Perception and preparedness of primary care physicians at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic
The electronic survey was filled by 35.2% (511/1450) of the investigated healthcare practitioners. Participating physicians were distributed as followed: 12.1% (n=62) from Belgium, 67.1% (n=343) from France and 20.8% (n=106) from Spain. Men represented 57.4% (n=292), median age was 56 years (IQR [42; 62]), and 70.7% (n=359) were working in urban areas (Table 1).
Table 1. Characteristics of primary care physicians by country
|
Total
N (%)
N=511
|
Belgium
N (%)
N=62
|
France
N (%)
N=343
|
Spain
N (%)
N=106
|
p-value
|
Participation
|
|
|
|
|
|
Targeted physicians
|
1450
|
98
|
1224
|
128
|
|
Respondents
|
511 (35.2%)
|
62 (63.3%)
|
343 (28.0%)
|
106 (82.8%)
|
|
Type of physicians (m.d.=0)
|
|
|
|
|
|
General Practitioners
|
491 (96.1%)
|
62 (100%)
|
343 (100%)
|
86 (81.1%)
|
|
Pediatricians
|
20 (3.9%)
|
0
|
0
|
20 (18.9%)
|
|
Sex (m.d.=2)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Female
|
217 (42.6%)
|
26 (41.9%)
|
131 (38.2%)
|
60 (57.7%)
|
<10-2
|
Male
|
292 (57.4%)
|
36 (58.1%)
|
212 (61.8%)
|
44 (42.3%)
|
Age (years) (m.d.=9)
|
|
|
|
|
|
25-39
|
106 (21.1%)
|
3 (4.8%)
|
100 (29.9%)
|
3 (2.9%)
|
<10-5
|
40-54
|
114 (22.7%)
|
9 (14.5%)
|
84 (25.1%)
|
21 (20%)
|
≥ 55
|
282 (56.2%)
|
50 (80.6%)
|
151 (45.1%)
|
81 (77.1%)
|
Median (IQR)
|
56 (42; 62)
|
61 (56; 65)
|
52 (37; 60)
|
60 (55; 62)
|
<10-5
|
Practice area (m.d.=3)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Rural
|
149 (29.3%)
|
22 (35.5%)
|
79 (23%)
|
48 (46.6%)
|
<10-4
|
Urban
|
359 (70.7%)
|
40 (64.5%)
|
264 (77%)
|
55 (53.4%)
|
Physicians’ anxiety (m.d.=7)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Low anxiety feeling
|
176 (34.9%)
|
24 (38.7%)
|
140 (41.3%)
|
12 (11.7%)
|
<10-5
|
Moderate anxiety feeling
|
246 (48.8%)
|
28 (45.2%)
|
164 (48.4%)
|
54 (52.4%)
|
High anxiety feeling
|
82 (16.3%)
|
10 (16.1%)
|
35 (10.3%)
|
37 (35.9%)
|
Median (IQR)
|
4 (2; 6)
|
3 (2; 6)
|
3 (2; 5)
|
6 (4; 7)
|
<10-5
|
Patients’ anxiety (m.d.=4)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Low anxiety feeling
|
107 (21.1%)
|
13 (21%)
|
73 (21.3%)
|
21 (20.4%)
|
0.85
|
Moderate anxiety feeling
|
286 (56.4%)
|
38 (61.3%)
|
188 (55%)
|
60 (58.3%)
|
High anxiety feeling
|
114 (22.5%)
|
11 (17.7%)
|
81 (23.7%)
|
22 (21.4%)
|
Median (IQR)
|
4 (3; 6)
|
5 (3; 6)
|
5 (3; 6)
|
4 (3; 6)
|
0.89
|
Risk of seeing infected patients in the next 2 weeks (m.d.=3)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Low risk
|
400 (78.7%)
|
46 (74.2%)
|
295 (86%)
|
59 (57.3%)
|
<10-5
|
Moderate risk
|
97 (19.1%)
|
15 (24.2%)
|
46 (13.4%)
|
36 (35%)
|
High risk
|
11 (2.2%)
|
1 (1.6%)
|
2 (0.6%)
|
8 (7.8%)
|
Median (IQR)
|
1 (0; 2)
|
1 (1; 3)
|
1 (0; 2)
|
2 (1; 5)
|
<10-5
|
Finding the measures taken by the health authorities suitable to limit the spread of COVID-19 (m.d.=3)
|
409 (80.5%)
|
51 (82.3%)
|
275 (80.2%)
|
83 (80.6%)
|
0.93
|
Changes in professional practices (m.d.=4)
|
207 (40.8%)
|
30 (48.4%)
|
124 (36.3%)
|
53 (51.5%)
|
<10-2
|
Impact on consultations (m.d.=3)
|
72 (14.2%)
|
8 (12.9%)
|
39 (11.4%)
|
25 (24.3%)
|
<10-2
|
Types of consequences (m.d.=5)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Questions about any links with China during consultations
|
44 (61.1%)
|
4 (50%)
|
19 (48.7%)
|
21 (84%)
|
|
Increased consultation time due to question about COVID-19
|
22 (30.6%)
|
1 (12.5%)
|
14 (35.9%)
|
7 (28%)
|
|
Specific consultations for information on COVID-19
|
6 (8.3%)
|
0
|
1 (2.6%)
|
5 (20%)
|
|
Phone calls on COVID-19
|
6 (8.3%)
|
2 (25%)
|
3 (7.7%)
|
1 (4%)
|
|
Consultations of patients who thought they had contracted COVID-19
|
6 (8.3%)
|
1 (12.5%)
|
4 (10.3%)
|
1 (4%)
|
|
Anticipation of the epidemic arrival (m.d.=3)
|
337 (66.3%)
|
40 (64.5%)
|
200 (58.3%)
|
97 (94.2%)
|
<10-5
|
Types of anticipation measures (m.d. =32)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Search of guidelines
|
205 (60.8%)
|
33 (82.5%)
|
113 (56.5%)
|
59 (60.8%)
|
|
Purchase of protection equipment
|
122 (36.2%)
|
4 (10%)
|
63 (31.5%)
|
55 (56.7%)
|
|
Re-use of the influenza pandemic kits
|
106 (35.7%)
|
N.A.
|
80 (40%)
|
26 (26.8%)
|
|
Office reorganization to avoid patients’ influx
|
60 (17.8%)
|
9 (22.5%)
|
34 (17%)
|
17 (17.5%)
|
|
Other measures
|
13 (3.9%)
|
1 (2.5%)
|
9 (4.5%)
|
3 (3.1%)
|
|
Level of information regarding the epidemic (m.d.=9)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Low information level
|
80 (16.3%)
|
6 (9.6%)
|
59 (17.5%)
|
15 (14.6%)
|
0.05
|
Moderate information level
|
168 (33.5%)
|
14 (22.6%)
|
120 (35.6%)
|
34 (33,0%)
|
High information level
|
254 (50.6%)
|
42 (67.7%)
|
158 (46.9%)
|
54 (52.4%)
|
Feeling prepared to face the epidemic (m.d.=4)
|
229 (45.2%)
|
28 (45.2%)
|
139 (40.6%)
|
62 (60.2%)
|
<10-2
|
m.d.: missing data; IQR: interquartile range; N.A.: not available
Only 16.3% of physicians (n=82) were highly worried about the COVID-19 pandemic, 80.5% (n=409) found the measures taken by the health authorities appropriate to control its spread, and 40.8% (n=207) had made changes in their professional practices (Table 1). The most frequent changes were “increased oral information given to patients about COVID-19” (60.4%, n=125), “increased handwashing or hand sanitizing” (49.8%, n=103), and “increased frequency of disinfection” (23.7%, n=49) (Figure 1). Physicians reported impacts on their consultations (like an increase in time) for 14.2% of them (n=72), and 66.3% (n=337) had started anticipating the epidemic arrival. The main anticipation measures were the research of action guidelines (60.8%, n=205) and the purchase of protection equipment (36.2%, n=122).
Half of the physicians (50.6%, n=254) felt they received clear information from health authorities overall. For 90.6% (n=454), the main source of information consisted of emails sent by health authorities (Figure 2).
Factors associated with preparedness
Less than half of primary care physicians (45.2%, n=229) felt prepared for the epidemic arrival, ranging from 40.6% (139/342) in France to 60.2% (62/103) in Spain. Factors positively associated with feeling prepared were: being a Spanish practitioner (adjusted odds ratio (aOR)=4.34; 95% confidence interval (CI) [2.47; 7.80]), being a man (aOR=2.57, 95%CI [1.69; 3.96]), finding the measures taken by authorities appropriate (aOR=1.72, 95%CI [1.01; 3.00]) and being highly informed (aOR=4.82, 95%CI [2.62; 9.19]). Factors negatively associated were: being moderately (aOR=0.34; 95%CI [0.21; 0.53]) or highly worried (aOR=0.27; 95%CI [0.14; 0.52]) (Table 2).
Table 2. Factors associated with the feeling of preparedness among primary care physicians (univariate and multivariate analyses)
|
|
n
|
Feeling prepared
|
OR [95% CI] Univariate analysis
|
p-value
|
OR [95% CI] Multivariate analysis
|
p-value
|
Age
|
25-39
|
105
|
43 (41.0%)
|
Ref.
|
0.01
|
|
|
40-54
|
114
|
39 (34.2%)
|
0.76 [0.44;1.32]
|
|
≥ 55
|
278
|
142 (51.1%)
|
1.53 [0.97;2.42]
|
Country
|
France
|
342
|
139 (40.6%)
|
Ref.
|
0.01
|
Ref.
|
<10-5
|
|
Belgium
|
62
|
28 (45.2%)
|
1.2 [0.69;2.07]
|
0.94 [0.5;1.75]
|
|
Spain
|
103
|
62 (60.2%)
|
2.21 [1.41;3.48]
|
4.34 [2.47;7.8]
|
Sex
|
Female
|
216
|
78 (36.1%)
|
Ref.
|
0.001
|
Ref.
|
<10-4
|
|
Male
|
291
|
151 (51.9%)
|
1.91 [1.33;2.74]
|
|
2.57 [1.69;3.96]
|
|
Type of practice area
|
Rural
|
149
|
69 (46.3%)
|
Ref.
|
0.74
|
|
|
Urban
|
358
|
160 (44.7%)
|
0.94 [0.64;1.38]
|
Physicians’ anxiety
|
Low
|
176
|
104 (59.1%)
|
Ref.
|
<10-4
|
Ref.
|
<10-5
|
|
Moderate
|
245
|
93 (38.0%)
|
0.42 [0.28;0.63]
|
0.34 [0.21;0.53]
|
|
High
|
82
|
31 (37.8%)
|
0.42 [0.24;0.72]
|
0.27 [0.14;0.52]
|
Patients’ anxiety
|
Low
|
107
|
54 (50.5%)
|
Ref.
|
0.46
|
|
|
Moderate
|
285
|
126 (44.2%)
|
0.78 [0.5;1.21]
|
|
High
|
114
|
49 (43.0%)
|
0.74 [0.43;1.26]
|
Risk of seeing infected patients in the next 2 weeks
|
Low
|
399
|
186 (46.6%)
|
Ref.
|
0.03
|
|
|
Moderate
|
97
|
35 (36.1%)
|
0.65 [0.41;1.02]
|
|
|
|
High
|
11
|
8 (72.7%)
|
3.05 [0.87;14.1]
|
|
|
|
Practice changes
|
No
|
300
|
131 (43.7%)
|
Ref.
|
0.39
|
|
|
Yes
|
206
|
98 (47.6%)
|
1.17 [0.82;1.67]
|
Impact on consultations
|
No
|
435
|
191 (43.9%)
|
Ref.
|
0.16
|
|
|
Yes
|
72
|
38 (52.8%)
|
1.43 [0.87;2.36]
|
Feeling response measures appropriate
|
No
|
99
|
32 (32.3%)
|
Ref.
|
0.01
|
Ref.
|
0.05
|
Yes
|
408
|
197 (48.3%)
|
1.95 [1.24;3.14]
|
1.72 [1.01;3]
|
Level of information
|
Low
|
80
|
21 (26.2%)
|
Ref.
|
< 10-5
|
Ref.
|
< 10-5
|
|
Moderate
|
167
|
46 (27.5%)
|
1.07 [0.59;1.98]
|
1.02 [0.54;2]
|
|
High
|
254
|
161 (63.4%)
|
4.86 [2.82;8.67]
|
4.82 [2.62;9.19]
|
Anticipation
|
No
|
171
|
84 (49.1%)
|
Ref.
|
0.20
|
|
|
Yes
|
336
|
145 (43.2%)
|
0.79 [0.54;1.14]
|