This longitudinal study conducted on a population basis demonstrated a notable association between post-breast cancer diagnosis depression and extended-term mortality among 5-year cancer survivors (CS). Notably, this research is the initial one to illustrate that depression subsequent to a breast cancer diagnosis is correlated with a heightened probability of mortality, especially non-cancer-related mortality, among 5-year CS in Korea.
Our finding of a significant association between post-breast cancer depression and increased mortality among 5-year cancer survivors is in line with previous evidence on the adverse impact of depression on cancer prognosis. A meta-analysis of 31 prospective studies found a 25% higher mortality rate among cancer patients experiencing depressive symptoms and a 39% increased mortality rate in individuals diagnosed with major depression, even after accounting for prognostic factors.[22] However, these meta-analyses faced limitations due to significant heterogeneity stemming from different cancer types.[23] Additionally, considering breast cancer's hormone-dependent nature, its reaction to mental health conditions might differ from that of other cancers.[5] A systematic analysis of 17 studies involving 282,203 breast cancer patients revealed that depression was linked to cancer recurrence [1.24 (1.07, 1.43)], all-cause mortality [1.30 (1.23, 1.36)], and cancer-specific mortality [1.29 (1.11, 1.49)].[5] However, most of these studies were conducted in Western countries, and few studies have examined the effect of depression on non-cancer-related mortality in breast cancer survivors. Our study is the first to demonstrate that depression after a breast cancer diagnosis is associated with a higher risk of non-cancer-related mortality among 5-year cancer survivors in Korea.
Currently, evidence on the association between depression and breast cancer mortality is limited to observational and genetic studies. One study in the UK Biobank cohort found that post-diagnostic use of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), a common antidepressant medication, was associated with a 27% increase in breast cancer mortality, but this association was largely attenuated when restricting to patients with prior depression or comparing to other antidepressant medications.[24] This study suggested a possible causal relationship between depression and breast cancer mortality, but also highlighted the potential confounding by indication. A randomized trial involving 125 women with metastatic breast cancer (MBC) revealed cortisol dysregulation in MBC patients compared to controls, predicting shorter survival.[8] This study suggests that irregular cortisol patterns in both MBC and depression may indicate an inadequate response to inflammation related to cancer. By disrupting cortisol regulation, tumors using inflammatory mediators may cause resistance to glucocorticoids, but addressing depression could potentially break this cycle, relieving related symptoms.[25] While these studies have demonstrated a biological link between depression and breast cancer mortality, but the evidence is limited to specific regions of the North American and European populations. Shim et al. (2020) discovered that depression and anxiety disorders, as studied using Korean NHIS data, heightened the risk of breast cancer mortality, particularly non-cancer-related death, and that antidepressant treatment attenuated the risk. Moreover, this effect was independent of sociodemographic and clinical factors.[26]
Depression may increase non-cancer-related deaths after breast cancer diagnosis through various biological mechanisms, such as metabolic, immuno-inflammatory, autonomic and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA)-axis dysregulations.[27] Breast cancer patients who have negative coping styles may suffer from chronic stress-induced immune dysregulation, impairing the body’s ability to cope with stress, infections, and chronic diseases, thereby resulting in increased morbidity and mortality.[28] Psychiatric patients with physical ailments might experience higher non-cancer-related mortality and reduced specificity in cancer-related issues owing to inadequate adherence to treatments and unhealthy behaviors.[29, 30] In Korea, where cancer is the leading cause of death, depression and anxiety are common among breast cancer patients and survivors, but often underdiagnosed and undertreated.[31] The Korean health system provides universal coverage for cancer treatment, but the access to and quality of mental health care and support systems for health and social welfare are still inadequate.[32, 33] Our study of the Korean cohort further extends evidence on the long-term mortality impact of post-breast cancer diagnosis depression among 5-year cancer survivors, highlighting the need for screening and treating depression in breast cancer patients, especially in Asian populations where depression may be overlooked and undertreated.
The strengths of our study stand out, which encompassed analyses of a large and representative study population linked to the Korean NHIS and death registry data to capture not only the diagnosis of depression and health service utilization, but also the cause and date of death. Moreover, we were able to address a diverse set of confounders for sociodemographic factors, health status, health behavior, comorbidities, and clinical characteristics for adjustment and stratified analyses to minimize potential bias in the analyses.
Limitations
Our study has several limitations. First, we did not have information on the type and duration of antidepressant medication used by the breast cancer survivors with depression. Instead, we only used the diagnosis of depression from the NHIS database as an indicator of antidepressant use. Nonetheless, previous studies have shown that antidepressant medication can reduce the risk of mortality in breast cancer patients with depression. Second, we did not account for the severity of the disease, duration since diagnosis, and the specific treatment undergone by the women with breast cancer. These variables also affect the depression levels of these patients. [34] Thus, the validity of our findings is limited by these confounding factors. However, we tried to reduce the effect of deaths caused by this factor by selecting only 5-year survivors for our study. A meta-analysis of 76 prospective studies with 105 samples showed that depression’s impact on mortality is independent of the disease stage in cancer patients.[35] Third, it should be noted that our study measured depression only once at the baseline. Therefore, whether the breast cancer survivors in our cohort had persistent or recurrent depression during the follow-up period remains unknown. Nonetheless, our results showed a significant association between depression and mortality, especially non-cancer-related mortality, in breast cancer survivors. This finding is consistent with previous studies that reported a higher risk of death from cardiovascular diseases, respiratory diseases, and suicide in breast cancer patients with depression.