The preparation of the NHSE and its static electrical performance
The fabrication process of the NHSE is presented in Figure 1a. The TPU nanofibers were electrospun from TPU-hexafluoroisopropanol (HFIP) solution, which generated fine (~600 nm in diameter, Supplementary Fig. 1) and robust nanofibers24. The LM nanoparticles were dispersed in ice-bathed isopropanol solution that enabled stable LM nanoparticle suspension25 to facilitate subsequent mechanical activation process (Supplementary Fig. 2). Then, the TPU nanofibers and the LM nanoparticles were collected on a metal collector simultaneously by electrospinning and electrospraying, respectively [Fig. 1a(i)]. After this process, the LM nanoparticles were bonded onto the TPU nanofibers through electrostatic force to form a LM nanoparticles @ TPU scaffold composite (LNSC) [Fig. 1a(ii)]26. As revealed by the top-down view of scanning electron microscopic (SEM) (Fig. 1b), the LM nanoparticles were composed of nano-sized particles and micro-sized ones that might be agglomerated from smaller ones. These LM nanoparticles were densely adhered on the TPU nanofibers scaffold. To break the oxide shell of the LM nanoparticles and achieve a conductive pathway, an external stimulus, e.g., scraping, was conducted on top of the specimen for the coalescence of the LM nanoparticles. Consequently, an ultrathin highly conductive LM film on the top part was formed, as sketched in Figure 1a(iii). The LM film showed a continuous morphology (Fig. 1c), which is supported by the porous nanofibers-based scaffold underneath. This phenomenon is due to the balance between the Laplace capillary force (Fl) and the gravitational force (Fg), as illustrated in Supplementary Figure 3. It has the same nature as the water-to-net interaction in the macroscopic world. The overall thickness of the NHSE is 50 μm, including an ultrathin LM membrane with a thickness of hundreds of nanometres on the top (Fig. 1d). It is possible that the LM nanoparticles fabrication lessened the surface tension of LM to enable such a LM membrane that is thinner than other works21, 27.
The NHSE exhibits an excellent intrinsic electrical performance, as illustrated in Figure 1e, f. Specifically, the sheet resistance of the NHSE reaches as low as 52 mΩ sq−1 under an electrospraying rate of 0.08 ml/min. The dependence of the sheet resistance on the electrospraying rate is presented in Figure 1e. The sheet resistance becomes lower due to the larger quantity of LM with increasing spraying speed (Supplementary Fig. 4 a‒d). Based on the mapping of the sheet resistance in an area of 2 × 2 cm2, a standard deviation of 5 mΩ sq−1 was obtained. (Fig. 1f). As the TPU scaffold enables exceptional mechanical stretchability and mechanical compliance, the NHSE shows a stretchability with a uniaxial elongation of ~570% (Fig. 1g). Illustrated in Figure 1h, it forms a seamless and conformal contact on human forearm without adhesives. No exfoliation was observed upon dynamic deformation of the skin. Besides, it is worth noting that the fabrication process is compatible to possible area-scalable production, as demonstrated by a sample with dimensions of 10 cm × 30 cm (Fig. 1i).
Electrical characterization of the NHSE under mechanical and environmental stimuli
The stability and robustness under mechanical deformation are the most critical criteria for stretchable electrodes, which were the highlights of recent works28, 29. The superior performance of the NHSE lies in three aspects. First, its electrical resistance is insensitive to large mechanical stretching; Second, the electrical resistance keeps stable despite of a large number of cyclic deformations; Third, it shows a high level of robustness against diverse environmental conditions, e.g., fluid soaking with different pH values, repeated washing, temperature variation, and long-time air exposure. The detailed results are presented below.
Frist, the electrical resistance was monitored as a uniaxial stretching was applied. For the sample made with an electrospraying speed of 0.08 ml/min, the resistance increases only by 17% and 350% at an elongation of 100% and 570%, respectively (Fig. 2a). In comparison, the resistance variation was found to be 1,000-8,000% at an elongation range of 300-600% in very recent state-of-the-art works1, 14, 29, 30. Besides, the resistance can almost immediately recover to its original value once the stretching is released. For example, if a sample undergoes four stretching cycles as follows, i.e., 0% → 100% → 0% → 200% → 0% → 300% → 0% → 400% → 0% (Fig. 2b). There are only 14% (26 mΩ) and 48% (270 mΩ) resistance variations after the first and the fourth cycles, respectively. Figure 2c exhibits the sheet resistance versus the mechanical stretchability. Having a combination of stretchability and conductivity, the NHSE in this work turns out to be superior to most recently reported stretchable electrodes14, 16, 31-40, including LM-elastomer composite, Fe-LM, Ag-LM, and Au-LM composite, Ag flakes, Ag NWs, conductive polymer, etc.
Second, the NHSE possesses exceptional electrical stability under dynamic cyclic deformations, illustrated in Figure 2d, e. After being stretched with a 100% elongation for 100,000 cycles at 0.2 Hz, the intrinsic electrical resistance without strain increases only by 5% (Fig. 2d). The slight increase is possibly due to the formation of the micro-scale wrinkles on the NHSE (Supplementary Fig. 5a‒c), which induces a prolonged conductive pathway. It is interesting that the resistance variation becomes smaller as more stretching cycles are applied (Fig. 2d insets). This can be also explained by the micro-wrinkles, which has been known for mitigating effective strain applied on stretchable devices41, 42.
Third, the NHSE almost constantly maintains the resistance as being stretched at 0%, 100% or 200% under different environmental conditions (Fig. 2e and Supplementary Fig. 6, 7). The resistance of the stretched NHSE barely changes after 1,000 washing cycles (Supplementary Fig. 6). There is a merely 11% resistance rise for a 200%-stretched NHSE after 30,000 washing cycles (Fig. 2e). Besides, samples soaked in artificial perspirations with pH 4.7 and 8.8 present a negligible resistance increase, respectively (Supplementary Fig. 7a, b). As for long-term stability of the NHSE in ambient environment, the sheet resistance remains approximately 60 mΩ sq−1 with a negligible variation after being exposure in air after 420 days (Fig. 2f). Also, the resistance stability of the NHSE was investigated through freezing and heating processes (Fig. 2f inset). The resistance of the NHSE gradually increased by 50% as the sample temperature varied from −30 ℃ to 120 ℃. The increase possibly comes from the oxidation of the LM surface at the elevated temperature. It is worth noting that there is a sharp increase of the electrical resistance at approximately 15 ℃, at which a phase transition of the LM from solid to liquid probably occurs43, 44.
Mechanism of the electrical robustness of the NHSE
Nature always enlightens us through various wonderful workmanship in materials design and mechanism analysis45. The NHSE highly resembles a natural phenomenon, in which a continuous water membrane spreads across a meshed fishing net (Fig. 3a). The evolution of the interaction between the water membrane and the meshed net is illustrated in Supplementary Fig. 8a−c as a strain is applied. The water membrane is deformable and maintains continuity at the initial stage of the strain. Under a large strain, if even cracks are generated, they are confined within individual mesh units without causing total rupture of the water membrane.
In the case of the NHSE, similar observations were found. To reveal the morphology evolution, samples with different levels of strain were examined under SEM (Fig. 3b−j). Here, the interface between the LM and the nanofibers is adaptable upon deformation, which is the key for the high level of electrical stability of the NHSE. This adaptable behaviour is presented in two stages, as sketched in Fig. 3b. The first stage involves a small strain range when the elongation is less 100%. In this stage, the morphology of the LM membrane evolves along with the deformation of the nanofibers without interface stress being built up. As a result, the LM membrane remains integral, which is justified by the SEM image as well as a video with in-situ stretching of 100% elongation (Fig. 3c, d and Supplementary Movie 1). Although random minor pits could be identified (Fig. 3d), neither proliferation nor propagation of the pits were found in subsequent stretching cycles (Fig. 3e, f). In the second stage in which the elongation increases beyond 100%, more pits are generated, and they expand to micro-scale voids at the same time. However, the voids do not propagate throughout the entire LM membrane. Instead, they are confined locally by the nanofibers that act as a boundary for isolating the voids from surrounding area (Fig. 3g, h). This confinement effect prevents the LM membrane from total rupture and preserves active conducting pathways. Even if the elongation reaches 500%, the confinement is still effective despite of largely expanded and distorted voids. As a result, the NSHE remains to be functional. The distortion observed in Figure 3i, j is due to the re-orientation of the nanofibers under a uniaxial strain. The alignment of the nanofibers is quantitatively characterized by SEM images and the 2D Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) plots in Supplementary Figure 9, 1046.
Based on the above analysis, the self-adaptable interfacial interaction is the key enabler for the insensitivity as well as the robustness of the electrical resistance against strain. To obtain this particular interface, the in-situ assembly fabrication method in this work plays a vital and irreplaceable role. In order to further prove this point, control experiments with other typical fabrication methods were conducted. In the first group, LM droplets were applied onto a commercial TPU substrate, and were scratched across the substrate to form a continuous film subsequently (Supplementary Movie 2). Without the self-adaptable interface, the LM film is broken into separated islands under an elongation of 100%, which is an irreversible failure (Supplementary Fig. 11). In the second group, a TPU-nanofiber-based scaffold was used as a substrate, and LM droplets were subsequently applied via the same procedure in the first group. This fabrication method was also reported in a very recent work27. The reported results showed that the electrical resistance of the stretchable electrode increased by 30% after 25,000 stretching cycles (100% elongation). In contrast, the NHSE in this work experienced only a 5% increase in the electrical resistance after 100,000 stretching cycles.
The application of the NHSE for stretchable conductor and ECG recordings
The NHSE shows a great promise of being used as interconnects in elastic electronic systems. As a demonstration, it was applied as an elastic conductor to power a stripe of light emitting diodes (~75 LEDs), presented in Figure 4a, b. It was stretched from original dimensions to an elongation of approximately 500%. Negligible variation of the LED’s brightness was observed. The repeatability was demonstrated through multiple stretching cycles. Still, the LED’s brightness remained constant (Supplementary Movie 3).
Being ultrathin and mechanically compliant, the NHSE is also suitable to be used in epidermal devices for on-body physiological signal collection (Fig. 4 c‒i and Supplementary Movie 4). In the following demonstration, the NHSE formed a tight and conformal bonding on human skin via van der Waals force47. Used as an epidermal electrode for electrocardiogram (ECG) recording, it has a comparable contact impedance as a commercial AgCl gel electrode (Fig. 4c). At a static state, the signal obtained from the NHSE is equivalently recognizable as that from the commercial gel electrode (Fig. 4d). The key advantage of the NHSE for this application lies in stable signal detection under external disturbance. Shown in Fig. 4f, the signal recording was accompanied by wrist movement. As a result, baseline fluctuation was found for the gel electrode, while the signal from the NHSE was unchanged. If water was poured onto the gel electrode during signal recording, significant noise buried the signal without recognizable regular patterns (Fig. 4i). In contrast, key features from the NHSE, i.e., P-waves, QRS complex, and T-waves, were still preserved and remained diagnosable. This contrast is attributed to seamless and conformal on-body contact from the NHSE.
The electrical self-healing property of the NHSE
The robustness of the NHSE is further verified as it survives from severe damages, including cutting and hole punching. As demonstrated in Figure 5a, a piece of NHSE was selectively and locally activated by drawing a line on top of the sample. This line became conductive and was used as a flexible circuit to power a LED. The conductive line was cut through using a razor blade on the left side of the LED. Subsequently, a hole punching was conducted on the other side of the LED. During and after the above operation, the LED was still lighting (Fig. 5a). The damaged flexible circuit was still functional even if it was stretched afterwards (Fig. 5b).
This observation is due to the reconstruction of conductive pathways at the damaged sites. As illustrated in Figure 5c, the line in the middle of the sample represents the region where the activation has taken place. For the rest of the area, it is subject to subsequent activation upon mechanical stimuli. Although cutting or punching disconnects the original conductive pathway, it essentially activates new sites around the cutting/punching mark (Fig. 5d, f). As a result, a fresh conductive pathway is reconstructed at the same time when the damage happens, which enables uninterrupted power supply. Quantitatively revealed in Figure 5g, a five-fold increase of the electrical resistance is observed after the first cut, and another 400% and 600% increase after the second and the third cuts, respectively. Similar observations were also found in the case of successive hole punching. Therefore, the NHSE shows an exceptional level of robustness despite of severe damages.