Previously, targeted deletion of AMPKα1 and AMPKα2 in brainstem catecholaminergic cells through Cre expression via the tyrosine hydroxylase promoter (TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockout) was confirmed by single-cell end-point PCR, viral injection of a Creinducible vector carrying a reporter gene [52] and by crossing THAMPK-α1/α2 knockout mice with mice engineered for Credependent expression of Rosa (tdTomato) and subsequent analysis by confocal imaging of caudal brainstem areas [50].
AMPK deletion attenuates cFos expression of a hypoxia-responsive nucleus within the nucleus tractus solitarius
Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) analysis previously indicated that THAMPKα1/α2 deletion in catecholaminergic neurons resulted in marked attenuation of neuronal activation during hypoxia within a “dorsal active region” (DAR) of the nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS) that exhibited right-sided bilateral asymmetry [52]. The overall shape of the DAR indicated that several anatomical subnuclei of the NTS were likely affected by AMPK deficiency. Surprisingly, AMPK deletion and subsequent reductions in neuronal activity within the DAR attenuated the hypoxic ventilatory response (HVR) [52, 50, 49] but not cardiovascular responses to hypoxia [49], despite the fact that both cardiovascular and respiratory compartments of the ventrolateral medulla (VLM) are in receipt of NTS afferent inputs. This suggests that an AMPK-dependent, hypoxia-responsive subnucleus within the NTS preferentially facilitates respiratory function. Therefore, we sought to identify the precise location of this NTS subnucleus along the neuraxis of TH-AMPKα1/α2 knockout mice. To this end, we employed immunohistochemical strategies to investigate the expression of cFos as a surrogate for neuronal activation during hypoxia.
Consistent with previously reported outcomes in adult rabbits and rats [14, 15, 30], exposures to severe hypoxia (8% O2) for 60 min resulted in significant increases in cFos expression within the NTS of control mice (Fig. 1A; p < 0.0001 for 8% O2 versus 21% O2) and TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts (p < 0.05 for 8% O2 versus 21% O2). However, comparison of average counts (Fig. 1A) revealed no significant difference in the total number of cFos+ nuclei for THAMPK-α1/α2 knockouts when compared to controls (p = 0.336; 60 min, 8% O2). Nevertheless, in AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts ventilatory responses to hypoxia (8% O2) were attenuated relative to controls for 60 min, matching the time period used to analyse cFos expression in NTS neurons. Minute ventilation of THAMPKα1/α2 knockout mice (Fig. 1B) fell below normoxic values within 5min, continued to rapidly decrease until 15min (10-15min: -34.1 ± 2.4%, p < 0.001 compared to controls) and thereafter remained significantly attenuated relative to controls for 60min (p < 0.01 to p < 0.001). At 60min both breathing frequency (Fig. 1C) and tidal volume (Fig. 1D) were significantly depressed in THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts relative to AMPK-α1/α2 Floxed controls (p < 0.01 for breathing frequency and p < 0.001 for tidal volume).
We therefore compared by double-blind analysis, counts of cFos+ nuclei for each subnucleus of the NTS across all Bregma (-7.44mm to -7.6mm) that spanned the DAR identified by fMRI. Normalisation of cFos counts by surface area and section thickness ensured that differences in the size of subnuclei spanning multiple Bregma were accounted for. Moreover, to assess bilaterality, counts were analysed as the total number of cFos+ nuclei per 1000µm3 for both sides of the NTS combined, and by right and left subdivisions. That said, exceptions were made for the AP and SolC, which in rodents and lagomorphs are midline structures [8, 39] and were, therefore, only analysed as a whole.
Using this strategy, we identified a small number of rostral NTS subnuclei that displayed a significant and Bregma-specific reduction in hypoxia-induced cFos expression in TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts relative to controls (Supplementary Fig. 1). Most notably, significant reductions in cFos expression of TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts were identified within SolDL and SubP at Bregma − 7.48mm, and in each case this was observed on the right side of the brainstem (SolDL, p < 0.05; SubP, p < 0.05) but not the left, in accordance with both the observed right-side dominance and approximate anatomical location of the epicentre of the DAR identified by fMRI. Like most other NTS subnuclei, both SolDL and SubP have been proposed to innervate respiratory and cardiovascular compartments of the VLM. However, SolDL may primarily innervate compartments of the rostral VLM responsible for the modulation and/or generation of respiratory rhythmogenesis [21, 2, 78, 34], which could, at least in part, explain our finding that AMPK-α1/α2 deletion in catecholaminergic neurons selectively attenuates the HVR [52, 49].
As mentioned above, cFos expression in SolDL was significantly attenuated in THAMPK-α1/α2 knockouts relative to controls at Bregma − 7.48mm (p = 0.0154), but not in the next most caudal or rostral Bregma (Supplementary Fig. 2 Ai & Bi). By contrast, for SubP significant reductions in cFos expression were identified at Bregma − 7.48 (p = 0.0294) and − 7.56mm (p = 0.0355; (Supplementary Fig. 2 Aiv & Biv)), the latter of which sits along this neuraxis at the caudalmost limit of the DAR identified by fMRI (Bregma − 7.44mm to -7.6mm). Interestingly, combining the cFos+ counts of SubP across the three caudal-most Bregma of this neuraxis enhanced the degree of significance further (Bregma − 7.48mm to -7.56mm: p = 0.0178). A similar pattern emerged for SolDL, whereby the highest degree of significance was achieved by combining the two rostral Bregma − 7.44mm and − 7.48mm (p = 0.0113).
This presented a paradox, because SolDL and SubP are not connected anatomically. Therefore, we considered the possibility that SolDM may be involved, given that SolDM neurons may aid coordination of orofacial movements via the nucleus ambiguus [26]. We first examined cFos+ counts along the entire neuraxis of the murine SolDM, which spans a distance that ranges from Bregma − 7.44mm to -7.50mm [23] but identified no statistical differences for any of these Bregma individually when comparing THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts to controls (Supplementary Fig. 3Ai & Bi), nor when any of the adjacent Bregma were combined. Nevertheless, in order to thoroughly cross-compare all possible different combinations, we tested various models that included each SolDL, SolDM and SubP combination, starting with those that delivered the highest statistical difference for cFos+ counts in response to hypoxia (Fig. 3A & B). To our surprise this resulted in the highest degree of statistical significance observed yet (p = 0.0043). Furthermore, the addition of SubP at Bregma − 7.44mm to this model marginally strengthened rather than weakening the degree of significance (p = 0.0042). Therefore, it would appear that the combination of SolDL, SolDM, and SubP, all of which contribute to cardiorespiratory control during hypoxia (Supplementary Fig. 4), at Bregma − 7.44mm and an extension for SolDL across two (-7.44mm to -7.48mm) and SubP across four (-7.44mm to -7.56mm) Bregma in a caudal direction most likely corresponds to the nucleus that exhibits reduced hypoxiaevoked neuronal activation in THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts (Fig. 3C). Strikingly, both the anatomical location and rightside dominant bilateral asymmetry of this hypoxia-responsive nucleus, named here as SubSolHΙe, within the caudal brainstem identified by cFos expression is consistent with the anatomical range, location and right-side dominant bilateral asymmetry of the DAR identified by fMRI (Bregma − 7.1mm to -7.6mm). A deficit in cFos expression was also observed within the AP, but this was only apparent at Bregma − 7.56mm and did not extend further in either direction along the neuraxis of the DAR (Fig. 3A). That said a role for this segment of the AP should not be discounted lightly.
The aforementioned findings are all the more intriguing, because extended wholebrain analysis of our previously published fMRI data [52] identified further regions of interest (Supplementary Fig. 5) that lay both caudal and rostral to SubSolHΙe which exhibited significantly lower signal change (P < 0.005) during hypoxia in AMPKα1/α2 knockouts than in AMPK-α1/α2 floxed controls. These regions of interest correspond by location, caudal to rostral, to the nucleus retroambiguus [38], the rostral ventral respiratory column (e.g., Bötzinger complex, retrotrapezoid nucleus / parafacial respiratory group) [32,5,20,45], the lateral nucleus of the cerebellum [73,47,70], and all are in receipt of noradrenergic inputs from the NTS and contribute to respiratory pattern formation (see discussion for further details).
Adding to the above, significant reductions in cFos+ neurons were seen in other nuclei of THAMPK-α1/α2 knockouts (Fig. 3) that were either left-side dominant (Fig. 3B), or bilateral (Fig. 3C), not previously registered by fMRI and located too lateral or too ventral to comprise any part of the hypoxia-responsive subnucleus identified by fMRI. Briefly, bilateral reductions in cFos+ neurons were identified for 10N at Bregma − 7.44mm (p < 0.01 for both sides, p < 0.05 for the right and left sides alone). Left-sided bilateral asymmetry was observed for SolCe at Bregma − 7.44mm (p < 0.01 for the left side alone), and SolV at Bregma − 7.64mm (p < 0.05 for both sides, p < 0.01 for left side alone) and Bregma − 7.44mm (p < 0.05 for both sides and left side alone); however, deficits in cFos counts within SolV were not enhanced by any combination of Bregma along this neuraxis.
AMPK deletion in catecholaminergic cells inhibits active expiration and increases sigh frequency during hypoxia
Downstream of the NTS, hypoxia-evoked afferent input responses impact the parafacial nucleus which coordinates active expiration [33] and the retrotrapezoid nucleus/parafacial respiratory group which coordinates sighs [45]. Therefore, we next investigated the effect of AMPK-α1/α2 deletion on these distinct ventilatory activities.
Active expiration was significantly attenuated in TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts relative to controls (Fig. 4A). During exposures to 8% O2, the expiration time ratio of hypoxia:normoxia (Te) in AMPK-α1/α2 Floxed mice displayed a marked reduction 30s after the onset of hypoxia (0.5 ± 0.02). Thereafter, a lengthening of Te occurred until approximately 2min followed by a secondary minor decrease and plateau, measuring 0.8 ± 0.02 by 5min (p < 0.0001 compared to 30s) and 0.8 ± 0.03 by 10min (p < 0.0001 compared to 30s, not significant compared to 5min). Similarly, following a nadir at 30s (0.7 ± 0.03), the Te of TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts lengthened over time, but unlike control mice the prolongation of expiration time plateaued close to normoxic values, measuring 1.1 ± 0.04 by 5min (p < 0.0001 compared to 30s) and 1 ± 0.04 by 10min (p < 0.05 compared to 5min). In short, TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts failed to maintain accelerated active expiration and instead rapidly returned to and remained at Te values equivalent to those measured during normoxia, that were significantly lengthened compared to controls at both 5min (p < 0.0001) and 10min (p < 0.001). Therefore, active expiration was blocked by AMPK deletion in catecholaminergic cells.
Sigh frequency was also significantly attenuated in TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts compared to controls (Fig. 4B) during both halves of 10min exposures to severe hypoxia (0-5min: p < 0.0001; 5-10min: p < 0.05). However, analyses at one-minute intervals revealed that although sigh frequencies were on average lower in THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts during every minute except the last, the difference only reached significance during the first 5min of exposures to 8% O2 compared to AMPKα1/α2 Floxed mice (p < 0.05 to 0.0001).
AMPK deletion in catecholaminergic cells triggers oscillating apnoeic salvos during hypoxia
Consistent with previous observations [52], TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts also exhibited a marked increase in apnoea frequency, apnoea duration and apnoea duration index compared to controls during the first 25min of exposures to hypoxia (Fig. 5A-C). Moreover, minuteby-minute analyses revealed periodic “apnoeic salvos” in THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts from 30-60min, which were characterised by timedependent phasic increases in the number of apnoeas, that occurred at a frequency of ~ 3–4 mHz and had a salvo duration of ~ 1min (Fig. 5A). These apnoeic salvos were present in each of the four THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts analysed (Supplementary Fig. 6). By contrast, AMPKα1/α2 Floxed mice maintained a steady apnoea frequency throughout 60min exposures to hypoxia. By contrast, there was dampened by a timedependent decline in apnoea duration in THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts to a level equivalent to controls (Fig. 5B) that dampened, as one might expect, oscillations in apnoea duration index (ADI) of THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts (Fig. 5C).
Attenuation of the HVR in mice by AMPK deletion in catecholaminergic cells is not compensated for by changes in whole-body metabolic rate
The fact that TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts exhibit a torpor-like state during hypoxia [52] concomitant with the observed ventilatory depression is indicative of mice entering a hypometabolic state [28] rather than hypoventilation per se. We therefore sought to assess the metabolic responses of control AMPK-α1/α2 Floxed and TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts during hypoxia. Metabolic rates during normoxia (21% O2) were comparable between control AMPKα1/α2 Floxed and TH-AMPK-α1/α2 knockouts for both oxygen consumption (VO2; Fig. 6Ai) and carbon dioxide production (VCO2; Fig. 6Bi).
During 10min exposures to 8% O2 (Fig. 6Aii & Bii), control AMPK-α1/α2 Floxed mice displayed a reduction in VO2 relative to normoxia by 5min, which was maintained until the end of the exposure at 10min. Likewise, VCO2 was reduced relative to normoxia in control mice by 5min and this reduction was maintained until 10min. Compared to this, the VO2 of THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts displayed no significant differences relative to controls. Similarly, VCO2 was slightly reduced but not significantly different compared to control mice.
Furthermore, O2 consumption and CO2 production were assessed during 5min exposures to graded hypoxia (5min each of 21% O2, 18% O2, 15% O2, 12% O2, 10% O2, 8% O2; Fig. 6Aiii & Biii). A progressive reduction in O2 availability that lasted for a total of 25min also revealed no differences between control and THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts with respect to the gradual reductions of VO2 and VCO2, respectively.
Deletion of AMPK in catecholaminergic neurons does not alter brainstem catecholamine content
Finally, we sought to assess the bioavailability of catecholamines within the central nervous system at the sites targeted by conditional AMPK deletion in catecholaminergic neurons. Bioamine levels within the brainstems and spinal cords (Fig. 7) of control AMPKα1/α2 Floxed and THAMPKα1/α2 knockouts revealed no differences in catecholamine levels; namely noradrenaline, serotonin, the catecholamine precursor L-DOPA, or the serotonin metabolite 5hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA).