The observational cohort study examined the effects of tracheal intubation in the ER, specifically focusing on the outcomes of patients with STBI when administered by trauma surgeons and anesthesiologists. The study revealed no statistically significant differences in the duration of tracheal intubation, 1-min success rate of intubation, and complications related to intubation between the two groups. However, the time from admission to intubation was notably shorter in the TI group compared to the AI group. Furthermore, the TI group exhibited lower incidence of aspiration pneumonia and duration of mechanical ventilation compared to the AI group. Nonetheless, early intubation did not result in a significant reduction in hospital mortality.
Unconscious STBI patients frequently encounter glossoptosis, difficulties with swallowing, and loss of coughing reflexes. This can result in the ingestion of oral secretions, vomit, traumatic bleeding, or leakage of cerebrospinal fluid, leading to respiratory blockage and subsequent occurrences of hypoxemia and hypercapnia.5 Early management of hypoxemia and hypercapnia during the acute phase can prevent the development of secondary injury caused by pathological processes. The connection between elevated intracranial pressure resulting from STBI and hypoxemia creates a detrimental cycle.6 STBI results in cerebral edema and elevates intracranial pressure, consequently causing respiratory depression. Furthermore, it exacerbates hypoxemia, which progressively inflicts harm upon the brain cells and tissues. Consequently, cerebral edema once again occurs, intensifying intracranial pressure. At the same time, hypoxemia exacerbates the damage to cardiovascular and pulmonary tissues, resulting in hypotension and the onset of acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS).7 Hypoxemia leads to gastrointestinal mucosa erosion and bleeding, disruption of the intestinal mucosal barrier, bacterial invasion, and the translocation of endotoxins into the bloodstream. These processes trigger a cascade of systemic inflammatory mediators and inflict damage on the body through free radicals, ultimately leading to systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS). The consequences include extensive tissue injury and the development of multiple organ dysfunction syndromes (MODS). Research has been conducted to explore the adverse repercussions of hypoxemia in patients with STBI. 8–10
Airway management plays a pivotal role in the primary intervention of patients with STBI who experience respiratory distress. Tracheal intubation not only serves as the quickest and most efficient technique for ensuring airway openness, but also facilitates oxygenation, sustains proper ventilation, and minimizes the potential for aspiration.11 Acknowledging the significance of airway management, the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma (EAST) has issued guidelines outlining the early intubation considerations for trauma patients. The guidelines outline the necessity of tracheal intubation in situations including but not limited to: cardiac arrest, obstruction of the airway, extreme hemorrhagic shock, profound oxygen deficiency, inadequate ventilation, and severe cognitive impairment (GCS < 9).12 The GCS plays a crucial role in evaluating STBI, and a revised edition has been endorsed in the ATLS − 10.13 Early tracheal intubation is necessary for patients with STBI.14 In the past, the anesthesiologists were the ones who performed the intubations which were time-consuming till they got to ER. Therefore, the concept of training trauma surgeons emerged. The establishment of a training and certification mechanism, with the aim of enhancing the professional skills of trauma rescuers, led to the formation of China Trauma Care Training (CTCT) by the Chinese Medical Doctor Association and trauma surgeon section. Comparable to the American ATLS, the CTCT programs were organized nationwide, with the objective of advocating the implementation of the 'Chinese mode' within the trauma care system.15 The CTCT events were conducted consecutively nationwide with the goal of promoting the 'Chinese model' of the trauma care system. Tracheal intubation is an essential component of the CTCT training program. All the trauma surgeons at our trauma care center have completed the China Trauma Care Training and received certification from CTCT. Moreover, trauma surgeons have also received standardized training in tracheal intubation under the guidance of an experienced anesthesiologist. Consequently, they have acquired proficiency in rapid sequence induction and tracheal intubation techniques. This article is the first to investigate the impact of tracheal intubation carried out by trauma surgeons and anesthesiologists on patients with STBI. The results of this research suggest that there is no noteworthy discrepancy in intubation outcomes for STBI patients between trained trauma surgeons and anesthesiologists. Prompt intubation in the emergency room reduces the incidence of aspiration pneumonia and the duration of mechanical ventilation. While there is a lack of specific comparative studies between trauma surgeons and anesthesiologists in terms of tracheal intubation, comparative studies have been conducted between emergency physicians and anesthesiologists. Previously, a survey conducted in UK emergency departments revealed that nearly 80% of intubations were performed by anesthesiologists, while Dean Kerslake's study indicated that emergency physicians were responsible for performing nearly three-quarters of the intubations.16,17 During the 13-year analysis, emergency physicians achieved comparable laryngoscopic views but had slightly lower rates of initial intubation success compared to anesthesiologists. However, since 2007, any discrepancy in the initial success rate has become indiscernible for the first-time successful intubation (anesthesiologists at 88%, emergency physicians at 87%, p = 0.909). The data indicates that emergency physicians have improved their intubation skills following training, while anesthesiologists are increasingly involved in challenging intubation cases. The study revealed that approximately 95% of practitioners had completed a minimum of three months of formal training in anesthesia. This could account for the higher rate of successful intubation procedures observed among emergency physicians.17
Proficient airway management plays a pivotal role in emergency departments. Currently, emergency physicians employ rapid-sequence intubation to handle the majority of urgent intubations in such settings, boasting an impressive success rate of up to 99%.19,20 Due to the widespread utilization of video laryngoscopes and the implementation of standardized anesthesia intubation training, trauma surgeons have acquired proficiency in tracheal intubation techniques. Consequently, there are negligible disparities in both the success rate of intubation and the incidence of complications related to intubation, when compared to anesthesiologists. Trauma medical practitioners are well-acquainted with the significance of effective time management. When it comes to providing emergency care to critically injured patients, it is imperative to comprehend the correlation between priorities and time. The fundamental principle in traumatology can be summed up by the adage "time is life, time is speed", which underscores the crucial requirements of this field.21,22 For patients experiencing severe trauma, prompt intubation performed by the trauma surgeon facilitates immediate airway protection and mitigates the risks of hypoxemia and hypercapnia.
This study found no statistically significant disparities in hospital mortality rates between the two cohorts of patients with STBI. Various factors, including age, admission GCS score, volume and location of intracranial hematoma, surgical method, and complications (such as hypernatremia, hyperthermia, gastrointestinal bleeding, and multiple organ failure), can influence patient mortality with STBI. 23,24 Therefore, the study suggests that early tracheal intubation has no significant impact on hospital mortality rates.