Here, we present a series of eight patients who were followed up since the onset of their first symptoms at the largest pediatric hospital in Brazil. We analyzed the clinical, neuropsychological, and land genetic profiles of these patients, as well as their familial characteristics.
Ataxia is a cardinal and frequent symptom of NPC [16]. Previous studies have reported improvements in ataxic symptoms following the initiation of miglustat treatment [17]. However, in our study, only one patient showed sustained stabilization of their condition. The other two initially stabilized and then exhibited sequential progressive worsening. Given the small sample size, attributing this medication stabilization solely to transience is challenging and may represent an individual characteristic of this sample.
Neuroimaging in patients with NPC reveals a variable pattern, with some individuals showing normal results, whereas others exhibit the most common changes, such as cortical and cerebellar atrophy [18]. The accumulation of lipid substrates within neurons leads to structural changes, including the formation of meganeurites, axonal distension, spheroid formation in axons, and ectopic dendritogenesis. Certain brain regions, such as the cerebellum, brain stem, hippocampus, and basal ganglia, are notably more affected in NPC, resulting in neuroaxonal dystrophy due to ganglioside accumulation [19]. These neuronal changes become evident during neuroimaging examinations as the disease progresses, manifesting as alterations in white matter integrity, myelination, and axonal integrity. Macroscopically, atrophy occurs in the cerebellum, thalamus, hippocampus, caudate, and cortical nucleus, which aligns with the MRI findings in the individuals in this study [20]. Consistent with previous studies, imaging changes are correlated with increased phenotypic severity, particularly ataxia and ocular motor function [18, 21]. These abnormalities may also be influenced by the patient’s genotype.
The Family Environment was evidenced as a structured and supportive family function, with better agreement between family members. This data is consistent with previous findings demonstrating a relationship between patient functioning and family agreement, which can influence the family's emotional state and prevent internal conflicts, especially during stressful events [22].
Cognitive and/or behavioral impairments were identified at different severities in all patients analyzed. Cognitive impairment is consistently observed in patients with NPC, and its extent is directly proportional to the patient's age and severity of clinical symptoms [5, 7]. The pathogenicity of the variant correlated with both greater clinical severity and cognitive impairment. Interestingly, even in milder variants, the cognitive impact increased with advancing age.
Psychotic symptoms are reported in approximately 25% of patients with NPC, although some studies have observed rates as high as 55% [23–25]. Notably, these patients often show resistance to antipsychotic medications, which may not be effective in managing these symptoms [26]. Moreover, behavioral symptoms commonly associated with frontal dysfunction, such as hyperactivity, social cognitive impairment, disinhibition, and impulsive behaviors, are most prevalent in patients with NPC [25]. Unlike cognitive impairment, the frequency of behavioral disorders did not increase in older patients despite signs of worsening as the disease progressed. Conversely, behavioral problems, especially those related to aggression, were predominantly reported in patients with the A1035V variant, indicating a potential relationship between the type of mutation and the observed behavioral disorders. Behavioral deterioration tends to occur in patients susceptible to this variant.
NPC exhibits a broad phenotypic spectrum, encompassing variations in the age of symptom onset, disease progression rate, severity, affected organs, impact on the central nervous system, and response to pharmacological treatments [27]. Moreover, the phenotypic expression of NPC can be influenced by factors such as the level of residual function of the defective protein and specific genetic variants involved. Cardinal symptoms primarily manifest as motor-related, behavioral, and psychiatric abnormalities that have a significant impact on the lives of patients and their families. Neurobehavioral and psychiatric manifestations, like phenotypic severity and neuroimaging abnormalities, correlate with the patient's genotype.
P1007A was initially described in Canadian patients [28] and represents one of the most common "variant" alleles [18, 29]. The P1007A mutation presents cellular changes typical of the so-called "variant biochemical phenotype," characterized by normal low-density‐lipoprotein (LDL)-induced cholesterol ester formation rate and minimal accumulation of non-esterified cholesterol in the vesicles [30]. A single P1007A allele is adequate for maintaining some degree of cholesterol trafficking, resulting in a variant phenotype typically diagnosed at a later age with lower biomarker levels [3, 30]. Despite the observed intrafamilial phenotypic variability in patients with homozygous P1007A variants, all patients had NPCCSS scores below 9, with the highest score recorded in a patient aged over 35 years.
A1035V appears as a relatively frequent allele in Portugal and Brazil [3, 30, 31]. A1035V is a conserved mutation that partially affects the level of mature mutant proteins, leading to a severe phenotype [32]. Typically, it manifests with a classical phenotype [3, 30].
Patients with compound heterozygosity for the A1035V and P1007A variants scored lower than 10; however, both patients experienced significant psychiatric and behavioral problems that were not identified in the other patients in this study. Psychotic symptoms and impulsivity are common manifestations of NPC [33]. Although these findings were primarily observed in patients with the A1035V variant, this may not necessarily indicate a direct correlation between psychiatric or behavioral symptoms and the A1035V variant. Instead, the milder clinical severity in patients with homozygous P1007A mutations or greater clinical severity in patients with loss-of-function or intronic variants could explain these findings.
Truncating mutations include nonsense, frameshift, and splice-site mutations [34], with one patient displaying a variant in the splice donor site in compound heterozygosity. Other variants of the splice donor site in intron 24 have been described in patients with NPC [29, 35]. All truncating mutations are severe [34]. In the case of patient (P5), who possessed both a mild and a severe variant, a moderate phenotype was observed.
Other truncating mutations, specifically L1230fs and Q991fs, were identified, both being uncommon variants resulting in loss of function. As presented in this study, patients with loss-of-function variants had more severe forms (neonatal and early childhood) [36], with an earlier age of onset and a higher NPCCSS score. Although the classical definition of a severe phenotype typically implies the presence of severe mutations in both alleles [34], the reported patients exhibited only one severe variant. This suggests that the presence of a single severe variant may be adequate for the development of an early and severe form of the disease.
Regarding family functioning, most analyzed families exhibited a typology characterized by a strong moral and religious structure, emphasizing ethical and religious values and issues within the family. This profile results from the condition of patients with NPC and can also be attributed to the cultural context in which these families are situated. Hispanics often rely significantly on religion as a vital support system for their families [37].
Despite its rarity, this study was constrained by a small sample size and the analysis conducted at a single site. Nevertheless, a comprehensive approach involving clinical, genetic, and psychological data contributes to a better understanding of this population.