This retrospective clinical evaluation study of patients diagnosed with mycetoma, who attended the Parasitology and Mycology laboratory at Aristide Le Dantec University Hospital in Dakar identified the causative agents of mycetoma in Senegal using direct 16S/ITS rRNA gene PCR followed by Sanger sequencing directly from grains. By using conventional macroscopic mycetoma diagnosis, we identified 47% black grain eumycetoma, and 38% red grain actinomycetoma. These findings are in line with the latest mycetoma epidemiological data in Senegal, which showed prevalences of eumycetoma ranging from 47–70% [6, 7, 12]. The limitation of conventional diagnosis rationalises the use of DNA-based diagnostic methods. We used direct 16S/ITS rRNA Sanger sequencing from the mycetoma grains to identify the causal agents. With this approach, we succeeded in 80% for black grains mycetoma diagnosis, and identified predominantly M. mycetomatis. This relatively high success rate might be explained by the large quantity of grains produced by this species, which allows us to obtain a sufficient quantity of fungal DNA and limits the amplification of contaminant microorganisms that often remain in samples, despite previous washing. These results are consistent with a similar study carried out by Ahmed et al. [16] in Sudan, where M. mycetomatis was involved in 90% black grains mycetoma. Our results also confirmed the study by K et al. [17], which demonstrated the feasibility and reliability of direct DNA-sequencing for the diagnosis of eumycetomas, especially for the identification of M. mycetomatis. In contrast, the implication of Cladosporium sphaerospermum as a causal agent of black grains eumycetoma remains controversial. Unfortunately, the retrospective study design hinders further investigation. The low number of grains produced by other pathogens explains the lower success rate for red and white/yellowish grains mycetoma. With regard to actinomycetes, Actinomadura pelletieri was the predominant pathogen (6/12), and the second most frequent pathogen in our study. In addition, a new species, A. geliboluensis was identified among white/yellowish grains mycetoma. To our knowledge, this is the first time that this species has been implicated in white/yellow grain mycetoma. In fact, this species was first isolated from soil, described and characterised by Turkish authors in 2012 [18]. Therefore, further investigations on this agent deserve to be carried out, although they may be compromised for the reasons mentioned above. The aetiological agent remained unknown in 40.6% of mycetoma cases, despite both 16S and ITS rRNA sequencing. In fact, grains contain a "microbiome" and DNA-based identification will only identify the microorganism whose DNA is most amplified. Otherwise, Sanger sequencing will generate mixed sequences that compromise DNA-based identification. This hypothesis is in line with the 16S rRNA deep sequencing data of Salipante et al., [19] which allowed the identification of Actinomadura madurae as the pathogen involved in a mycetoma where conventional diagnosis by culture or Sanger sequencing had always been interpreted as contamination. The authors concluded that the proliferation of contaminant micro-organisms limits diagnosis by culture and direct Sanger sequencing [19].
The mean age of our patients was similar to those described in a previous study carried out in the same laboratory between 2008 and 2010 by Ndiaye et al, [12]. Similar results were found in studies carried in the countries bordering Senegal, including in Mauritania [13] and in Mali [14]. This relatively young age of the patients could be explained by their strong involvement in rural activities such as agriculture and livestock breeding. These activities being more practiced by male than women, this could justify the predominance of men in our study population. This observation is shared in almost all studies because the exercise of these activities exposes one to inoculating trauma, particularly through thorn pricks and minor injuries [1]. Our study was no exception to this rule since most of the patients included were farmers (25%) and/or livestock breeders. The characteristics of our study population were rather typical [15].
The majority of our patients came from the west (region of Thiès, Diourbel and Fatick) and the north (region of Louga and Matam) of Senegal. This finding is consistent with a previous study in Senegal [12] and may be explained by the hot and dry climate in these regions, which favours the development of causative microorganisms. One case was reported from the region of Dakar (the capital city). Mycetoma is less common in this region. This could indicate a change in the epidemiology of mycetomas in Senegal [7]. However, these data should be interpreted with caution. In fact, patients know that Dakar is the only place in Senegal where medical mycology laboratories exist, and they often prefer to give their visiting address in Dakar rather than their home address.
Consistent with our findings, a predominance of podal location of mycetoma has been observed in the majority of previous studies [3, 12, 15]. Involvement of the knee and thigh also occurred. The high exposure to inoculation trauma may explain this predominance of lower limb involvement. After the lower limbs, the gluteal and perineal areas were the second most common, which may be related to daily rural living habits, especially sitting on the floor and sometimes lying on their backs.