Our research demonstrates the anti-diabetic and neuroprotective potential of Isatis tinctoria L. hydroalcoholic leaf extract for the first time. It shows that the effect of the extract on the reduction of protein glycation is significant. Additionally, IT extract inhibits alpha-glucosidase activity in a concentration dependent manner and AchE activity at some concentrations. We also show the results of preliminary in vivo safety studies and show that intraperitoneal administration of hydroalcoholic extract of IT leaf at doses from 50 mg/kg b.w. to 500 mg/kg, is most likely safe for the organism. Moreover, the tested extract has no cytotoxic properties, even at concentrations characterized by a strong reducing effect.
Neurodegenerative, cardiovascular, and metabolic diseases have a significant negative effect on the quality of life and life span of the aging population. The increased accumulation of damaged proteins is responsible for the formation of bulky aggregates and plaques typical of the aforementioned diseases. Type 2 DM is one of the most important risk factors responsible for age-related cognitive impairment [32]. The pathophysiology of AD is attributed to numerous factors such as cholinergic dysfunction, amyloid/tau toxicity and oxidative stress/mitochondrial dysfunction [33]. Interestingly, clinical evidence considers hyperglycemia to be one of the risk factors for the development and progression of AD [34]. Consequently, plant products that inhibit AchE activity, alpha-glucosidase activity, and protein glycation, in addition to exhibiting antioxidant properties, have anti-diabetic and neuroprotective potential.
Numerous medicinal herbs and dietary plants, containing polyphenols, were found to prevent protein glycation in in vitro studies [35–38]. The anti-glycating activity of many flavonoids, including quercetin, quercitrin, genistein, kaempferol, naringin, rutin, and propyl gallate, has been documented [39–44]. Phenolic acids could effectively protect BSA from glycation in vitro [45–48].
The IT extract we chose for our research contains many different compounds in various concentrations, including e.g.: vicenin-2 (7.51 mg/g), flavone-di-glucoside (6.42 mg/g), isovitexin (5.46 mg/g), stellarin-2 (4.69 mg/g), apigenin-di-glucoside (4.51 mg/g), apigenin-glucoside (4.68 mg/g), isoscoparin (3.89 mg/g), quercetin (1.86 mg/g), neochlorogenic acid (1.84 mg/g), sinapic acid (1.49 mg/g) and kaempferol (1.48 mg/g) [21]. Some of these compounds have proven anti-glycation and antioxidant activity; and an inhibitory effect on some enzyme activity, e.g. alpha-glucosidase or AchE. Despite the inhibition of protein glycation by the extract being less intense than the inhibition exerted by the main compounds (vicenin-2 and quercetin) of this extract at the tested concentrations, it is still detectable.
Earlier studies clearly demonstrate that the accumulation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs) in tissue is the leading cause of age-related degeneration, atherosclerosis, and diabetic complications such as neuropathy, retinopathy, cardiomyopathy, and nephropathy [49, 50]. Recent studies suggest that AGEs interact with specific receptors (RAGE) in the plasma membrane, modifying gene expression, changing intracellular signal transmission, and promoting the release of free radicals and pro-inflammatory molecules [51, 52]. Therefore, inhibition of AGE formation is a potential therapeutic target for preventing the progression of the aforementioned complications of diabetes and protecting against the development of age-related cognitive impairment and neurodegenerative disorders.
Alpha-glucosidase is an enzyme located in the digestive tract which is responsible for breaking down carbohydrates to facilitate the absorption of monosaccharides. Inhibition of alpha-glucosidase activity can reduce diabetic complications [53, 54], making its inhibition by the main compounds in IT, vicenin-2, quercetin, of great value [25]. In our study, IT leaf extract was more active than these compounds at almost all the tested concentrations. The inhibition of alpha-glucosidase shows the potential of IT extract in the management of hyperglycemic states, diabetes, obesity, and neurodegenerative diseases.
AchE plays a key role in the hydrolysis of acetylcholine in the regulation of cholinergic neurotransmission [55]. Inhibitors of this enzyme can delay the progress of mental illness, thus providing a rational therapeutic alternative in the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease. Our study shows that IT extract has a weak inhibitory effect on AchE. Vicenin-2 and quercetin also possess weak activity in this regard. The effect on AchE activity can be considered as an additional benefit of this extract in the management of neurodegenerative disorders.
A limitation of our study is the difficulty in drawing a direct comparison between the potency of the extract and the potency of the main compounds. For that reason, we consider the results to be preliminary, since the main compounds isolated from IT and the reference compounds (acarbose, tacrine) were used in molar concentrations so that their activity could be compared, which cannot be done for the extract.
Few in vivo studies showing the effects of various IT leaf extracts on the organism are presented in the literature [20, 24, 56, 57], and these mainly concern their anti-inflammatory effect. Moreover, most of the manuscripts focus on the in vitro activities of the various extracts of this plant with interesting therapeutic properties [15, 21, 58].
Oxidative stress is characteristic of many diseases including, type 2 diabetes mellitus, atherosclerosis, hypertension, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, major depression, Alzheimer's disease, inflammation, and cancer, making the development of effective antioxidant therapies of great importance [59]. Free radicals are oxidizing agents, causing tissue damage. Uncontrolled oxidative activity is the basis of various pathological conditions and can be countered by antioxidant treatment. Nonetheless, oxidants may exert beneficial effects by regulating cell signaling cascades [60]. In an in vitro study, we demonstrated the absence of cytotoxic activity by the tested extract on HT-22 cells, even at concentrations with significant reducing power. Subsequently, in plasma collected from animals, we determined the plasma reduction force by determining the reduction force of Fe3 + ions, which is interpreted as the total antioxidant force of plasma [61]. IT extract administered to mice at a dose of 500 mg/kg b.w. had a significant antioxidant effect one hour after a single intraperitoneal administration. This is an important property of the extract in vivo.
From the simple measurements of basal body weight after administration of the plant extract/compound, basic conclusions on the effects on the organism can be drawn. Since animals that feel somehow unwell after the administration of an agent have reduced locomotor activity [62, 63], and consume less food, they may lose significant body mass. Weight loss can also be the result of increased activity and calorie expenditure. It should be noted that such changes in the mice can be noticed in a short timeframe because they constantly consume food throughout the day [64]. Furthermore, it is worth noting that body weight is a dynamic parameter and that daily fluctuations, are within the range of approximately 2–3% (in control animals).
In our research, we measured body weight prior to and 24 hours after the administration of IT extract, weighed the amount of food consumed, and measured the influence on locomotor activity. The extract tested did not have a significant effect on mouse body weight. Interestingly, after administration of the extract at doses of 500 and 50 mg/kg b.w., a slight decrease in body weight was established. In all groups, the mice ate a similar amount of food within 24 h, that is, 20g/24h/6 mice ± 1 g. However, locomotor activity, after administration of the leaf extract at a dose of 50 mg/kg b.w., significantly decreased in comparison to the spontaneous activity determined in the control group. This observed decrease in activity could explain the slightly lower weight gain observed in this group after administration of the extract. A limitation of these studies is s the short time (5 minutes) allocated to determination of the effect of IT extract on spontaneous activity, therefore further studies should be carried out to monitor spontaneous activity for e.g., 24 hours after administration of the tested extracts. An interesting result is that IT extract only has a sedative effect at the lowest dose used. These differences in the effect on spontaneous activity may be attributed to the differences in the action of the compounds in the extract at different concentrations. At lower doses, certain compounds may have significant activity (sedation), whereas, at higher doses, other compounds may become active and suppress or counteract the effects of the compounds acting at lower doses.
In our previous research, we demonstrated that IT hydroalcoholic leaf extract can reduce stress-induced behavioral disturbances by regulation of neuro-nitrosative, neuro-oxidative, and neuroimmune pathways [24]. However, given the reports, some centrally acting compounds or drugs, e.g.: antidepressants, stress relievers, and anxiolytics, may negatively affect motor coordination [65, 66]. In view of this, we conducted preliminary safety studies to reduce the use of animals later on, since products that disturb motor coordination are excluded from further studies. The results obtained from the motor coordination tests clearly show that at the doses used, the IT extract does not significantly disturb the motor coordination of mice. However, it should be taken into account that at a dose of 100 mg/kg b.w., the extract significantly prolonged the time of exit of mice from the chimney compared to the time of exit from the chimney of the control mice - which suggests that at this dose, the activity of the compounds in the extract is the least safe. This coincides with the observations described in the earlier manuscript, where a dose of 100 mg/kg b.w. was considered the least favorable [24].
As part of the safety studies conducted, we also performed assays on plasma collected from animals to determine the activity of enzymes such as gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (gGT), alkaline phosphatase (AP), alanine aminotransferase (AlaT), and aspartate aminotransferase (AspaT). These were done to check the acute effect of the tested extracts on liver cells (liver integrity or hepatocellular damage).
Liver toxicity is one of the most common difficulties encountered in drug development. However only 43% of the toxicities seen in rodents are observed humans, as was established by a retrospective study on the toxicity of pharmaceuticals in development [67]. Enzymes synthesized in cells perform specific functions intracellularly, and few are secreted into the extracellular space. Each tissue has its own specific enzyme profile. The presence of intracellular enzymes in body fluids may indicate tissue damage (damage to the cell membrane – reversible, or cell breakdown - irreversible). The current best-practice recommendation for nonclinical safety assessment is that a minimum of four serum parameters is used to assess hepatocellular (a minimum of two markers) and hepatobiliary (a minimum of two markers) injury [68, 69]. Any two markers of glutamate dehydrogenase activity, sorbitol dehydrogenase activity, alanine transaminase activity, and aspartate transaminase activity, can be used to evaluate hepatocellular injury, whilst any two of gamma-glutamyl transferase activity, alkaline phosphatase activity, total bile acids and 5′-nucleotidase, total bilirubin can be used to assess hepatobiliary injury [70].
In our study, we determined the activity of four enzymes in plasma 60 minutes after administration of the test extract, similarly as other authors earlier [71]. After administration of the IT extract, only a significant increase in AP activity was determined in comparison to the activity determined for the control group. This difference was only observed at a dose of 100 mg/kg b.w. ip. Since plasma levels of AP increase as the patency of the bile duct is reduced, AP is widely used in nonclinical and human clinical settings as a marker of cholestatic liver injury [70]. In the absence of an increase in the other measured enzymes, especially gGT, hepatic disorders are excluded. It is known that fluctuations of AP need to be interpreted cautiously in nonclinical settings since there is an intestinal isoform of AP whose activity transiently increases postprandially [68].