Synthesis and structure characterization. Kf-AQ was mechanochemically synthesized by a Schiff-base condensation reaction of Tp and AQ with CH3COONa (NaAc) as the catalysts (Fig. 1a). Fourier-transformed infrared spectra (FT-IR) spectra clearly revealed a new C-N stretching band at 1260 cm− 1 and a disappeared N-H stretching band at 3459 ~ 3151 cm− 1 for NH2 groups in AQ (Fig. S2)27. The as-prepared Kf-AQ powder displays a red-black color, corresponding to its outstanding optical absorption with the edge extended to 900 nm (Fig. S3), which is obviously red-shifted as compared to the absorption edge at 780 nm of TpAQ prepared by a traditional solvothermal method28. The simulated powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) pattern of Kf-AQ with eclipsed AA stacking mode agreed well with the experimental data (Fig. 1b), suggesting the validity of such structure in Kf-AQ. Particularly, the broad peak at 26.54o was caused by the strong π-π stacking construction arisen from the existence of a multilayered COF structure with an interlayer distance of 3.48 Å. TEM and SEM images also displayed that Kf-AQ had a lamellar stacking structure and excellent crystallinity (Fig. 1c, d and Fig. S4)28. Moreover, Kf-AQ had a specific surface area of 129 m2 g− 1 and a pore size of 2.12 nm (Fig. S5), which was well matched with the simulated value (2.18 nm) in Fig. 1a.
Solid-state NMR spectra revealed that Kf-AQ had an almost exclusive keto-form structure (Fig. 1e). The chemical shifts at 184 ppm, 144 ppm and 109 ppm in 13C NMR spectra were all indexed to the keto-form structure of Kf-AQ25,27,29, while the chemical shift at 4.4 ppm for the enol-form (c, C-OH) was absent in the 1H NMR spectra (Fig. S6)30. Only C, O and N elements were present in the XPS survey spectrum of Kf-AQ, without any residual Na (Fig. S7). More evidences of keto-form structure in Kf-AQ could be found in high resolution XPS spectra (Fig. S8). The content of C = O in Kf-AQ was approximately 60%, about three times that of C-OH (22%) (Fig. 1f). The content of C-N-H (56%), corresponding to the deconvolution peak at the binding energy of 400.4 eV in N 1s spectra, was obviously higher than that of C = N (31%) (Fig. S9a)31, while C 1s XPS spectra also illustrated more C-C (52%) and less C-O (38%) in Kf-AQ (Fig. S9b)32. All these above results supported the successful synthesis of an exclusive keto-form AQ COF.
The formation of Kf-AQ might be attributed to a NaAc-catalyzed Schiff-base condensation process as follows. Upon the heat generated from the collision of balls, the carbonyl oxygen on Tp monomer undergoes a nucleophilic addition with Na+ to form aldehyde salts33,34, resulting in the neighbor carbon acquiring a positive charge to fulfill another nucleophilic addition with nitrogen atoms in AQ. The generated α-hydroxyl undergoes further dehydration with adjacent amino hydrogen to form an enol-form COF. Subsequently, Ac− anions as the Lewis base tend to bind with the hydrogen of hydroxyl group in enol moieties and then induce electron transfer from oxygen to alkene group, thus enabling the enol-form transformation into the thermodynamically more stable keto-form moiety (Fig. S10). Such a transformation cannot be driven in the traditional solvothermal synthesis, but might partially occur in alkaline water to produce a keto-form dominated AQ COF25,35.
Efficient H 2 O 2 photosynthesis. The H2O2 photosynthesis performance of Kf-AQ was evaluated by dispersing the powder in water at neutral and alkaline solutions (pH = 9, 11, 13, 14) with continuous O2 purging. Upon visible light (λ > 400 nm) irradiation, the rate of H2O2 production at pH 13 reached as high as 4784 µmol h− 1 g− 1 (Fig. 2a), a new record in H2O2 photosynthesis of AQ containing COFs with water (Fig. 2b and Table S1). Upon a prolonged irradiation for 5 h, the H2O2 production was steadily growing (Fig. S11), and kept constant during five cycles of reaction (Fig. 2c). The crystal structure and surface functional groups of the reacted Kf-AQ did not change (Fig. S12), demonstrating its excellent stability for the H2O2 photosynthesis. The contribution of Na+ to the enhanced H2O2 production was ruled out by the replacement of NaOH with NaCl and KOH (Fig. S13), confirming the crucial promoting effect of hydroxide anions on the H2O2 photosynthesis of Kf-AQ.
The kinetic of H2O2 production was analyzed by fitting the time-dependent H2O2 production curves (Text S2). Kf-AQ exhibited the highest H2O2 formation rate constant (kf, 31.39 µM min− 1), but a medium decomposition rate constant (kd) (0.031 µM min− 1) at pH 13 (Fig. 2d and Table S2). Thus, the superior H2O2 photosynthesis performance of Kf-AQ with alkaline water was mainly attributed to its better H2O2 formation ability. The apparent quantum efficiencies (AQY) of Kf-AQ at different wavelengths were well matched with its absorption spectrum, and the highest value appeared at 400 nm and reached 15.8% (Fig. 2e and Table S3). To the best of our knowledge, the AQY of Kf-AQ is higher than those of most reported H2O2 synthesis photocatalysts36,37. The solar-to-chemical conversion (SCC) efficiency of Kf-AQ was estimated to be 0.70% at pH 13 (Fig. S14 and Table S4), which was almost seven times of the average solar-to-biomass conversion (SBC) efficiency in nature23.
Mechanism investigation. We first checked the basic semiconductor properties of Kf-AQ to understand its superior performance in H2O2 photosynthesis. The Tauc plot showed that the band gap of Kf-AQ was 1.55 eV (Fig. S15a), and ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS) determined its valence band potential (EVB) as 1.90 V (Fig. S15b), suggesting that the conduction band potential (ECB) of Kf-AQ was accordingly calculated as 0.35 V. Therefore, both 2e− ORR (0.68 V vs. RHE) to produce H2O2 and 4e− WOR (1.23 V vs. RHE) to evolute O2 were thermodynamically feasible for Kf-AQ photocatalysis (Fig. 3a)38. We further conducted density functional theory (DFT) calculations to elucidate the exciton dissociation in photocatalysis by using a dimer model of Kf-AQ. As depicted in Fig. 3b, the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) of the dimer uniformly dispersed in the whole structure, while the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) localized over AQ units. Thus, the HOMO-LUMO transition under excitation can redistribute electron density from the Tp moieties to the adjacent AQ units, thus resulting in effective intramolecular charge transfer in Kf-AQ.
We then explored the sources of H and O for the H2O2 production by various control experiments and isotopic labeling analysis. In comparison to oxygen atmosphere, either air or N2 purging resulted in poor H2O2 production (Fig. 3c), and the O2 concentration in an airtight oxygen saturated suspension decreased obviously during photocatalysis (Fig. S16), suggesting the dominated contribution of ORR to the H2O2 production. AgNO3 was added as the electron scavenger in N2 atmosphere to evaluate the contribution of water oxidation. The negligible amount of H2O2 generated in the Kf-AQ suspension ruled out the direct contribution of WOR to the H2O2 production. However, H2O2 was obviously produced in case of N2 purging and absence of AgNO3, suggesting that photocatalytically produced O2 via 4e− WOR (Fig. 3c) enabled the consequent ORR to produce H2O2 (Fig. S17). Significant H2O2 was only detected in the mixed solution of H2O and acetonitrile (v/v = 1:1) other than pure acetonitrile (Fig. 3d), confirming that water was the exclusive hydrogen source for the H2O2 photosynthesis.
We conducted the isotopic photoreaction experiments by purging H216O suspensions with 18O2 gas during the H2O2 photosynthesis, and then used MnO2 to catalytically decompose the as-synthesized H2O2 into oxygen. After 8 h of photoreaction, strong 18O2 (m/z = 36, 93.7%) and very weak 16O2 (m/z = 32, 6.3%) signals appeared in the gas chromatography-mass spectra (GC-MS) of collected gas (Fig. 3e), demonstrating that H218O2 was the dominated product and mainly came from the reduction of 18O2. Gradually, the signal of 18O2 peak decreased (80.5%), accompanying with an increased 16O2 signal (19.5%) at 24 h of reaction, because the photocatalytic oxidation of H216O produced 16O2 to increase the proportion of H216O2 in the products. The electrons transfer number (n) of ORR was further measured to be about 2.06 ~ 2.09 by the RDE method (Fig. 3f and Fig. S18)24. Thus, we suppose that both 2e− ORR and 4e− WOR take place during H2O2 photosynthesis over Kf-AQ at pH 13.
To probe the active sites of Kf-AQ for the H2O2 photosynthesis, we synthesized two control COFs by respectively replacing the monomers of Tp and AQ with 1,3,5-trimethylbenzaldehyde (LZU) and 2,6-diaminoanthracene (DA), namely LZUAQ and TpDA (Fig. S19 and S20). Their H2O2 photosynthesis performance was much worse than that of Kf-AQ (Fig. S21), suggesting that anthraquinone groups were the indispensable active sites for ORR, and the keto and AQ conjugated configuration accounted for the efficient WOR over Kf-AQ.
We then employed in-situ FTIR and Raman spectra to further understand the critical role of water adsorption and dehydrogenation in the superior H2O2 photosynthesis of Kf-AQ. Upon irradiation, three obvious O-H stretching vibration bands appeared in the in-situ FTIR spectra of Kf-AQ (Fig. 4a), corresponding to the water clusters including Na+(H2O)3 or OH−(H2O)3 (3540 cm− 1), OH−(H2O)4 (3410 cm− 1), and OH−(H2O)5 (3292 cm− 1)39,40. These adsorbed water clusters were the proton precursors for H2O2 photosynthesis, which can be further checked by in-situ Raman spectra. The notable O-H stretching bands in Raman spectra at around 3000–3700 cm− 1 can be deconvoluted into three bands, corresponding to the four-coordinated hydrogen bonded water network (V1, 3254 cm− 1), the two-coordinated single donor hydrogen bonded water clusters (V2, 3420 cm− 1) and the Na+ ion hydrated water (Na⋅H2O) clusters (V3, 3553 cm− 1), respectively (Fig. 4b)41–43. The intensity of these bands for Kf-AQ was significantly higher than those for TpAQ, suggesting the formation of stronger hydrogen bond between keto moiety (-C = O) and OH−(H2O)n clusters43, possibly because the vibrational dipole moment (the direction of O-H bonds) in the clusters (such as Na⋅H2O) is parallel to the direction of the interfacial electric field, thus favoring the combination of hydrogen in the clusters with carbonyl groups of Kf-AQ. Simultaneously, V2 and V3 were the dominant forms in the Kf-AQ Raman spectrum, and generally had relatively weaker hydrogen bond network than V1, the dominant form in the TpAQ Raman spectrum. These differences can be attributed to the strong interaction between water clusters and carbonyl groups of Kf-AQ, resulting in the disorder and stretching of H-bonds in the arrangement of water molecules44, and the strong dipole-dipole force between Na+ and H2O molecules in the Na+ solvation structures further destroy the water-water interactions to form small water clusters of weak H-bonding environment44, thus favoring the photocatalytic dissociation of water and release of hydrogen. Therefore, the unique exclusive keto-form of Kf-AQ enhanced the adsorption and dissociation of water, thereby promoting hydrogen abstraction from water for the H2O2 photosynthesis.
We compared water adsorption over Kf-AQ and TpAQ by DFT calculations. In case of one water molecule adsorption, the adsorption energy of Kf-AQ was − 0.26 eV, much lower than that of TpAQ (-0.18 eV) (Fig. S22). Increasing water cluster sizes to (H2O)3, the adsorption energy of Kf-AQ decreased to -0.35 eV, and further decreased to -0.44 eV for the OH−(H2O)2 clusters, which was the dominant form of adsorbed water in alkaline water (Fig. S23), suggesting the superior water adsorption capability of Kf-AQ. Moreover, the bond energy of terminal H-O in OH−(H2O)2 form was 4.3 eV, much lower than that of (H2O)3 (5.9 eV) (Fig. 4c), suggesting the easier hydrogen dissociation from the terminal water, and thus favoring the subsequently combination with the neighboring H2O to form hydronium ion (H3O+)18.
We detected the intermediates of H*ads and OHads species by the cyclic voltammogram (CV) (Fig. 4d). The H*ads species generated in the reduction stage by reducing hydronium ion (H3O+) were oxidized, corresponding to an oxidative peak at about 0.25 V vs. RHE45,46. The oxidative peaks in the CV curves were more distinct with the increase of hydroxide anion concentrations, suggesting the increase of H*ads dosages at strong alkaline conditions18. Simultaneously, the reduction peak at 0.77 V was attributed to the reversible adsorbed OHads species, which were produced via the loss of electrons in OH− (ref. 47). The OHads species would be stabilized by forming hydroxyl-water-alkali metal cation cluster (OHads-Na+-(H2O)n), thus accordingly preventing its depletion by H3O+. Therefore, we propose that the dissociation of H2O into H*ads and OHads species takes place in the 2e− ORR and 4e− WOR pathways.
These above results strongly suggest a synergism of keto and anthraquinone moieties in Kf-AQ for superior H2O2 photosynthesis from water and oxygen, as depicted in Fig. 5. Initially, OH−(H2O)n clusters preferentially adsorbs onto the keto-form moieties in Kf-AQ, thus weakening the H-O bond of the terminal H2O via forming the H-OH(H2O)n−1OH− clusters and facilitating the dehydrogenation in water molecules. The detached protons then combine with the neighboring H2O to form H3O+. Upon visible light irradiation, surface H3O+ on Kf-AQ can be reduced by interfacial electrons (e−) to release H*ads species, which preferentially bind with the quinone groups (-C = O) in AQ and subsequently hydrogenate AQ to yield anthrahydroquinone (H2AQ). Afterwards, the parahydrogen atoms of H2AQ are abstracted to produce radicals, which react with O2 to form 1,4-endoperoxide species, a well-known intermediate for the formation of H2O2, which was confirmed by the new Raman peak at 891 cm− 1 (Fig. S24). Then, 1,4-endoperoxide species couples the adjacent hydrogen in the hydroxyl group of H2AQ to release H2O2. Meanwhile, another dissociation product, OHads intermediate, would not be dissociated as OH− within the interface layer, but form an adsorbed hydroxyl-water-alkali metal cation cluster (OHads-Na+-(H2O)n)47. Upon visible light irradiation, the photogenerated holes (h+) oxidizes this OHads to produce O2 in a 4e− WOR pathway. Therefore, the formation of OHads-Na+-(H2O)n and H3O+ intermediates over Kf-AQ at high pH conditions facilitates water oxidation and hydrogen extraction from H2O molecules, resulting in its superior photocatalytic H2O2 production.