The present study indicated that PVRL2 rs6859 could modify the TG effect on the MCI-AD progression. High TG level showed a protective role on the MCI-AD progression in MCI subjects carrying non-risk genotype of PVRL2 rs6859 GG, while a promotive role in those carrying risk genotype of PVRL2 rs6859 AG/AA.
To our knowledge, this is the first prospective cohort study to report the interactive effect of TG and PVRL2 rs6859 on MCI-AD progression in Chinese elderly population. Previous studies largely focused on the relationship between TG and AD risk irrespective of AD risk-related SNPs, and there was no unified conclusion [7–16]. For example, Power, M.C found that elevated TG at midlife were associated with cognitive decline over the follow-up of 20 years in non-dementia subjects of the Atherosclerosis Risk in American population [10]. To the contrary, Lv Y.B et al. found that each 1-mmol/L increase of TG was associated with a nearly 20% lower risk of cognitive decline during the 5 follow-up years in 930 Chinese oldest (mean age: 94.0 years) [7]. Moreover, Sabrina found that higher baseline TG concentrations were associated with mixed dementia while it disappeared after adjusting for vascular risk factors in the Three-City (3C) study of European population (mean age = 76.3 years) with up to 13 years of follow-up [8]. We think these discrepancies might deprive from differences in effect based on age at lipid assessment or duration of follow-up [37], selection bias in older cohorts [38], ethnicity of study population, sample size and so on. For genetic factors, the Framingham Heart Study (FHS) indicated the interrelationships between genetic risk score (GRS) of AD susceptibility loci and TG on AD risk [17], however, this study did not find the significant results regarding to the TG effect on AD risk in stratification analysis by genetic markers.
Importantly, we found that PVRL2 rs6859 was significantly associated with MCI-AD progression and that PVRL2 rs6859 and APOE ε4 had similar role of modifying the TG effect on MCI-AD progression. Consistent with our finding, PVRL2 rs6859 was previously confirmed as the AD risk factor in a cross-sectional study in Chinese Han [39]. Although the APOE ε4 allele is the strongest genetic risk factor for sporadic AD, 40–50% people with sporadic AD do not carry the APOE ε4 allele [19, 20]. In our study, only 20.8% of MCI subjects carried APOE ε4, but 55.2% of MCI subjects carried the risk genotype of PVRL2 rs6859 AG/AA; even 46.2% of APOE ε4- subjects carried the PVRL2 rs6859 AG/AA genotype (Table S7). Additionally, in APOE ε4- subjects, PVRL2 rs6859 still had a significant association with MCI-AD progression (AG/AA vs. GG, HR = 3.09, P = 0.005, Table S2). Therefore, our study suggested that PVRL2 rs6859 could be used to supplement the APOE ε4 to better predict the MCI-AD progression in Chinese population. Furthermore, PVRL2 rs6859 and APOE ε4 similarly modified the TG effect on MCI-AD progression. TG possessed a protective role of MCI-AD progression in subjects with PVRL2 rs6859 GG or APOE ε4-, however a promotive role in subjects with PVRL2 rs6859 AG/AA or in APOE ε4+. Hence, PVRL2 rs6859 may influence the pathological process of AD through a similar mechanism with APOE ε4, at least in part. All these results suggested that PVRL2 rs6859 should be considered for a complementary risk assessment of AD to implement targeted prevention by controlling the TG level in Chinese population.
There were some possible mechanisms of TG effect on nervous system for explaining and understanding the opposite effect of TG in different genetic risk group. On the one hand, TG was reported to have protective role for neurons. Medium-chain triglyceride (6–12 carbons), the main constituent of coconut and palm kernel oils, is currently prescribed for mild to moderate Alzheimer’s disease (AD) patients [40], because its metabolite (ketone body) serves as an alternative source of energy to the brain and has neuroprotective effects [41, 42]. In mouse model of AD, ketone body was also reported to show a cognition-sparing property and to reduce Aβ deposition and tau pathology [43, 44]. Alzheimer’s disease (AD) patients have been shown to exhibit decreases in brain glucose metabolism and glycolytic enzymes, however, brain ketone uptake is still normal in MCI and in early AD, which could help explain why ketogenic interventions improve cognitive function in MCI and AD subjects [45]. However, on the other hand, previous preclinical studies suggested that high serum levels of TG might play a promotive role in cerebral amyloidosis [46, 47]. Katarina found that increased levels of TG at midlife could predict brain Aβ and tau pathology 20 years later in cognitively healthy individuals independent of age, gender, APOE ε4 and vascular risk factors [48]. Mamo et al found that Aβ was associated with plasma lipoproteins, especially those enriched with TG, and that TG-rich lipoprotein particles in blood may serve as Aβ carriers [49]. The circulating TG-rich lipoprotein-Aβ complex may compromise blood–brain barrier (BBB) integrity and ultimately increased cerebral amyloid deposition [50]. Therefore, TG has both protective and promotive roles. Based on our findings that PVRL2 rs6859 and APOE modified the TG effect on MCI-AD progression, we suspected that genetic factor was one of the factors influencing TG function.
APOE ε4 is the strongest genetic risk factor for sporadic AD [18], it is critical in the transport of lipid, and activation of lipolytic enzymes [51]. Consistent with our findings that TG possessed a protective role of MCI-AD progression in subjects with non-genetic risk genotype (PVRL2 rs6859 GG or APOE ε4−), while promotive role in subjects with genetic risk genotype (PVRL2 rs6859 AG/AA or APOE ε4+). Reger et al. found that single intake of medium-chain triglyceride drink significantly facilitated performance on the Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale-Cognitive Subscale (ADAS-cog) for APOE ε4 − subjects, but not for APOE ε4 + subjects in American population [52]. The consistent results were also found in Japanese population [53] and Chinese population [54]. It is possible that APOE ε4 − individuals were better able to utilize ketones (produced by TG) than were the APOE ε4 + subjects. PVRL2, also known as cell adhesion molecule 2 (NECTIN2) [55], is important for maintaining proper cell junction and controlling BBB permeability, and may protect brain from spreading the viral infection which was also suggested for APOE [56]. Liu M found that PVRL2 rs6859 AG + AA genotypes were significantly associated with higher TG level and increased risk of dyslipidemia compared with GG genotype in the Chinese Maonan population [57], but this relation was not found in our study with Chinese Han population. In addition, the high confidence (determined by a methylation individual-nucleotide-resolution crosslinking and immunoprecipitation experiment) m6A-SNP rs6859 in the 3'-untranslated region of PVRL2 was found to be associated with TG levels, as well as PVRL2 mRNA expression in artery tibial and whole blood [58]. Based on evidence above, we made an assumption that person with different genotypes of AD risk related-SNPs had different pathway of TG metabolism and subsequent Aβ formation, thereby causing different TG effect on AD progression. In individuals with APOE ε4 − or rs6859 GG, TG could be normally metabolized to ketone bodies which had neuroprotective effects and meanwhile the circulating TG-rich lipoprotein-Aβ complex maintained a low level. Hence, TG showed a protective role on MCI-AD progression. However, APOE ε4 + or rs6859 AG/AA may cause the dysfunction of TG metabolism and destroy the equilibrium of TG-rich lipoprotein-Aβ complex in blood. Therefore, high TG may compromise blood–brain barrier integrity and increase cerebral amyloid deposition and virus infection, thus shows the promotive role for risk of MCI-AD. Further researches are justified to formally test the hypothesis.
There are some limitations in this study as well. First, this study was composed of individuals of Chinese descents aged 72.07 ± 8.07 years and therefore these results had a limited generalizability to populations of different age-ranges and other ethics. Secondly, we had a relatively small sample size for statistical analysis because nearly half of the subjects were lost to follow-up. The small sample size may skew our results to be statistically non-significant. For example, APOE was not observed as significant risk factor on MCI-AD progression in our study. In addition, the subjects who were lost to follow-up were older than those who were followed-up, and may be more likely to develop AD thus AD incidence and effect of the association between TG and AD incidence might be underestimated. Thirdly, the study had a short follow-up time. However, this average 4.5-year follow-up study was able to achieve a sufficient statistical power in analysis because MCI is a transitional clinical state between normal and AD-type dementia thus has a relative higher conversion rate to AD than cognitive normal status (18% in our study) within a short follow-up time. Fourthly, the effect of TG and TG-genetic interaction on MCI-AD progression were not adjusted for TG-lowing therapy because only < 10% subjects in our study have lipid-lowing medication intake.