PKD is representative of paroxysmal dyskinesia, and it is widely accepted that primary PKD is attributed to genetic factors, but more than 60% of PKD patients are not identified with certain mutations.1 In our previous study, we identified TMEM151A as the second causative gene for PKD by means of GRIPT.22 Here, we applied the same strategy to analyse the WES data of both PRRT2- and TMEM151A-negative patients and eventually filtered out and focused on the KCNJ10 gene. Because PKD is a rare disease with incomplete genetic penetrance, the high frequency of KCNJ10 variants in PKD patients suggests its potential role in the pathogenesis of PKD.
KCNJ10 (NM_002241.5), located on chr 1q23.2, consists of 2 exons and encodes 379 amino acids. Its protein product is the inwardly rectifying potassium (Kir) 4.1 channel. The primary structure of the Kir4.1 subunit is composed of two transmembrane (TM) regions, an extracellular pore-forming region, which has a -G-Y-G- signature sequence acting as an ion filter, and intracellular N- and C-terminal domains (Fig. 1B).24 In this study, a total of 15 KCNJ10 variants (4 nonsense/frameshift and 11 missense) were identified, and most of them (11 mutations) cluster in the N-terminal cytoplasmic domain (Fig. 1B), while mutation c.436C > T (p.Leu146Phe) is in the transmembrane domain and two frameshift mutations {c.321_322del (p.Val109Glyfs*15) and c.422delC (p.Pro141Hisfs*57)} are in the extra-membrane domain. It was initially known that homozygous and compound heterozygous KCNJ10 mutations are associated with sensorineural deafness, ataxia, impaired intellectual development, and electrolyte imbalance (SeSAME syndrome) and enlarged vestibular aqueducts.25 Frequent mutations of the KCNJ10 gene in patients with SeSAME syndrome can cause marked inhibition of Kir4.1 channels.24 To validate whether the variants in this study lead to the dysfunction of Kir4.1, we investigated the electrophysiological changes of the mutants, and the results illustrated that all the mutations caused the decreased Kir4.1 current to different degrees. Moreover, most mutations (13/15) profoundly reduced the Kir4.1 current (≥ 80% Kir4.1-sensitive currents blocked), indicating that the mutations identified in PKD patients significantly disturbed the function of Kir4.1. All the patients with KCNJ10 presented typical clinical features of PKD and it is hard to conclude the relationship between the degree of the Kir4.1 blockage and the severity of phenotype in this study. However, the clinical and genetic heterogeneity of PKD is widely accepted as one mutation could cause different phenotype varying from asymptomatic carriers to complicated form of PKD. 1,5 The underlying reason for the heterogeneity is unclear but more collected data in the following study would assist to clarify the mechanism.
However, whether Kir4.1 defects are related to PKD needs further exploration. Therefore, we investigated the expression pattern of Kcnj10, and the results showed that Kcnj10 mRNA was relatively low during the embryonic period, significantly increased during postnatal stages, peaked at adolescence (P30), and finally declined in adulthood. In 2015, Moroni et al. disclosed a gradual increment of Kir4.1 expression in the somatosensory cortex of rats during postnatal to P30.26 In the present study, we detected an increment before P30 but a progressive decrease during P30 ~ P84 of Kir4.1 expression in both cerebellum and cortex of mice by quantifying the immunoreactivity of Kir4.1 immuno-positive cells in cerebellum and cortex, which is accordance with the mRNA expression pattern during qPCR. The finding is consistent with the natural course of PKD, and the other two specific proteins related to PKD, Prrt2 and Tmem151a, also share the same tendency of expression.
Although the mechanism of PKD is not yet well elucidated, it has long been established that this disease is related to the disturbance or imbalance in neural excitability based on its clinical features and electrophysiological studies19. Moreover, recent studies have highlighted that abnormal excitability in the cerebellum is involved in PKD.17, 20, 21 Because of the high expression of Kcnj10 in the cerebellum, we further explored the motor ability of cerebellar Kcnj10-cKO mice. Poor balance and deficits in motor learning ability were obvious in Kcnj10-cKO mice, revealing that the dysfunction of cerebellar Kir4.1 could disturb motor function in mice. Although Kir4.1 is mostly expressed in astrocytes in the nervous system, it plays a crucial role in maintaining the structural and functional integrity of the brain, including formation of the blood‒brain barrier, regulation of synaptogenesis, and maintenance of metabolic, ionic, and neurotransmitter homeostasis.24 Among these functions, spatial potassium (K+) buffering by astrocytes is an essential system for controlling extracellular K+ concentration and neuronal excitability.27, 28 It has been validated that the inhibition of Kir4.1 channels by gene mutations, expressional suppression, or pharmacological treatments could compromise the spatial buffering of K+, resulting in increased extracellular K+ and depolarized RMPs.24 In addition, Kir4.1 channel-mediated spatial K+ buffering is functionally linked to excitatory amino acid transporters (EAATs) and plays an important role in glutamate homeostasis in tripartite synapses.28–31 Kir4.1 channel blockade can cause a depolarization of astrocytes, which in turn inhibits astrocytic glutamate uptake via EAAT2.30–32 Elevated levels of extracellular K+ and glutamate are both key factors for the hyperexcitation of neurons. In accordance with the theory, we induced the dystonic posture in cerebellar Kcnj10-cKO mice by applying high K+ concentration on local surface of the cerebellar cortex. The inducement of the phenotype not only verified that defect Kir4.1 might be associated with the attack of PKD, but also indicated that the abnormal excitability is related with the impaired spatial K+ buffering by astrocyte. Further aberrant DCN neuronal firing was observed in cerebellar Kir4.1-deficient mice in the present study. In the cerebellum, the DCN plays an essential role in motor coordination,33 and its dysfunction has been implicated in animal models of dyskinesia.34–37 The increased rate of DCN firing in this study suggests hyperexcitability of the cerebellum, which is involved in the mechanism of PKD. In Prrt2 mutant mice, similar electrophysiological abnormalities in the DCN have also been observed.17 Therefore, we speculate that the dysfunction of Kir4.1 caused by heterozygous KCNJ10 variants might be associated with abnormal hyperexcitability in the cerebellum, which is involved in the pathogenesis of PKD. In other words, cerebellar Kir4.1 probably acts as a negative modulator of neural excitability in PKD. However, a more detailed mechanism of Kir4.1 in the regulation of cerebellar neurons in PKD remains to be discovered.
In this study, KCNJ10 variants accounted for approximately 3.07% (16/522) of PRRT2- and TMEM151A-negative PKD probands. Its frequency in overall PKD patients is lower than that of PRRT2 and TMEM151A mutations.5, 22 Although DNA analysis was not conducted in all the parents of the probands, the current results of co-segregation analysis showed that incomplete penetrance is apparent in KCNJ10-related PKD, which is also common in PKD with PRRT2 and TMEM151A mutations. Due to the limited parents enrolled, the exact incomplete penetrance could not be obtained. However, PRRT2 mutations are identified in one-third of PKD patients and the prevalence of PRRT2 mutations in familial PKD is much higher than in sporadic cases,5 indicating that incomplete penetrance is more common in sporadic cases and other genotype except PRRT2. Following DNA analysis would be continued to figure out the accurate incomplete penetrance in PKD patients with KCNJ10 mutations and the underlying reason for the high frequency of incomplete penetrance in PKD. Regarding clinical manifestations, patients with KCNJ10 mutations are more similar to those carrying TMEM151A mutations than PRRT2 + patients.5, 22KCNJ10 + patients have predominantly sporadic cases, tending to have a later onset age and a short duration of attacks. Other phenotypic spectra of the KCNJ10 + patients, including triggers, attack form, occurrence of facial involvement and aura, were similar to the patients with PRRT2 and TMEM151A mutations in our previous studies.5, 22, 38, 39 Nevertheless, as patients with KCNJ10 mutations are still limited, more subjects are needed to determine the definite phenotype-genotype correlation. Moreover, an increasing number of studies have reported the relationship between brain diseases and Kir4.1 dysfunction despite classical SeSAME, including depressive disorders, epileptic diseases, Huntington’s disease, autism spectrum disorders, Parkinson’s disease, Alzheimer’s disease, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and neuropathic pain.24, 40 In the present study, 3 mutations (c.889C > T/p.Arg297Cys; c.811C > T/p.Arg271Cys; c.1042C > T/p.Arg348Cys) were previously documented in other phenotypes (SeSAME syndrome; digenic non-syndromic hearing loss; seizure susceptibility, respectively).25, 41, 42 However, all the 3 documented variants were reported in cases with homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations, while heterozygous KCNJ10 mutations are the cause for PKD. In general, the symptoms in diseases with autosomal recessive inheritance are more severe than that in disorders with autosomal dominant inheritance. SeSAME syndrome is a complicated syndrome composed of several symptoms including seizures, sensorineural deafness, ataxia, impaired intellectual development, and electrolyte imbalance. In contrary, KCNJ10-related PKD is much less severe in manifestation compared with SeSAME. The different type of inheritance and phenotype indicate that impaired Kir4.1 in different degree could result in a wide range of clinical phenotypes and PKD would be a new spectrum and milder phenotype of Kir4.1-associated channelopathy.