In 1968, Lindenberg et al. discovered extensive eosinophilic intranuclear inclusions in the brain and internal organs of a 28-year-old man with intellectual disability by autopsy, marking the first recorded case of NIID(15). Until 2011, only approximately 40 cases of NIID diagnosed through postmortem brain biopsy had been described worldwide(1, 8). In recent years, the number of reported NIID cases has gradually increased due to the use of skin biopsies and genetic tests for diagnosis. The understanding of NIID is also constantly being updated.
3.1 Pathogenesis of NIID
NIID is associated with GGC repeat amplification in the 5'UTR of the human-specific NOTCH2NLC gene(16). NOTCH2NLC is one of three human-specific NOTCH2NL-associated genes that have been implicated in recurrent neurodevelopmental disorders(8). The exact pathogenesis of GGC amplification in NOTCH2NLC is currently unknown. Researchers have proposed several hypotheses regarding the pathogenesis of NIID, including the toxicity of polyamino acid proteins(17–19), toxic RNA gain-of-function(19, 20), and aberrant methylation of GGC repeat sequences(21). Recently, some studies have suggested that dysfunction of ribosome biogenesis and translation and mitochondrial dysfunction might be related to the pathogenesis of NIID(22, 23). However, the specific mechanisms driving the pathogenesis of NIID remain unclear, and extensive experiments in cellular and animal models are required for further studies.
3.2 Clinical manifestations of NIID
NIID is a clinically heterogeneous, multisystemic intranuclear inclusion body disease. The clinical symptoms of adult-onset NIID mainly involve the central, peripheral, and autonomic nervous systems. Here, we report the case of a patient with NIID who developed tremors. YouNi et al. demonstrated that tremors were the most common initial symptom, and the mean age at onset and diagnosis in patients who started with tremors was lower than in patients without tremors(24). Cao et al. also showed that tremor was not only common in adult-onset NIID but also an early disease manifestation(9). Compared with previous studies, there was a higher prevalence of tremors (64.71% vs. 15.8–47.5%)(11, 24). The subtype of NIID with tremor is easily misdiagnosed as essential tremor, and after long-term follow-up, some patients initially diagnosed with essential tremor are eventually diagnosed with NIID(11). Yang et al. suggested that the loss of tendon reflexes could be an important clinical clue(11). The case reported herein also showed an absence of tendon reflexes. Therefore, considering that the clinical course of NIID is usually slow and insidious, one should consider NIID in patients with tremor as the main presentation, especially in combination with absent tendon reflexes. Long-term follow-up should be conducted to confirm the diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis of the disease. During follow-up visits, it is particularly important to note any impairments of higher neurological functions, such as in the patient reported herein, who showed symptoms of mental abnormality and unresponsiveness as the disease progressed. It is essential to actively enhance skin biopsy and genetic testing to clarify the diagnosis. A recent study summarized the mean age of onset of different systemic involvements in patients with NIID and found that the neurological system was the last to be involved compared with other systems(4). This suggests that early clinical symptoms in patients with NIID may be atypical, and further clinicopathological studies are needed to identify the differences between the early clinical manifestations of NIID and other systemic diseases. This will facilitate early diagnosis, slow disease progression, and improve patient prognosis as much as possible.
3.3 Imaging features of NIID
High DWI signals along the corticomedullary junction is a typical neuroimaging manifestation of NIID(25). Pathology studies have revealed areas of focal spongiform vasculopathy in the subcortical white matter proximal to U-fibres, corresponding to a high DWI signal on MRI(3). High DWI signals at the corticomedullary junction usually show a progression from anterior to posterior, which typically starts from the frontal lobe and gradually involves the temporoparietal and occipital lobes. The newly identified imaging features include a high DWI signal in the corpus callosum and a high T2-weighted signal in the caudal cerebellar vermis and middle cerebellar peduncle, and abnormal signals in the corpus callosum may be an early imaging change of the disease. It has been shown that some patients can present with a separate lesion involving the corpus callosum prior to the corticomedullary junction area, suggesting a similar susceptibility of the callosal contact fibres and subcortical arcuate fibres(26). A high signal (corticomedullary junction) on DWI may not appear(27), and it may appear or disappear in the late stages(28). The present patient only showed a high-intensity signal in the corpus callosum on DWI in the early stages of the disease; as the disease progressed, the signal did not increase significantly and never disappeared. We also observed that the high-intensity signal at the corticomedullary junction gradually progressed from the frontal lobe. Simultaneously, a high-intensity signal in the bilateral cerebellar vermis and middle cerebellar peduncle was also observed on fluid attenuated inversion recovery images. The above imaging features demonstrate that the appearance of a persistent non-resolving high-intensity DWI signal in the corpus callosum should be taken seriously; it should be followed up, and the possibility of NIID should be considered.
3.4 Diagnosis of NIID
As research progresses on the pathogenesis of NIID, the diagnostic criteria for the disease are constantly evolving(2, 4, 29). In 2011, Sone et al. found that dermal intranuclear inclusions had similar pathological backgrounds to those seen in neuronal cells of patients with NIID. Therefore, skin biopsies are widely used as a convenient and concise diagnostic method for NIID. Ubiquitin- and p62-reactive eosinophil inclusions are highly sensitive and specific pathological markers of NIID(2, 7, 26). However, it has been shown that eosinophil intranuclear inclusions are also observed in other GGC repetitive expansion disorders, such as fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome and oculopharyngeal myopathy(30, 31). Therefore, the diagnosis of NIID should integrate clinical manifestations, imaging features, pathological features, and genetic testing to avoid misdiagnosis. In 2016, Sone et al. proposed that DWI hyperintensities at the corticomedullary junction were a strong diagnostic basis for NIID diagnosis. Thus, they proposed a diagnostic pipeline for NIID in adults and applied exclusion criteria since no causative gene had been identified. Subsequently, a significantly larger number of patients were diagnosed with NIID(25). However, given that no causative gene was found, only exclusion criteria can be applied. In 2019, four different teams successively reported that a GGC repeat expansion in the 5'UTR of the human-specific NOTCH2NLC gene was responsible for NIID(16, 32–34). Henceforth, genetic diagnosis has become the principal ascertainment criterion. However, Tian et al. found that GGC repeat expansions may also be seen in Alzheimer’s disease and parkinsonism phenotypes. Therefore, the term “NIID-related disorders” was proposed. It represents a spectrum of disorders that include NIID and other disorders caused by GGC repeat expansion in NOTCH2NLC(32). Recently, it has been shown that GGC repeat expansion in the NOTCH2NLC gene is associated with a broader disease spectrum, including NIID, Parkinson’s disease, essential tremor, and oculopharyngeal myopathy type 3. As a result, a new term, “NOTCH2NLC-related repeat expansion disorder”, was proposed. In fact, some patients who were diagnosed with dementia or parkinsonism early ended up clinically converting to the typical features of NIID during a long follow-up. However, whether all GGC repeat gene carriers in NOTCH2NLC will eventually be diagnosed with NIID requires further longitudinal studies in larger cohorts(35).
3.5 Treatment of NIID
No specific treatment can cure NIID, and only symptomatic treatment can be administered to patients(6). Advances in the study of disease mechanisms form the basis for the development of preventive and therapeutic interventions. It has been suggested that NIID may be associated with mitochondrial dysfunction; therefore, therapeutic measures for mitochondrial disease may be effective for patients with NIID(23). Yan et al. suggested that inflammation might also play an important role in the pathogenesis of NIID(29). Chen et al. found diffuse inflammatory cell infiltration and oedema in different tissues containing intranuclear inclusion bodies(36); therefore, dehydration and anti-inflammation may be therapeutic targets for NIID. Considering that fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome and NIID have similar pathogenesis and are both trinucleotide repeatable diseases, Xu et al. suggested that some therapeutic measures referring to CGG expansion disorder might be effective for the treatment of NIID. These therapeutic measures include antisense oligonucleotide therapy, ribonucleic acid interference, small molecules, and gene editing. However, there are some challenges, such as off-target effects, low delivery efficiency due to the blood-brain barrier, the risk of immunogenicity, and the potential problems associated with introducing a virus into patients(37).