This study combined extensive survey data and comprehensive trait measurements on almost 300 tree species to reveal the ecophysiological basis for how climate, soil and biogeography have structured rainforest tree assemblages across 9° of latitude in the Australian subtropics. The filtering effect of climate was overarching; the interaction between Trait PC1 and Climate PC1 was more than twice as strong as any other trait-by-environment interaction that we examined (Extended Data Fig. 2). In fact, based on the strength of this interaction and others, the model reproduced the community weighted means for all traits very reliably (Extended Data Fig. 5).
Consistent with the widely reported safety-efficiency trade-off, species with highly efficient water-use strategies were more prevalent in mesic locations (Fig. 4a), permitting greater transpiration and growth rates required to reach higher-radiation positions in the forest canopy, and achieve their large reproductive size16,29. Furthermore, the inclusion of a deciduous indicator variable captured drought-avoiding strategies as viable alternatives to safe evergreen strategies in drier climates (Figs. 4a & b), consistent with findings in tropical forests30,31. While such traits relating to tree hydraulics are known to influence species’ distributions along climatic gradients32,33, we provide an unparalleled, community-scale demonstration of how species’ hydraulic traits modulate their occurrences along a large and continuous climate gradient.
The hydraulic axis also interacted significantly with the quadratic Climate PC1 term (Extended Data Fig. 2), whereby species with safer strategies tended to have linear relationships (quadratic coefficients closer to zero) and efficient species had more hump-shaped trends (more negative quadratic coefficients) along the moisture gradient (Extended Data Fig. 3a). The more linear relationships for very safe species arose for two reasons. First, the distributions of very safe species extend into drier climates34, so our data did not capture how their occurrence probabilities decline beyond our study region. Second, many very safe species occurred in all (or most) very dry sites, allowing their probabilities of occurrence to decline linearly (on the modelled scale) from high values in very dry locations, to lower values as moisture availability increased. The hump-shaped trends for hydraulically efficient species likely emerged for the opposite reason. Very mesic rainforests support more species, including more endemic and range-restricted tree species27 thus reducing the average likelihood of recording a given efficient species in multiple mesic sites (Extended Data Fig. 6).
Occurrence probabilities of efficient hydraulic strategies also increased with relative elevation (Extended Data Fig. 3b), especially at the wet end of Climate PC1, where rainforests at higher relative elevations were more likely to contain species with highly efficient hydraulics compared with those at low relative elevations (not shown). This can likely be attributed to the region’s topographic complexity which positions a number of our sites near the orographic cloud base35. Consistent with the Massenerhebung effect, small, isolated peaks (with greater relative elevations) support a lowering of the cloud base, associated with higher relative atmospheric humidity at a given altitude36,37. Fog or cloud may further improve plant water status by reducing solar radiation and thus water loss via transpiration, as well as by facilitating direct foliar uptake of water38. This effect can decouple a site’s microclimate from the regional climate and buffer against climatic extremes39, in turn supporting tree species with greater hydraulic demands.
With increasing moisture availability (along Climate PC1) we also captured the emergence of tall canopy species (Fig. 4d) with relatively small, reinforced lumens (as indicated by Trait PC3). While taller trees have access to high-radiation habitats in mesic forests, they must also tolerate increasing vessel path length resistance17,40, as well as greater vapour pressure deficits in exposed forest canopies41. Consequently, in these taller canopy trees, pronounced vessel tapering may serve to reduce cavitation risk in longer, inherently more vulnerable vessels – preventing large negative tensions in the most distal portions of the canopy42. Indeed, this is consistent with hydraulic theory43 and has been observed in tropical tree species44. Ultimately, we demonstrate here that tall canopy trees, while employing efficient water-use strategies, can coordinate their traits to circumvent the biophysical challenges of larger stature42.
These taller species at the positive extreme of Trait PC3 were also more likely to occur in locations with lower minimum temperatures (Extended Data Fig. 2), which were typically high-altitude sites far from the coast (not shown). Such cooler, elevated sites are less likely than lower-elevation sites to experience the combined effects of drought and extreme heat45,46, which may enable the persistence of larger trees by minimizing the risk of drought-induced hydraulic failure47,48. Our results are mirrored in mesic, tropical forests; Binks et al.49 identified that, under nonlimiting soil water supply, rainforest tree communities growing under higher temperatures tended to be shorter in stature.
Our model also revealed strong trait-modulated responses of species to soil fertility and texture. Compared to their evergreen counterparts, deciduous species were more likely to occur in higher-P sites (Extended Data Fig. 3e), which aligns with findings in tropical dry forests50,51. Drought-deciduous species typically combine high hydraulic efficiency with acquisitive leaf economics to enable rapid re-leafing and to maximise growth during favourable climatic periods29. As such, these species require higher soil fertility to facilitate the frequent turnover of high-SLA leaves, with nutrient loss via leaf shedding not adequately compensated in low-fertility soils52, even if some nutrient resorption occurs prior to shedding53. Consequently, evergreen species that combine safe hydraulics with conservative leaf economics become dominant in less fertile dry forests30,54,55, as we found in this study (Fig. 5). Safe, conservative strategies also confer greater resistance to physical damage, preventing high repair costs in infertile sites56,57.
Soil texture is expected to operate as an additional edaphic filter by moderating the total amount of plant-available soil water in these rainforest systems25. The lower water-holding capacity of coarse-textured soils58 led species to adopt more conservative leaf economics (higher Trait PC2 values) (Extended Data Fig. 2), likely to help maintain leaf turgor at lower leaf water potentials9,20. In contrast, species with ‘fast’ leaves (lower Trait PC2 values) were associated with clay soils that improve soil water access52, consistent with higher rates of resource acquisition in more productive habitats59. These results indicate that soil fertility and texture modulate the adaptive value of traits in a given climate, and thus underscore the importance of accounting for soil, climate and their interactive effects as habitat filters during community assembly54.
In addition to strong climatic and edaphic filtering, we found strong signatures of dispersal and biogeographic processes that have also structured contemporary rainforest assemblages. At the mesic extreme of Climate PC1, higher-altitude sites have been identified previously as regional refugia – areas that have maintained stable rainforest habitat through historical climate oscillations, most recently during the Pleistocene27,60. We accounted for these refugia by simply measuring the distance of each site to the closest refugium (as identified by Weber et al.27) and then adjusting for correlation with climate variables to separate historical from contemporary processes. While it has long been recognized that these refugia support a greater richness of endemic species61, our data shows that these stable refugia have specifically permitted the persistence and accumulation of evergreen species with efficient hydraulic strategies (Extended Data Fig. 3b). Within these habitats, light competition is expected to have driven strong life history trade-offs among species, reinforcing selection for highly efficient water-use strategies that permit taller canopy positions62,63. Moreover, we revealed that deciduous species most commonly occur further from these refugial locations (Extended Data Fig. 3f), likely because deciduousness is a less competitive strategy in environments where water is reliably available64.
The distance to refugia-by-diaspore diameter interaction was only close to significant in our full model (Table S4), but two other strong and significant interactions indicate that dispersal has also played an important role in structuring tree communities during Pleistocene climatic oscillations28,65. The Climate PC1-by-diaspore diameter (Fig. 4c) and relative elevation-by-diaspore diameter interactions (Extended Data Fig. 3i) both indicated that larger-fruited species increase in occurrence probability as the climate becomes wetter, and as relative elevation increases. In a supplementary analysis (Supplementary information), we examined species’ dispersal modes using a mixed-effects multinomial model and found that occurrence probabilities of species with large endozoochorous diaspores (> 10 mm) increased sharply along Climate PC1 (Extended Data Fig. 7), while those with small diaspores declined just as sharply. This is consistent with well-dispersed, smaller-fruited species recolonising less stable habitats during wetter interglacial periods28, and also aligns with the probable extinction of large frugivores from the subtropics that has since inhibited dispersal of larger-fruited species out of refugia66,67.
The strength of trait-by-climate interactions in our model highlights its considerable potential for predicting future distributions of tree strategies, or even entire assemblages, under climate change. We refrained from making such projections using available ensemble models because of high uncertainty in rainfall predictions for the Australian subtropics68. In ongoing research, we will explore applications of our data to storylines that more transparently represent such uncertainty69. Nevertheless, this study has revealed how climate, soil and biogeography have jointly acted on tree hydraulic, leaf economic and dispersal strategies to create the distinct assemblages present across the Australian subtropics. Our strong results emphasise the importance of choosing functional traits that are related to the major gradients of resource availability70, and with well-understood links to relevant physiological processes21,22, to increase the physiological resolution of community assembly research.