; the parental cell line is designated 7298, while the cytarabine resistant cell line is designated 7298CR (Fig. 8B-C). A dose-dependent effect on both cell growth (Fig. 8D) and viability (Fig. 8E) was evident in the parental 7298 (Dck WT) cell line, whereas the 7298CR (Dck deleted) cell line showed little effect at any concentration of ATC tested. We used the GEMINI assay described in Fig. 7A to generate single cell clones of both the 7298 and 7298CR cell line following treatment with 1000 nM ATC. WES revealed a marked increase in both the number (Fig. 8F) and proportion (Fig. 8G) of C > G transversions in the 7298 clones, whereas 7298CR clones had very few C > G transversions (Supp Data Table 8). SBS profiles of the 7298 clones demonstrated the same 5’-NCG-3’ context that was identified in the murine T- and B-ALL samples, whereas profiles of the 7298CR clones had very few C > G transversions (Fig. 8H) (Supp Fig. 6). These results demonstrate that Dck expression is required for ATC induced C > G mutagenesis and suggest that lymphoid leukemia induction in the context of ATC treatment may be due to high Dck expression in lymphoid cells.