RMD, one of the special clinical phenotypes of caveolinopathies, was first described in a family with an involuntarily rolling contraction of the muscles induced by mechanical stimuli in 1975, and the first pathogenic variant in the CAV3 gene was identified in five families with autosomal-dominant RMD until 2001 [12, 13]. Thereafter, an increasing number of pathogenic mutations in the CAV3 gene have been found out. In this study, we reported a heterozygous missense mutation of c.80G>A (p.R27Q) in exon 1 of the CAV3 gene in a Han Chinese family with RMD. Previously, such variation has also been documented in patients with distal myopathy, LGMD1C, benign hyperCKemia, and overlapping muscle disease phenotypes [9, 14–16]. Although R27Q mutation is not unusual, it has been rarely reported in Chinese family with RMD.
To our knowledge, RMD is featured by signs of muscle hyperexcitability, including percussion-induced rapid contraction, muscle mounding, and electrically silent muscle contractions (rippling muscle), resulting in muscle stiffness, pain, and cramps. Apart from hyperexcitable symptoms of skeletal muscle, moderate hyperCKemia, mild muscle atrophy, and distal muscle weakness are also frequent in patients with RMD [6, 9, 17, 18]. Moreover, some infrequent symptoms, such as toe walking, easy fatigability, and proximal weakness, have also been noted in RMD [19, 20]. RMD therefore overlaps with other clinical phenotypes, and there is no significant correlation between genotype and phenotype of caveolinopathies [21, 22]. The same pathogenic variant can give rise to heterogeneous clinical phenotypes and histopathologic changes, even in individuals within the same family. In this study, the proband and his mother presented with RMD, which was initially noticed during their childhood or adolescence, accompanied with increased level of serum CK. Muscle weakness and atrophy of four limbs remain absent in those two patients so far. Based on the WES and co-segregated analysis, a pathogenic c.80G>A mutation in the CAV3 gene was identified in this family, showing an autosomal dominant inheritance. The clinical presentations can be classified as isolated RMD, without overlapping syndrome. After carefully checking the first generation’s medical information, we were not difficult to notice that the proband’s grandfather had increased serum CK. In spite of failing to obtain blood samples from the first generation for further genetic analysis, we speculate that the proband’s grandfather may carry the same pathogenic variant in CAV3 gene, resulting in asymptomatic hyperCKemia instead of RMD. This observed intrafamilial phenotypic variability suggests that other genetic modifiers may exist.
CAV3 consists of 151 amino acids and contains three separate domains. The N’- and C’-terminal portions are exposed to the cytoplasm and the middle hydrophobic portion is inserted into the lipid bilayer in the form of a hairpin loop [7, 23]. The caveolin scaffolding domain, located at the juxta membrane part of the N’-terminal cytoplasmic tail, is associated with many signaling pathways and aggregates caveolins into larger assemblies. Nine CAV3 monomers assemble to make up a toroidal shape complex, leading to membrane invagination into pits, the so-called caveolae [24]. CAV3 has been shown to play crucial roles in muscle development and repair, energy metabolism, lipid metabolism, T tubule system, regulation of potassium channel and adrenergic receptors, and mitochondrial homeostasis [7]. Arg27 is located at the highly conserved amino acid sequences of N’-terminal portion. Previous studies have confirmed that c.80G>A (p.R27Q) mutation in the CAV3 gene, also previously reported as R26Q, leaded to dysfunction of caveolins. First and foremost, CAV3 R27Q mutation increases the Triton solubility and oligomeric state of CAV3 and decreases the steady-state expression levels of CAV3, resulting in intracellular retention of CAV3 in Golgi compartment and reduced expression of CAV3 at the surface of the sarcolemma [25]. In the absence of CAV3, dysferlin is rapidly endocytosed and membrane repair is compromised [26]. Furthermore, such mutation is linked with deregulations in distinct signaling pathways. CAV3 R27Q myotubes are unable to assemble sufficient amounts of functional caveolae at the sarcolemma, contributing to uncoupling the regulation of IL6/STAT3 signaling with mechanical stress [27]. Surface biotinylation experiments show that CAV3 R27Q mutation decreases epidermal growth factor signaling and the internalization of TrkA [28]. Those signaling pathways are important for the development and maintenance of the neuromuscular junction as well as muscle development and regeneration [29, 30].
Regarding the muscle pathology of caveolinopathy, routine stains usually reveal abnormal findings with nonspecific changes, such as disseminated atrophic fibers, some fibers with internal nuclei, foci of degeneration with necrosis and phagocytosis, proliferation of endomysial and perimysial connective tissue, and variation in fiber size [31, 32]. Furthermore, typical dystrophic changes with numerous endomysial inflammatory infiltration in the muscle fibers have been rarely described [32, 33]. Although most immunohistochemical studies demonstrated reduced immunoreaction of CAV3, a quarter of patients had normal expression of CAV3 along the surface of sarcolemma that may increase the probability of misdiagnosis for clinician [34]. In our study, we just found slight variation in fiber size and increased numbers of internal nuclei in the muscle fibers, without obvious atrophy. Hence, it is sometimes difficult to distinguish caveolinopathy from other myopathies by pathology alone.
Previously, the majority of patients with RMD demonstrated normal skeletal muscle imaging. Nevertheless, abnormal skeletal MRI features have been rarely described in patients with caveolinopthies [22, 35, 36]. In previous reports of patients with RMD, peripheral rectus femoris and semitendinosus muscles are commonest affected, presenting significant fatty infiltration with a symmetrical distribution on T1-weighted spin echo [22, 34]. Peripheral rectus femoris involvement in a ring-shaped pattern appears to be specific for this disorder. In addition, some patients had more extensive high T1W signal intensities, involving in the semimembranosus, biceps femoris, gracilis, adductor longus, and gastrocnemius muscles [22]. It is worth noting that the muscle MRI of the proband did not reveal fatty replacement or atrophy. However, axial STIR sequences disclosed symmetric and patchy hyperintensities in bilateral semimembranosus, semitendinosus, biceps femoris long head, and sartorius muscles. After retrospectively scanned the muscle biopsy, we could not find any inflammatory infiltration or necrosis. We therefore speculate that these STIR hyperintensities might be linked with muscle oedema. As far as we know, STIR hyperintensity on muscle MRI has been previously described in only one patient with asymptomatic hyperCKemia caused by the CAV3 gene mutation [37].
Several limitations need to be emphasized in our study. Firstly, we fail to obtain the informed consent of the proband’s mother for conducting muscle MRI and biopsy examinations. Whether there are heterogeneous muscle MRI findings and histopathologic changes between individuals within this family are unknown. Secondly, absent genetic testing of the first generation has an influence on exploring the relationship between genotype and phenotype. Finally, long-term clinical and radiological follow-up for our patients has not been included in this study. To better evaluate the progression of muscle symptoms and the changes of abnormal signal intensity on muscle MRI, a multicenter study with larger sample sizes should be further performed.
In conclusion, we identified a heterozygous missense mutation of c.80G>A (p.R27Q) in the CAV3 gene in a Han Chinese family, which is associated with hereditary RMD. RMD can overlap with other clinical phenotypes. Early recognition of special clinical phenotypes plays important role in timely diagnosis of caveolinopathies. Regarding muscle MRI features of RMD, this study first reports STIR hyperintensity in the thighs, which may be linked with muscle oedema.