CPV-2 infection is very common in dogs throughout the world. CPV-2 is categorized into 3 antigenic variants: CPV-2a, CPV-2b, and CPV-2c. These variants have different mutation frequencies and are found across the world [8–10]. The genomic substitution rate of CPV-2 is approximately 1 x 10− 4 substitutions per site per year [26]. Thus, although CPV-2 is a DNA virus, the rate at which variants are produced is similar to an RNA virus. Continued mutations of the CPV-2 genome may result in the emergence of a CPV-2 antigenic variant for which the current vaccine is no longer effective. Currently, none of the known CPV-2 antigenic variants has a negative impact on the vaccine efficacy. However, given the genetic diversity of CPV-2, it is important to continue tracking the presence of CPV-2 antigenic variants in dogs.
A number of countries have performed phylogenic analysis of CPV-2 based on the complete sequence of VP2. VP2 is the major structural protein that determines the antigenicity of CPV-2 [9, 27–29]. In Japan, phylogenic analysis of CPV-2 based on the complete sequence of VP2 has not been performed for over 10 years [30]. In addition, there is little information available on the complete sequence of VP2 in CPV-2 identified in Japan. We analyzed the complete sequence of VP2 to provide information about CPV-2 antigenic variants founds in Japan.
Our phylogenetic analysis showed that 2 of CPV-2a and 4 of CPV-2b formed the same cluster. In other words, we demonstrated that the two antigenic variants were related to one another. Similar findings have been reported in previous studies [31]. This suggests that the classification based on the difference in 426aa of VP2 may not be accurate for CPV-2. Studies have also identified this limitation. Thus, additional studies are needed to examine the accuracy of the CPV-2 antigenic variant classification [32, 33]. In addition, the amino acid sequence for VP2 in the 4 CPV-2b that were found in the cluster was similar to the sequence found in CPV-2b vaccines used in Europe, and the United States. In Australia and the United States, the VP2 amino acid sequence of CPV-2 found in clinical samples from dogs was shown to be identical to the CPV-2b vaccine strain [32]. To our knowledge, the CPV-2 vaccine based on the CPV-2b strain was available in Japan until February 2017. However, all samples in which the CPV-2b vaccine strain-like virus was detected were collected in March 2018. Based on the information shown in Table S1, these samples likely came from pups having the same mother. However, it remains unclear as to why the CPV-2b vaccine strain-like virus was identified from these pups. Future studies are needed to examine if a similar phenomenon occurs in other samples.
Our sequence analysis demonstrated that CPV-2b was the dominant variant in Japan. Among 146 strain of CPV-2b, 116 strain had the same complete sequence for VP2. CPV-2c strains are currently circulating in East and South-East Asian countries [16–22]. However, we demonstrated that none of the dogs in Japan was infected with CPV-2c. To our knowledge, among other Asian countries that conduct regular epidemiological studies of CPV-2, Japan remains the only country in which CPV-2c has not been detected. This could be attributed to various possible factors: 1) Import of CPV-2c-infected dogs to Japan is geographically challenging as Japan is isolated from countries where CPV-2c is prevalent, and 2) it is unlikely that dogs that enter Japan are infected with CPV-2c as they are strongly recommended to be vaccinated. Interestingly, CPV-2c has not been detected in New Zealand, which is an island country like Japan [34]. CPV-2c has been identified in wild carnivores such as leopard cats and the Asian palm civet [35, 36]. Thus, it is possible that dogs in countries where CPV-2c is prevalent may frequently come in contact with these wild carnivores. The CPV-2 vaccine efficacy tends to be lower against CPV-2c compared with other antigenic variants. Thus, epidemiological studies should be conducted regularly to ensure that CPV-2c outbreaks do not occur in Japan.
Our findings, as well as those of the previous study by Soma et al. [14], indicate that the dominant antigenic variant of CPV-2 in Japan has been CPV-2b for approximately 20 years since 2000. This is a rare phenomenon compared to other countries. Furthermore, VP2 of the dominant CPV-2b identified in the present study had the same amino acid sequence as CPV-2b identified in 2003 in Japan (AB128923; mistakenly registered as “CPV-2a” in Genbank). This suggests that the dominant CPV-2b in Japan underwent little to no antigenic drift for over 17 years. This phenomenon indicates that the vaccine used in Japan, which is based on the original CPV-2 sequence, may not be effective against dominant CPV-2b. Thus, it is important to determine whether dogs that have been vaccinated for CPV-2 have sufficient neutralizing antibodies against dominant CPV-2b, and consider the presence of maternally-derived antibodies at the time of vaccination. Recent studies in Australia indicate that the dominant antigenic variant is shifting from CPV-2a to CPV-2b [32]. While it remains unclear whether CPV-2b becomes dominant, it is important to continue monitoring the data from Australia.
In the present study, we analyzed samples collected from 2014 to 2019 in Japan and demonstrated that CPV-2b was the dominant antigenic variant. CPV-2 infections remain one of the most common infections among dogs in Japan. In order to eliminate CPV-2 infections, a number of steps need to be taken including improved vaccination, development of an appropriate vaccination protocol, and appropriate management of dogs. Moreover, in order to prevent CPV-2c outbreaks in Japan, it is important to ensure that dogs and cats that are imported to Japan have received vaccination against CPV-2 and to identify possible CPV-2 infections among wild carnivores. Epidemiological studies are important and should be performed regularly to prevent novel CPV-2 epidemics.