Fabrication and characterization of CEAB
We first develop a method to prepare CEAB film with controlled thickness and scalability, based on the pressure exertion. The fabrication process of the electrode is illustrated in Fig. 1b (Further setup details in Supplementary Fig. S1a). Firstly, the DES is synthesized by mixing ChCl and EG stirred at 80 ℃ for 20 mins. Then monomer AA is dissolved in DES to form a clear solution46. After that, the betaine as zwitterion, and Irgacure 2959 as the photoinitiator are dissolved in the solution to prepare the CEAB precursor. The precursor solution consists of ChCl, EG, AA, and betaine in a molar ratio of 2:4:4:1, and the weight percentage of Irgacure 2959 is 0.1% (Fig. 1a). The transparent precursor (Supplementary Fig. S1b) is then cast between two pieces of Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) supporting films, covered by a flat glass mold, different forces are exerted on the surface to generate precursor layer with different thickness. Upon polymerization of the precursor using UV light (365 nm, 10 W power, 5 min), the resulting CEAB gel serves as an adhesive and stretchable dry electrode for capturing epidermal biopotentials such as ECG, EMG, and EEG (Fig. 1d).
The thickness of the CEAB film is influenced primarily by two main factors: the magnitude and duration of pressure. Ensuring proper duration of pressure facilitates precursor diffusion between the PET films, subsequently impacting the film's thickness post-photopolymerization. Precursor diffusion largely completes within 5 minutes under free load, as evidenced in Supplementary Movie 1. Therefore, we set the pressure duration to 5 minutes. Figure 2a demonstrates that the CEAB film's thickness can be varied via the applied forces on the glass surface. Specifically, when controlling the pressure from 4109 to 0 Pa, the thickness is changed from 3.55 µm to approximately 46.9 µm. For films with a thickness surpassing 50 µm, we employ a molding strategy. This involves placing a spacer with a specific thickness between two glass plates and PET support films, followed by film removal post-curing. We coat the PET film's surface with silicone oil to ease the CEAB film's separation, a critical step for maintaining the structural integrity of sub-5µm freestanding samples52. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) and atomic force microscope (AFM) (Fig. 2b and 2c) both show the freestanding CEAB film's smooth morphology, indicating considerable macro-scale homogeneity. Moreover, the AFM height image reveals that the CEAB film's surface roughness remains below 10 nm (Fig. 2c and Supplementary Fig.S2). In comparison to traditional techniques, our pressure-diffusion approach can provide a broad film thickness control range and extensive surface homogeneity. Supplementary Fig. S3 further illustrates the self-adhesion of a 200 µm thick CEAB film on the palm, showcasing its capability to replicate complex, curved surfaces over large areas.
The 200 µm CEAB film demonstrates an impressive optical transmittance exceeding 95% between 400–800 nm wavelengths (Fig. 2d). This exceptional transmittance results from macroscopic averaging of compositional and structural factors. Furthermore, a QR code enveloped by this CEAB film remains effortlessly scannable, as depicted in the inset of Fig. 2d. Utilizing Attenuated Total Reflection-Fourier Transform Infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy, we delineate the characteristic peaks of the CEAB film and discern their interactions (Fig. 2e). CEAB film and EG show OH peak at 3307 cm− 1 and 3297 cm− 1, this redshift of OH group indicates the hydrogen bond formation53, which is a characteristic of DES. For CEAB, both the ν(C = O) of AA and betaine shift to higher wavenumbers, while ν(C-N) of betaine shift to lower wavenumbers, suggesting the formation of [N(CH3)3]+:[COO−] ion pairs50,54. Additionally, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA; Fig. 2f) confirms the film's exceptional temperature stability, with minimal weight loss (< 5%) until 82.5°C, and a decomposition temperature nearing 240°C, suitable for high demanding conditions. Concurrently, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) in Fig. 2g establishes that the CEAB's glass transition temperature (Tg) remains below − 60°C, underscoring its flexibility even at low temperatures. Supplementary Fig. S4 further demonstrates the flexibility of 2 mm thick CEAB film that it can be easily twisted at both 25 ℃ and − 30 ℃. Figure 2h reveals that, in contrast to Ag/AgCl hydrogel, the CEAB gel exhibits a weight increase of approximately 15% at 60% relative humidity (RH) and experiences minimal weight loss (below 5%) at 10% RH over 7 days. This result underscores the CEAB film's potential for effective epidermal moisture retention. Figure 2i details the temperature-dependent ionic conductivity within a range of -50 to 60°C. To determine the electrical conductivity (σ) of CEAB film, the formula σ = d/RS is employed, where d represents the gel thickness, S signifies the gel area, and R denotes the value where the plot intersects the Z' axis. As temperature ascends, CEAB exhibits enhanced conductivity; for instance, its conductivity registers as 1.69 × 10− 2, 1.33, and 8.18 mS·cm− 1 at temperatures of -25°C, 25°C, and 60°C respectively (Supplementary Fig. S5a). Besides, the ionic conductivity's temperature dependency follows with the Vogel − Fulcher − Tammann (VFT) relationship55, demonstrating a robust congruence between theory and empirical findings (Supplementary Fig. S5b). Such elevated conductivities arise from rapid proton migration within the CEAB at high temperatures, inferred from its composition. DES contains ionized components such as hydrogen donors and hydrogen acceptors, which offer more protons to increase the conductivity. In addition, the low melting point of DES contributes to the free mobility of the protons, thus providing high conductivity of CEAB.
Mechanical properties and self-healing ability
Mechanical properties akin to the skin are pivotal for the application of epidermal electrodes, serving as a seamless interface between skin and electronics14,15. To evaluate the mechanical attributes of the CEAB film, a uniaxial tensile setup is employed. The true stress-strain curve (Fig. 3a) of the CEAB film, varying in thickness, reveals strain-stiffening behaviors reminiscent of skin. This indicates the film presents a soft texture upon initial touch but swiftly stiffens, safeguarding against damage under elevated strains. Additionally, Young’s moduli of the CEAB films range from 3.23 to 59.74 kPa, aligning with values measured in the fibrous dermis (35–150 kPa) and the hypodermis (2 kPa)56. As delineated in Supplementary Table 2, Young’s modulus increases twentyfold as the film's thickness dwindles from 500 µm (3.23 kPa) to 3.55 µm (59.74 kPa). This enhancement stems from denser cross-linking for thinner precursors under identical UV exposure durations. Impressively, the CEAB film can stretch approximately 800% (engineering strain) of its original length without exhibiting discernible mechanical failure, a capability aligning well with on-skin electronics requirements, given that skin typically endures a maximum strain of around 30%56.
CEAB gel demonstrates rapid self-healing attributes, which meet the requirement of an ideal epidermal electrode that self-recovers from external mechanical damage. As depicted in Fig. 3b, the scar on the CEAB film vanishes entirely within 10 minutes at room temperature, with bubbles near the scar dissipating within 8 hours (Supplementary Movie 2). This self-healing process is attributed to the electrostatic interaction in betaine, reversible H-bonds in ChCl, EG, and polyacrylic acid, facilitating polymer chain diffusion at the interfaces. To assess CEAB film's self-adhesion on porcine skin, a 90° peeling experiment is conducted, as illustrated in Fig. 3c. Within a thickness range from 3.55 µm to 500 µm, the CEAB exhibits a peeling interface toughness ranging between 5–20 J/m2, demonstrating strong adhesive capability for artifact-resistant epidermal electrical signal collection during movement. Supplementary Fig. S6a-d further verifies the strong adhesion to plastic tubes, paper, PET film, and rubber gloves respectively. Concurrently, the 500 µm CEAB film demonstrates a shear strength of 63 kPa on the porcine skin (Fig. 3d), translating to a maximal shear force of 12.60 N—70 times of the 90° peel force (0.18N). Despite its superior adhesive qualities, the CEAB film allows for effortless and comfortable removal, as depicted in Fig. 3e. Unlike conventional tapes (3M VHB) that often induce discomfort due to excessive adhesion and residual islands, the CEAB film ensures a user-friendly detachment.
Conformability and biocompatibility
CEAB films demonstrate remarkable conformability across diverse rough surfaces. Two primary factors influencing a material's conformability are its Young’s modulus and thickness; a decrease in both parameters enhances the material's ability to conform to irregular surfaces57. Supplementary Fig. S7a-d reveal that both 50 µm and 200 µm CEAB films adhere tightly to human skin due to their ultrasoft nature, fostered by hydrogen bonding on both the electrode-skin boundary and internal electrode, as well as weak electrostatic interactions in the electrode. These CEAB films readily accommodate skin deformations, such as stretching and squeezing. In Supplementary Fig. S8a-c, a 50 µm CEAB film affixed to the dorsal hand synchronizes with skin movements seamlessly—elongating upon stretching and forming wrinkles similar to skin creases during compression. In contrast, a 50 µm PET adhesive tape partially loses contact with the skin, failing to emulate the skin's subtle wrinkles due to modulus disparities between the skin and the PET film. Additionally, the 50 µm CEAB film exhibits conformal adhesion to fruit peels, including apples and avocados, as depicted in Supplementary Fig. S9, whereas PET tape demonstrates partial attachment from these fruit surfaces.
Besides, since the geometry of the glyphic patterns at hands varies at the different locations, 3.55 µm and 200 µm thick CEAB film are attached to different regions of the hand to investigate the local texture conformability, including distal phalanges, proximal phalanges, metacarpophalangeal, and palm. Silicon rubber is used as the human hand replica, and bare skin without an attached electrode is captured to demonstrate the primitive morphology. As depicted in Fig. 4a, with 3.55 µm thick CEAB film covering the surface, glyphic lines on proximal phalanges and metacarpophalangeal, including primary, secondary, tertiary, and even quaternary lines can be distinguished under the optical microscope. Additionally, the 3.55 µm thick CEAB film precisely conforms to the ridges and valleys, revealing fine structures including dense and directionally varying grooves, as well as irregular elevations between furrows with high resolution. The intimate contact between the fingerprint replica and 3.55 µm CEAB film is further investigated using SEM (Fig. 4b), which reveals a secure adherence of the 3.55 µm CEAB film to the fingerprint replica, indicating distinct ridges and valleys with no detectable formation of air gaps. However, as the thickness of the CEAB film increases to 200 µm, the ability to discern fine structures such as grooves and papules is restricted due to a size mismatch; specifically, the depth between ridges and valleys is typically less than 60 µm58. Nonetheless, covered by the 200 µm CEAB film, the ridges, and valleys on the distal phalanges and palm remain discernible due to their ultrasoft mechanical properties. In agreement with optical images, ridges, and valleys can be discerned on the metacarpophalangeal replica covered by 200 µm CEAB film, with no observable air gaps due to the ultrasoft mechanical properties.
The cytotoxicity assay with NIH3T3 cells proves the biocompatibility of CEAB gel that is suitable for on-skin applications (Fig. 4c). As depicted in Fig. 4d, for both the control group and the CEAB-conditioned group, NIH3T3 fibroblasts exhibit a flattened morphology after 12-hour incubation, followed by the development of fine cytoplasmic extensions after 24 hours of incubation. The water vapor transmission ability of CEAB film is compared with common interactive materials for human-machine interface substrates, such as PDMS and Parylene. After 5 days, CEAB had nearly 50% water vapor transmission, while PDMS and PET only had 10% or less water vapor transmission (Fig. 4e). This indicates that CEAB film, as a wearable electrode material, will not block the skin surface and affect skin respiration. We summarize the overall comparison of our CEAB film with the most representative ionic gels in Supplementary Table 3.
Electrode/skin contact impedance and epidermal biopotential detection
The electrode/skin contact impedance within 1 h of the CEAB electrode is measured in the frequency range of 1-104 Hz. The CEAB electrode shows stable electrode/skin contact impedance (Supplementary Fig. S10a). The average electrode/skin impedance with 1 h of CEAB electrode is much lower than the commercial Ag/AgCl gel electrode, i.e., 284.259 kΩ, 1873.981 kΩ for the former and 337.698 kΩ, 2450.774 kΩ for the latter at 100 Hz and 10 Hz, respectively (Supplementary Fig. S10b). Stable and lower electrode/skin contact impedance contributes to high-quality biopotential acquisition. The wearable 200 µm CEAB electrodes are employed to investigate epidermal ECG, EMG, and EEG. Figure 1d illustrates two CEAB electrodes attached to a volunteer's chest for ECG signal recording. Notably, rhythm-related parameters—including P, Q, R, S, and T waves—are distinctly identifiable in both static and dynamic states, crucial for clinical diagnoses59, as shown in Fig. 5a. In contrast, the Ag/AgCl gel electrode exhibits higher noise levels and unstable peaks during motion. Benefitting from its robust adhesion and conformability, the CEAB electrode has superior signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) of 32.7 dB and 29.9 dB in static and dynamic states, respectively, surpassing the 28.0 dB and 18.8 dB of the Ag/AgCl gel electrode, as depicted in Fig. 5b. This performance underscores the CEAB electrode's resilience against motion artifacts.
Additionally, to capture muscle biopotentials, two CEAB electrodes are affixed to the forearm as working electrodes, while one is placed on the elbow as a reference electrode. By sustaining a grip force of 50 N, we assess the SNR and noise level of CEAB electrodes during EMG signal acquisition. Figure 5c illustrates the noise analysis using RMS (root mean square) on baseline signals acquired during rest periods. The average noise level of the CEAB electrode (21.7 µV) is reduced by 33.6% over the 3.5 h monitoring period compared to the Ag/AgCl gel electrode (32.7 µV). Furthermore, the CEAB electrodes consistently outperform Ag/AgCl gel electrodes in SNR, averaging 12.5 dB—a 48.9% improvement over the 18.7 dB of the Ag/AgCl gel electrodes. This evidence solidifies that CEAB electrodes offer superior noise reduction and enhanced SNR compared to commercially available Ag/AgCl gel electrodes. Subsequent tests involving varied grip forces of 50 N, 320 N, and 650 N confirm that EMG signals remain distinguishable, aligning with the Ag/AgCl gel electrodes (Fig. 5d). Notably, the CEAB electrode captures more stable EMG signals with minimal baseline fluctuations, demonstrating superior reliability. Supplementary Fig. S11 further illustrates that CEAB electrodes effectively differentiate EMG signals across various hand gestures, essential for human-machine interface applications. Coincidently, Supplementary Movie 3 further demonstrates the EMG signals of the forearm during various single-finger and hand movements.
The facial muscles typically exhibit non-uniform distribution, and facial skin is prone to wrinkles development with facial expressions, undergoing substantial deformation60. Acquiring stable and high-quality facial EMG signals using flexible electrodes with excellent conformality remains a significant challenge. To ascertain the efficacy of CEAB electrodes as proficient facial EMG electrodes, we collect facial EMG data during volunteers' smiling episodes, with Ag/AgCl gel electrodes serving as a reference. As illustrated in Fig. 5e, both electrodes demonstrate the capability to capture signals of good quality during volunteer smiles. However, the CEAB electrodes exhibit lower baseline noise. Throughout the entire data-acquisition process, the signals acquired by the CEAB electrodes have consistent baseline noise levels. In contrast, with an increasing time of smiles, substantial noise emerges between adjacent peaks for the Ag/AgCl gel electrode after 4 seconds. This occurrence can be attributed to the wrinkles induced by smiling, leading to motion artifacts between the Ag/AgCl gel electrode and the skin surface. The superior stretching ability and Young's modulus comparable to that of the skin of CEAB film facilitate accurate EMG signal acquisition, particularly during facial motion.
Given the CEAB electrode's superior resistance to motion artifacts, minimal baseline noise, and enhanced SNR compared to Ag/AgCl gel electrodes, we utilize it for long-term EEG recordings on a volunteer, spanning up to 12 hours. Throughout this long duration, the volunteer is engaged in varied activities, including sleep, exercise, and relaxation. Notably, the quality of EEG signals remains consistent, even when the volunteer perspires during physical activities. Figure 5f illustrates three distinct EEG signals corresponding to different mental states: heightened activity during exercise and reduced activity during sleep. By employing fast-Fourier transformation (FFT), we segment the EEG brainwaves into specific frequency bands: δ (0-2.5 Hz), θ (3.5–6.75 Hz), α (7.5-11.75 Hz), β (13–30 Hz), and γ (31–50 Hz)61. The β waves, are associated with increased energy levels and can reflect the degree of mental concentration and physical involvement62,63. Then we extract the β wave from the signal and compare the discrepancy. As depicted in Fig. 5g, the intensity of β wave during exercise state is much stronger than that at rest or sleep status, which accords with the fact that β usually increases during physical exertion.
Clinical detection and depression detection
The knee jerk reflex is classified as a monosynaptic stretch reflex. In clinical settings64, tendon reflex examinations are commonly employed to assess the circuit integrity of the stretch reflex arc and to evaluate motor neuron functionality. To diagnose spinal pathway function, we affix CEAB electrodes to a healthy volunteer's thigh muscle. Consistent with hospital tests, when the kneecap is tapped with a small hammer, the CEAB electrodes capture a rapid surge in muscle electrophysiological activity, as depicted in Fig. 6a. This observation aligns with findings from clinical studies and literature. Moreover, the CEAB electrodes monitor voluntary thigh muscle contractions during leg extensions. Unlike the knee-jerk reflex, these stronger contractions manifest larger amplitudes and prolonged durations due to the engagement of multiple motor units, resulting in more pronounced motor unit action potentials, as illustrated in Fig. 6b.
Depression is a severe mental disorder characterized by persistent feelings of sadness and potential suicidal tendencies65,66. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), as of 2023, over 264 million people globally are afflicted with depression, underscoring the urgency for early diagnosis and intervention67. Given EEG‘s ability to provide a direct reflection of brain neurological activity with high temporal resolution, EEG is increasingly recognized as a potent tool for non-invasive depression diagnosis68,69. Utilizing the CEAB electrode, we have designed a machine-learning approach to analyze single-channel EEG data of subjects at rest state, facilitating swift and reliable depression diagnosis, as depicted in Fig. 6c-f. Specifically, real-time data collection is conducted, followed by preprocessing with Python 3.8. EEG signals inherently display temporal variability and dynamics, and different frequency components correspond to different temporal and physiological states70. To build extensive training datasets for machine learning, we segment the EEG data into 2-second intervals, incorporating a 50% overlap to capture the intricate and dynamic attributes of EEG effectively (Fig. 6c). This windowing strategy has been demonstrated to encapsulate relevant information across varied EEG types, thereby enhancing classification outcomes71. Our dataset encompasses 633 samples, balanced between healthy and depression-afflicted samples. As showcased in Fig. 6d, we apply FFT to the original EEG signals, delineating frequency bands and deriving eSense values via NeuroSky's algorithm72,73. This algorithm can express the mental state information (attention and meditation) of the human brain with eSense values. Then we extract two distinct feature categories from the EEG data: linear attributes, including Variance, Absolute Power, Mean, and Coherence, juxtaposed against nonlinear attributes like Entropy and C0-Complexity74(Fig. 6e). Linear features contain signal specificity, whereas nonlinear attributes underscore intricacy and stability74. Subsequently, these features are concatenated and then input into a range of classifiers, namely Supporting Vector Machine (SVM)75, K-Nearest Neighbor (KNN)76, XGBoost77, and Random Forest (RF)78 for depression detection (Fig. 6f). As illustrated in Table 1, the RF performs the best accuracy of 92.91%, recall of 92.91%, and precision of 93.19% on test dataset. Figure 6g further illustrates the confusion matrix of RF models on depression prediction.
Table 1
Machine Learning model results.
| KNN | XGBoost | SVM | RF |
Precision | 89.78% | 89.78% | 69.28% | 93.19% |
Recall | 89.76% | 89.76% | 69.29% | 92.91% |
F1 score | 89.77% | 89.77% | 69.28% | 92.91% |
To delve deeper into understanding feature contributions for predicting depression, we employed the Gini importance method within scikit-learn for enhanced feature analysis79. Utilizing the RF model, individual feature importance is computed and graphically depicted in Supplementary Fig. S12. The histogram highlights four paramount features: mean attention, standard deviation σ, mean of the low γ band, and mean of the δ band (Supplementary Fig. S13a-d). Approximately 80% of individuals with depression exhibit diminished attention compared to healthy counterparts. Furthermore, ~ 20% of samples manifest higher σ, where higher variance indicates greater emotion change among subjects with depression80. Notably, the low γ band's sensitivity to emotional nuances indicates a trend that a majority of depression patients register elevated low γ values, thereby identifying these metrics as potential depression biomarkers81,82. Additionally, over 80% of depression samples have lower mean δ values, which is correlated to heightened psychological distress, potentially amplifying depression vulnerability83. Leveraging CEAB electrodes, we build a single-channel RF model finding digital depression biomarkers. EEG with CEAB electrodes offers an efficient, user-friendly, and feasible solution for depression detection via a single-channel wearable EEG headband.
Hand gesture replication by robotic hands
Hand gestures play a pivotal role in conveying concise messages and carrying emotional implications, making them essential in both realistic and digital communication, especially within human-machine interaction applications84. While traditional methods of gesture sensing and recognition primarily depend on algorithms to semantically interpret images or videos85–88, they often face challenges due to environmental interferences such as obstructed objects and varying lighting conditions89. Unlike traditional methods, EMG, which captures signals before muscle contraction, provides a robust solution for hand gesture recognition without interference from external environmental factors90. We utilize CEAB electrodes to record forearm EMG signals from volunteers performing six distinct hand gestures. The captured signals are subsequently combined with sophisticated algorithms and embedded techniques to instruct robotic arms to mimic the recorded hand movements.
Firstly, we collect an EMG dataset of different gestures from volunteers, encompassing categories of "rest", "six", "eight", "good", "yeah", "ok", and "fist". These samples are carefully segmented into intervals with 1000 data points with a 95% overlap, strategically designed to augment the dataset and encapsulate essential biopotential information related to gesture motion. Subsequently, we establish a two-layer Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) model tailored for efficient gesture classification. Figure 7a provides a visual representation of this CNN model's architecture. The analysis begins by reshaping the input data into a 2D array, followed by convolutional and pooling layers to extract pertinent features. The following steps include flattening and deploying dense layers to achieve multi-label classification. Figure 7b presents the confusion matrix results for gesture recognition, where the predicted and actual type counts are consistent, differing only in one or two instances. The training loss and accuracy are shown in Supplementary Fig. S14, highlighting the model's gesture recognition capabilities. Our results achieve 99.78% for precision, recall, and accuracy due to larger signal differences (Supplementary Fig. S11b) captured by CEAB electrodes among various gestures.
Subsequently, we utilize the algorithm to recognize gestures and instruct the robotic arms to replicate human gestures. Upon feeding the forearm biopotential data of various gestures into the trained models, the system returns a predicted label in approximately 150 ms. This label is then relayed to the robotic arm, instructing it to execute the corresponding gesture. To account for the time delay required for the robotic arm's movement, we set an appropriate delay before accepting the subsequent EMG input. Figure 7c-e demonstrates the hand gestures replication by the robotic arm. Details of forearm biopotential driving the robotic arm to imitate human gestures can be found in Supplementary Movie 4.