The apnea test is the central component of international guidelines and the most critical part of clinical testing of BD. Various approaches have been described in the literature on how to perform the AT in a targeted and simultaneously effective manner without endangering the patient. The standard method that is also mentioned in most international guidelines involves disconnection of the patient from the ventilator and insufflation of 100% oxygen (“apneic oxygenation”). The resulting PEEP-loss frequently leads to cardiopulmonary instability particularly in patients with concomitant severe pulmonary diseases like ARDS. The method presented here, which allows the AT to be performed without disconnection and thereby avoiding the critical PEEP-loss is patient-friendly and safe. It is therefore highly relevant to everyday clinical practice.
The main task of the apnea test is to reliably detect a potentially preserved respiratory drive of the patient. Breathing patterns in patients with severe brain damage, which are triggered by the patient when PaCO2 rises, appear as Biot or Cheyne-Stokes respiration(18, 19), similar to an agonal or sigh respiration (”gasping”). In Biot respiration, deep and vigorous breaths are interrupted by pauses; in Cheyne-Stokes respiration, a crescendo-decrescendo pattern of depth of breaths and additionally regularly changing intervals between breaths occur. Small, fine respiration efforts that are difficult to detect do not occur in this patient cohort. Moreover, as PaCO2 rises, breathing efforts increase and become more frequent.
Correspondingly, all n = 12 candidates examined in our study, in whom the AT demonstrated preserved spontaneous breathing when PaCO2 increased, also showed deep breaths, similar to the aforementioned breathing patterns. Additional certainty is provided by the automatic detection of patient-triggered breaths now available on most ventilators. It is important to appreciate patients in whom the rating of a positive apnea test is impossible. In this context, the guidelines often only refer to pulmonary impairment (e.g. caused by COPD or chest contusion) or centrally-acting drugs or medication. However, caution is also warranted in patients with lesions of the upper cervical myelon. It is not possible to distinguish between central failure of spontaneous breathing caused by brainstem areflexia and complete or partial peripheral failure of spontaneous breathing caused by lesions of the anterior horn neurons (C2-C4) or nerve tracts of the phrenic nerve in this cohort.
To solve the central problem of sufficient patient oxygenation (and hereby simultaneously exclude AT-related danger to the patient and at the same time ensure organ protection with potential organ donation in mind), the PEEP was increased by 2 points in each case. This provides sufficient alveolar O2 circulation and ensured sufficient oxygenation in all patients in our study despite an average of 15 minutes of apneic oxygenation in the absence of ventilation as demonstrated by PaO2 at the end of mAT. At the same time, the mere increase in PEEP without ventilation does not result in CO2 washout, which permits the required PaCO2 increase to ≥ 60 mmHg.
Of note, mAT with apneic oxygenation was not only feasible in patients with various extents of ARDS but proved to be favourable for these patients in our study. After 10 minutes of preoxygenation, the patients were classified into ARDS grades 0–3 (modified Berlin definition(20)). In patients with no ARDS (i.e. grade 0), the delta between PaO2 pre and post mAT showed no significant difference. By contrast, in patients with mild ARDS, a significant increase in PaO2 post mAT could be observed (p < 0.05) and in patients with moderate and severe ARDS, this difference was pronounced and highly significant (p < 0.01). This result is in line with current guidelines on the management of patients with ARDS. These suggest low tidal volumes as well as low plateau and driving pressures to reduce work of breathing and lung tissue shear stress in this patient group (i.e. lung-protective ventilation)(21).
The increase in PaCO2 is known to cause a drop in pH during AT with consecutive vasodilation and a possible drop in blood pressure(22, 23), which was also seen in our collective. Therefore, i.v. norepinephrine was started in all BD candidates in our study prior to initiation of mAT, if this had not already been started as part of general circulatory stabilization. In patients in whom MAP dropped to < 60 mmHg, a transient increase in the dose of norepinephrine i.v. was sufficient to consecutively, none of the patients experienced critical destabilization of blood pressure despite high PaCO2 values after mAT in some cases. No other cardiocirculatory problems (e.g. arrhythmia, circulatory arrest) occurred. Sixteen of the patients in this study were treated with vaECMO. In this subgroup, mAT was also consistently feasible without complications.
We therefore believe that the following techniques that are currently (or have historically been) used in the context of AT in brain death testing are obsolete: (i) for reasons of patient safety: disconnection from the ventilator with tracheal O2 insufflation. (ii) for reasons of unambiguity: the use of a fine thread to capture minimal breaths by watching it be pulled into the disconnected intubation tube since respiration in this patient cohort resembles agonal or gasping respiration (i.e. a brain stem reflex) which is always characterised by deep and unambiguous breaths. (iii) again for reasons of unambiguity: holding a mirror in front of the open intubation tube to observe its fogging.
Some ventilators may not allow complete turn-off of apnea ventilation (e.g., 2 mandatory breaths per minute). In these cases, we recommend hypoventilation in combination with (brief) ventilator disconnection after reaching a PaCO2 of 60 mmHg, as previously suggested(12). In this case, particular care needs to be taken to not confuse machine-generated and patient-generated spontaneous breaths and the disconnection period should be kept as short as possible.
Limitations:
Our study has been conducted without a control group and in a single-center setting which may limit its generalizability. The findings would profit from confirmation in a multi-center setting which is currently being planned on a national level in the IGNITE! Network of the German Society of Neurointensive Care (DGNI). A control group could consist of patients that undergo the standard AT with disconnection from the ventilator.