Nano crystallization process increases the solubility of MAGL23
MAGL23 is an organic molecule of medium molecular weight (369.436 g/mol) which, basing on the Chemicalize.com prediction (predicted physicochemical properties are reported in Table 1), is highly hydrophobic and insoluble at physiological pH levels (Figure 2a) at which it is mainly in its neutral form (94% at pH=7.4) (Figure 2b). In order to confirm the poor solubility of MAGL23 at neutral pH, a solubility test was performed on drug powder, following the method reported in section 2.2. The experimentally determined solubility is lower than 0.01 mg/ml (the lowest measurable value) in accordance with the prediction.
logP
|
4.18
|
Isoelectric point
|
3.50
|
Intrinsic solubility
|
0.808 μg/ml
|
pKa (strongest acid)
|
8.63
|
pKa (strongest base)
|
-1.64
|
Table 1. Physicochemical properties of the drug predicted (by Chemicalize.com)
Despite the fact that neutral compounds (having zero charges) are more favorable for biological membrane penetration than energetically charged compounds [4,35], poor solubility is often an impediment for the development and the clinical use of a drug. The drug formulation for enhancing aqueous dispersion often require the use of surfactants or nanoparticles, which may result in an increased systemic toxicity of the drug [36]. Nanocrystals having an high ratio between the carried drug and the excipients avoid toxicity and deliver a substantial amount of drug to the cells [24]. In fact, to overcome MAGL23 solubility issue, the drug was formulated as nanocrystals covered by albumin, which strongly binds to lipophilic drugs [24]. Wrapping MAGL23 nanocrystals with albumin was important for the safe delivery without a toxic nanocarrier and helped to stabilize and to internalize the nanocrystals into the cells [27]. The formulation proposed with both surfactants led to a significant increase in drug solubility as experimentally confirmed, reaching 0.82±0.06 mg/mL with at least eighty-fold increase of solubility in comparison with the stand-alone drug.
Yield and coating
The absorbance in the UV region was utilized to measure the loading of the MAGL23. Six separate synthesis were performed; Table 2 shows the average of the percentage of yield for each analyzed compound and the average of the percentage of HSA bonded to MAGL-AF and MAGL-AC nanocrystal samples. The results showed that the nanocrystallization protocol solubilizes MAGL23 up to 0.82 mg/ml and the percentage of HSA bound to the nanocrystals were 22% and 34% by weight in MAGL23-AF and MAGL23-AC, respectively.
Samples
|
Yield (%)
|
% bonded HSA
|
MAGL23-F
|
82 ± 6
|
-
|
MAGL23-AF
|
59 ± 7
|
22 ± 4
|
MAGL23-C
|
76 ± 4
|
-
|
MAGL23-AC
|
58 ± 6
|
34 ± 11
|
Table 2. Percentage yield of nanocrystal samples and percentage of interacting HSA (data are reported as mean ± standard deviation).
Morphological Analysis
The morphological analysis was performed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) on nanocrystal samples and drug powder (MAGL23). The formulation with both surfactants produced a reduction in crystal size with similar size frequency distributions (Figure 3 a,b,c) with average sizes of 389 nm (95% CI: 336-442) and 391 nm (95% CI: 344-439) for MAGL23-AC and MAGL23-AF, respectively. The images of nanocrystal samples at intermediate state of formulation (MAGL23 and MAGL23-F) are reported in supporting information Figure S1. Clearly, the size decreased and monodispersibility increased compared to MAGL23 while employing pluronic acid as surfactant.
Dispersion and homogeneity of the crystals were evaluated for MAGL23-AF and MAGL23-AC (Figure 3 d,e,f). TEM data support the fact that surfactants allowed to increase the solubility of the drug by creating smaller and more monodisperse nanocrystals with a hydrophilic coat. The size of MAGL23-AF suspended particles measured using DLS technique was around 395.4 nm (PdI 0.1), a value close to that identified by analysis on the TEM pictures, highlighting good dispersion of the crystals. Conversely, the hydrodynamic diameter of MAGL23-AC measured by DLS was bigger with an average crystal size of 477.2 nm (PdI 0.2) and it could be due to self-agglomeration of the particles in solution as it was possible to ascertain from in vitro observations. This unfavorable behavior and the higher toxicity of CTAB (see IC50 results, Table 3) led us to proceed further with pluronic F127 formulation only.
Characterization of nanocrystals, MAGL23 and coating components
The nano-crystallization process should not change the chemical and structural properties of the drug to maintain its efficacy, while increasing its pharmacokinetic properties by size reduction and coating.
To investigate the structure of the nanocrystals and study them during the crystallization process, X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements were performed. XRD diffractograms of nanocrystal samples MAGL-F, MAGL-AF and MAGL23 are reported in Figure 4a for values of 2θ ranging from 10 to 40° since for higher value of 2θ there were no peaks. Nanocrystals samples and MAGL23 diffractograms show intense and sharp diffraction peaks, which evidence their crystalline structure. All the major peaks of MAGL inhibitor diffractogram are present in nanocrystal samples, at 2θ values of 13.5, 15.75, 17.95, 18.95, 19.75, 23.5°, despite the dilution effect influences the nanocrystals samples. These results indicate that the crystallization process did not interfere with the inner crystalline structure of the drug.
To assess the possible interactions between the drug and the surfactants present on crystal surface in the nanocrystal formulation, FTIR spectroscopy analysis were performed for nanocrystal samples and MAGL23 (Figure 4b). Nanocrystal samples (MAGL-AF and MAGL-F) show mostly all MAGL23 bands (around 3430 cm-1 OH, 3167 cm-1 aromatic CH, 2865,2929,2961 cm-1 aliphatic CH, 1683 cm-1 chetonic CO, 1621 cm-1 ammidic CO, 1320 cm-1 CF [37]) without any significative shift. The only difference is the strong band at 3438 cm-1 steeper in MAGL-F and MAGL-AF, evidencing the presence of water in the samples probably due to the incomplete lyophilization [38,39]. The Pluronic F-127 weak band at 1100 cm-1 in MAGL-F is the only coating components band visible in the nanocrystal samples. Therefore, FTIR spectra evidence that the chemical structure of the drug remains unchanged during the crystallization process and that the drug delivery system is mainly formed by the active compound with little amount of coating components not strongly interacting with it. The chemical stability of MAGL23-AC and MAGL-C were also tested by FTIR spectra (supporting information Figure S2). No change was observed in the structure even by employing CTAB as surfactant.
Eventually, the FTIR and XRD spectra evidenced that during the crystallization process, the drug remained chemically and structurally unchanged and the drug delivery system was mainly formed by the active compound.
MAGL23-AF has an optimal release profile
MAGL23-AF in vitro release test results are reported in Figure 5 as percentage of the released drug over the initial drug amount. It is evident that the dissolution rate is low. Indeed, after one day only the 19 ± 7% of the drug was released and this value reached the 42 ± 6% after three days. The low release rate is in agreement with the stability of the complex [40]. This means that the nanocrystal formulation allows to increase the solubility, avoiding burst release of the drug and toxic effects during the blood circulation site. Taking advantages from the Enhanced Permeability Retention (EPR) effect and the targeting ability of the albumin, the drug should be released mainly at the targeted site reducing the side effects and promoting the uptake in cancer cells over more cycles of cell division [41,42].
Cell viability assay
MAGL enzyme is overexpressed in a large variety of cells deriving from ovarian and colorectal cancers, and also has a key role in tumor progression [43,44]. Therefore, the new formulations of MAGL23 were tested on tumor cell lines inherent to ovarian [45] (A2780, Skov3 and Ovcar3) and colorectal [46] cancers (Colo205 and HCT116).
Before testing MAGL23 nanocrystals, pluronic acid F127 and CTAB were evaluated. The IC50 values are reported in the Table 3. The IC50 of the CTAB are significantly lower than those of F-127, which suggests a marked self-cytotoxic activity. Conversely, pluronic acid F-127 did not display a significant cytotoxic activity and should be considered the best biocompatible formulant [47,48] among those tested. We therefore focused only on compounds treated with F-127, as a biocompatible surfactant with low intrinsic cytotoxicity. In Table 3 are reported the calculated IC50 values of MAGL23 initially dissolved in DMSO and MAGL23-AF dissolved in aqueous solution. In general, IC50 values were in the same range for each tumor cell line treated with MAGL23-AF compared to MAGL23 stand-alone.
Cell Line
|
IC50 (µM)
|
MAGL23
|
MAGL23-AF
|
CTAB
|
F-127
|
A2780
|
4.0±2.0
|
4.1 ± 0.4
|
0.6 ± 0.3
|
>200
|
SKOV3
|
15±2*
|
37 ± 9
|
0.35 ± 0.03
|
>100
|
OVCAR3
|
57 ±2*
|
23 ± 13
|
0.04± 0.01
|
>200
|
COLO205
|
3.0 ± 0.5
|
27 ± 6
|
0.042 ± 0.002
|
>200
|
HCT116
|
21 ± 1.0*
|
16± 2
|
1.1 ± 0.4
|
>200
|
Table 3. Calculated IC50 results for drug solution, nanocrystals samples and surfactants (data are reported as mean ± standard deviation).* Data from reference [16]
MAG23-AF and MAGL23 have comparable efficacy, in agreement with the results obtained from the nanocrystal characterization, which evidenced the maintenance of structural and chemical characteristics of the drug during the nanocrystallization procedure. Therefore, the drug delivery system allows to increase the water solubility without perturbing the molecule and consequently maintaining unaltered its activity on cells. Furthermore, the albumin coating should improve the biodistribution in vivo because albumin works first of all as a carrier to transport molecules in the blood [49,50], and secondly because albumin has a high affinity with sialoglycoprotein gp60, a protein present in the vascular endothelium and closely related to the formation of caveoles and transcytotic processes and SPARC (Secreted Protein, Acidic and Rich in Cysteine), which are overexpressed in the tumors [42,51,52]. These characteristics allow MAGL23-AF to extravasate more easily in vivo than MAGL23, significantly increasing the possibility of concentrating the drug around the tumor mass and therefore improving its effectiveness.
MAGL23-AF internalized into the cells through lysosomes
To determine the intracellular localization of MAGL23-AF, A2780 cells were probed with Hoechst 33342 (blue nucleus) and Lysotracker (green Lysosomes). MAGL23-AF was probed with rhodamine as reported previously [27]. A time course analysis at 1 hour and 24 hours showed that MAGL23-AF accumulates in the lysosomes with a Pearson’s correlation coefficient (R) of 0.73 and 0.67, respectively (yellow signals, Figure 6). These data suggest an active mechanism of cellular import with a partial trafficking to lysosomes (Figure 6).