Scn2a- deficient mice display impaired learning and memory.
Profound autism is often accompanied by intellectual disability manifested as impaired cognitive learning and memory [2, 27]. To understand the impact of Scn2a deficiency on the learning and memory of mice, the Morris water maze was used to test long-term learning and memory. In the Morris water maze, mice were trained to escape water by remembering the location of a hidden platform. Over the seven-day testing period, WT mice found the platform with an increased performance each day and spent more time in the target quadrant area of the platform (Fig. 1A, B). Meanwhile, Scn2a-deficient mice took a significantly longer time to find the platform (often timing out) with an only slight improvement in each subsequent day (Fig. 1A, B). The swimming velocity, however, was similar between WT and Scn2a deficient mice, suggesting no significant impairments in swimming ability (Fig. 1C). The Morris water maze results thus reveal a significant impairment of long-term learning and memory in the Scn2a-deficient mice.
Additionally, we further assess the shorter-term spatial working memory of Scn2a-deficient mice with the Y maze [28]. This test consists of two phases. For the learning phase, mice are trained with one of the arms closed off. Then four hours later, the memory phase of the test was performed with all arms open. It is expected that WT mice should readily explore the previously closed-off “novel” arm. Indeed, we found that WT mice quickly enter the novel arm, while Scn2a-deficient mice have a significant delay to enter the novel arm (Fig. 1D), even though the duration in the novel arm was not notably altered (Fig. 1E). Together, our data indicate that Scn2a-deficient mice have disrupted learning and memory.
The synaptic function and structure are impaired in Scn2a-deficient mice.
Impaired learning and memory are often associated with altered synaptic transmission in the hippocampus [29, 30]. To investigate whether Nav1.2 deficiency affects synaptic transmission in principal pyramidal neurons of the hippocampal CA1 region, we recorded miniature excitatory postsynaptic currents (mEPSCs) at several time points during the development (Fig. 1F-H). We found that the frequency of mEPSCs was significantly decreased in Scn2a-deficient mice compared to WT mice at the P29-31 and adulthood (P > 90) periods (Fig. 1G, H), but not at the P9-11 developmental period (Fig. 1F). These results suggest an impairment in the synaptic transmission in Nav1.2 deficiency mice starts only in the middle of the developmental stage.
Functional synaptic transmission needs proper pairs of pre- and post-synapses. Thus, it is important to determine whether the number of co-localized pre- and post-synapses markers are altered in Scn2a-deficient mice. Since EPSC represents excitatory synaptic transmission, we investigated the excitatory synapses first. To this end, we performed immunohistochemistry (IHC) to detect colocalized VGLUT1 (pre-synaptic marker) and PSD95 (post-synaptic marker) puncta, as well as Synapsin1/2 (pre-synaptic marker) and Homer1 (post-synaptic marker) puncta (Supplementary Fig. 1A-J). Indeed, we found that the number of co-localized pre- and post-synaptic markers for excitatory synapses in the hippocampus was significantly reduced in P30 and P > 90 with no detectable changes at P5 and P10 (Supplementary Fig. 1A-E, F-J). These results obtained via IHC are consistent with our electrophysiological findings. Additionally, we checked the co-localization of inhibitory synapses with VGAT (pre-synaptic marker) and Gephyrin (post-synaptic marker). Interestingly, we found that inhibitory synapses of hippocampal neurons in Scn2a-deficient mice only reduce at P > 90 but display no detectable change at other time points (Supplementary Fig. 1K-O).
Functional alteration in synaptic transmission and reduced pre- and post-synapse colocalization are likely to be accompanied by the change in spine density. To test this, we performed Golgi staining at multiple time points to study the synaptic structure. Consistent with our EPSC and pre- and post-synapse colocalization results, we found that the spine density of hippocampal CA1 decreased significantly from P30 to P > 90 in Scn2a-deficient mice, but not at P5 and P10 (Fig. 1I, J). Moreover, we performed spine type analysis and found that hippocampal neurons from Scn2a-deficient mice have more immature spines with increased filopodia and thin spines in both apical and basal spines during many of the development stages (P5, P10, and P30) in vivo (Supplementary Fig. 2A-F). Notably, we also found that the mature spines (e.g., mushroom spines) decreased during most of the developmental stages we examined. Our data thus suggest that while neuronal dendritic spines in hippocampal CA1 of Scn2a-deficient mice are less mature throughout development starting from P5, the spine density only starts to decrease at around P30 and continues to be low into adulthood.
Spine density in neurons could be controlled by neuron intrinsic machinery but may also be dynamically regulated by other cell types including microglia in vivo [19]. To dissect these possibilities, we established primary neuron culture from Scn2a-deficient mice and WT littermates to study the spine density and spine maturity of hippocampal primary neurons without microglia (Fig. 1K-M). We found that the proportion of immature spines (e.g., filopodia and thin spines) of neurons from Scn2a-deficient mice increased substantially in vitro (Fig. 1L), similar to what we found in vivo. Interestingly, we did not find a significant difference in the spine density of hippocampal primary neurons between the WT group and the Scn2a-deficient group in vitro (Fig. 1M), which is different from our in vivo results. Together, these results are likely to suggest that the Nav1.2 deficiency per se mainly affects the maturity of the dendritic spine but not spine density in hippocampal pyramidal neurons. Another cell type in the brain (but not in the in vitro culture) thus could be essential to modulate the spine density in neurons of Scn2a-deficient mice in vivo.
The hippocampal microglia have altered morphology and display an increased volume of lysosome in adult Scn2a-deficient mice.
Microglia, as the resident immune cells and the primary phagocytes in the brain, play a key role in regulating neuronal plasticity and participate in the pathogenesis of neuronal diseases by excessively engulfing synapses (pre-synapses or post-synapses) [31–33]. Our finding of no notable difference in spine density between the WT and the Scn2a-deficient neurons in vitro and reduced spine density in vivo prompted us to hypothesize that microglia may be responsible for the reduced spine density in Scn2a-deficient mice. We thus further studied the morphology and gene expression of microglia in vivo in our disease model (Fig. 2A-C). We found that the microglial morphology was changed, with increased cell body area (Fig. 2B1), decreased number of branches (Fig. 2B2), and reduced total length of the process (Fig. 2B3) in hippocampal CA1 of adult (P>90) Scn2a-deficient mice compared to adult WT mice. It seems that this change in microglia morphology is not limited to the hippocampal region as we found similar changes in microglial morphology in the medial prefrontal cortex in our Scn2a-deficient mouse model (Supplementary Fig. 3A-D). Microglial morphological changes are often accompanied by microglial activation, neuroinflammation, or proliferation [34]. Interestingly, the Western blot result showed that there was no significant difference in Iba1 protein expression between WT and Scn2a-deficient groups (Fig. 2C, C1), suggesting minimal changes in microglia proliferation. However, the volume of microglial lysosome marker (CD68) increased significantly in the Scn2a-deficient group compared to the WT group (Fig. 2D, D1). The elevated CD68 positive volume data indicates that microglia are likely to be partially activated, exerting increased phagocytosis. Taken together, our morphological analysis and immunolabeling results indicate that microglia are partially activated in Scn2a-deficient mice.
Excessive phagocytic pruning of synapses by microglia occurs during development and adulthood in Scn2a-deficient mice.
Since we identified partial microglia activation in adult Scn2a-deficient mice, and phagocytosis of spines is a primary function of activated microglia [35], we further investigate whether the activation of microglia translates into enhanced synaptic phagocytosis in the Scn2a-deficient mice. Moreover, if they do, which kind of synapses (pre- vs post-synapses) do the microglia prefer to engulf? To this end, we assessed microglial engulfment of pre-synapses (VGLUT1) and post-synapses (PSD95) in hippocampal CA1 of adult mice. We performed IHC for VGLUT1 or PSD95 tri-stained with IBA1 (microglia staining) and CD68 (lysosome staining) (Fig. 3A, B). We quantitated the amount of VGLUT1 or PSD95 within IBA1+/CD68+ microglial lysosomes. We found that microglial engulfment of PSD95 post-synapses was significantly elevated in adult Scn2a-deficient mice, but display no detectable changes in engulfment of VGLUT1 pre-synapses (Fig. 3C, D). These data show that the phagocytosis of microglia in the hippocampus has been elevated and has a selective over-engulfment of post-synapses to regulate the neuronal plasticity in adult Scn2a-deficient mice.
Since we identified a post-synapse specific enhancement of engulfment by microglia in adulthood, we seek to understand when this engulfment starts during the development. To this end, we performed IHC for PSD95 tri-stained with IBA1 and CD68 and examined at three time points (P5, P10, and P30). We choose these time points because, at P5, microglia have not yet entered the hippocampus; At P10, microglia start to enter the hippocampus; and at P30, the number of microglia reaches the peak of the whole life [36]. Using the orthogonal view (Fig. 3E) and the reconstruction images (Fig. 3E1), we confirm that the PSD95+ areas were indeed in the volume of IBA1+/CD68+ labeling from three angles of view at P30 (Fig. 3E). Moreover, we found that the occupancy of CD68+ inside IBA1+ was significantly increased only at P30 in Scn2a-deficient mice, but not at P5 and P10, compared to the WT mice (Fig. 3F-H). Similarly, we quantitated the amount of PSD95 within IBA1+/CD68+ microglial lysosomes and found that microglial engulfment of PSD95 synapses was only elevated at P30 in Scn2a-deficient mice, but not P5 and P10 (Fig. 3I-K). Representative images of these analyses were shown in (Supplementary Fig. 4A-C). Together, our results indicate that excessive post-synaptic pruning occurs from P30 when the microglia have peaked at the hippocampus and continues during the development into adulthood (P > 90), consistent with our EPSC, pre- and post-synapse co-localization, and spine density results.
Complement component C3 is involved in the microglial phagocytosis of synapses in Scn2a-deficient mice.
The classical complement cascade-dependent phagocytic signaling pathway is a molecular mechanism used by microglia to prune synapses during development [37, 38]. Therefore, we hypothesize that during the development of Scn2a-deficient mice, the classical complement cascades pathway could be overactivated and leading to the phagocytosis of a large number of immature dendritic spines. To investigate whether the C3 and C1q target the post-synapses, we performed IHC for colocalized PSD95 and C3 or C1q puncta (Fig. 4A-C, Supplementary Fig. 5A-C). We found that the puncta levels of both PSD95+/C3+ and PSD95+/C1q+ in Scn2a-deficient mice were significantly increased at P30, but not at P5 or P10 compared to WT mice (Fig. 4A1, B1, C1, Supplementary Fig. 5A1, B1, C1).
Increased co-localization of C3/C1q with PSD95 may result from switched locations of C3/C1q or overly increased C3/C1q deposits. To test this, we performed IHC for C3 and C1q deposits at P30 in hippocampal CA1 from WT and Scn2a-deficient mice (Fig. 4D, Supplementary Fig. 5D). We found that both C3 and C1q deposits were elevated in Scn2a-deficient mice compared to WT mice (Fig. 4D1, Supplementary Fig. 5D1). These data show that it is likely that during early development, the increased number of immature dendritic spines leads to an overactivation of the complement pathway, producing extra C3 and C1q deposits to promote microglia to engulf excessive immature dendritic spines.
Synaptic transmission and spine density can be partially restored in hippocampal CA1 of Scn2a-deficient mice with microglia ablation.
To further investigate a causal role of microglia in synapse functions, we next studied whether microglia ablation from early life would restore altered synaptic functions. Microglia depletion was initiated using the CSF1R inhibitor PLX3397 formulated in the chow for consecutive 3–4 weeks starting from P21 (Fig. 5A). Efficient ablation of microglia from the hippocampus was achieved within three weeks (Fig. 5B). Whole-cell patch-clamp recordings were then performed with hippocampal CA1 pyramidal neurons of Scn2a-deficient mice with control chow or PLX3397 chow (Fig. 5C). We found that the frequency of mEPSCs was increased in neurons from Scn2a-deficient mice treated with PLX3397, accompanied by a large shift of its cumulative curve, compared to Scn2a-deficient mice treated with control chow (Fig. 5D, E). Notably, the frequency of mEPSCs in Scn2a-deficient mice with PLX3397 chow was increased to almost the same level as that in WT mice with control chow (Fig. 5D, E). As a positive control, we found that WT mice with PLX3397 chow had a higher frequency of mEPSCs than WT mice with control chow, which is consistent with published studies [39] (Supplementary Fig. 6A-C). Together, our data indicate that microglia depletion could partially restore the altered synaptic transmission in Scn2a-deficient mice.
As microglia participate in the synaptic remodeling and plasticity by altering spine density [38, 40, 41], we next examined the spine density in control and PLX3397-treated Scn2a-deficient mice. We found that the spine density was also partially restored in Scn2a-deficient mice with PLX3397 chow compared to the Scn2a-deficient mice with control chow (Fig. 5F, G), showing a significant increase towards the WT value. These results further confirm that microglia play a key role in regulating synaptic functions, and microglia depletion could partially restore synaptic transmission and spine density in Scn2a-deficient mice.
Human microglia exert enhanced elimination of post-synapses in human cortical organoids carrying autism-associated SCN2A-C959X mutation.
Autism-associated SCN2A loss-of-function and protein-truncating mutations result in Scn2a deficiency, which could partially be modeled with the Scn2a-deficient mouse model. To extend our findings from rodent models to human cells, we established a human-induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) model carrying a heterozygous SCN2A protein-truncating/stop-codon C959X mutation. Heterozygous C959X mutation was identified in patients with autism, and the C959X mutation in SCN2A leads to a non-functional Nav1.2 channel (SCN2A deficiency) [42]. To study the C959X mutation, we engineered it into the reference iPSCs [43, 44] accordingly to our published protocols [45, 46]. These engineered human iPSCs then were differentiated into cerebral organoids that are expected to partially recapitulate the complexity of the human brain. Using this advanced human cell-based model, we aim to study how microglia regulates synapses in human neurons with Nav1.2 deficiency. Since it is known that Nav1.2 is minimally expressed in the microglia [26], we deliberately only generated human microglia from the reference (control/WT) iPSCs to simplify the research design. Once generated, control hiPSCs-derived microglia would then be added to the cortical organoids (C959X or control cortical organoids) for two weeks (Fig. 6A). Excitingly, we found that the human microglia could grow uniformly, incorporate, and distribute evenly within C959X organoids as well as control cortical organoids (Fig. 6A). We then performed IHC for PSD95 tri-stained with IBA1 and CD68 to understand whether the human microglia may respond to C959X organoids or control organoids differently (Fig. 6B, C). We reconstructed the 3D images of both types of organoids for quantification. While we did not notice a notable change in the size of microglia (IBA1 positive volume) (Fig. 6D), interestingly we found that the CD68 occupancy (within IBA1 + area) was significantly increased in human microglia co-cultured with C959X organoids compared to these co-cultured with control organoids (Fig. 6E). Moreover, we revealed that both volumes of PSD95+ positive signals within CD68+ (Fig. 6F) and the number of PSD95+ puncta within CD68+ (Fig. 6G) were significantly elevated in human microglia co-cultured with C959X organoids, consistent with what we found in the Scn2a-deficient mice. Together, our results from the human cells-based model further support that microglia have enhanced synaptic phagocytosis in neurons with SCN2A deficiency, extending our findings from rodent models to human cells.