The present study showed that low HDL/ apoA-I and low FT3 level could increase CAD risk which was similar to previous studies. In addition, we firstly found the interactive role in the association between HDL-C/apoA-I and FT3. The risk of CAD was significantly increased in subjects with HDL/apoA-I ≤ 0.89 mmol/g and FT3 ≤ 4.5 pmol/L, which suggested that thyroid hormones might affect the granule structure of HDL-C.
The concentration of HDL-C and apoA-I were strongly and inversely associated with the risk of CAD in many studies [15]. Previous studies found that every 1-mg (0.03mmol/L) increase in HDL-C reduced the risk of future coronary heart disease by 2–3%. However, other studies showed that increasing the HDL-C level by preventing the cholesterol ester transfer protein failed to decrease cardiovascular events. A randomized controlled trial enrolled 3,414 patients from AIM-HIGH investigators had shown no clinical benefit from the addition of niacin to during a 36-month followed-up period [16]. Group AS et al. also failed to reduce cardiovascular disease by increasing HDL-C with fibrates [17]. So, more and more researchers pay more attention to HDL size which may be associated with cardiovascular disease and diabetes [18]. Norman A et al. proposed that the HDL-C/apoA-I ratio could be an available biomarker for estimating HDL size by a large-scale experimental examination of the updated Shen model [19].
HDL-C/apoA-I ratio is a biomarker of the HDL-C particle to predict cardiovascular risk. Previous studies have found that oxidative damage to HDL-c-assocation lipid-poor apoa-I in the arterial wall may decrease the capacity of HDL-C/apoA-I and promote atherosclerosis occurrence and development by regulating cholesterol efflux. Miller et al. found that there was a lower HDL-C/apoA-I ratio in patients with CAD, suggested that lower HDL-C/apoA-I ratio might be associated with higher cardiovascular risk [20]. However, some studies pointed that increased HDL-C/apoA-I ratios were associated with higher coronary artery calcium scores, risk of CAD, subclinical atherosclerosis and mortality. In the present study, we found that the lowest HDL-C/apoA-I tertiles had the most patients with CAD compared with the other two groups, which was similar to Miller et al’ result. Logistic regress analysis further showed that HDL-C/apoA-I was protective factor for CAD (OR = 0.614, 95% CI = 0.488–0.772, P = 0.000).
Thyroid dysfunction was found in 23.3% of patients with coronary heart disease patient [21]. Hypothyroidism is known to be increased LDL-C, TG and HDL-C [22] which is possibly owing to the reduction of catabolism of lipoproteins and subclinical hypothyroidism [23] patients who have higher inflammatory markers that promote CAD. Thyroid hormone has direct anti-atherosclerotic effects, such as production of nitric oxide and suppression of smooth muscle cell proliferation. Coceani et al. showed the FT3 levels were inversely related to CAD presence and an adverse prognosis on low T3 syndrome was conferred [24]. In a study enrolled 588 outpatients with suspected CAD draw a conclusion that FT3 inversely associated with artery calcification scores and the incidence of in major adverse cardiac events patients [25].
The results of multiple linear regression analysis showed that that FT3, TSH were independent predictors for HDL-C/apoA-I and negatively associated with HDL-C/apoA-I (P < 0.005). With FT3 and TSH increasing 1 pmol/L, HDL-C/apoA-I reduced by 0.116 and 0.061mmol/g, respectively. FT3 might increase the mRNA levels of CYP7A1, the scavenger receptor-BI protein levels of liver lead to the decreased HDL-C level [26–27]. Anna et al. pointed that plasma cholesteryl ester transfer protein (CETP) and phospholipid transfer protein (PLTP) activity was decreased in patients with hypothyroidism which was associated with decreased HDL2 and increased HDL3 cholesterol levels [25].
This was the first study to investigate interaction between HDL-C/apoA-I and FT3 on risk of CAD. The main findings showed that patients in the lower median for HDL-C/apoA-I (≤ 0.89mmol/g) and FT3 (≤ 4.5pmmol/L) had the highest CAD risk (OR = 2.441, 95% CI = 1.717–3.470, P < 0. 001).
HDL-C/apoA-I-FT3-stratified risk factor interaction was analyzed in our study. The association of lower age group, female, EH, non-DM with CAD risk was the strongest in patients with HDL-C/apoA-I (≤ 0.89mmol/g) and FT3 (≤ 4.5pmmol/L). This may guide us to evaluate the risk of CAD in clinical work, and the specific mechanism needs further study.
Limitations
Several limitations existed in the present study. Firstly, the present study was a hospital-based observation study. Sample size was small and the number of cases and controls was not absolutely matched. Secondly, we could not analyze some useful data, such as CRP might affect CAD and lipid levels.